Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Greenblood
Senior
Posts: 3466
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:16 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by Greenblood »

northbeachsf wrote:If you look at the Fremeau Efficiency Index (FEI), our defense was actually solid in 2014. The FEI considers each of the nearly 20,000 possessions every season in major college football. All drives are filtered to eliminate first-half clock-kills and end-of-game garbage drives and scores. A scoring rate analysis of the remaining possessions then determines the baseline possession efficiency expectations against which each team is measured.

Oregon's defensive FEI rank last year? No. 14.
Basically, that means WHEN IN MATTERED in games, Oregon was in the Top 15 for preventing their opponent from scoring.

Thanks, Northbeach. These are the kinds of stats I was trying to point out on this board on a number of occasions late last year. What makes such rankings all the more amazing is that they are cumulative (of course) for the whole year to that point, meaning that late last year, when I think we all saw the significant uptick in the performance of the D, Pellum's D was arguably playing as well as almost any team in the nation's D.

Yes, we're trying (I think) to talk about this year's Duck D, but some of the negative criticism about this year's seems to be that it's a continuation of the "same ol'" from Pellum, which I think that Northbeach has shown is a gross mischaracterization. Yes, I think we all agree that we hope this year's D performs better than it has so far. But I don't think that the D has truly "cost" us this year, as we barely lost a game that the oddsmakers had us losing, and I don't think the D was anymore at fault than the O was.

The proof will be in the pudding, beginning this week. As long as the Ducks can score more points than their opponent week after week, then I guess the D is playing well enough.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

As long as the Ducks can score more points than their opponent week after week, then I guess the D is playing well enough.
I'd amend this to say, "as long as the defense is putting the offense in position to score more than their opponents, then it's playing well enough."

That's what past Oregon defenses have excelled at, but it's where this one may struggle against pass-heavy teams. Against MSU, though, the defense did its job, and it was the offense that didn't show up for three quarters. We'll win the conference championship this year if the D can play as well as it did against MSU, but we don't stand a chance if our offense is that anemic for such long stretches of the game.

In fact, the Utah game could be as much of a litmus test for our offense as it is for our defense. We beat up on two FCS teams that aren't very good defensively, but then we were anemic in our only matchup against a skilled defensive unit.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

I absolutely think we should sell out on the run and force Utah to try and beat us through the air. We may give up yards, but we should capitalize off some turnovers that way. I also agree that we should bring pressure in this game. Wilson is dinged and he is not going to want to get hit.

I see people screaming about not blitzing more and bringing pressure, but I believe it depends on the opponent and the situation. As an example, I would be willing to bet that not too many people know that Conner Cook has a 70+% completion rate and 14 TDs and ZERO INTs against the blitz over the past two season. Still want to blitz him?

The defensive game plan against MSU was solid and as Pezsez stated above, it was the offense that cost us that game (7 first half points / 21 total points). That is not going to get it done against any team.
duckfan22 wrote:it will be interesting to see Oregon against Utah. Do we see the Ducks play a 4-3 that i have heard they
have worked on in practice? Will they bring the linebackers up closer? I think because Utah is a better
running team then passing do we dare them to pass? Booker is the real deal at running back. We need to
keep him in check the best we can. Utah likes to use play action also and booker is dangerouse out of the
back field. This weekend i think the linebackers have to show up and play better. We need to be more aggresive
especially on 3rd down. If Utah's QB gets comfortable back there then it may be a longer day. I just dont see
dropping eight back as the best way to stop Utah..Just my take on the D. Not very impressed with it right now.
Thought the D line would play better then they have. They dont seem to get the push as in past years.
Last edited by THETADUCK on Tue Sep 22, 2015 10:31 am, edited 1 time in total.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I think the thing with the defense that bothers me is the lack of accountability. What I see from Pellum is excuses and not I need to do better at getting them ready. If we look across the country whether it be in pro or in college we see a lot of coaches taking responsibility for poor play. What we get from Pellum is excuses. If he manned up and admitted he is not getting them to get the results and is working on it I might be a little more forgiving. I also agree the faceless opponent mentality seems to be gone. Oregon had chances to make a statement against EWU and especially against Georgia State. They did not make a statement in either game. Some of the turnovers Oregon got against Georgia State were not due to being a good defense and were just bad mistakes hat ended up being a turnover. The first pick 6 comes to mind on that. A good Pac 12 team would not miss the receiver as bad as Georgia State did on that throw. Another accountability issue with the defense is when it comes to 3rd downs. 3rd downs are an opportunity for the defense to show we are going to stop you and get the ball back to our lethal offense. Instead they give up the first down and prolong the drive. Then blame the offense for scoring to fast. Course we live in a society is easier to point the finger at someone else than to take responsibility and point finger at self.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

I think you have to take those FCS games with some salt. We were going deep into rotations and were testing guys. Don't read too much into that right now.

MSU should be the measuring stick right now and the defense actually played pretty well in that game, sans the missed tackle and bad angle that resulted in a 62 yard run. Even with that play, Oregon still held MSU under 400 yards of total offense. In addition, Oregon turned the ball over twice and shanked two punts giving MSU very short fields.
GoDucksIn09 wrote:I think the thing with the defense that bothers me is the lack of accountability. What I see from Pellum is excuses and not I need to do better at getting them ready. If we look across the country whether it be in pro or in college we see a lot of coaches taking responsibility for poor play. What we get from Pellum is excuses. If he manned up and admitted he is not getting them to get the results and is working on it I might be a little more forgiving. I also agree the faceless opponent mentality seems to be gone. Oregon had chances to make a statement against EWU and especially against Georgia State. They did not make a statement in either game. Some of the turnovers Oregon got against Georgia State were not due to being a good defense and were just bad mistakes hat ended up being a turnover. The first pick 6 comes to mind on that. A good Pac 12 team would not miss the receiver as bad as Georgia State did on that throw. Another accountability issue with the defense is when it comes to 3rd downs. 3rd downs are an opportunity for the defense to show we are going to stop you and get the ball back to our lethal offense. Instead they give up the first down and prolong the drive. Then blame the offense for scoring to fast. Course we live in a society is easier to point the finger at someone else than to take responsibility and point finger at self.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:
As long as the Ducks can score more points than their opponent week after week, then I guess the D is playing well enough.
I'd amend this to say, "as long as the defense is putting the offense in position to score more than their opponents, then it's playing well enough."

That's what past Oregon defenses have excelled at, but it's where this one may struggle against pass-heavy teams. Against MSU, though, the defense did its job, and it was the offense that didn't show up for three quarters. We'll win the conference championship this year if the D can play as well as it did against MSU, but we don't stand a chance if our offense is that anemic for such long stretches of the game.

In fact, the Utah game could be as much of a litmus test for our offense as it is for our defense. We beat up on two FCS teams that aren't very good defensively, but then we were anemic in our only matchup against a skilled defensive unit.
This logic is why those who defend the defense will never get it. 432 yards and 28 points (yes, a ST score counts) against a top 5 team on the road is somehow considered "anemic". The standard for defense at Oregon has become embarrassingly low. Allowing 400 yards and 30+ points any time we face a decent offense is the defense doing it's job? Really? It's essentially a guaranteed loss if our offense doesn't score more than 30. That's not acceptable. I don't understand why anyone would defend that.

And please, stop with all the obscure statistical data. It doesn't tell the whole story. Recently our defense fails us every time our offense doesn't have a great game. Yet they're never held responsible. The story line is always how the offense didn't hold up its end, ignoring the fact that our defense NEVER holds up its end. They are 100% reliant on our offense scoring a ton of points and hiding our defensive flaws. It's a flaw in our coaching philosophy and in the past when we had minimal talent it was excusable but that's no longer the case.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

432 yards and 28 points (yes, a ST score counts) against a top 5 team on the road is somehow considered "anemic".
These numbers are meaningless in the same way that "total defense" numbers are meaningless.

I've never seen a football game where the winner is determined by who gets the most yards. It's all about points. And, for three quarters against MSU, our offense only put up 7 points... that is terrible. And the comment above is why I don't understand the double standard between discussing our offense and defense.

Again, everyone here agrees this year's defense has problems. Nobody is making "excuses" for anything. At the same time, it's silly to be offended by the fact that our offense left our defense out to dry against MSU. Seriously, our offense for most of that game was terrible, terrible, terrible. Just seven points with two turnovers (plus a third turnover on downs at the goal line) in three quarters of play... and people would STILL rather rant about the defense in that game while giving the offense a free pass? Sheesh, talk about making excuses.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

THETADUCK wrote:I think you have to take those FCS games with some salt. We were going deep into rotations and were testing guys. Don't read too much into that right now.

MSU should be the measuring stick right now and the defense actually played pretty well in that game, sans the missed tackle and bad angle that resulted in a 62 yard run. Even with that play, Oregon still held MSU under 400 yards of total offense. In addition, Oregon turned the ball over twice and shanked two punts giving MSU very short fields.
That game is a perfect example of the justification of a below average defensive performance. At the end of the game the box score doesn't look half bad and there was plenty of excuses provided by our offense so hey! Our D played great! If you watch the game though you see an inexcusable amount of missed tackles and realize we should have allowed about half the yards and points we did and won easily. But the offense was just ANEMIC like always so we ignore that and just blame the offense.
Image
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:
432 yards and 28 points (yes, a ST score counts) against a top 5 team on the road is somehow considered "anemic".
These numbers are meaningless in the same way that "total defense" numbers are meaningless.

I've never seen a football game where the winner is determined by who gets the most yards. It's all about points. And, for three quarters against MSU, our offense only put up 7 points... that is terrible. And the comment above is why I don't understand the double standard between discussing our offense and defense.

Again, everyone here agrees this year's defense has problems. Nobody is making "excuses" for anything. At the same time, it's silly to be offended by the fact that our offense left our defense out to dry against MSU. Seriously, our offense for most of that game was terrible, terrible, terrible. Just seven points with two turnovers (plus a third turnover on downs at the goal line) in three quarters of play... and people would STILL rather rant about the defense in that game while giving the offense a free pass? Sheesh, talk about making excuses.
Total points is a meaningless stat?

I don't disagree that our offense wasn't good for a majority of the game. But they scored 28 points and held the ball for 28+ minutes. The defense was not completely hung out to dry. If the defense just tackles like any decent D-1 team does we win easily.

The offense provided some excuses for the defenses, like always. But the tackling by the defense was INEXCUSABLE. And was every bit of why we lost the game as anything else.

The offense did enough for us to win. The defense didn't. And never does in big games.
Image
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I think Dthomas=DDixon is spot on in both of his posts. Helfrich might be a good coach. He certainly has the winning percentage that a lot of coaches wish they had. I think though the Pellum thing will end up hurting Helfrich in the long term. The mediocrity and not taking responsibility will end up costing Oregon games. I do not see Helfrich getting rid of Pellum if that does end up happening. Long term wise it will end up hurting Helfrich if I am right. Oregon needs to step up big time. Even Mike Bellotti said he has no clue where Oregon's defense is. That is a guy who use to coach at Oregon.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

The offense did enough for us to win. The defense didn't. And never does in big games.
I read this and I think we didn't even watch the same game. The offense was MIA for three quarters and committed two turnovers during that time.

Also, the offense did not score 28 points; it scored 21. That's not good enough. We can't count on special teams bailing out the offense in every game. And if you're going to start counting special teams play as offensive production, then I'd better see you give equal consideration to botched special teams play working against our defense -- which, again, I never see here (reference last year's Cal game, when our defense was put on several short fields thanks to offensive turnovers and special teams miscues).

The defense did enough for us to beat MSU, and the offense totally choked. Sadly, this is what has happened in some of Oregon's biggest games over the past few years... such as our home loss to Stanford that cost us a natty berth, and also our national championship game against Auburn.

But yeah, keep blaming the defense for the offense's awesome 21 points.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Tue Sep 22, 2015 11:26 am, edited 1 time in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

Disagree completely. Against MSU, the defense was hung out to dry all game. Do you really think it is unreasonable that we gave up 31 points to the No. 5 team in the country when we shanked two punts and gave them the ball on our side of the field and turned it over six times (four on downs and two INTs)? Here is a summary of our offensive possessions in the first half:
TD
Punt - 3 plays, 1 yard
Punt - 3 plays, -1 yard
INT - 2 plays, 3 yard
Downs - 10 plays, 82 yards
INT - 4 plays, 29 yards
Downs - 6 plays, 17 yards

TERRIBLE.

That loss is 100% on the offense and the kicking game.
dthomas=ddixon wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
432 yards and 28 points (yes, a ST score counts) against a top 5 team on the road is somehow considered "anemic".
These numbers are meaningless in the same way that "total defense" numbers are meaningless.

I've never seen a football game where the winner is determined by who gets the most yards. It's all about points. And, for three quarters against MSU, our offense only put up 7 points... that is terrible. And the comment above is why I don't understand the double standard between discussing our offense and defense.

Again, everyone here agrees this year's defense has problems. Nobody is making "excuses" for anything. At the same time, it's silly to be offended by the fact that our offense left our defense out to dry against MSU. Seriously, our offense for most of that game was terrible, terrible, terrible. Just seven points with two turnovers (plus a third turnover on downs at the goal line) in three quarters of play... and people would STILL rather rant about the defense in that game while giving the offense a free pass? Sheesh, talk about making excuses.
Total points is a meaningless stat?

I don't disagree that our offense wasn't good for a majority of the game. But they scored 28 points and held the ball for 28+ minutes. The defense was not completely hung out to dry. If the defense just tackles like any decent D-1 team does we win easily.

The offense provided some excuses for the defenses, like always. But the tackling by the defense was INEXCUSABLE. And was every bit of why we lost the game as anything else.

The offense did enough for us to win. The defense didn't. And never does in big games.
Last edited by THETADUCK on Tue Sep 22, 2015 11:33 am, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

Do you really think it is unreasonable that we gave up 31 points to the No. 5 team in the country when we shanked two punts and gave them the ball on our side of the field and turned it over six times (four on downs and two INTs)?

Here is a summary of our offensive possessions in the first half:
TD
Punt - 3 plays, 1 yard
Punt - 3 plays, -1 yard
INT - 2 plays, 3 yard
Downs - 10 plays, 82 yards
INT - 4 plays, 29 yards
Downs - 6 plays, 17 yards

TERRIBLE.

That loss is on the offense and the kicking game.

Couldn't agree more. We're not going to win many games if our offense craps itself like that against quality opponents.

That said, I think our offense will be fine. Our defense is certainly more of a liability right now. But some people have such blind rage toward our defense (and/or our coaches) that it's getting increasingly difficult to have real nuts-and-bolts discussions here.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by duckfan22 »

Years ago when Ralph Miller was coaching that basketball team up north
he was asked by a reporter on what his team had to do to win the game that
night and in his very own grouchy tone he said " Well Todd we have to score more points then them".
That really is the bottom line. Some games we will win when the the defense sucks and offense is clicking.
We can win when the offense is sub par and the defense plays well. When we lose it really falls on both sides
and coaches i think.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I agree that the defense did enough in Michigan State game to win. They are a good team on defense and we did not play well on offense. The O Line was getting blasted and pushed back anytime MSU wanted to blitz they did so with very little resistance from our O line. The 2 shanked punts were just horrible. The offense scored 21 points. Lots of games if offense scores 21 points the team will lose.
Post Reply