Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by GrantDuck »

QB: B-. Running I'd give him an B, passing a C+. The one thing Shough did well is he made the lay-ups. The quick passes and option pitches, and easy routes...and then letting his guys compete for his deep passes.

Also a general thought: I know there's some comments about arm strength...we were spoiled with Herbert. Tyler did get a throw out to the far hash that Jake Browning couldn't make his whole career, so he's got..enough for a college QB. He's not going to be a super star(I think Ty Thompson is going to be THAT dude soon), but if he can minimize mistakes, we can win a lot of games with him. He also had some real awful reads over the middle...that's gotta get better for us to compete at a high level or he's going to have some 3 interception games very shortly.

RB: B+;
Dye and Verdell have worked so hard to get better every year. Great job finishing runs tonight at the goal line. Dye spin move at full speed was crazy good and Verdell knocked Furd's linebacker about 6 yards on his first TD. CHL fumbled and Dollars only got the 1 carry, but overall solid game here.

WR/TE: A-. Maybe not as much separation at times, we still don't have that BURNER at WR, but some awesome catches from Pittman and JJIII tonight. Cool to see DJ get his shot and play well at TE too. He's a willing blocker in the pit. I'll also say, you can tell Devon Williams played at USC because he doesn't BLOCK like our starting WR's do. He'll learn.

OL: B. Furd D front is always pretty good. No major penalty issues, which is big the first time out for a new O-Line. For 6 new guys, thought they were great, relatively. Thought George Moore looked solid all game. Sala is an absolute mauler in the run game, but as someone mentioned, he's a guard not a tackle long term. Got stacked up a bit too much in the first half and pass pro is kind of an "incomplete" because we didn't do many longer routes.

DL: C+. 2nd unit outplayed the first. Kayvon didn't get close to the QB all night, so real disappointing night for him outside of the one run play. Dorlus was a wrecking ball in there and got a shoutout from Penei himself on Twitter during the game. Fatmac got better as the game went on. Pass rush was disappointing in general.

LB: C. Mathis is pretty bad still. That first drive I counted him in the wrong gap 3 times alone! Sewell as everyone says is going to be a super-star, but he also ran himself out of a handful of plays and missed a tackle. ISM is pretty solid as a tackler still, and overall thought he had a decent game after the first drive. Funa I thought played pretty well and Adrian Jackson I counted twice with really nice pass coverage on a running back and a TE.

DB: C. Lenoir gets an A, everyone else gets a D. It's funny, because every year there's hyped players in camp, especially from sunshine Rob and it's always a coinflip as to whether those players are for real or not. Jamal Hill looked SLOW and stiff out there and didn't wrap up at all while tackling. He's certainly a big strong dude, but man, for his hype, I'd say was a massive whiff there. DJ James shouldn't play against good teams.

Wright is interesting...he has ALL the physical skill in the world, but his technique is pretty bad at times, which gets him PI penalties because he doesn't find the ball. We have a new secondary coach this season and can't say I think much of his coaching so far, after game 1...but it's game 1..and young guys in the secondary is probably always the hardest position seemingly unless you're Cliff Harris and you're enlightened from all the weed. So plenty of time to wait and see here. If we see improvement, then we'll know it's more inexperience than coaching.


Coaches.
Offense A: Moorhead had a really solid debut. We have a real OC again, no doubt! Those little TE pop plays were super smart adjustments and we saw some really sweet 3rd down play calls and tempo stuff...more than once we caught Stanford confused with our tempo at just the right time.

Also, shoutout to Cristobal and Mirabal for the O-line coaching. You RARELY see an OL THAT green make so few obvious mistakes.

Defense B-: We kept it pretty vanilla, Secondary coach...it's game 1, but that was a concern because I did not see good technique out there except for Lenoir, and he's learned from Donte. Gave up WAAAAY too many yards overall to have a much higher grade, but losing Holland/Dye/Graham..there's going to be some growing pains. The D-line...Kristian Williams and Dorlus..those 2 kids are getting coached up nicely!
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by duck023 »

I give the qb an A. Shough beat Stanford in his first game moving the ball up and down the field. I've seen guy's like Lockie, Allie, and Burmeister struggle moving the ball against bad defenses. The interception he made was an interception I've seen both Mariota and Herbert make a bunch of times. Shough sort of reminds me of a better version of Bryan Bennett. I'm happy the Ducks had Mariota but I always felt like the Ducks would have been successful with Bryan Bennett as well.
User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by Alan »

TE - A, I was pleasantly surprised we have a 6’6”, 260lb TE with decent spid and looks solidly built.
Sewell played well...... true freshman
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by buckmarkduck »

I felt like Tyler tried to much for the long ball, he will have to learn to take what is open. He had the RB open a few times, and instead tried to pass into triple coverage. He will learn, in HS you can do that but not here.

Predator should be our starting TE from now on, he is just scratching the surface of his TE ability. 260 and can run the way he does, and he was blocking as well as anyone out there.

The D playing the way they did wasn't shocking. Its what we've seen all over college this year, due to the covid. D is about communicating, having time to learn to play as a unit. Tough to do that on a zoom call. They will improve.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by GoDucksTroll »

This is pretty much spot on.

I was disappointed with Shough’s arm, not just in a this isn’t Herbert kind of way. Way too much arc on some passes, good DBs will make him pay for those. It’s just one game and in the 2019 spring game Shough’s arm strength looked better. Definitely something to keep an eye on.

Wright needs to turn his head and find the ball. He’s as fast a corner as we’ve ever had, so he can do that without getting beat. The DPI call wasn’t great, but a long completion could have been an interception earlier in the game if he just looked back.

Agree on Hill, he looked lost a lot. Holland was so important.

On OL they did a solid job in the run game, pass pro from the two guards was bad. Steven Jones had several plays where he went out of position and left Shough exposed. The type of play where Lemieux would crack the rusher and give the QB another second.

Minus the fumble by Cyrus where no one touched him and his knee hit it out the RBs were excellent. Both Dye and Verdell looked great, they couldn’t run on this Stanford team last year.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40726
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by UOducksTK1 »

I miss Graham and Holland.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by lukeyrid13 »

My 2 cents

QB: B Shough played solid and his legs were a nice pleasant surprise. Needs to work on his reads in the passing game a bit more

RB: A- Dye ran hard and Verdell did as well. I'd still like to see Verdell improve on breaking low arm tackles and not getting tripped up but a really well played game from them

TE A- DJ Johnson played an almost perfect game. His strength and blocking on the wham blocks is an asset and other than 1 drop he is an asset in the passing game now as well. Will be interesting to see him run some more routes, like drag routes or short curls and see if he is as effective there as well.

WR. A- Really solid game for our WRs. I'd like to see more separation in our routes but some amazing catches and the level of improvement from 2-3 years ago is unreal


OL B Solid but unspectacular. They will improve as we along this season. We also ran some 6 lineman sets in a tight jumbo package


DL C- KT had a nice tackle and Dorlus did as well, outside of those 2 plays, they were basically invisible and 0 sacks and 0 QB hurries is just not going to cut it. We have depth, but they really underwhelmed last night


LB C Our OLB (Funa and Jackson) were also strangely quiet last night. ISM played well and Sewell had some great stops but needs to work on his gap control. Mathis maybe has more discipline than Sewell, but Noah should get a majority of those snaps as his ceiling is FAR higher.

CB B Daewood Davis is the ultimate team player but he was badly beat multiple times. Lenoir was a stud and Wright had some great plays and isn't afraid to get physical. As long as one of DJ James or Dontae Manning steps up as the season progresses, we should be good. If Lenoir had not come back, our team would be much worse off


S C Jamal Hill was non-existent and McKinley got beat a few times. Breeze and Holland would have really helped in the running game. I wouldn't be surprised if we saw more of Happle as the season progresses
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by buckmarkduck »

Maybe I missed the drop by DJ, but I don't remember seeing it. I remember Williams having a drop.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by lukeyrid13 »

buckmarkduck wrote:Maybe I missed the drop by DJ, but I don't remember seeing it. I remember Williams having a drop.
It was on the same route he had success on, the slow developing fake wham block RPO where he releases to the weak side.
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3314
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Based on score, 14 points, would be a B+ grade at minimum for the defense.

Watching the actual game I'd grade it at C- or D. Only two forced punts and no sacks or turnovers. A ton of yardage against a team that lost its starting QB and Receiver on game day was disappointing. Really only one player had a strong game and played up to expectation and the inside linebacker and safety play was 2015-ish soft.

But scoreboard baby!
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

Yeah given the fact that Stanford was without their starting qb i would think the defense would dominate more. If their kicker makes their kicks it is a 9 point win. I am not as confident that the 9 points though would be the margin of victory. The Oregon offense, never really felt pressured during the game, so not sure if they would have been able to score the points they did if felt pressured to perform.

I just watched the game again. Overall I was happy with the way the offensive line played given the fact had 5 new starters out their. Not a lot of penalties from the offensive line. I think the defensive line under performed. KT was not dominate. I do not think they had any sacks, and their was no turnovers. That is shocking given the fact they were without their starting qb.
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by nogerO »

Coaches.
Offense A: Moorhead had a really solid debut.

Huh? Run it up the gut on first down almost every single time? How about outside read once or twice? Put us in second and long the majority of the time. Breaking in a new QB and putting him in second and long every drive? Wow. Stanford stacked the box on first downs and then dropped 8 almost every series or blitzed and forced Shough to run. Pretty sure I'd give Moorehead a C or D and that's generous. Very disappointed. We beat a mediocre Stanford team missing a lot of pieces. WSU will watch the video and be ready for our offense so Moorehead better take the training wheels off and put Shough in more manageable situations. Guess I was watching another game.
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I think I would give the new offensive coordinator a B for a grade. This season is unlike any season we have ever had. Oregon is breaking in 5 new offensive linemen. Before fall camp they had to do all their coaching via zoom. This on top of learning a new system. I do not think it was perfect. I do think for a first game given all they have had to go through the last 6 months this was good. Remember they did not get to have a spring game and only had 4 practices before the spring was cancelled. If they play like this in game 3 or 4 then feel can be more critical. Not very many penalties on the offensive line, and had a decent running game. Do they need to improve absolutely.

I want to see our front 7 on defense be more dominant. They were pretty much missing all game.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by Duck07 »

nogerO wrote:Coaches.
Offense A: Moorhead had a really solid debut.

Huh? Run it up the gut on first down almost every single time? How about outside read once or twice? Put us in second and long the majority of the time. Breaking in a new QB and putting him in second and long every drive? Wow. Stanford stacked the box on first downs and then dropped 8 almost every series or blitzed and forced Shough to run. Pretty sure I'd give Moorehead a C or D and that's generous. Very disappointed. We beat a mediocre Stanford team missing a lot of pieces. WSU will watch the video and be ready for our offense so Moorehead better take the training wheels off and put Shough in more manageable situations. Guess I was watching another game.
So the problem on those early drives was that Shough wasn't making the right reads on the option so we ended up with runs up the middle that instead had the option for Shough to run to the outside if the dive-man went inside.

Once he took off it seemed to click for him as he trusted those reads and then those runs up the middle went for 6-7 because that dive-man wasn't able to dive onto the back of the RBs legs by staying outside to respect Shough running.

The follow-up for the Defense to that is that they'd bring another defender in close to contain Shough which is where the passes to DJ Johnson were so effective because it's built in to counter the shift made by the D.

That we weren't letting Herbert run last year on those same read options was what was infuriating for us to watch because the D never respected the QB run...until the Rose Bowl.
Image
User avatar
nogerO
Senior
Posts: 4517
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:48 pm
Location: Wyoming

Re: Game 1 Thoughts Grades on Re-Watch

Post by nogerO »

The problem was that he stubbornly kept handing it off to the dive man when the read was to pull and go outside as you say. Who is responsible for coaching that? Moorhead. Should have been fixed in the first quarter not the third. It was the first game so I'll rescind my original grade for Moorhead. I'll give him a C. Really was expecting more but again it was the first game. Let's see what he does in the Palouse against the weather and a team that has had our number for a long time.

Go Ducks!
"To give anything less than your best, is to sacrifice the gift." - Steve Prefontaine
Post Reply