buckmarkduck wrote:Marshall actually has vision and is willing to hit people, Lache had one vision, the sideline, and avoided contact at all cost. IMO the only comparison is that they are both RB. Marshall is 190-195 right now and could put on another 10-15 lbs with ease over the next couple of years.
I think Tra will be a factor, but won't be a big factor until 2013 when he's a JR. Although by then it could be the Marshall and Tyner show. Having to many RB is a great problem to have though, much better than having to play a DB (Whitehead) at RB. Who is one of my favorite ducks of all time btw, but he should have played D.
Totally agree, except I think Whitehead was a linebacker.
The changes that Carson needs to make is simply natural, physical maturation. Given our history of RBs I don't think anyone is going out on a limb by saying that he's going to do just fine next year. Granted, I think we'd all be shocked if Tra went on to break all of LMJ's college records too, but I didn't see anything from him this year that has me thinking he won't be another stud RB for us.
As for Marshall, I imagine the coaches would probably try to RS him next year which might be why he could be looking elsewhere.
Duck07 wrote:The changes that Carson needs to make is simply natural, physical maturation. Given our history of RBs I don't think anyone is going out on a limb by saying that he's going to do just fine next year. Granted, I think we'd all be shocked if Tra went on to break all of LMJ's college records too, but I didn't see anything from him this year that has me thinking he won't be another stud RB for us.
As for Marshall, I imagine the coaches would probably try to RS him next year which might be why he could be looking elsewhere.
I don't think there's any chance he redshirts unless we get another RB this year that's more ready than him. I mean, we've got KB, Tra, and some walk-ons. I guess you can count DAT there, but he plays TZR primarily.
oregontrack wrote:whitehead was a hell of a pro style tailback.
Guy had the filthiest cut back I've ever seen. It as unstoppable ha.
My only beef with Whitehead...WHY WAS HE SO FAT IN '05?! Haha.
As far as Tra Carson, Gary Campbell has already said he (along with DAT) is probably the hardest working and knowledgeable true freshman he's seen through this program. I have confidence he will progress well.
Duck07 wrote:The changes that Carson needs to make is simply natural, physical maturation. Given our history of RBs I don't think anyone is going out on a limb by saying that he's going to do just fine next year. Granted, I think we'd all be shocked if Tra went on to break all of LMJ's college records too, but I didn't see anything from him this year that has me thinking he won't be another stud RB for us.
As for Marshall, I imagine the coaches would probably try to RS him next year which might be why he could be looking elsewhere.
I don't think there's any chance he redshirts unless we get another RB this year that's more ready than him. I mean, we've got KB, Tra, and some walk-ons. I guess you can count DAT there, but he plays TZR primarily.
Forde looked really good for being just a walk on.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
Duck07 wrote:The changes that Carson needs to make is simply natural, physical maturation. Given our history of RBs I don't think anyone is going out on a limb by saying that he's going to do just fine next year. Granted, I think we'd all be shocked if Tra went on to break all of LMJ's college records too, but I didn't see anything from him this year that has me thinking he won't be another stud RB for us.
As for Marshall, I imagine the coaches would probably try to RS him next year which might be why he could be looking elsewhere.
+1
The guy took some garbage time reps this year... running behind 3rd string offensive lineman... with the entire defense knowing we're running the clock out.
And people are shocked he didn't get 7 yards per carry.
As long as he stays the course and continues to work hard... I think he will be a 1,000 yard rusher next year.
I don't know why people are so hard on Carson, he did pretty good this year, he just had two great RB's in LMJ and KB in front of him, and he had a freak of nature in DAT in front of him. He may not be a huge superstar, but one thing I guarantee you is that this off-season, he will work his but off with DAT. I still think Carson will be the next J Stew by the time he's a JR. I have high expectations for him.
Boom wrote:
As long as he stays the course and continues to work hard... I think he will be a 1,000 yard rusher next year.
Seriously? The only chance of that is if there are injuries. Otherwise, the best case scenario for Tra is that he will rank third on the team in running back carries next season, behind Barner and DAT. Needless to say, that won't even get him in the same zip code of 1,000 yards. Heck, Barner didn't even reach 1,000 yards as the primary backup/starter for a few games.
OregonFan4Life wrote:I still think Carson will be the next J Stew by the time he's a JR.
I assume you mean a significantly slower version of J Stew?
J Stew got faster during his career at Oregon, why can't Carson?
Dude, J Stew was significantly faster before he ever came to Oregon than Carson ever was, or ever will be. That is an irrefutable fact that just isn't going to change. Asking why Carson can't become as fast as J Stew is like asking why Darron Thomas can't become as fast as Dennis Dixon. One of the players in the comparison is significantly faster than the other, that is why.
Speed has always been an issue with Carson. That is why the Ducks were initially reluctant to offer him a scholarship. It is something that will never be a strength for him, but he can take steps to minimize it as a weakness and accentuate the strengths he does bring to the table.
Boom wrote:
As long as he stays the course and continues to work hard... I think he will be a 1,000 yard rusher next year.
Seriously? The only chance of that is if there are injuries. Otherwise, the best case scenario for Tra is that he will rank third on the team in running back carries next season, behind Barner and DAT. Needless to say, that won't even get him in the same zip code of 1,000 yards. Heck, Barner didn't even reach 1,000 yards as the primary backup/starter for a few games.
Seriously. In 2008 we had JJ and LG toting the rock for 1000 yards each. DAT will get carries no doubt, but as I mentioned earlier, I think DAT will end up getting the bulk of his yards in the form of receptions and not carries. Now it might be more realistic if Carson only gets around 800 yards and falls short of 1000 but either way I don't think KB gets as many carries per game as LMJ did the last two years and that means more of those "bulk" carries will go to Carson in my estimation because he's an entirely different back than KB or DAT.
Seriously, we almost had a 2000 yard rusher and a 1000 yard rusher this last season. Our offensive line will improve. We play a creampuff schedule and 7 home games. We ran for over 4000 yards as a team. I don't think its out of the realm of possibility to see KB around 1300 yards with Carson and DAT around 800 each while DT, Forde, Huff, BB and others fill in the rest of those yards.
Duck07 wrote:Now it might be more realistic if Carson only gets around 800 yards and falls short of 1000 but either way I don't think KB gets as many carries per game as LMJ did the last two years and that means more of those "bulk" carries will go to Carson in my estimation because he's an entirely different back than KB or DAT.
Did you watch the Arizona State game this past season? That was a mini preview of what is to come, against a good opponent in a close game with LMJ injured. Barner carried the bulk of the load at RB, DAT was the primary backup RB while also factoring into the passing game (just like he will next season) and Carson was a non-factor with 1 carry. I am not saying that Carson is necessarily going to be a non-factor this upcoming season, but being a "different" back didn't get him more carries than Barner or DAT this past season and there is absolutely no reason to believe being "different" will get him more carries than either of them next season. The reason for this is because the coaches don't give a rat's ass about players being "different," they care about getting the ball to their best players. Barner and DAT are clearly the best running backs on the roster, thus they will get the bulk of the carries.
Seriously though, barring injuries, there is a 0% chance Carson breaks 1,000 yards next season.