Green & Houston

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3314
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by GrandpaDuck »

I do think Armstead enters into the draft regardless of what the NFL report tells him. I think his mind is set. Hope I'm wrong.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Green & Houston

Post by Duck07 »

GrandpaDuck wrote:Every school that Green appears to have a heavy interest in runs a 3-4.

Armstead would be a DT in a 4-3.

In the NFL he projects as 3-4 DE, just as he plays now.

Are there any 4-3's left other than Cal in the PAC-12? Stanford, UO, USC, UCLA, Utah, UW are all 3-4 and Arizona is a 3-3-5. 4-3 defenses are very vulnerable to Tempo teams who can pass and run and Spread teams. With half the PAC being both you can see why the only team that switched from a 3-4 to a 4-3 is by far the worse defense in the league.

I have seen Armstead projected in the 1st round as late as last week, but that is by media types going off hype. When the actual NFL people review film, I would be shocked if he goes higher than 5th round this year. I could be wrong as I am not an NFL draft honk by any means, but he is not a top 5 DE in this league let alone nationally at this point. Taylor Hart went in the 5th round. Does anyone think Armstead is anywhere near the player Hart was or Buckner is?
Utah still is a 43 Defense. I disagree about 43 D's being vulnerable to tempo teams, its really about personnel and how the defense attacks the offense. Most 34 and 43 teams don't stay in their base against those teams anyways because most tempo teams have at least 3 wrs on the field so how they play in their nickel D is usually more telling.
Image
duckphanatic23
One Star Recruit
Posts: 84
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:27 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by duckphanatic23 »

He may be best suited to be on the O-Line. I thought he came to Oregon as one of the best OT in the country. With no D-Line he kind of went that way...no?
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Green & Houston

Post by Duck07 »

duckphanatic23 wrote:He may be best suited to be on the O-Line. I thought he came to Oregon as one of the best OT in the country. With no D-Line he kind of went that way...no?
His brother Armond played DL as well and we let him decide what he wanted to do. Aut
Image
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3314
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Duck07 wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:Every school that Green appears to have a heavy interest in runs a 3-4.

Armstead would be a DT in a 4-3.

In the NFL he projects as 3-4 DE, just as he plays now.

Are there any 4-3's left other than Cal in the PAC-12? Stanford, UO, USC, UCLA, Utah, UW are all 3-4 and Arizona is a 3-3-5. 4-3 defenses are very vulnerable to Tempo teams who can pass and run and Spread teams. With half the PAC being both you can see why the only team that switched from a 3-4 to a 4-3 is by far the worse defense in the league.

I have seen Armstead projected in the 1st round as late as last week, but that is by media types going off hype. When the actual NFL people review film, I would be shocked if he goes higher than 5th round this year. I could be wrong as I am not an NFL draft honk by any means, but he is not a top 5 DE in this league let alone nationally at this point. Taylor Hart went in the 5th round. Does anyone think Armstead is anywhere near the player Hart was or Buckner is?
Utah still is a 43 Defense. I disagree about 43 D's being vulnerable to tempo teams, its really about personnel and how the defense attacks the offense. Most 34 and 43 teams don't stay in their base against those teams anyways because most tempo teams have at least 3 wrs on the field so how they play in their nickel D is usually more telling.
If a 4-3 team doesn't play a 4-3 against tempo teams, and most of the games on their schedule are against tempo teams are they truly a 4-3 team or our they 4-2-5 who occasionally plays a 4-3 depending on the opponent?

I haven't seen Utah play much this year but aren't they a flex team that a plays 4-3 with 3-4 personnel? Orchard is 255 pounds and his backup is 215 pounds, not a prototypical 4-3 DE set-up.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Green & Houston

Post by Duck07 »

All a 43 really is, is a 1-gap attacking scheme. A 34 is just a 2-gap scheme. Running out your nickel/dime packages usually doesn't change that although some 34 teams DO 1-gap in some passing situations.

Undersized DE's absolutely are the norm for a 43 scheme because they are fast and not meant to be run-stoppers. Nick Reed, Kenny Rowe and Torrodney Prevot in HS are all classic 43 DEs.

A 425 D is also usually a 1-gap scheme and that 5th DB is usually a SS who can blitz (Anthony Trucks was a great 5th DB) but if you bring a 3rd CB on, its not considered a 425 even if the personnel grouping could be called as much. I would call Michigan a spread tempo team and I saw Utah stay in a ton of 43 groupings throughout that game. Orchard might stand up at times, but his responsibilities are still the same.

When you look at Philly and Chip, come 3rd and long, they don't look like a 34 Defense but a 43 Defense. Its all about creating packages that work in specific situation and its a major reason why we are so atrocious on 3rd and long.
Image
rjfrik
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 101
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 10:26 am

Re: Green & Houston

Post by rjfrik »

This is why I think he stays. I just don’t see him going in the first or second round this year and I honestly believe if Arik comes back he will be a first round guy the following year. He needs to get stronger and develop his technique.


Duck07 wrote:
mdm0302 wrote:
Duck07 wrote:No F'in way is Armstead a first rounder this year. What have you guys seen that I haven't?
what round do you think he goes?
With what he's done this season, he's a 5th rounder but he'll get a grade from the NFL that says return to school. The NFL has changed grading policies so if you're not considered a lock (or near lock) as a 1st or 2nd, they tell you to go back to school now so guys no longer get mid-round grades.

Now before you talk potential, teams will see him right now as having more potential to take 2 years and learn OT than they will to think he'll be a starter at 5tech DE in a 3-4. Some team might think he has potential as a 1-gapping DT, but again, a team would really have to project Arik to do things that he has not shown at this point. He needs to stay another year, get stronger and work on his leverage/hands so that by next season, he is showing teams how dominant he can be at the point of attack and be a 3 down player.
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3314
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Duck07 wrote:All a 43 really is, is a 1-gap attacking scheme. A 34 is just a 2-gap scheme. Running out your nickel/dime packages usually doesn't change that although some 34 teams DO 1-gap in some passing situations.

............
I think you need a better differentiation between a 4-3 and 3-4 than one gap versus 2 gap as almost all 3-4s also one gap in a range between occasionally to most of the time.

Every defense can call themselves whatever the heck they want in their press releases, as Oregon has often done. But to the quick observer trying to relate across the various team specific terminologies the first number 3 or 4 is the number of hands down linemen. Now if your 4th linemen stands but never has pass coverage responsibilities I wouldn't debate if you called that a 4 man front.

I haven't seen Utah play a tempo team in 2014, just saw a little of them against OSU the anti-tempo. I did see that Orchard's backup is 215 pounds and I had read Utah had gone more 3-4 in 2013 so assumed they must play some 3-4.
skdragon1
Two Star Recruit
Posts: 114
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:24 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by skdragon1 »

Good point by GrandpaDuck. Simply comparing the formations by gap responsibilities is not accurate. For example, Wade Phillips only ran 3-4s, but they were all one-gapping 3-4s, - you know the 3-4 defense that JJ Watt, the DE, blew up in. Would be very interested in seeing us run something like that, having Armstead and Buckner penetrate more.
User avatar
Phenom
All Pac-12
Posts: 9914
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:49 am

Re: Green & Houston

Post by Phenom »

What Watt is doing from the 3-4 DE position is unprecedented. I don't think it's ever been done before.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Green & Houston

Post by Duck07 »

GrandpaDuck wrote:
Duck07 wrote:All a 43 really is, is a 1-gap attacking scheme. A 34 is just a 2-gap scheme. Running out your nickel/dime packages usually doesn't change that although some 34 teams DO 1-gap in some passing situations.

............
I think you need a better differentiation between a 4-3 and 3-4 than one gap versus 2 gap as almost all 3-4s also one gap in a range between occasionally to most of the time.

Every defense can call themselves whatever the heck they want in their press releases, as Oregon has often done. But to the quick observer trying to relate across the various team specific terminologies the first number 3 or 4 is the number of hands down linemen. Now if your 4th linemen stands but never has pass coverage responsibilities I wouldn't debate if you called that a 4 man front.


I haven't seen Utah play a tempo team in 2014, just saw a little of them against OSU the anti-tempo. I did see that Orchard's backup is 215 pounds and I had read Utah had gone more 3-4 in 2013 so assumed they must play some 3-4.
I was merely trying to make a general point rather a dissertation, I think by and large most will agree that 43 Defenses are 1 gap and 34 Defenses are 2 gap, right? Shall we get into some of the common differences in coverages and really split every hair if we want to argue every detail or difference? I don't.

This all stems from your statement about 43 teams not being in a 43 against tempo teams (or being any good against them) when all they are in is simply a sub package, not anything different schematically.
skdragon1 wrote:Good point by GrandpaDuck. Simply comparing the formations by gap responsibilities is not accurate. For example, Wade Phillips only ran 3-4s, but they were all one-gapping 3-4s, - you know the 3-4 defense that JJ Watt, the DE, blew up in. Would be very interested in seeing us run something like that, having Armstead and Buckner penetrate more.
Yup, the one D that is different. They also run a lot of nickel packages with 4 down lineman in those defenses by Wade Phillips, but of course you know that.
Image
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3314
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Duck07 wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
Duck07 wrote:All a 43 really is, is a 1-gap attacking scheme. A 34 is just a 2-gap scheme. Running out your nickel/dime packages usually doesn't change that although some 34 teams DO 1-gap in some passing situations.

............
I think you need a better differentiation between a 4-3 and 3-4 than one gap versus 2 gap as almost all 3-4s also one gap in a range between occasionally to most of the time.

Every defense can call themselves whatever the heck they want in their press releases, as Oregon has often done. But to the quick observer trying to relate across the various team specific terminologies the first number 3 or 4 is the number of hands down linemen. Now if your 4th linemen stands but never has pass coverage responsibilities I wouldn't debate if you called that a 4 man front.


I haven't seen Utah play a tempo team in 2014, just saw a little of them against OSU the anti-tempo. I did see that Orchard's backup is 215 pounds and I had read Utah had gone more 3-4 in 2013 so assumed they must play some 3-4.
I was merely trying to make a general point rather a dissertation, I think by and large most will agree that 43 Defenses are 1 gap and 34 Defenses are 2 gap, right? Shall we get into some of the common differences in coverages and really split every hair if we want to argue every detail or difference? I don't.

This all stems from your statement about 43 teams not being in a 43 against tempo teams (or being any good against them) when all they are in is simply a sub package, not anything different schematically.
skdragon1 wrote:Good point by GrandpaDuck. Simply comparing the formations by gap responsibilities is not accurate. For example, Wade Phillips only ran 3-4s, but they were all one-gapping 3-4s, - you know the 3-4 defense that JJ Watt, the DE, blew up in. Would be very interested in seeing us run something like that, having Armstead and Buckner penetrate more.
Yup, the one D that is different. They also run a lot of nickel packages with 4 down lineman in those defenses by Wade Phillips, but of course you know that.
Most of our disagreement is in terminology. I see a team playing a 4-2-5 on most 1st and 10s as a different base defense than a team playing a 4-3-4 on most first downs. If the same team bounces between a 4-2-5 and a 4-3 as the base 1st and 10 defense depending on the opponent, to me that is a team I would categorize as either a 4 Man Front (or an Even Front) playing multiple defenses. You see that team as a 4-3 playing a sub-package against a particular opponent. Neither is right or wrong, as there is so much grey area in football terminology.

My original point was that classic 4-3s playing 4 down linemen with 3 big linebackers (not a safety playing SOLB) on most 1st and 10s get abused by tempo teams. 5 years ago that was the majority of the teams in the PAC-12, now it is virtually nobody. And most of the teams have changed to an odd front not to a variation of a 1 gap even front.

That is what the original discussion was about, a desire by some posters that we should go away from the 3-4 which has proven to be the most effective PAC-10 defense and is what most teams that have been less effective have moved to. What teams have successfully moved from a 3-4 to an even front in the PAC-12 in the last few years? There are many cases of significant improvement going from even to odd.
User avatar
EncinitasDuck
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1158
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 6:45 pm
Location: Grants Pass Oregon

Re: Green & Houston

Post by EncinitasDuck »

So about Green and Houston... Does the detour of this thread mean we've given up all hope?
woundedknees
All-American
Posts: 12826
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:06 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by woundedknees »

EncinitasDuck wrote:So about Green and Houston... Does the detour of this thread mean we've given up all hope?
As in, "Abandon Hope, All Ye Who Enter Here"?

I have no clue...
Autzen Stadium... Where great teams go to die...Hard!

Image
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: Green & Houston

Post by Tray Dub »

EncinitasDuck wrote:So about Green and Houston... Does the detour of this thread mean we've given up all hope?
Pretty sure it just means this is an online forum and that's what happens. TK1 said they really enjoyed their visit.
Post Reply