Page 2 of 2

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 11:53 am
by OregonFan4Life
I don’t know how so many duck fans are thinking about playoff opponents, last I checked we have to beat the Beavs just to get into the CFG then have to beat the Huskies who already beat us earlier in the season and I’m sure their offense will be clicking on all cylinders in a rematch. I can’t let myself think that far ahead, I’ve seen enough Oregon football to know this team can easily miss the playoffs.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 12:10 pm
by squintsdd
OregonFan4Life wrote:I don’t know how so many duck fans are thinking about playoff opponents, last I checked we have to beat the Beavs just to get into the CFG then have to beat the Huskies who already beat us earlier in the season and I’m sure their offense will be clicking on all cylinders in a rematch. I can’t let myself think that far ahead, I’ve seen enough Oregon football to know this team can easily miss the playoffs.
But you have to realize that we're not all Debbie downers

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 1:03 pm
by DuckMastaFunk
IMHO, this is the most complete (offensive and defensive) team I've seen in my lifetime. Georgia is a juggernaut, but they're not the same team that wiped the floor with us last year. You want to be the best you have to beat the best.

Our chance at a backdoor national championship came and went in 2012 when we lost a fluke game in OT to Stanford. That prevented us from playing Notre Dame in the National Championship. Notre Dame had no business being in the BCS that year we likely would have broke the record for most points in a BCS game.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 1:30 pm
by 73duck
They are probably not supposed to do this, but I suspect that they will manipulate the seeding to avoid a first-round Oregon-Georgia matchup. So Oregon would likely only see Georgia if Oregon beat Ohio State/Michigan/Alabama/FSU/whoever in the first round. Yes, I would take that.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 1:34 pm
by StevensTechU
73duck wrote:They are probably not supposed to do this, but I suspect that they will manipulate the seeding to avoid a first-round Oregon-Georgia matchup. So Oregon would likely only see Georgia if Oregon beat Ohio State/Michigan/Alabama/FSU/whoever in the first round. Yes, I would take that.
Why would anyone avoid that? It'd be a ratings hit.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 1:56 pm
by Duck07
StevensTechU wrote:
73duck wrote:They are probably not supposed to do this, but I suspect that they will manipulate the seeding to avoid a first-round Oregon-Georgia matchup. So Oregon would likely only see Georgia if Oregon beat Ohio State/Michigan/Alabama/FSU/whoever in the first round. Yes, I would take that.
Why would anyone avoid that? It'd be a ratings hit.
Well with UGA at #1 right now they'll likely stay there.

B1G champ (assuming no Iowa upset) is the #2.

Now as far as #3 goes, does FSU drop a game? Does UW automatically jump above the Noles this week (deservedly so btw and not because of the injury)?

I think either UW/UO winning out would actually see that team reach #3 in the final poll while it would come down to FSU and Texas winning out for #4. I also think a lot of my previous pessimism has been wiped out by the Jordan injury, unfortunate as it is for him and those players like former Duck Trey Benson. (FSU served their penance for poaching our HC and making us better as the 3rd time looks like a charm!)

The networks would likely view a #1UGA-#4Texas and #2Ohio State-#3Oregon battle as the SEC and B1G Semi-Finals.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 2:10 pm
by lmduck
OregonFan4Life wrote:I don’t know how so many duck fans are thinking about playoff opponents, last I checked we have to beat the Beavs just to get into the CFG then have to beat the Huskies who already beat us earlier in the season and I’m sure their offense will be clicking on all cylinders in a rematch. I can’t let myself think that far ahead, I’ve seen enough Oregon football to know this team can easily miss the playoffs.
Uhm- their offense was not exactly clicking in Corvallis. Not saying it won't going forward but they were pretty pedestrian on Saturday night.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 2:35 pm
by duck55
DuckMastaFunk wrote:IMHO, this is the most complete (offensive and defensive) team I've seen in my lifetime. Georgia is a juggernaut, but they're not the same team that wiped the floor with us last year. You want to be the best you have to beat the best.

Our chance at a backdoor national championship came and went in 2012 when we lost a fluke game in OT to Stanford. That prevented us from playing Notre Dame in the National Championship. Notre Dame had no business being in the BCS that year we likely would have broke the record for most points in a BCS game.
Even more than the 59 we hung on the unbeatable FSU in 2015?

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 2:39 pm
by woundedknees
While ND has a long history of success, I believe they now receive a ridiculous amount of respect for their potential impact on the bottom line (Media Bucks) that exceeds theur actual accomplishments on a seasonal basis.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Mon Nov 20, 2023 11:59 pm
by OregonDucks
As a competitor, I can’t fathom someone asking this question.

The Oregon Ducks football team is on a mission to win a national championship. They would rather have the opportunity and come up short than win some meaningless bowl game.

This team can beat anyone, if they play up to their standard.

Re: Hypothetical Playoff Question (Do We Really Want In?)

Posted: Tue Nov 21, 2023 5:25 am
by Phalanx
Thanks to the OP for starting this thread, despite the negative responses. It's a good question to start a discussion, as evidenced by the multiple pages of posts. Count me in among those who would love to face Georgia. All one ever hears in comments sections on Duck videos is how Georgia creamed Oregon in Lanning's first game, as if that game has any meaning at all for the identity of either program. It's been a talking point for the SEC honks to latch onto for nearly two seasons now, and I for one believe Oregon would have a really good chance to change that narrative. Oregon has won NY6 bowls already - a bunch of them. The only way to grow now is to break into that top tier. Maybe that means losing sometimes, but getting there is the important thing. Once you get there, anything can happen.