Rebuilding

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

BearlyBalanced
One Star Recruit
Posts: 36
Joined: Sat Jan 13, 2018 2:25 am

Re: Rebuilding

Post by BearlyBalanced »

My only rationalization for the DL (or insert your underperforming veteran) comes from my subjective experience. I got really sick this year in Feb/Mar with the Vid. It wasn't anywhere near a manflu/cold that I occasionally get and puts me down hard, it was more just annoying and towards the end of it, I actually experienced some real scary breathing anomalies that have permanently affected my VO2Max & conditioning ability. Re-starting my NON-D1 Athletic Regimen this fall has been the most HUMBLING physical experience I have had without any 'good reason' for it.

I could be wrong, but I highly doubt this is a result of just lazy undisciplined kids not trying as hard. EVERYONE is affected and many in ways we won't understand for years to come. JMHO take or leave it. Peace
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Rebuilding

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Shough isn’t the problem, blaming him is comical. The offense put up 38 points with no short fields. Is he national championship good? No, but good enough to beat the Beavs.

The defense is a major glaring issue, and the fans blaming covid are hilarious (fits right in with our culture right? Blame covid for our problems. Apparently covid is making people fat, not being lazy and overreacting). I’d understand some missed tackles and blown coverage, but what we are seeing is an incredibly soft defense, we’re seeing talented big guys get pushed around badly by smaller and less talented guys. They are so weak mentally that they play so soft. What the reason is? We don’t know, but it’s pathetic, and seeing the head coach after the game come out and say complete BS like “the defense is fighting hard” won’t make it any better. Don’t cal out players individually or insult guys, but they need to be held accountable for playing so soft and unmotivated and Mario and Avalos are not doing that.
Image
lmduck

Re: Rebuilding

Post by lmduck »

OregonFan4Life wrote:Shough isn’t the problem, blaming him is comical. The offense put up 38 points with no short fields. Is he national championship good? No, but good enough to beat the Beavs.

The defense is a major glaring issue, and the fans blaming covid are hilarious (fits right in with our culture right? Blame covid for our problems. Apparently covid is making people fat, not being lazy and overreacting). I’d understand some missed tackles and blown coverage, but what we are seeing is an incredibly soft defense, we’re seeing talented big guys get pushed around badly by smaller and less talented guys. They are so weak mentally that they play so soft. What the reason is? We don’t know, but it’s pathetic, and seeing the head coach after the game come out and say complete BS like “the defense is fighting hard” won’t make it any better. Don’t cal out players individually or insult guys, but they need to be held accountable for playing so soft and unmotivated and Mario and Avalos are not doing that.
You don't know what's being said behind closed doors and if you want a coach to publicly throw his team.under the bus to make you feel better then that's your issue.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: Rebuilding

Post by duck023 »

OregonFan4Life wrote:Shough isn’t the problem, blaming him is comical. The offense put up 38 points with no short fields. Is he national championship good? No, but good enough to beat the Beavs.

The defense is a major glaring issue, and the fans blaming covid are hilarious (fits right in with our culture right? Blame covid for our problems. Apparently covid is making people fat, not being lazy and overreacting). I’d understand some missed tackles and blown coverage, but what we are seeing is an incredibly soft defense, we’re seeing talented big guys get pushed around badly by smaller and less talented guys. They are so weak mentally that they play so soft. What the reason is? We don’t know, but it’s pathetic, and seeing the head coach after the game come out and say complete BS like “the defense is fighting hard” won’t make it any better. Don’t cal out players individually or insult guys, but they need to be held accountable for playing so soft and unmotivated and Mario and Avalos are not doing that.
I agree at some point a coach has to get mad. They had zero effort on defense you can't say " they were playing hard" everyone knows its a lie including the players that now know they can get away with it.
User avatar
Boom
All Pac-12
Posts: 5816
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
GM: Houston Rockets

Re: Rebuilding

Post by Boom »

This year is strange with the early opt outs, lack of spring/fall camp, and Covid restrictions. I view this season more as practice/warmup for next year. Hopefully guys stay healthy and continue to get better.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Rebuilding

Post by OregonFan4Life »

lmduck wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:Shough isn’t the problem, blaming him is comical. The offense put up 38 points with no short fields. Is he national championship good? No, but good enough to beat the Beavs.

The defense is a major glaring issue, and the fans blaming covid are hilarious (fits right in with our culture right? Blame covid for our problems. Apparently covid is making people fat, not being lazy and overreacting). I’d understand some missed tackles and blown coverage, but what we are seeing is an incredibly soft defense, we’re seeing talented big guys get pushed around badly by smaller and less talented guys. They are so weak mentally that they play so soft. What the reason is? We don’t know, but it’s pathetic, and seeing the head coach after the game come out and say complete BS like “the defense is fighting hard” won’t make it any better. Don’t cal out players individually or insult guys, but they need to be held accountable for playing so soft and unmotivated and Mario and Avalos are not doing that.
You don't know what's being said behind closed doors and if you want a coach to publicly throw his team.under the bus to make you feel better then that's your issue.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I’m not saying Mario should go all Mike Leach on the team and insult them or throw them under the bus, but don’t blatantly lie to the public and say they’re “fighting hard” when that isn’t the case. That’s like telling your child’s teacher that he/she studied hard after getting a D- and there’s no learning disability to explain it. Either explain that due to sickness or some other thing there are conditioning issues or say the effort could be better. Don’t simply say they fought hard when they didn’t.
Image
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Rebuilding

Post by buckmarkduck »

At some point Mario needs to bench guys who are missing tackles. I'd rather have a Fr like Navarrette or Laduke, who may not know the D very well, playing. Tell them see ball, hit ball. Put guys out there who will play hard. I'd rather have a guy go 110% the wrong way, then watch guys miss tackles, get blocked for 5 seconds, or just plain run themselves out of plays, and not hit the ball carrier for 10 yards.

On many of plays our DL got upfield, but they did so by not maintaining gaps, which then allowed OSu slow QB to run untouched for a 1st down. Basic fundamentals seems to be missing this year. Maybe Dye covered them up last year, but I don't think that was the case.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Rebuilding

Post by GoDucksTroll »

buckmarkduck wrote:At some point Mario needs to bench guys who are missing tackles. I'd rather have a Fr like Navarrette or Laduke, who may not know the D very well, playing. Tell them see ball, hit ball. Put guys out there who will play hard. I'd rather have a guy go 110% the wrong way, then watch guys miss tackles, get blocked for 5 seconds, or just plain run themselves out of plays, and not hit the ball carrier for 10 yards.

On many of plays our DL got upfield, but they did so by not maintaining gaps, which then allowed OSu slow QB to run untouched for a 1st down. Basic fundamentals seems to be missing this year. Maybe Dye covered them up last year, but I don't think that was the case.
Yep, if guys aren’t performing then play the younger ones. Tackling isn’t an experience issue anyway, it’s instinct and physicality. If the young guys are out of position it won’t be any different.

The issue is who are the ones playing badly. I think fans are mistaken on who is. Faoliu (both of them) have been awful, as has Funa. Happle has been too. I haven’t rewatched last nights game, but Bennett Williams who I wanted to see more of had some really bad ones.

Pickett is much, much better than Oregon fans think he is - at least better than the alternatives. Jordon Scott is nowhere near as good as I remember him but he’s not downright awful. ISM is one of our better players, but not in Troy Dye league. He is the center of the defense and gets blamed for others mistakes in real time.

Lenoir, Thibodeaux, Wright, and Sewell are the stars of the defense. Not all are perfect but no defense is, it’s the nature of the game.
User avatar
GoDucksTroll
Sophomore
Posts: 1742
Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am

Re: Rebuilding

Post by GoDucksTroll »

StevensTechU wrote:Everyone always says that by the third year, that's when it's the new coach's team. I'm looking at the commit list from 2018, ranked #13 by 247 in the country, and it's frankly panned out as one of the worst Oregon recruiting classes I've ever seen.

'Rebuilding' is not an excuse, as OSU was also breaking in a new quarterback and new OL.

Edit: here's a link to the 2018 class that has two guys going first round in the nfl and then a while lot of nothing. https://247sports.com/college/oregon/Se ... l/Commits/

Bad take, 2018 isn’t really Cristobal’s class - Willie left in December when it was almost done and we had mass de-commits which Mario had to salvage. The team was 7-5 when he took over and had gone 4-8 the year before, Cristobal was the third head coach in 13 months.

De-commit list: https://247sports.com/college/oregon/Se ... Decommits/

24 guys and 3 transfers, let’s break it down. Some are Taggart’s guys Mario was able to keep, a few are his. Keep in mind these are either redshirt sophomores or true juniors:
* 2 grand slam home runs: Penei Sewell and Jevon Holland
* 5 Starter quality good to potentially very good: Travis Dye, Steven Jones, Tyler Shough, Karsten Battles, Verone McKinley.
* 7 Jury is still out but rotation: Adrian Jackson, Spencer Webb, Dawson Jaramillo, Steve Stephens, Bryan Addison, Andrew Faoliu, MJ Cunningham.
* 2 Depth JuCo exhausted eligibility: Haki Woods, Sione Vea Kava.
* 2 We hardly knew ya busts: Jalen Hall, Jamal Elliott.
* 2 Injury busts: Andrew Johnson, Justin Johnson.
* 2 Apparent busts still on roster: Chris Randazzo, Isaah Crocker.
* 2 busts gone: JJ Tucker, Kahlef Hallassie.
* 3 transfers in, all up to or above expectation: Dallas Warmack, Kano Dillon, DJ Johnson.

You can take issue with some of the groupings, just a rough sorting.

The 2 superstars, 4 position recruits and 1 two year grad transfer starter are okay for one recruiting class. Then there are the rotation guys who could be starters. Webb and Addison had 36 catches as redshirt freshmen. The others are depth at the worst, although Adrian Jackson and Steve Stephens have a chance to be starters.

Some of the guys were brought in as risks and chances after Taggart bolted bolted and left us in the lurch. We badly needed WRs - Jalen Hall was a risk worth taking. Crocker was a highly recruited guy. JJ Tucker was filler. Jamal Elliott was a Coach Pimp guy.

My verdict: Overall okay but not fantastic class. Very good given the circumstances. 8/27 true busts, 9/27 definitely worth it, 10/27 in various levels of maybe, ranging from almost certainly in Spencer Webb to maybe not in MJ Cunningham.
User avatar
StevensTechU
All Pac-12
Posts: 7116
Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
Location: Hoboken, NJ

Re: Rebuilding

Post by StevensTechU »

Crap class. Will write more later, but a proper way to measure is how many starting seasons you get from the class. I agree its not entirely on Cristobal, though. He had a significant hand in it, particularly with how many OL didn't work out and with Jalen Hall episode, but agreed that he shouldn't be held liable for it. But my point was that the lack of quality and depth from that class is why this team is struggling.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Rebuilding

Post by buckmarkduck »

StevensTechU wrote:Crap class. Will write more later, but a proper way to measure is how many starting seasons you get from the class. I agree its not entirely on Cristobal, though. He had a significant hand in it, particularly with how many OL didn't work out and with Jalen Hall episode, but agreed that he shouldn't be held liable for it. But my point was that the lack of quality and depth from that class is why this team is struggling.

I'm not sure how you blame Hall on Mario? Kid was from.a.terrible neighborhood, who fell in with the wrong group. He tried to leave, and they talked him into going back. Now he's in prison for 20 years or whatever. The way Willie left, that class fell apart, especially at WR. Mario did what he could to try and hold it together, but its hard to do that when half the staff leaves in Dec and January.
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Rebuilding

Post by Duckenstein »

StevensTechU wrote:Everyone always says that by the third year, that's when it's the new coach's team. I'm looking at the commit list from 2018, ranked #13 by 247 in the country, and it's frankly panned out as one of the worst Oregon recruiting classes I've ever seen.

'Rebuilding' is not an excuse, as OSU was also breaking in a new quarterback and new OL.

Edit: here's a link to the 2018 class that has two guys going first round in the nfl and then a while lot of nothing. https://247sports.com/college/oregon/Se ... l/Commits/
That was a terrible class to be sure, but that was the year Willie Taggart left right before signing day. Not sure you can blame that class on Mario
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40719
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Rebuilding

Post by UOducksTK1 »

"'Rebuilding' is not an excuse, as OSU was also breaking in a new quarterback and new OL."

This is very true. A rebuilding Oregon Ducks team still shouldn't have lost to OSU or Cal. Beavers and Bears haven't beat anyone except Oregon and each other. They are 0-7 otherwise! No excuses.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6461
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Rebuilding

Post by pezsez1 »

I'm really trying not to blame Shough for this season. It's not all his fault.

THAT SAID... the reality is that if Shough didn't randomly turn into a turnover machine a few times per game, then we'd probably be 5-0 without too much trouble right now. Shough has plenty of skill and he plays with guts, but man, he goes from looking like a solid QB one minute to suddenly throwing the ball at two defenders (with no receivers nearby) the next. His turnovers have come at really bad times and we're lucky more of his bad passes haven't been picked off.

So, again, not trying to blame Shough here... just trying to point out that this team is THIS CLOSE to us talking about how we've already clinched a Pac-12 title berth. The sky isn't falling. By next year, we'll have better leadership in the defense and either Shough will be better or he'll be replaced by someone who is. And the 2022 season is shaping up to be really special if MC holds together the bulk of this incoming recruiting class.

And you know what? I bet we beat Washington this Saturday and then USC in the Pac-12 title game. Just wait and see. The defense showed up in the second half against Cal and now we just need the offense to take a similar step forward.

One more thing, too... stop minimizing the loss to OSU. The Beavers are actually pretty good this season. They caught a horrible break against UW and nearly beat Utah without their starting QB or RB. Jonathan Smith is getting the most out of scrappy players who are a bit more experienced than our younger, more talented guys. Losing to the Beavs this year wasn't an abomination -- it was predictable. Not trying to "make excuses" because I literally don't see the need to. It was a predictable outcome. Some years just line up like that. It's not the end of the world, and it will likely be many years before the Beavs match up so well again.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Duckenstein
Freshman
Posts: 1433
Joined: Tue Jun 14, 2016 7:43 pm

Re: Rebuilding

Post by Duckenstein »

pezsez1 wrote:I'm really trying not to blame Shough for this season. It's not all his fault.

THAT SAID... the reality is that if Shough didn't randomly turn into a turnover machine a few times per game, then we'd probably be 5-0 without too much trouble right now. Shough has plenty of skill and he plays with guts, but man, he goes from looking like a solid QB one minute to suddenly throwing the ball at two defenders (with no receivers nearby) the next. His turnovers have come at really bad times and we're lucky more of his bad passes haven't been picked off.

So, again, not trying to blame Shough here... just trying to point out that this team is THIS CLOSE to us talking about how we've already clinched a Pac-12 title berth. The sky isn't falling. By next year, we'll have better leadership in the defense and either Shough will be better or he'll be replaced by someone who is. And the 2022 season is shaping up to be really special if MC holds together the bulk of this incoming recruiting class.

And you know what? I bet we beat Washington this Saturday and then USC in the Pac-12 title game. Just wait and see. The defense showed up in the second half against Cal and now we just need the offense to take a similar step forward.

One more thing, too... stop minimizing the loss to OSU. The Beavers are actually pretty good this season. They caught a horrible break against UW and nearly beat Utah without their starting QB or RB. Jonathan Smith is getting the most out of scrappy players who are a bit more experienced than our younger, more talented guys. Losing to the Beavs this year wasn't an abomination -- it was predictable. Not trying to "make excuses" because I literally don't see the need to. It was a predictable outcome. Some years just line up like that. It's not the end of the world, and it will likely be many years before the Beavs match up so well again.
You're a lot more forgiving than I am. The Beavers and the Bears are winless outside of us and each other. These are not good football teams even if they play hard.

Shough has been incredibly bad, but it's really the defense that is the problem. The defense is as bad as the Hoke year in my opinion. They line up a couple feet off the line, they don't tackle, problems at Safety, Corner, ILB, OLB, and all along the line. Without naming players, several veterans are clearly out of shape and mailing it in.
Post Reply