The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the aisle

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Locked
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck24 »

Shannon Sharpe of all people had a pretty well thought out response to the demonstrations this weekend. I don't particularly car for the show, his hack partner or the network but he was very well spoken IMO.
User avatar
Hoagduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 977
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:37 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Hoagduck »

Black people in this country do not have equal protection under the law. Many times in recent memory police officers have been free to murder unarmed black people without facing any legal consequences. Our ridiculous president has said publicly that police officers should assault and abuse people who protest him, and has pardoned a police chief who has been responsible for horrific profiling and deaths of many people of color. The president said that every one who kneels is a "son of a bitch" and I'd gladly support everyone who kneels in opposition to that. The national anthem before the game is about expressing gratitude for the country we live in, and I can't imagine why anyone would feel that way right now.

Rob Moseley has already said on Twitter that Oregon athletes are free to express themselves or peacefully protest as they see fit. Ducks don't come out until the national anthem, on some level I'm glad these kids don't have to make a hard choice about what to do on national television.
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by GrantDuck »

karlhungis wrote:
People can do as they please but I don't like what's going on for multiple reasons mainly that it's being used as a divisive tool to once again shift our attention to things of little importance
This guy gets it.

I am also a vet I respect their right to protest. This should be a non-issue but it is being used as a tool to divide the country. That upsets me way more than the protests ever will.



Also, I can't imagine this thread ending well.
So far it's gone pretty well.

I think some people might disagree with you regarding issues of "little importance".
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

Hoagduck wrote:Black people in this country do not have equal protection under the law. Many times in recent memory police officers have been free to murder unarmed black people without facing any legal consequences. Our ridiculous president has said publicly that police officers should assault and abuse people who protest him, and has pardoned a police chief who has been responsible for horrific profiling and deaths of many people of color. The president said that every one who kneels is a "son of a bitch" and I'd gladly support everyone who kneels in opposition to that. The national anthem before the game is about expressing gratitude for the country we live in, and I can't imagine why anyone would feel that way right now.

My friend no one is disagreeing or disputing that. The question is what does that actually have to do with the flag and anthem. We as a people can choose to fix the issue without creating a total s*** storm on the one thing garunteeing to silence discussion before it can even be had.
Rob Moseley has already said on Twitter that Oregon athletes are free to express themselves or peacefully protest as they see fit. Ducks don't come out until the national anthem, on some level I'm glad these kids don't have to make a hard choice about what to do on national television.
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

Lol phone fail!
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
GrantDuck
Senior
Posts: 2629
Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by GrantDuck »

TualatinDuck wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
TualatinDuck wrote:As someone who served in uniform, I do not believe the flag or anthem should be used as a political vehicle.

Grant you are correct they do stand for values and ideals of this country, that hasn't changed. We as a society has changed and neither side is willing to work with the other. That's not the flag or anthems fault, it's ours as a people. Failing to honor those same ideals the the flag and anthem represents offends me personally. Those values and ideals are not gone, we just stopped embracing them.

I support the players message and right to protest, I do not support using the very symbols of that freedom as a political tool. They have the money and means to prove their cause in a less divisive way.
Understand that point of view, that the flag is something so special and unique that it is beyond politics, but to me a flag by its nature is inherently political as it represents the United States and its ideals to not only us but the rest of the world. It may have been leaning for awhile, but Charlottesville was the tipping point(not just for me, but so many of these athletes), because at that point, the flag no longer to me represented an America that stands for those ideals of equality, freedom, welcoming, and liberty. It started to stand for inequality, bondage, xenophobia, and restriction. When it represents those former things again, I can stand for it again.

Maybe that's wrong. Maybe the flag should always stand for the best ideals of freedom and I shouldn't let outside perception change that, but those wounds cut very deep.
That sir is the exact problem. You are letting perception drive your actions. Sins of the few should not be inflicted on the many.

By your logic, since I am middle aged white conservative man, must also be a racist bigot which is far from the case. Unfortunately in today's world, perception equals reality.

I'll defend your right to protest, but I will not defend your platform of choice. Wearing a yellow ribbon will not make it better but I appreciate your desire to honor our men and women in uniform.
The infliction of titles such as "racist and bigot" or even a misapplied "nazi" to anyone who reasonably disagrees in a discussion involving race or equality are deeply disappointing and undermine so much. Not only does it piss people off, it's entirely unfair and counterproductive.
Last edited by GrantDuck on Tue Sep 26, 2017 4:19 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
Hoagduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 977
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:37 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Hoagduck »

TualatinDuck wrote:
Hoagduck wrote:My friend no one is disagreeing or disputing that.
Nobody here is, but many people are. Including the white house
The question is what does that actually have to do with the flag and anthem.
It's about bringing attention in a peaceful manner. Boy has it worked!

The anthem is about celebrating country, kneeling show reverence, but brings attention to our deep, dangerous flaws as a country.

It doesn't need to make everyone feel good, it's a protest after all. The majority of people opposed MLK and the civil rights movement of the 60's, the majority of people are free to disagree now.
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

GrantDuck wrote:
TualatinDuck wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
TualatinDuck wrote:As someone who served in uniform, I do not believe the flag or anthem should be used as a political vehicle.

Grant you are correct they do stand for values and ideals of this country, that hasn't changed. We as a society has changed and neither side is willing to work with the other. That's not the flag or anthems fault, it's ours as a people. Failing to honor those same ideals the the flag and anthem represents offends me personally. Those values and ideals are not gone, we just stopped embracing them.

I support the players message and right to protest, I do not support using the very symbols of that freedom as a political tool. They have the money and means to prove their cause in a less divisive way.
Understand that point of view, that the flag is something so special and unique that it is beyond politics, but to me a flag by its nature is inherently political as it represents the United States and its ideals to not only us but the rest of the world. It may have been leaning for awhile, but Charlottesville was the tipping point(not just for me, but so many of these athletes), because at that point, the flag no longer to me represented an America that stands for those ideals of equality, freedom, welcoming, and liberty. It started to stand for inequality, bondage, xenophobia, and restriction. When it represents those former things again, I can stand for it again.

Maybe that's wrong. Maybe the flag should always stand for the best ideals of freedom and I shouldn't let outside perception change that, but those wounds cut very deep.
That sir is the exact problem. You are letting perception drive your actions. Sins of the few should not be inflicted on the many.

By your logic, since I am middle aged white conservative man, must also be a racist bigot which is far from the case. Unfortunately in today's world, perception equals reality.

I'll defend your right to protest, but I will not defend your platform of choice. Wearing a yellow ribbon will not make it better but I appreciate your desire to honor our men and women in uniform.
The infliction of titles such as "racist and bigot" or even a misapplied "nazi" to anyone who reasonably disagrees in a discussion involving race or equality are deeply disappointing and undermine so much. Not only does it piss people off, it's entirely unfair and counterproductive.
100% agree with that!
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

Hoagduck wrote:
TualatinDuck wrote:
Hoagduck wrote:My friend no one is disagreeing or disputing that.
Nobody here is, but many people are. Including the white house
The question is what does that actually have to do with the flag and anthem.
It's about bringing attention in a peaceful manner. Boy has it worked!

The anthem is about celebrating country, kneeling show reverence, but brings attention to our deep, dangerous flaws as a country.

It doesn't need to make everyone feel good, it's a protest after all. The majority of people opposed MLK and the civil rights movement of the 60's, the majority of people are free to disagree now.
I actually think that is the one good thing about what has been happening, people are talking. That's a good thing.

I just wish they wouldn't use the anthem and flag as the vehicle to drive the discussion. I feel it cheapens my service and the oath I took. But that's just my feeling.
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
User avatar
Hoagduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 977
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:37 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Hoagduck »

The infliction of titles such as "racist and bigot" or even a misapplied "nazi" to anyone who reasonably disagrees in a discussion involving race or equality are deeply disappointing and undermine so much. Not only does it piss people off, it's entirely unfair and counterproductive.
Yeah, you won't see me going around calling everyone I disagree with a Nazi or a Bigot. It's intellectually lazy. Hollering that at well meaning people isn't effective. People absolutely need to be aware when they are on the same side as Nazis and Bigots though, and to self-examine if they want to be.
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck24 »

karlhungis wrote:
People can do as they please but I don't like what's going on for multiple reasons mainly that it's being used as a divisive tool to once again shift our attention to things of little importance
This guy gets it.

I am also a vet I respect their right to protest. This should be a non-issue but it is being used as a tool to divide the country. That upsets me way more than the protests ever will.



Also, I can't imagine this thread ending well.
I was chuckling to myself that this is the longest a remotely political thread has gone without someone flying off and starting name calling.

I think reasoned discourse actually helps everyone involved. Reasoned being the keyword. I'm always open to other people's opinions, even if I think they're completely wrong. I'm not going to change that persons opinion and they aren't going to change mine, but I always enjoy hearing the other side. In the back of my head I might be saying that person it batshit crazy, belongs in the looney bin and be astounded that their vote counts the same as mine, but again, I always enjoy hearing the other opinions and will openly listen to it so long as they afford me the same respect. Politics is an emotional thing for all involved and it can be tough to keep it in check but I think we are all better for it the more we talk about it. Avoiding the conversations and letting it come to a head results in the type of environment we have now.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck07 »

I don't think it's worked or is working when it seems like it's having the opposite effect of creating division. Awareness is just a BS excuse when it isn't followed up with action.
Image
User avatar
Tray Dub
Senior
Posts: 4994
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:31 pm

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Tray Dub »

Duck07 wrote:I don't think it's worked or is working when it seems like it's having the opposite effect of creating division. Awareness is just a BS excuse when it isn't followed up with action.
What would you say the "action" Martin Luther King took beyond protesting in various forms? Protest has a long history of being both divisive and effective. To think it isn't "action" makes no sense to me.
TualatinDuck
Senior
Posts: 2439
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 1:23 am
Location: Tualatin

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by TualatinDuck »

Duck24 wrote:
karlhungis wrote:
People can do as they please but I don't like what's going on for multiple reasons mainly that it's being used as a divisive tool to once again shift our attention to things of little importance
This guy gets it.

I am also a vet I respect their right to protest. This should be a non-issue but it is being used as a tool to divide the country. That upsets me way more than the protests ever will.



Also, I can't imagine this thread ending well.
I was chuckling to myself that this is the longest a remotely political thread has gone without someone flying off and starting name calling.

I think reasoned discourse actually helps everyone involved. Reasoned being the keyword. I'm always open to other people's opinions, even if I think they're completely wrong. I'm not going to change that persons opinion and they aren't going to change mine, but I always enjoy hearing the other side. In the back of my head I might be saying that person it batshit crazy, belongs in the looney bin and be astounded that their vote counts the same as mine, but again, I always enjoy hearing the other opinions and will openly listen to it so long as they afford me the same respect. Politics is an emotional thing for all involved and it can be tough to keep it in check but I think we are all better for it the more we talk about it. Avoiding the conversations and letting it come to a head results in the type of environment we have now.
Very well said! I sometimes think some liberals are bat s*** crazy but I can't understand where they are coming from if I don't take the time to listen. Seek first to understand before being understood. Discussion should always be our first option.
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: The Anthem Saturday, will you stand, sit, kneel in the a

Post by Duck07 »

Duck24 wrote:I was chuckling to myself that this is the longest a remotely political thread has gone without someone flying off and starting name calling.

I think reasoned discourse actually helps everyone involved. Reasoned being the keyword. I'm always open to other people's opinions, even if I think they're completely wrong. I'm not going to change that persons opinion and they aren't going to change mine, but I always enjoy hearing the other side. In the back of my head I might be saying that person it batshit crazy, belongs in the looney bin and be astounded that their vote counts the same as mine, but again, I always enjoy hearing the other opinions and will openly listen to it so long as they afford me the same respect. Politics is an emotional thing for all involved and it can be tough to keep it in check but I think we are all better for it the more we talk about it. Avoiding the conversations and letting it come to a head results in the type of environment we have now.
Have you seen Accidental Courtesy with Daryl Davis on Netflix? Great movie to change our perceptions about another way of dealing with those whose viewpoints we don't agree with.
Image
Locked