Oregon's offense actually looks better then it did last year with Herbert. Oregon's defense last year was the best its ever been by a long shot and all Herbert could do was lead them to a 2 loss Season which is basically what Kellen Clemens did with a much worse defense. Also the Defense was the main reason Oregon beat Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl. The Defense looks awful this year and you can't just blame that on the draft. You don't go from having a defense close to LSU's or at least a good big ten team and then have a bad Mountain West type defense the next year from draft picks.bigsugarduck wrote:Has there ever been a player that, in performing such a way, has made their previous team look worse than Herbert has with Oregon? I reckon there have been plenty of players who have performed spectacularly below expectations (thus reflecting poorly on the previous team), but nothing like this...
It is so fun watching Herbert, but the better he does, the worse Oregon looks...a confounding, bizarre, unpresented thing to reconcile.
Herbert Oregon narrative
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Yes, Oregon's offense looks better as a whole even though anybody with any iota of football acumen can see that we've regressed tremendously in the QB department. Herbert doesn't lose this game tonight.duck023 wrote:Oregon's offense actually looks better then it did last year with Herbert. Oregon's defense last year was the best its ever been by a long shot and all Herbert could do was lead them to a 2 loss Season which is basically what Kellen Clemens did with a much worse defense. Also the Defense was the main reason Oregon beat Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl. The Defense looks awful this year and you can't just blame that on the draft. You don't go from having a defense close to LSU's or at least a good big ten team and then have a bad Mountain West type defense the next year from draft picks.bigsugarduck wrote:Has there ever been a player that, in performing such a way, has made their previous team look worse than Herbert has with Oregon? I reckon there have been plenty of players who have performed spectacularly below expectations (thus reflecting poorly on the previous team), but nothing like this...
It is so fun watching Herbert, but the better he does, the worse Oregon looks...a confounding, bizarre, unpresented thing to reconcile.

-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Herbert scored 24 points last year against Oregon St and Verdell rushed for 200 yards. He would have definitely lost this game. If the defense and Verdell didn't bail Herbert out last year they would have lost to Oregon St last year. Shough threw 100 more yards then Herbert. Also the one blow out Herbert had last year against USC was mainly because Shough played great in garbage time.Duck07 wrote:Yes, Oregon's offense looks better as a whole even though anybody with any iota of football acumen can see that we've regressed tremendously in the QB department. Herbert doesn't lose this game tonight.duck023 wrote:Oregon's offense actually looks better then it did last year with Herbert. Oregon's defense last year was the best its ever been by a long shot and all Herbert could do was lead them to a 2 loss Season which is basically what Kellen Clemens did with a much worse defense. Also the Defense was the main reason Oregon beat Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl. The Defense looks awful this year and you can't just blame that on the draft. You don't go from having a defense close to LSU's or at least a good big ten team and then have a bad Mountain West type defense the next year from draft picks.bigsugarduck wrote:Has there ever been a player that, in performing such a way, has made their previous team look worse than Herbert has with Oregon? I reckon there have been plenty of players who have performed spectacularly below expectations (thus reflecting poorly on the previous team), but nothing like this...
It is so fun watching Herbert, but the better he does, the worse Oregon looks...a confounding, bizarre, unpresented thing to reconcile.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Herbert scored 24 points last year against Oregon St and Verdell rushed for 200 yards. He would have definitely lost this game. If the defense and Verdell didn't bail Herbert out last year they would have lost to Oregon St last year. Shough threw 100 more yards then Herbert. Also the one blow out Herbert had last year against USC was mainly because Shough played great in garbage time. I've seen Herbert lose games like this all the time. If the defense and running game wasn't going good I always expected Herbert to join them sort of like the ASU game.Duck07 wrote:Yes, Oregon's offense looks better as a whole even though anybody with any iota of football acumen can see that we've regressed tremendously in the QB department. Herbert doesn't lose this game tonight.duck023 wrote:Oregon's offense actually looks better then it did last year with Herbert. Oregon's defense last year was the best its ever been by a long shot and all Herbert could do was lead them to a 2 loss Season which is basically what Kellen Clemens did with a much worse defense. Also the Defense was the main reason Oregon beat Wisconsin in the Rose Bowl. The Defense looks awful this year and you can't just blame that on the draft. You don't go from having a defense close to LSU's or at least a good big ten team and then have a bad Mountain West type defense the next year from draft picks.bigsugarduck wrote:Has there ever been a player that, in performing such a way, has made their previous team look worse than Herbert has with Oregon? I reckon there have been plenty of players who have performed spectacularly below expectations (thus reflecting poorly on the previous team), but nothing like this...
It is so fun watching Herbert, but the better he does, the worse Oregon looks...a confounding, bizarre, unpresented thing to reconcile.
Last edited by duck023 on Sat Nov 28, 2020 12:38 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15429
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Shough is not the better college QB, he’s nowhere near Herbert’s freshman year. Shough just has the luxury of having a good OC.

- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Hi Tyler's Mom!duck023 wrote:I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.

-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Hi Justin's Grandma!!! Shough isn't perfect but if he played like Herbert last year he would have lost the Washington State game.Duck07 wrote:Hi Tyler's Mom!duck023 wrote:I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
duck023 wrote:Hi Justin's Grandma!!! Shough isn't perfect but if he played like Herbert last year he would have lost the Washington State game.Duck07 wrote:Hi Tyler's Mom!duck023 wrote:I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.
So we blame Justin for that, or the crap coach he had? All facts point to it being Arroya and not Herbert's issues. Hamilton has had no issue making Herbert into a legit top 10 QB. Meanwhile Arroyo and his great offense, got held to under 150 yards by Brady Fn Hoke.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
One thing I forgot is that Herbert is a hometown kid so I do understand why you guy's defend him but criticize the guy from Arizona. I do think you guy's have a point about Arroya being way worse then Moorehead. The problem is I want to blame Shough. I like blaming the qb when things go badly but Oregon's defense and running game is playing so bad that Shough seems like the one positive thing. If the defense only gave up 20 points and Verdell had 150 yards rushing I'd be the first guy wondering what is wrong with Shough.buckmarkduck wrote:duck023 wrote:Hi Justin's Grandma!!! Shough isn't perfect but if he played like Herbert last year he would have lost the Washington State game.Duck07 wrote:Hi Tyler's Mom!duck023 wrote:I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.
So we blame Justin for that, or the crap coach he had? All facts point to it being Arroya and not Herbert's issues. Hamilton has had no issue making Herbert into a legit top 10 QB. Meanwhile Arroyo and his great offense, got held to under 150 yards by Brady Fn Hoke.
-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
duck023 wrote:One thing I forgot is that Herbert is a hometown kid so I do understand why you guy's defend him but criticize the guy from Arizona. I do think you guy's have a point about Arroya being way worse then Moorehead. The problem is I want to blame Shough. I like blaming the qb when things go badly but Oregon's defense and running game is playing so bad that Shough seems like the one positive thing. If the defense only gave up 20 points and Verdell had 150 yards rushing I'd be the first guy wondering what is wrong with Shough.buckmarkduck wrote:duck023 wrote:Hi Justin's Grandma!!! Shough isn't perfect but if he played like Herbert last year he would have lost the Washington State game.Duck07 wrote:Hi Tyler's Mom!duck023 wrote:I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.
So we blame Justin for that, or the crap coach he had? All facts point to it being Arroya and not Herbert's issues. Hamilton has had no issue making Herbert into a legit top 10 QB. Meanwhile Arroyo and his great offense, got held to under 150 yards by Brady Fn Hoke.
Maybe I'm missing the part where I blamed Tyler for anything? Its funny you are making this a Tyler vS Herbert issue.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Sorry I know I got off topic. I do like Herbert and wish him well. I don't think Shough is as good as Herbert was yet. I just wished the defense was playing on a similar level as last year so we can at least have a fair comparison. Also last year many people said we were a young team but we somehow got younger so now I realize that last year might have been Oregon's best shot at a national title. Oregon will never have a defense like that again with a senior quarterback and they blew it.buckmarkduck wrote:duck023 wrote:One thing I forgot is that Herbert is a hometown kid so I do understand why you guy's defend him but criticize the guy from Arizona. I do think you guy's have a point about Arroya being way worse then Moorehead. The problem is I want to blame Shough. I like blaming the qb when things go badly but Oregon's defense and running game is playing so bad that Shough seems like the one positive thing. If the defense only gave up 20 points and Verdell had 150 yards rushing I'd be the first guy wondering what is wrong with Shough.buckmarkduck wrote:duck023 wrote:Hi Justin's Grandma!!! Shough isn't perfect but if he played like Herbert last year he would have lost the Washington State game.Duck07 wrote:Hi Tyler's Mom!duck023 wrote:I think Herbert is a better NFL quarterback but he is very cautious and tends to just over throw his receivers. Shough seems to be the better college quarterback he takes what the defense gives him and he might underthrow someone and still get a completion. He is also a better runner.
So we blame Justin for that, or the crap coach he had? All facts point to it being Arroya and not Herbert's issues. Hamilton has had no issue making Herbert into a legit top 10 QB. Meanwhile Arroyo and his great offense, got held to under 150 yards by Brady Fn Hoke.
Maybe I'm missing the part where I blamed Tyler for anything? Its funny you are making this a Tyler vS Herbert issue.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
- UOducksTK1
- Site Admin

- Posts: 40719
- Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
- GM: Boston Celtics GM
- Location: Portland, Oregon
Re: Herbert Oregon narrative
Good company!Duck07 wrote:Only rookie to do it too since Mahomes sat for a year.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13