Would an eight team playoff be better?

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

Assuming all the favorites win, MSU knocks off Iowa, and there is a two team limit from conference:

1 Clemson vs 8 Houston
4 Oklahoma vs 5 Ohio State

2 Alabama vs 7 Notre Dame
3 Michigan State vs 6 Stanford

Left out: Iowa, Florida State, TCU, and Baylor

You could dial it a few different ways, but sounds pretty fun to me.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
QuackininBama
All Pac-12
Posts: 5741
Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by QuackininBama »

Iowa is a joke, its honestly insulting to me they are a shoo in for the playoffs. Anyone look at that schedule lately?
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by buckmarkduck »

If Iowa gets in, forget about seeing anymore UO vs MSU type match ups again. What's the incentive? If a team can make it playing a bunch of garbage, and a better te gets left out, because they lost to a top 10 team ooc?
whosyourwally
Freshman
Posts: 1320
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
Location: Columbus, Ohio

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by whosyourwally »

QuackininBama wrote:Iowa is a joke, its honestly insulting to me they are a shoo in for the playoffs. Anyone look at that schedule lately?
I've wanted to believe that all year, and they might be, but they look pretty solid when you watch them play. I don't think we can call them "a joke", just untested right now. If Michigan wipes the floor with them, then we can call them a joke.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Oregonian
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 931
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:01 am

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by Oregonian »

I say go Top 6:
Rd1:
1. Clemson (13-0) - BYE
2. Alabama (12-1) - BYE
#6 Ohio State (11-1) @ #3 Oklahoma (11-1), in Norman, 12/12
#5 Stanford (11-2) @ #4 Michigan State (12-1), in East Lansing, 12/12

Rd2:
Clemson vs. winner of Stanford/MSU @ Peach Bowl, 12/31
Alabama vs. winner of OSU/Oklahoma @ Cotton Bowl, 12/31

If you look at recent history with the BCS and try to apply the current 4-team model, I think there's plenty of years where #5 or even #6 can reasonably be in consideration for a playoff discussion... when you get down the #7 and #8, the conversation is just much harder... 7-15 tends to be a lot more variable in rankings, as you have much more teams that fall in that range of wins (just look at this year).

The fact of the matter is that we have five power conferences - if we believe those conferences are as good as we say they are, each champion should theoretically be a viable playoff contender. Six gets you enough to get them all in. I don't think, if you move to six, you should necessarily auto-bid all the champions - there will be years where one P5 slumps and another puts out multiple contenders. I also don't think guaranteeing a Group of 5 team is an answer either. I think expanding the number is right, it's just a matter of getting the right number and tailoring it to keep the regular season super compelling while also reserving a premier playoff with only the best of the best.
User avatar
fpsduck
Senior
Posts: 2862
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:10 am

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by fpsduck »

8 is enough?

I say, let's make it 16.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by lukeyrid13 »

8 is the perfect number IMO
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3976
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by UofDuck »

Oregonian wrote:I don't think, should necessarily auto-bid all the champions - there will be years where one P5 slumps and another puts out multiple contenders. I also don't think guaranteeing a Group of 5 team is an answer either.
I disagree because how many times have computers or humans been shown to have a bias, or influenced by media saturation and love fests, or crazy lingering pre-seasons rankings? I want those involved to have earned it by beating their competition on the field. Just last year Alabama and FSU would have been in the natty according to the BCS model with Alabama favored to win it all. tOSU barely squeaked in. How did that turn out? I hate "voting" teams in. Win your conference and get in, plus the highest ranked non power 5 plus 2 at large beauty contest winners. The few wild cards keeps interest for fans to hold on to with the hope of sliding in under the wire
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I don't want 8.. My problem is this... these kids are playing 12 games before conference championship... so that makes it 13... then you have 2 or 3 more games... and you are up to 15 or 16 games. Look at how hard it is to stay healthy in the NFL... and these are the best players. Besides that ... I want the bowl games to matter. I like the 4 teams being how it is done. It still makes bowl games important and every game during the season important.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by StevensTechU »

I'm for making the playoff 8 teams and reducing the regular season schedule by 2 games. The length of the season is getting out of control.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by Alan »

I also for 8, 16 is too many. Good suggestion reducing the regular season game, but I say by one, cut out one of the non conference games....... who wants to see a 74-0 blow out of a lower division team. Also get the NCAA to put all power five on a level playing field, all conferences have a championship game and all play the same amount of conference games.

As far as Iowa being a joke, they play good hard nose football and are basically untested. They are exactly were they deserve to be, they lose in the championship game they are out, they win and their in...... They are no joke.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by duckfan22 »

I am torn between 4 teams vs 6 or 8 teams . 4 teams keeps the suspense on what teams make it or dont. Does going to
more teams dumb it down a bit. If you go to more teams and conference champs get a free pass? Then if USC wins Saturday would
that mean a 4 loss USC makes the playoffs? Another thing going to more teams means more time away from Academics for the
players? I have no problem watching more college football best time of year. If they go to eight teams how long before they go to
10?
SuperDuck
Senior
Posts: 4671
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
Location: Arizona, USA
Contact:

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by SuperDuck »

StevensTechU wrote:I'm for making the playoff 8 teams and reducing the regular season schedule by 2 games. The length of the season is getting out of control.
I agree, though I think one game less would be enough and 8 would be a good number. Teams in conference title games would play 12 games plus a Bowl game. Teams that went to the playoffs would play a max of 14 and that's only 2 teams per year.

That being said, I also think that conference title games should be eliminated and turn them into regional play-in games because a 4 loss team has no business playing for the Rose Bowl. A 10-12 team playoff would allow most teams that are on the fence to have a chance to play their way in. Give the Top-6 a bye and let the teams ranked #7-#10 play their way into an 8 team field.

That way all Power-5 teams and Notre Dame/Best-5 Mid-Major would be #1-#6 and the last 4 would be at-large teams.

If things stay as they are but expand to 8 teams, I'd like to see all 5 Power-5 conference champs, Notre Dame/Best-5 Mid-Major and 2 at-large teams. It still wouldn't be perfect, but it should eliminate most arguments.
John 3:36
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Would an eight team playoff be better?

Post by UOducksTK1 »

GoDucksIn09 wrote:I don't want 8.. My problem is this... these kids are playing 12 games before conference championship... so that makes it 13... then you have 2 or 3 more games... and you are up to 15 or 16 games. Look at how hard it is to stay healthy in the NFL... and these are the best players. Besides that ... I want the bowl games to matter. I like the 4 teams being how it is done. It still makes bowl games important and every game during the season important.
Like others said, remove a game or two in the regular season then.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
Post Reply