Cross-Positional Recruiting
Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Cross-Positional Recruiting
This may be a nuance that few others care about, but I personally find all things strategic to be interesting. In the case of recruiting, which I liken to marketing far more than to football, there are strategic decisions about branding, messaging, sales force, competitive intelligence, etc. that get made either consciously or subconsciously that will effect overall performance.
Though it's early, it already appears that Oregon is taking a slightly different approach to recruiting in 2017. In years past, it has been the responsibility for a positional recruiter to go after their guys and take on that responsibility wholly and alone. The roles are such that positional coaches give their input on a potential offer but generally just handle their own guys, the head ball coach meets the families toward the end, and the recruiting operations guys make sure they get to camp/coordinate official visits/perform background checks/get into school academically.
What's different is that this year, it's already evident that at least Yost and Lubick are recruiting outside of their positions. Further, Hoke isn't focusing on a position group, but rather seems to be helping recruit each level of the defense. Hop on the twitters and you'll see that Yost's most recent follows include offensive linemen, a linebacker, a TE/DE, and a running back. Similarly, Lubick is recruiting not just WRs, but also helping with DBs and RBs.
I think this is possibly due to a lesson learned with concentrating too much of the recruiting on only a few guys (Chinander), and also out of an understanding that more relationships increase your chances with a recruit. If, say, Salvon Ahmed visits campus and already knows 4-5 coaches instead of 1, he's going to have a better experience.
Anyway I think about it, it seems to be a better idea. Looking forward to the new attention made on the recruiting trail after a fairly lackluster 2016.
Though it's early, it already appears that Oregon is taking a slightly different approach to recruiting in 2017. In years past, it has been the responsibility for a positional recruiter to go after their guys and take on that responsibility wholly and alone. The roles are such that positional coaches give their input on a potential offer but generally just handle their own guys, the head ball coach meets the families toward the end, and the recruiting operations guys make sure they get to camp/coordinate official visits/perform background checks/get into school academically.
What's different is that this year, it's already evident that at least Yost and Lubick are recruiting outside of their positions. Further, Hoke isn't focusing on a position group, but rather seems to be helping recruit each level of the defense. Hop on the twitters and you'll see that Yost's most recent follows include offensive linemen, a linebacker, a TE/DE, and a running back. Similarly, Lubick is recruiting not just WRs, but also helping with DBs and RBs.
I think this is possibly due to a lesson learned with concentrating too much of the recruiting on only a few guys (Chinander), and also out of an understanding that more relationships increase your chances with a recruit. If, say, Salvon Ahmed visits campus and already knows 4-5 coaches instead of 1, he's going to have a better experience.
Anyway I think about it, it seems to be a better idea. Looking forward to the new attention made on the recruiting trail after a fairly lackluster 2016.
-
SuperDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 4671
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:29 am
- Location: Arizona, USA
- Contact:
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
Agreed. Alto often we hear of kids decommitting if the coach that primarily recruited them leaves for another job. That's understandable. By having more connections from different coaches, many would look at a coach leaving like "that really sucks that Coach Smith is leaving, but at least, Coach Jones and Coach Williams are still there, so it's not like I won't know anyone when I get there."StevensTechU wrote:This may be a nuance that few others care about, but I personally find all things strategic to be interesting. In the case of recruiting, which I liken to marketing far more than to football, there are strategic decisions about branding, messaging, sales force, competitive intelligence, etc. that get made either consciously or subconsciously that will effect overall performance.
Though it's early, it already appears that Oregon is taking a slightly different approach to recruiting in 2017. In years past, it has been the responsibility for a positional recruiter to go after their guys and take on that responsibility wholly and alone. The roles are such that positional coaches give their input on a potential offer but generally just handle their own guys, the head ball coach meets the families toward the end, and the recruiting operations guys make sure they get to camp/coordinate official visits/perform background checks/get into school academically.
What's different is that this year, it's already evident that at least Yost and Lubick are recruiting outside of their positions. Further, Hoke isn't focusing on a position group, but rather seems to be helping recruit each level of the defense. Hop on the twitters and you'll see that Yost's most recent follows include offensive linemen, a linebacker, a TE/DE, and a running back. Similarly, Lubick is recruiting not just WRs, but also helping with DBs and RBs.
I think this is possibly due to a lesson learned with concentrating too much of the recruiting on only a few guys (Chinander), and also out of an understanding that more relationships increase your chances with a recruit. If, say, Salvon Ahmed visits campus and already knows 4-5 coaches instead of 1, he's going to have a better experience.
Anyway I think about it, it seems to be a better idea. Looking forward to the new attention made on the recruiting trail after a fairly lackluster 2016.
I like the thought process.
John 3:36
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
Interesting observation. I think you might be on to something. I can't to reflect who we lost when Chins left. 1) Vavae-- Not a huge loss considering our RB coach didn't want to offer and Chins was the one who convinced the staff to offer. (If you believe Jhop.... gulp). Murphy.... Ducks didn't love him in the end and stopped recruiting him. Who did we lose when Chins left? Was he even that great of a judge of talent? (I know it's hard to tell as his classes are just now hitting their productions years). Last question, was he even that great of a position coach? His unit was a major issue the past two seasons.
I know not a direct comment to yours STU, but worth a look. Any feedback?
I know not a direct comment to yours STU, but worth a look. Any feedback?
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
I couldn't really say how much of a reason it was for Vavae switching commitments, but it wwas pretty apparent that Kyle Porter was Campbell's preference, not Vavae.
Chins was charged with doing both his job and Ron Aiken's job on the recruiting trail. That's the value lost. However, with Brady Hoke I think they got the right guy that will let Aiken to just coach his position and not worry so much about recruiting, which is his preference.
Chins was charged with doing both his job and Ron Aiken's job on the recruiting trail. That's the value lost. However, with Brady Hoke I think they got the right guy that will let Aiken to just coach his position and not worry so much about recruiting, which is his preference.
- FlDuckFan
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 5068
- Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
- GM: Orlando Magic GM
- Location: Florida
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
Good post,
I think it's smart of Yost to be involved in the recruiting of lineman , I mean they will be the one's protecting his qb's.
I think it's smart of Yost to be involved in the recruiting of lineman , I mean they will be the one's protecting his qb's.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40737
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
That isn't quite true:In years past, it has been the responsibility for a positional recruiter to go after their guys and take on that responsibility wholly and alone.
Chinander, or "Chins" to the inner circle has been given credit for the commitments of Canton Kaumatule, Gary Baker, Fotu Leiato, Dylan Kane and Gus Cumberlander. You could make an argument for him to be rewarded with the commitments of Ugo Amadi, Rex Manu and Paris Bostick. Not only has Chinander helped recruit the linebackers and the state of Hawaii, he's been pivotal to helping sign one of Oregon's best defensive line classes ever. (247 Sports)
Chins recruited a lot of the defense. I also remember Frost recruiting across the board too even when he was only a positional coach.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
Right, so everything has certain exceptions. In my 2:53pm ET post, I mentioned Chins was doing Aiken's job (Kaumatule, Manu, Cumberlander). Neal was the primary recruiter for Kane, even if Chins did attend the in-home visits when he was in Hawai'i. Amadi was Neal, as well, so no idea where the idea that that was Chins comes from (Neal knew Amadi's private coach, and when Amadi decommitted from LSU, that coach called up Neal). I can't speak to Fotu, though, no idea there.
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40737
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
In general though, I feel like this is normal. There's always a dude or two on the roster, who recruits beyond his position.StevensTechU wrote:Right, so everything has certain exceptions. In my 2:53pm ET post, I mentioned Chins was doing Aiken's job (Kaumatule, Manu, Cumberlander). Neal was the primary recruiter for Kane, even if Chins did attend the in-home visits when he was in Hawai'i. Amadi was Neal, as well, so no idea where the idea that that was Chins comes from (Neal knew Amadi's private coach, and when Amadi decommitted from LSU, that coach called up Neal). I can't speak to Fotu, though, no idea there.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
-
jimmy12
- Senior
- Posts: 2823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:38 am
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
While I appreciate your post, why is everyone so keen on naming a class "the best class ever." Need I remind you that NONE of those guys you named have done anything remotely good to warrant that label. They may in the future, but for now we will have to live with potential. This is why I said, "I know it's hard to tell as his classes are just now hitting their productions years." While Chins may have helped get some guy in the door, I am not even close to labeling this a huge loss until I see a) how his guys turn out and b) how the new coaches recruit. All I have to go on are potential and under performance on the football field in his position.
- DuckMastaFunk
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1044
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:07 pm
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
He the crap does the highest paid position coach get away with not recruiting??!StevensTechU wrote:I couldn't really say how much of a reason it was for Vavae switching commitments, but it wwas pretty apparent that Kyle Porter was Campbell's preference, not Vavae.
Chins was charged with doing both his job and Ron Aiken's job on the recruiting trail. That's the value lost. However, with Brady Hoke I think they got the right guy that will let Aiken to just coach his position and not worry so much about recruiting, which is his preference.
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Cross-Positional Recruiting
Aiken doesn't have the same bonus potential in his contract. After bonuses, he's not the highest paid.DuckMastaFunk wrote:
He the crap does the highest paid position coach get away with not recruiting??!