mdm0302 wrote:If we don't get a premier QB this cycle that will be a HUGE drop of the ball. Could of had Kelley or Tua
Not really. Jonsen and Wilson look good and I am higher on the kid from Sheldon than most.
Not saying Tua was the answer at QB, but you can't not fill the QB spot again. We just went through that and it sucked. Heck, we're still gonna feel it this next year when we all see that Prukop is no VA.
Recruiting is full of uncertainty but doesn't seem like Helfrich knows how to play the game. Can't let these huge holes bring the program to its knees.
We are talking about high school juniors, a lot of them will change their mind in the nine months til signing day. On May 6th last year Terry Wilson committed to Nebraska yet several months later enrolled at Oregon.
More importantly many players will develop during their senior year. A year ago Justin Herbert was an unknown coming off an injury. If I remember correctly Marcus Mariota was a wide receiver waiting to switch positions at a similar point in his high school career. As a junior Darron Thomas averaged 100 yards passing and 50 yards rushing per game. I doubt he had any scholarship offers.
maxduck wrote:We are talking about high school juniors, a lot of them will change their mind in the nine months til signing day. On May 6th last year Terry Wilson committed to Nebraska yet several months later enrolled at Oregon.
More importantly many players will develop during their senior year. A year ago Justin Herbert was an unknown coming off an injury. If I remember correctly Marcus Mariota was a wide receiver waiting to switch positions at a similar point in his high school career. As a junior Darron Thomas averaged 100 yards passing and 50 yards rushing per game. I doubt he had any scholarship offers.
Trevone Boykin and Connor Cook both vastly improved from their junior to senior seasons, as well. And then there's recent NFL draft picks like Paxton Lynch (Memphis) and Carson Wentz (NDSU) who were unknowns.
Don't think I've ever seen a recruit recommend the school he just decommitted from to other recruits. Kinda strange and makes me wonder what the full story is behind his decommitment.
Don't think I've ever seen a recruit recommend the school he just decommitted from to other recruits. Kinda strange and makes me wonder what the full story is behind his decommitment.
Now I'm even more convinced that it wasn't a good system fit for Kelley. Both he and the coaches probably came to the same conclusion. Maybe that is why he is encouraging another player to consider a flip.
mdm0302 wrote:If we don't get a premier QB this cycle that will be a HUGE drop of the ball. Could of had Kelley or Tua
Not really. Jonsen and Wilson look good and I am higher on the kid from Sheldon than most.
Not saying Tua was the answer at QB, but you can't not fill the QB spot again. We just went through that and it sucked. Heck, we're still gonna feel it this next year when we all see that Prukop is no VA.
Recruiting is full of uncertainty but doesn't seem like Helfrich knows how to play the game. Can't let these huge holes bring the program to its knees.
yes, we have good depth as a program now but in terms of the recruiting cycle, net getting a premier QB would really be dropping the ball when we could of had Tua or RK.
mdm0302 wrote:If we don't get a premier QB this cycle that will be a HUGE drop of the ball. Could of had Kelley or Tua
Not really. Jonsen and Wilson look good and I am higher on the kid from Sheldon than most.
Not saying Tua was the answer at QB, but you can't not fill the QB spot again. We just went through that and it sucked. Heck, we're still gonna feel it this next year when we all see that Prukop is no VA.
Recruiting is full of uncertainty but doesn't seem like Helfrich knows how to play the game. Can't let these huge holes bring the program to its knees.
yes, we have good depth as a program now but in terms of the recruiting cycle, net getting a premier QB would really be dropping the ball when we could of had Tua or RK.
I think had they offered Tua right away, he would have been an Oregon commit as fast as Kelley was. Now they're back to square one in having to build relationships with potential QBs while other schools have already made it past the "get-to-know-you" phase and on to the unofficial visit phase.
mdm0302 wrote:If we don't get a premier QB this cycle that will be a HUGE drop of the ball. Could of had Kelley or Tua
Not really. Jonsen and Wilson look good and I am higher on the kid from Sheldon than most.
Not saying Tua was the answer at QB, but you can't not fill the QB spot again. We just went through that and it sucked. Heck, we're still gonna feel it this next year when we all see that Prukop is no VA.
Recruiting is full of uncertainty but doesn't seem like Helfrich knows how to play the game. Can't let these huge holes bring the program to its knees.
yes, we have good depth as a program now but in terms of the recruiting cycle, net getting a premier QB would really be dropping the ball when we could of had Tua or RK.
I think had they offered Tua right away, he would have been an Oregon commit as fast as Kelley was. Now they're back to square one in having to build relationships with potential QBs while other schools have already made it past the "get-to-know-you" phase and on to the unofficial visit phase.
thats what im saying, he would have committed. Thats why I'm saying the coaching staff blew it unless they can pull something off late in the process. starting at square one, like you said
We also have to remember that they were able to get Wilson in September and Herbert in October so it's not exactly like it's impossible to get quality QBs late in a recruiting cycle. While they'll likely strike out on the top QBs on the West Coast they were conceivably in position for, there are still some guys that may turn out to be good QBs given some time and are willing to bide their time instead of expecting early playing time.
We should also consider that perhaps the staff continues to not be a Tua believer. Maybe there's some sort of red flag the staff is concerned about be it on the field, in life, or in the classroom. They have waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more access to intel on recruits than we do.
I mean, we could say that we missed out on having Richie Incognito. We actually had him on the roster but kicked him off the team for being Coo Coo for Cocoa Puffs. On the field, Incognito would have been our best lineman at the time and we went another direction once we had the right info. Could have had him, but passed. Right choice.
To me, when the staff passes on someone they're obviously aware of, it's for a reason. I wouldn't say we missed out on Jameis Winston by not offering. He probably wouldn't have ever come to UO, but I'd say we hit a home run by not going after him at all.
Please don't mistake this as equating Winston and Incognito with Tua as people. More like we're passing and the coaches have a reason. To me, that means no reason to worry about it. Over the past several years, this staff has done an outstanding job of vetting these young people before bringing them to the University. They've earned my trust in the process.
ncduck wrote:We should also consider that perhaps the staff continues to not be a Tua believer. Maybe there's some sort of red flag the staff is concerned about be it on the field, in life, or in the classroom. They have waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more access to intel on recruits than we do.
I mean, we could say that we missed out on having Richie Incognito. We actually had him on the roster but kicked him off the team for being Coo Coo for Cocoa Puffs. On the field, Incognito would have been our best lineman at the time and we went another direction once we had the right info. Could have had him, but passed. Right choice.
To me, when the staff passes on someone they're obviously aware of, it's for a reason. I wouldn't say we missed out on Jameis Winston by not offering. He probably wouldn't have ever come to UO, but I'd say we hit a home run by not going after him at all.
Please don't mistake this as equating Winston and Incognito with Tua as people. More like we're passing and the coaches have a reason. To me, that means no reason to worry about it. Over the past several years, this staff has done an outstanding job of vetting these young people before bringing them to the University. They've earned my trust in the process.
He had offers from every school. i see your line of thinking... passing on Incognito and who ever. But this is just a drop of the ball. They lost out on Tua by making RK their main man and now we are at square one looking for a new guy this cycle. Should have taken the guy who loved Oregon and would have been 100% solid from the start. i could be more empathetic towards the staffs discretion but Tua wasn't a bum, he's a big time prospect. I almost feel like Frost was overly enamored in the NFL prototype player like Marcus.
Don't think I've ever seen a recruit recommend the school he just decommitted from to other recruits. Kinda strange and makes me wonder what the full story is behind his decommitment.
Now I'm even more convinced that it wasn't a good system fit for Kelley. Both he and the coaches probably came to the same conclusion. Maybe that is why he is encouraging another player to consider a flip.
UO system is similar to ASU, which from what I'm hearing is where he'll end up, except our system is much more dynamic. It has nothing to do with system, or our coaches not being high on him or anything. He decided he wanted to stay close to home, period.
ncduck wrote:We should also consider that perhaps the staff continues to not be a Tua believer. Maybe there's some sort of red flag the staff is concerned about be it on the field, in life, or in the classroom. They have waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more access to intel on recruits than we do.
I mean, we could say that we missed out on having Richie Incognito. We actually had him on the roster but kicked him off the team for being Coo Coo for Cocoa Puffs. On the field, Incognito would have been our best lineman at the time and we went another direction once we had the right info. Could have had him, but passed. Right choice.
To me, when the staff passes on someone they're obviously aware of, it's for a reason. I wouldn't say we missed out on Jameis Winston by not offering. He probably wouldn't have ever come to UO, but I'd say we hit a home run by not going after him at all.
Please don't mistake this as equating Winston and Incognito with Tua as people. More like we're passing and the coaches have a reason. To me, that means no reason to worry about it. Over the past several years, this staff has done an outstanding job of vetting these young people before bringing them to the University. They've earned my trust in the process.
He had offers from every school. i see your line of thinking... passing on Incognito and who ever. But this is just a drop of the ball. They lost out on Tua by making RK their main man and now we are at square one looking for a new guy this cycle. Should have taken the guy who loved Oregon and would have been 100% solid from the start. i could be more empathetic towards the staffs discretion but Tua wasn't a bum, he's a big time prospect. I almost feel like Frost was overly enamored in the NFL prototype player like Marcus.
It was Frost call on that, and from what I've been told ( VA wasn't a HS recruit) he just didn't like he height of Tua, or Martell. I'm hoping We change our recruiting philosophy, and not judge kids by height, and also offer multiple qbs every year. It's stupid to act like it's Willy Wonkas golden ticket, and only offer to one kid at a time. Offer multiple qbs, take the one who commits, but also keep going after other kids.