Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

In the reading way too much into one blurb...
Devon Williams had a nice reception from Anthony Brown in a good-on-good period and also caught two passes from Tyler Shough in the final 11-on-11 period of the day. … Henry Katleman and Camden Lewis each made a 49-yard field goal in a pressure situation orchestrated by Cristobal.
Correct me if I'm wrong but typically the final 11 v 11 period is the #2 offense. Either way not a lot written about offensive success.
Image
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by lukeyrid13 »

I’d prefer Brown start.

But I expect Shough starts and plays the first 2-3 series, but if comes out flat again we see him replaced.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksTroll »

I wouldn’t be surprised to see Shough-Brown-Shough-Brown.

The worst possible system, the ol’ “two QBs means there is no QB” type of deal.

I’m still mad they didn’t put in Brown in the second half against Cal because it really looked like there was something wrong with Shough.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6461
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by pezsez1 »

I have a feeling we'll see Brown starting. I mean, Brown went in against USC during the game's biggest moments. If I'm choosing a QB to play the whole game, I'm choosing the guy who is most reliable when it really counts. We'll see, though. If Shough goes in, hopefully he plays the game of his life.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
ISU_Fan
One Star Recruit
Posts: 25
Joined: Mon Dec 21, 2020 9:22 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by ISU_Fan »

Duck07 wrote:I feel like this game will end up like our 2010 Rose Bowl against Ohio State only that we'll win it. ISU will move the ball and have untimely turnovers while we convert drives and scoring opportunities through being more physical.

It seemed like such a landmark game for us at the time and yet in what was seemingly a down year for the Buckeyes they still outplayed us.

All bets are off though if we get the Tyler Shough at QB we've seen through 6 games this season. It might be Vegas Bowl against BYU bad.
I don’t doubt how tough your team is but saying you guys will be more physical than us might be something you take back after the game. I could be wrong but we make our hay on being physical, especially on D and if your QB is gun shy that is just blood in the water. I think you guys could cause some serious issues with your D line though. Brock doesn’t get sacked often because he’s shifty but if you can get him out of the pocket then you will keep our O in check some. Breece somehow gets all his yards despite what can be atrocious play by our O line.
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

pezsez1 wrote:I have a feeling we'll see Brown starting. I mean, Brown went in against USC during the game's biggest moments. If I'm choosing a QB to play the whole game, I'm choosing the guy who is most reliable when it really counts. We'll see, though. If Shough goes in, hopefully he plays the game of his life.
Brown went in for very specific moments, which were short yardage situations or to try to run out the clock at the end of the game. He performed admirably in that role, and executed well, but the way people are talking on here, it’s like he was throwing darts downfield. It’s the classic situation of the backup QB being the most popular player on the team. He’s not a downfield threat, and you’d see a very limited playbook with Brown in there.

Nobody is trying to state that Shough hasn’t struggled, but he has better tools than Brown, so you try to let him work it out. I was watching clips of the UCLA game the other day, and in my opinion, it was night and day from how Shough looked at the end of the season. I personally think that constantly getting hit and pressured in the pocket due to a struggling o-line has got him rushing things back there and knocked down his confidence a bit. I’m hoping he’s able to turn it around, as this team has a much higher ceiling next year with Shough playing well than Brown.

I know people here seem to think Thompson is a shoe-in to start despite having never attended a collegiate practice, but if he’s starting that early, I don’t think it bodes well for next year either. Show me the number of true freshman QBs that led their teams to highly successful seasons. It’s incredibly rare, because there are expected growing pains in a starter’s first year, much like Shough is going through now. (I know it’s his 3rd year in the program, so he should be a finished product despite a new offense with 0 offseason and next to 0 game experience. That’s how my players progressed in NCAA Football ‘14!).
karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by karlhungis »

droop10 wrote: Nobody is trying to state that Shough hasn’t struggled, but he has better tools than Brown, so you try to let him work it out.
Is the bowl game really the time to let him try to "work it out?" I feel like that is supposed to happen against the weaker teams like Cal and OSU, where he struggled and continued his regression. I just have a very difficult time believing that a flip will be switched and he turns it around this game.


My guess is that he starts the game and stays in as long as he is effective and he gets pulled at the first sign of struggling.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
ducks5ever
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 936
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by ducks5ever »

I don't see how Shough is a downfield threat either. How many passes did he complete against USC that were 15 yards past the LOS again [not including yac]? I'm sure Brown can chuck the ball down the field and give the receivers a 50/50 ball too.

I have no idea what better tools you speak of. I would like to believe Brown has a better arm and more importantly has an inkling of an idea of what the defense is giving him. The OL play hasn't been great this year but OL play won't get any better in the span of 2 weeks and the fanbase wants to win this NY6 game. At least with Brown maybe they could move the pocket; has Shough ever thrown on the run.... no.

I'm tired of giving Shough such a hard time. He's 20 or 21 and has a world of expectations on him as the starting QB here. I'm sure he's a great person and would succeed in the right offense. It's just not the offense Moorehead runs around here. I wish him the best and hopefully we can move on from him.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

ISU_Fan wrote: I don’t doubt how tough your team is but saying you guys will be more physical than us might be something you take back after the game. I could be wrong but we make our hay on being physical, especially on D and if your QB is gun shy that is just blood in the water. I think you guys could cause some serious issues with your D line though. Brock doesn’t get sacked often because he’s shifty but if you can get him out of the pocket then you will keep our O in check some. Breece somehow gets all his yards despite what can be atrocious play by our O line.
I'm making a comparison to 2 games from a decade ago, one we lost and one we got embarrassed in.

I've yet to see a single ISU fan even think they could possibly lose this game, the confidence for your team is through the roof being the higher ranked team with seemingly better skill players on offense in your best season ever. This to me all sounds a lot like when Oregon was playing Ohio State in that Rose Bowl game and that y'all are in our shoes. Ohio State and Jim Tressell had time to scheme against us and made us pay for it by continually moving the chains on 3rd down, getting crucial stops and winning the turnover margin.

The Buckeyes didn't blow the doors off of us in that game but they did show us that we still had a lot to improve upon despite our improvements. That's what I see an Oregon win over Iowa State looking like.
Image
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

karlhungis wrote:
droop10 wrote: Nobody is trying to state that Shough hasn’t struggled, but he has better tools than Brown, so you try to let him work it out.
Is the bowl game really the time to let him try to "work it out?" I feel like that is supposed to happen against the weaker teams like Cal and OSU, where he struggled and continued his regression. I just have a very difficult time believing that a flip will be switched and he turns it around this game.


My guess is that he starts the game and stays in as long as he is effective and he gets pulled at the first sign of struggling.
Eh, I'm still of the mind that the bowl game is a meaningless game, along with the season. Of course I want the team to win, but I think using the time to try to develop the guys and get them game experience is more valuable than a win would be. This is exactly the time to give guys time to develop and prepare for next season. I still expect Brown to come in for the short yard packages, because he's more comfortable holding on to the ball on the read option, which gives the defense something extra to think about on those plays. If Shough looks absolutely horrid, maybe they bench him at half, but I'm not making the assumption that he'll play terribly as most here are.

Folks expect Brown to want to come back next year, but I don't think that's a certainty. He has graduated, been in school 5 years, and might just be ready to move on. So, how does it benefit the team to play him? They don't need recruiting momentum, as they've got plenty of that, and I don't see any additional benefit that it would provide beyond bragging rights. If they want to go crazy and put in Butterfield or Millen, I'm game for it, because what the hell? Might as well see what they've got. I just don't like giving playing time to a 5th year senior that isn't head over heels better than the other options.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

droop10 wrote: Brown went in for very specific moments, which were short yardage situations or to try to run out the clock at the end of the game. He performed admirably in that role, and executed well, but the way people are talking on here, it’s like he was throwing darts downfield. It’s the classic situation of the backup QB being the most popular player on the team. He’s not a downfield threat, and you’d see a very limited playbook with Brown in there.

Nobody is trying to state that Shough hasn’t struggled, but he has better tools than Brown, so you try to let him work it out. I was watching clips of the UCLA game the other day, and in my opinion, it was night and day from how Shough looked at the end of the season. I personally think that constantly getting hit and pressured in the pocket due to a struggling o-line has got him rushing things back there and knocked down his confidence a bit. I’m hoping he’s able to turn it around, as this team has a much higher ceiling next year with Shough playing well than Brown.

I know people here seem to think Thompson is a shoe-in to start despite having never attended a collegiate practice, but if he’s starting that early, I don’t think it bodes well for next year either. Show me the number of true freshman QBs that led their teams to highly successful seasons. It’s incredibly rare, because there are expected growing pains in a starter’s first year, much like Shough is going through now. (I know it’s his 3rd year in the program, so he should be a finished product despite a new offense with 0 offseason and next to 0 game experience. That’s how my players progressed in NCAA Football ‘14!).
Don't be daft on this.

Plenty of QB recruits have stepped into situations and had good years. Darron Thomas' time against BSU showed he was the truth as a True Freshmen. Mariota was capable of doing it as a True Freshman and if we got True Freshmen Herbert level performance next year from Thompson I'd feel great about our chances both next year and going forward.
Image
droop10
Freshman
Posts: 1439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:07 am

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by droop10 »

ducks5ever wrote:I don't see how Shough is a downfield threat either. How many passes did he complete against USC that were 15 yards past the LOS again [not including yac]? I'm sure Brown can chuck the ball down the field and give the receivers a 50/50 ball too.

I have no idea what better tools you speak of. I would like to believe Brown has a better arm and more importantly has an inkling of an idea of what the defense is giving him. The OL play hasn't been great this year but OL play won't get any better in the span of 2 weeks and the fanbase wants to win this NY6 game. At least with Brown maybe they could move the pocket; has Shough ever thrown on the run.... no.

I'm tired of giving Shough such a hard time. He's 20 or 21 and has a world of expectations on him as the starting QB here. I'm sure he's a great person and would succeed in the right offense. It's just not the offense Moorehead runs around here. I wish him the best and hopefully we can move on from him.
Well, we've got 3 years of evidence that Anthony Brown is an average QB with accuracy issues, and about 2-3 games of Tyler Shough struggling (I'm hesitant to say he had a terrible game at OSU, because he put up 38 points and nearly 300 yards of passing. Yes, he had a couple of mistakes, including a crucial pick at the end, but those are the kind of mistakes that young guys occasionally make). So, I'm willing to give more of the benefit of the doubt to the younger kid that showed flashes at the beginning of the year. You're singling out 1 game, where he clearly struggled, but to say he hasn't made some nice downfield passes in previous games is simply untrue. He has the ability to hit the deep pass, but has definitely rushed plays the last few games as the pocket has consistently collapsed fairly quickly. Just because you would like to think that Brown has a better arm doesn't make it the case. Shough's problems have been all mental in my opinion, and are not at all related to arm strength. I'm not sure if you only watched the SC game, and are making your entire assessment on just that game or if you can only remember back 1 game, but there have been plenty of times that Shough threw on the run.

Watch the clips of this game, and tell me he doesn't have good arm strength (not saying elite like Herbert, but good) and has never thrown on the run.



The RPO play that everyone is lauding Brown for executing, requires him to be running laterally each time it's run and Shough has executed it countless times throughout the season (not saying that's an impressive throw, but that's all the evidence people have of Brown's throwing ability and apparently that's enough to call for him to replace Shough). I'm not out here to say that Shough is the prototypical QB for this offense or that he's a future first round pick, but he's their best option right now and likely for next year. The fans here have been spoiled by great QB play over the years, and don't realize how hard it is to the play the position, and that it requires a learning curve. Not every QB comes in firing on all cylinders like Mariota. Then again, this is the fan base that also called for Herbert to be benched for Shough last year, and now lauds Herbert as a future Hall of Famer, so I should be used to it by now.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

Tyler Shough's single best throw this year, before half at WSU, is a prime example of him missing a wide open throw. That play should have been 6 and it all worked out fine, but against a decent team/cb that pass is deflected because he waited so long to throw it and it was late.

I'm done talking about him. He's a good kid who isn't cut out to be a major D1 QB because he's far too inconsistent.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6461
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by pezsez1 »

I've never heard Brown described as an average QB who is prone to mistakes until now.

Shough isn't ready to be our starter. I'm sure he's great in practice, but whatever he does on the practice field doesn't translate to games. He repeatedly fails to read defenses, he regularly underthrows receivers, and his reads are inconsistent. It's not that he's a bad QB, but it's as if every game is the first time he's played and he keeps making the same mistakes. He really does remind me of Dakota Prukop or maybe a more talented version of Jeff Lockie. It seems like he SHOULD be better -- and he would have been had he grown throughout the season -- but he didn't, and he's not.

Anthony Brown, to me, wins the job if he simply takes better care of the football. Shough is an unassisted turnover waiting to happen and that could kill us on Saturday.

Now, to switch gears... I don't think we'll be *more* physical than Iowa State. That's a pretty physical group. But I absolutely believe we could be equally physical. The USC game looked so much like last season's Utah game (both for the Pac-12 title)... in each game, it was as if the defense completely came together and dudes stepped up who we hadn't really seen all season. (Last year it was Brady Breeze... this year it was Jamal Hill.) If I had to place a bet, I'd wager last season's trajectory will repeat itself this season, and that the D will come with brass knuckles for the Fiesta Bowl. The offensive side of the ball is more of a question mark, but if our QB (whoever it is) can limit mistakes then I really like our chances to score lots of points. I hope we see more of Sean Dollars... he reminds me of Ken Simonton, perhaps lacking elite speed but just really good at finding lanes and using his blockers -- SO MUCH BETTER than Verdell at that, based on what little we saw against USC.

Like we did against USC, Oregon wins the talent battle against Iowa State. If we can equalize the physicality then we should win the game.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Wed Dec 30, 2020 10:27 am, edited 1 time in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
ducks5ever
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 936
Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm

Re: Fiesta Bowl: Iowa State vs Oregon (Jan. 2 Sat 1 PM ESPN)

Post by ducks5ever »

Again, I'm really done ragging on Shough but your commentary deserves an explanation.

Shough showed flashes at the beginning of the year because defenses didn't have much film on our scheme or Shough's QB play. That changes as the year goes on, and obviously defenses have a much better idea of how to handle Shough and the offense now. His downfield passes are decent but not necessarily that great either - this is the best WR core we've had since the MM days. This WR group has made up for a lot of Shough's shortcomings. I'm not saying it's all the WR's, it's just that we need to take into account their major contributions too. Arm strength - neither QB has shown to have a better arm, but that's what's wrong with claiming that Shough has better tools. What tools? You haven't mentioned any asides from possibly a better arm.

Putting up film of Shough against one of the worst pass defenses we faced this year (and one of the worst in the nation) is completely meaningless. I can put up a highlight reel of Dakota Prukop putting up giant numbers and nice passes against UVA or UC Davis. Does that mean that he is a good QB for the Pac-12... obviously not.

Thing that you are missing is that the expectation is that we field competitive teams with at minimum average (game-manager/no turnover) QB play. We bring in some great recruiting classes and we have what appears to be competent coaching. The fanbase wants to compete against some of the elite teams... that means that the team and QB have to show up for bigger games, like USC. USC is a fair benchmark to work off of for where we want to be, which is why I bring it up, not against one of the worst pass defenses in the nation.
Post Reply