The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the aisle

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Locked
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by buckmarkduck »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
Phenom wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.
They're not quite THAT close. Other big differences include how to tax the wealthiest Americans, whether all citizens should be entitled to healthcare, gun control, whether the federal minimum wage should be lifted, subsidies for education, investment in social services, attitudes toward immigration (hello Dreamers), support for religious freedom laws, investments in alternative energy and curbing man-made climate change.... those are just off the top of my head.

I'd even argue that liberals don't really focus on abortion as much as they do preserving access for women to receive healthcare... and conservatives often threaten that with a scorched-earth approach to abortion access. Each side frames the argument based on what they value most.

I think Democrats and Republicans used to be closer than they are currently, but the influence of the alt-right within the GOP has really pushed the party to the right. And now, perhaps as a reaction, you have the Berniecrats making noise and trying to take Democrats farther left. So far, though, the left's progressive wing hasn't had nearly the same impact as the right's Tea Party/alt-right wing. (Though I highly doubt Trump would have won had the GOP's "establishment" voters not been split among so many candidates during the primaries.)
I'm gonna have to disagree with this. There is a bit of an alt-right movement, but they have numbers in the thousands, maybe tens of thousands. They make up such a small percentage of the conservative right that without the media spotlighting them and giving guys like Milo Y and David Duke an outlet they'd essentially go unnoticed(Charlotesville not withstanding). I'm of the opinion that the left has shifted more than the right who has stayed grounded in their ideals(calling card of the right) while the left has changed their opinions on: Gay marriage, transgender laws, healthcare, relaxing on immigration, free speech etc just in the past decade. There has been a shift and the sides are certainly further apart, we can at least agree on that and it's just a matter of perspective I suppose.
Alt right is way bigger than "thousands".
I looked it up and there is no concrete number but KKK membership is around 7,000. There are obviously other radicals out there and I saw one estimate that around 140,000 right wing extremists/Alt-Right were out there. Definitely too large but not incredibly alarming. Now, I will say that if Trump had denounced them in primaries, and after Charlotesville things would presumably be very different. He needs PR help desperately, and by my and most estimates the voters/support he might lose by losing the Alt-Right wouldn't even affect his numbers. That's the only explanation I have for him not denouncing them whenever he can, is that he's afraid of losing some votes but he would be incredibly wise to bite the bullet on that front.
I'm convinced he doesn't want to win again. Of course I was convinced he didn't want to win to begin with and that's why he says half the dumb things he says.
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

buckmarkduck wrote:
Duck07 wrote:For those who do feel upset about showing any respect or positive sentiment towards the flag or the country, did you have those feelings prior to Kaepernick and if not, what changed with his kneeling?

Are the issues that they and others protesting getting worse or have they been increasing over time and relative to each generation?
I really wasnt mad or even giving it much thought when Kaep did it. My problem is players doing it to protest the President, who cares what he said? I liked how Seattle and Tennessee did it, not everyone wants to kneel and not everyone wants to stand, so go back to how the nfl used to do it until 2001 or whatever, and stay in the locker room. And my argument is and will continue to be the flag doesn't represent any president. I'm all for everyone having equal rights and I'd bet most here are for that.
It doesn't represent the current president, but it does represent a country that is falling short of its ideals of freedom and justice for all, and doing so to a troubling extent because of people like the president and the political forces that got him elected. Protesting during the anthem isn't about the flag or other national symbol representing the president; it's about pointing out the major shortcomings of our society and the awful people - like the president - who contribute to it.
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Groundswell »

lukeyrid13 wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
The easiest way to explain the differences at the Federal level is that a Democratic POTUS favors abortion while a Republican POTUS does not. Every single issue they all agree on except that one.
They're not quite THAT close. Other big differences include how to tax the wealthiest Americans, whether all citizens should be entitled to healthcare, gun control, whether the federal minimum wage should be lifted, subsidies for education, investment in social services, attitudes toward immigration (hello Dreamers), support for religious freedom laws, investments in alternative energy and curbing man-made climate change.... those are just off the top of my head.

I'd even argue that liberals don't really focus on abortion as much as they do preserving access for women to receive healthcare... and conservatives often threaten that with a scorched-earth approach to abortion access. Each side frames the argument based on what they value most.

I think Democrats and Republicans used to be closer than they are currently, but the influence of the alt-right within the GOP has really pushed the party to the right. And now, perhaps as a reaction, you have the Berniecrats making noise and trying to take Democrats farther left. So far, though, the left's progressive wing hasn't had nearly the same impact as the right's Tea Party/alt-right wing. (Though I highly doubt Trump would have won had the GOP's "establishment" voters not been split among so many candidates during the primaries.)
I'm gonna have to disagree with this. There is a bit of an alt-right movement, but they have numbers in the thousands, maybe tens of thousands. They make up such a small percentage of the conservative right that without the media spotlighting them and giving guys like Milo Y and David Duke an outlet they'd essentially go unnoticed(Charlotesville not withstanding). I'm of the opinion that the left has shifted more than the right who has stayed grounded in their ideals(calling card of the right) while the left has changed their opinions on: Gay marriage, transgender laws, healthcare, relaxing on immigration, free speech etc just in the past decade. There has been a shift and the sides are certainly further apart, we can at least agree on that and it's just a matter of perspective I suppose.
The Alt-Right gets a lot of press because the leaders have/had key positions in the Trump presidency. They basically ran his campaign and shaped his strategy. Those thousands you looked up are all on the internet spreading their ideology, which was used to great affect/effect to influence voters. The Wall and the other resentment propaganda Trump uses came straight from them. He was never going to build a wall and isn't. He doesn't care about the National Anthem and never will. He doesn't care about Religion. Abortion. Gun rights. Nada. But the Alt-Right taught him how to win the presidency by ginning up controversy. The Alt-Rights numbers might not be huge, but their influence has been tremendous. They know there are a lot of pissed off white people, and they are taking advantage. And so some well-meaning Americans get lumped into that group by the Left because those influences are working on them. In the same way not every Lefty is a Feminazi or a Libtard or a Commie.

Edit: If anybody wants to read a Lefty rags take on Brietbart, Bannon, and the Alt Left, this article is interesting. It's long. It's academicish. And I don't recommend it to any but the supremely curious. But it covers the alliance to Trump, and the numbers and influence, and how they all came to work together and the Alt Right doesn't show up until the second half of the article:

https://www.jacobinmag.com/2016/11/brei ... och-trump/
Last edited by Groundswell on Wed Sep 27, 2017 7:12 pm, edited 1 time in total.
User avatar
Kimber45
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2011 5:39 pm
Location: Alaska

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Kimber45 »

*Enter Village Idiot; Stage Left*

1. What a wonderful thread. Honestly one of the best, most rational discussions about the whole kneeling thing I have read anywhere on the interwebs. Kudos to everyone.

2. I stood watch in far away places so that all Americans could have their right to speak freely. And that includes hate speech, whether from Antifa or the KKK, as well as people who express themselves by opting to kneel during the National Anthem.

3. The Star Spangled Banner is an homage to the United States of America. Kneeling during the Star Spangled Banner is protestation against the United States of America.

4. If you kneel to protest during the Star Spangled Banner you're a schmuk.
Grantduck wrote:The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.
Who defines the "ideals" you speak of? The Founding Fathers? The troops that gave their lives in service of their country? Millennial social justice warriors?

[quote=""Hoagduck"] I can personally attest that my Grandpa Horace was pretty racist, and even worse a USC fan! He also would've hated players kneeling, so if you hate players kneeling, you're not necessarily a racist of course, but you are inarguably on the same side as racists, and you need to look within yourself and ask if you're okay with that.[/quote]
You'll get further in conversation if you don't end your comments with a conversation ender. RACISIM!!! ERRYWHERE!!!
Phalanx wrote: This post betrays a startling lack of understanding of the political landscape in the U.S, and probably what the word 'conservative' means. Trump has never been thought of as a 'conservative' - the man was a Democrat until only a few years ago. He is completely on his own program. The conservative element in the House and Senate is constantly at odds with the leadership in both parties - they aren't close to a majority in either. Moreover, if conservatives held the Supreme Court, murdering babies would definitely be illegal by now.
The Bernie Bros think they are the revolution. The actual revolution, as you point out, is currently happening within and between the establishment Rs and the independents/libertarians/moderates/conservatives who feel abandoned by the uniparty.
Pez wrote: I didn't go to any Duck games last year, and I probably won't go to any this year. Part of the reason is money -- I could justify a couple games, but the budget would get tight -- but part of the reason is honestly the national anthem. It would take a lot to make me sit. For now, though, standing through it makes me feel ill. Had to do it the other night at a high school football game, and honestly I felt like a fraud. I'd rather stay in the locker room than go anywhere near the flag or the anthem. In other words, best for me to stay home and barbecue where I can sit in peace.
There's always Canada. And as a distance runner it shouldn't cost much to stop by a Starbucks and then head north from Seattle. Post us a postcard from Bellingham perhaps.
Duckenstein wrote: Definitely, media seems to favor Democrats over Republicans but one can make a good argument that the Democratic Party is center right on most issues. Which issues are the Democrats to the left? Yes, they talk a good game, but they don't generally pursue leftist policy.
Does the Patient Portability and Afforadable Care Act ring any bells?
Lukeyrid13 wrote: I'm gonna have to disagree with this. There is a bit of an alt-right movement, but they have numbers in the thousands, maybe tens of thousands.
Point of order here. Two maybe. First, who defines the term 'Alt-Right'? To me Alt-Right represents the new wing of the conservative party battling within the conservative establishment. I'm proudly Alt-Right. Your definition seems to incorporate a rebranding of the term "White Supremacist". I disagree. IMO the Left have, yet again, coopted language to control the populace. If being Alt-Right is synonymous with being a White Supremacist then why not just refer to use the latter term?
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by lukeyrid13 »

http://www.dailywire.com/news/8638/what ... n-shapiro#


I am going off of Ben Shapiro's definition of the Alt-Right because he is way smarter than I pertain to be.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by GrantDuck »

Kimber45
Grantduck wrote:The thing for me is that the flag/anthem don't represent "troops". They represent the ideals the United States stands for and that the troops fought for. If the anthem/flag no longer stand for those ideals, then I can't in good conscience stand for ideals so starkly and drastically opposed to that. Ideals that undermine who we are as a people, who I am as a person, and what so many fought and died for.
Who defines the "ideals" you speak of? The Founding Fathers? The troops that gave their lives in service of their country? Millennial social justice warriors?

We do collectively as a nation and as individuals, based on our history and founders, primarily. The Founding Fathers, the troops, even the whiny and often ignorant SJW's get a say.

Freedom, individual liberty, welcoming to the oppressed regardless of race or religion as is written on the Statue of Liberty, those are the ideals that I believe America was founded on and that's what the flag stands for. Lincoln and the constitution are big influences for me , personally in my understanding and shaping of those ideals. That's what the flag and my national pride has always been based in.

Right now, collectively, as a nation, we are no longer espousing those core values, and I can't portray some false nationalistic pride in something I don't believe in. It doesn't mean I want to give up, it means I want to promote change and dedicate my life to changing those things and make America the place that it deserves to be again. I try and do that every day, even if my individual role means very little on a larger scale.
User avatar
Kimber45
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2011 5:39 pm
Location: Alaska

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Kimber45 »

lukeyrid13 wrote:http://www.dailywire.com/news/8638/what ... n-shapiro#


I am going off of Ben Shapiro's definition of the Alt-Right because he is way smarter than I pertain to be.
Love Ben Shapiro but he's wrong about this. The Alternative-Right is the ongoing movement within the Right Wing party. The Left has usurped the term to connote radical right-wing ideology/white supremacy. Same with the term White Nationalism. Both are intended to dog whistle 'white supremacy' without having to say the words.

Not arguing with you. Only pointing out that the term Alt-Right apparently means two very different things between us.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6487
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by pezsez1 »

Right now, collectively, as a nation, we are no longer espousing those core values, and I can't portray some false nationalistic pride in something I don't believe in. It doesn't mean I want to give up, it means I want to promote change and dedicate my life to changing those things and make America the place that it deserves to be again. I try and do that every day, even if my individual role means very little on a larger scale.
Exactly.

Run away to Canada? Why? The majority of Americans still think and believe as I do. Our government is strangely out of sync with the nation's majority heartbeat, but this isn't permanent. For all I know -- thanks largely to gerrymandering and congress refusing to seat Obama's SCOTUS justice -- this awkward social/political imbalance could last a lifetime. But anything I can do to help restore balance makes staying well worth it. That's what patriotism is all about. You can be a patriot and still be disgusted by your countrymen. For some, patriotism means taking a knee when the country's predominant demographic has turned a blind eye to their needs.

Also, the "you can move to Canada" thing is a complete myth. It's incredibly difficult to move to Canada. You pretty much need to already have a job there (a good one) and learn to speak French. I'm doing quite well for myself here in the United States. I'm white, male, educated, and I get healthcare through my employer. I've got privilege to burn. But it's not my own personal hardships (or lack thereof) that makes me ashamed to be an American right now.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Wed Sep 27, 2017 9:04 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Kimber45
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 498
Joined: Fri Aug 26, 2011 5:39 pm
Location: Alaska

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Kimber45 »

@GrantDuck and Pez.

Well, at least you guys are honest about it.

You'll kneel during the Nation Anthem to protest America.

I can't respect that.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6487
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by pezsez1 »

You'll kneel during the Nation Anthem to protest America.
I specifically said up above that I'd stand, not kneel. I stood through it just last week. (And wtf does "to protest America" even mean?)

I'm just saying it makes me feel sick and ashamed, so I'd rather just avoid the anthem entirely.

Frankly, I couldn't care less whether you respect that. I don't need anyone's respect or permission to sit, stand, kneel or do cartwheels. If you're not proud of this country -- and when you have a president who acts more like a 14-year-old mean girl than the leader of the free world -- then it's just another song.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Wed Sep 27, 2017 9:20 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

Kimber45 wrote:@GrantDuck and Pez.

Well, at least you guys are honest about it.

You'll kneel during the Nation Anthem to protest America.

I can't respect that.
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is. In other words, they'd be doing something to help express some hard truths about America in order to help America become better that it currently is. If you can't respect people trying to improve America, then it's hard to think that you like America and respect America as much as you say you.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6487
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by pezsez1 »

They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
lukeyrid13
All-American
Posts: 10475
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
GM: Portland TrailBlazers

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by lukeyrid13 »

pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
As I said before, I don't want to start a vitriolic argument but instead a civil discussion....but in what ways is the gov't racist and where do we see systemic racism? I am fully against racism, but outside of a few nut jobs in Charlottesville, where is all this racism affecting the average American?
Groundswell
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 753
Joined: Sun Jan 08, 2017 3:36 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Groundswell »

Kimber45 wrote:*Enter Village Idiot; Stage Left*

1. What a wonderful thread. Honestly one of the best, most rational discussions about the whole kneeling thing I have read anywhere on the interwebs. Kudos to everyone.

2. I stood watch in far away places so that all Americans could have their right to speak freely. And that includes hate speech, whether from Antifa or the KKK, as well as people who express themselves by opting to kneel during the National Anthem.

3. The Star Spangled Banner is an homage to the United States of America. Kneeling during the Star Spangled Banner is protestation against the United States of America.
I wish you would have stopped right here. Most everybody is trying to do their best not to call names and tell people to move to Canada or whatever. The reason this thread is impressive is because people are trying.

PS. The Affordable Care Act is a center-Right bill. It was taken directly from the GOP. The Republican drafted a very similar bill in reaction to "Hillarycare" when Bill Clinton was president. That was their way of trying to offer an alternative. Romney later used it in Massachusetts. Obamacare is a centrist piece of legislation. Or at least it was 15 years ago.
Last edited by Groundswell on Wed Sep 27, 2017 10:24 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Handsome Dan
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 688
Joined: Sat Jul 03, 2010 3:04 am

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Handsome Dan »

pezsez1 wrote:
They said they'd protest the disparity between what America says it is and what it actually is.
I didn't say that, either. I'm not protesting anything. But I'm firmly behind the protesters. If pressed, I'd rather kneel with them than pretend racism is dead and that everything is tremendous and beautiful.

You know who I have zero respect for? The hypocritical idiots who boo the national anthem protesters. You can't be against anthem protests and then protest them during the anthem. That's not how life works.
That's what I was getting at. I put it in an inaccurate frame because of the post I was responding to and some laziness.
Last edited by Handsome Dan on Wed Sep 27, 2017 9:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Locked