I normally don't comment on recruiting because it is irrelevant until they sign on the line and then report for camp. But these "insiders" ARE nothing but fans that hound kids for every little tidbit they can and it is borderline creepy. Not much journalistic quality and a pretty strange way to make a living. No wonder these HS kids step on campus with a sense of entitlement and it is not getting any better.
Prehm and Hopkins can barely write. Summers and Martindale are old gossip mongers. The UW sites are far worse and basically set the baseline for stalking. If any of these guys get "inside" info it is because the Oregon coaches, AD or the influential 3-4 donors want it out there. Otherwise they are left to pester kids. None of these guys would ever put anything out there that would effectively get them put on the outs and burn the bridge that gets them that morsel of cheese.
Personally, I thought it was great that Kelly shut out the fan boy crowd and kept his business in-house. His results allowed that to happen. This DC search was also classic in that all these guys were shut out and had no clue what was going on yet all thought they had the scoop.
Such of a waste of a comment. Nothing to do with Keith Simms and you come across as another "Know it all, keyboard coach". Probably stick to not commenting especially when complaing, or move the comment to a thread that your comment has relevance in. Just my 2 cents
pezsez1 wrote:I don't get why so many moms are so against their kids going farther away. My mom wouldn't even let my sisters and me entertain the thought of Portland State -- too close to home. She'd have been thrilled if any of us had gone across the country.
Really depends on the situation. Personally, I'm close to my parents and I love some home-cooked persian food. So it's definitely a big 'nice to have' being close to my family. With that being said, I was enrolled to go to grad school in Utah before I got a job here. So, for me, if a great opportunity far away from home presented itself, I would still consider it despite being further away from my family.
But I'm not your average recruit. A fair amount of these recruits have single moms, who work really hard to get their sons in a situation to succeed. And there's a strong bond usually between recruit and mom, so I can understand why distance could be a problem.
I think "creepy" is a little harsh. Nothing wrong with giving people the chance to be interviewed as long as your tactics aren't over-the-top. But I do agree that "insider information" isn't always all it's cracked up to be.
Also, mainstream beat writers are getting more savvy and starting to keep up in many cases with the pay-site "insiders." And yeah, most of these pay-site reporters can't write, and I'll always prefer to read well-written articles over the equivalent of rough forum posts.
gosterman01 wrote:Such of a waste of a comment. Nothing to do with Keith Simms and you come across as another "Know it all, keyboard coach". Probably stick to not commenting especially when complaing, or move the comment to a thread that your comment has relevance in. Just my 2 cents
Well maybe I have had a relative go through the process and giving a comment is far from a complaint, and no I don't know it all, far from it. Maybe you should take your own advice hotshot.
The problem with recruiting is its a lot like salesman, they always think they are going to get the sale. So if any insider is talking to a coach, the coach is always going to say "hey we are looking great for so and so." Or the classic is when the coach says "we moved on from him, we didn't want him." Come on coach, your just like a salesman making some lame excuse why the sale fell through. Don't play it off like you suddenly didn't want the stud you had been recruiting for a year or more. Then the insiders are taking to 16-17-18yo, most of whom just say whatever they think you want to here, and honestly how many of us would have been open with some stranger from 1500 miles away when we were in high school? To say non of them have contacts and they are just fan boys, is ignorant on anyone's part. Just as its ignorant to take whatever is reported on those sites as the 100% lock.
But I do agree with two thing, most of these guys can't write. And what's more embarrassing about that, is Prehm has a degree from UO. And Prehm has next to zero contacts when it comes to football, but I believe he talks to a couple of the basketball coaches.
Marty and Steve clearly have sources at Oregon. I think they are a little more old school and prefer to confirm things before coming out with some insider news. With social media and such these days, I think coaches and other inside guys are more close to the vest with info than before, especially when working with a big time recruits or maybe ones committed elsewhere. Also, I think you would be surprised at some of the long time posters over there. Several have deep ties (think DAF donors, ex players and such).
We have a couple guys on this board that are generally viewed as real insiders (StevensTechU being the most prominent one right now). If we find them credible, we should be open to the possibility that such people exist on the other boards. Some people really do have good contacts with information not widely available, so we need to evaluate those who claim to be insiders on a case-by-case basis, because some really are and some are full of it.
I do get the sense that JHop isn't that trustworthy from what I see on this board about what he predicts and what comes true. I also think I'd need to be reading him firsthand to really have a solid opinion. But I don't think it makes sense to dismiss all recruiting journalists as just fans who tweet high schoolers too much.
gosterman01 wrote:Such of a waste of a comment. Nothing to do with Keith Simms and you come across as another "Know it all, keyboard coach". Probably stick to not commenting especially when complaing, or move the comment to a thread that your comment has relevance in. Just my 2 cents
Come on. You know how conversations go from topic to topic in real life? Same thing on the internet. Sometimes something interesting comes up and people want to talk about it. If it's not interesting to you, tough. It's not your place to try to police the topic of conversation and the mods, whose job it is, shouldn't start demanding that we never have tangential conversations because it'd stifle the board. They do a good job of keeping things in check, why don't you just leave it to them.
pezsez1 wrote:I don't get why so many moms are so against their kids going farther away. My mom wouldn't even let my sisters and me entertain the thought of Portland State -- too close to home. She'd have been thrilled if any of us had gone across the country.
Black fams might be different than white fams in this regard. Every culture is different, and lot of recruits are black, might have a different way of doing things.