#9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39368
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
I think we're seeing how much having Dye, Holland, Breeze, Graham, and even Lamar Winston really helped Avalos' scheme. With so many inexperienced guys back there now, it's getting exposed by everyone.

- GoDucksTroll
- Sophomore
- Posts: 1742
- Joined: Wed Sep 07, 2016 9:34 am
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
100% agree. Troy Dye, Graham, and Holland were leaders. Dye was the heart and soul of the defense, and basically for the team. I have no idea who is even the leader by default.greenyellow wrote:Oregon is just so leaderless on the field. There doesn't seem to be anyone who's been willing or able to step up in that role. The losses of Dye, Graham, Breeze, and Holland are absolutely massive in that regard.
-
shoparound
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 791
- Joined: Sat Mar 19, 2016 1:56 am
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
I wish this program put in as much time and energy into beating OSU and WSU, as it does UW and the SoCal schools.
The team did everything they could to throw away this game, it was laughable.
The team did everything they could to throw away this game, it was laughable.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
-
GrantDuck
- Senior
- Posts: 2629
- Joined: Wed Feb 04, 2009 4:05 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39368
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
- DuckzRule
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 976
- Joined: Sun Mar 22, 2020 3:30 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
Not gonna lie, I actually started crying in agony when I realized we lost to one of the worst teams on the Pac-12 and our second biggest rivals, I wish we outright lost to UCLA instead, I couldn't sleep well thinking that Oregon will get mocked on Twitter and that their undefeated season went to trash.
I wish I could punch a Beavers player on the face but I'm aware that it was actually Oregon's fault, they kept doing the same dumb plays such as the one of giving the ball to a nearby player to ram into the other players instead of the one where you throw the ball to another player at a far distance (the play Oregon State kept doing when they started playing good in the last quarter and eventually cost us the game)
I wish I could punch a Beavers player on the face but I'm aware that it was actually Oregon's fault, they kept doing the same dumb plays such as the one of giving the ball to a nearby player to ram into the other players instead of the one where you throw the ball to another player at a far distance (the play Oregon State kept doing when they started playing good in the last quarter and eventually cost us the game)
-
whosyourwally
- Freshman
- Posts: 1320
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
But if you look at that differently (when we have experience, Avalos’s scheme works well), then we have a reason to hope for improvement with experience. As fans, what else do we have besides hope...?greenyellow wrote:I think we're seeing how much having Dye, Holland, Breeze, Graham, and even Lamar Winston really helped Avalos' scheme. With so many inexperienced guys back there now, it's getting exposed by everyone.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
whosyourwally
- Freshman
- Posts: 1320
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 10:52 am
- Location: Columbus, Ohio
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
Also, best summary of the game I’ve seen so far:
https://youtu.be/ySboWtK7Jow
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
https://youtu.be/ySboWtK7Jow
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
Herbert took a whole lot more risks than Shough did but he had the arm to get away with it. That people are looking for ways that Shough is somehow better than Herbert is hilarious to me.GrantDuck wrote:Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
The 2nd INT cost us big-time and yes, the Defense is soft as yogurt but Shough can't read a defense to keep drives alive.

- Alan
- Senior
- Posts: 4359
- Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
Agreed, D needs work on wrapping up and tackling but Slough cost us the game, possibly more than then the D did, with his two sloppy int’s.Duck07 wrote:Herbert took a whole lot more risks than Shough did but he had the arm to get away with it. That people are looking for ways that Shough is somehow better than Herbert is hilarious to me.GrantDuck wrote:Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
The 2nd INT cost us big-time and yes, the Defense is soft as yogurt but Shough can't read a defense to keep drives alive.
Also to quote Tom Hanks.... there’s no crying in football..... we lost, move on.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
I get that Herbert has a big arm and everything physically you want in a quarterback but that doesn't score points. Herbert always underperformed when it came to scoring points. Last year against OSU he could barely score and relied on Verdell having a 200 yard game just to score 24 points. I get some of you guy's are Herbert fans but you have to face the reality that he Trent Dilfered his way to winning a Rose Bowl. Shough doesn't have half the defense that Herbert did. Also Herbert threw those over the middle interceptions too.Duck07 wrote:Herbert took a whole lot more risks than Shough did but he had the arm to get away with it. That people are looking for ways that Shough is somehow better than Herbert is hilarious to me.GrantDuck wrote:Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
The 2nd INT cost us big-time and yes, the Defense is soft as yogurt but Shough can't read a defense to keep drives alive.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
duck023 wrote:
I get that Herbert has a big arm and everything physically you want in a quarterback but that doesn't score points. Herbert always underperformed when it came to scoring points. Last year against OSU he could barely score and relied on Verdell having a 200 yard game just to score 24 points. I get some of you guy's are Herbert fans but you have to face the reality that he Trent Dilfered his way to winning a Rose Bowl. Shough doesn't have half the defense that Herbert did. Also Herbert threw those over the middle interceptions too.
I love how you ignore Arroyo and Moorhead in any analysis too when it comes to the Offense as if somehow an actual Top 10 QB in the world right now would be less than Shough in this offense. Trent Dilfer...We get it you love Shough.

-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
How is Shough to blame when he scored 14 more points then the Herbert did last year? The defense going from 10 points given up to 41 points given up is to blame. Lets not pretend Herbert didn't have games where he did absolutely nothing but throw interceptions and the defense bailed him out. The only game Herbert played great in last year was against USC but Shough also had his best game against USC.Alan wrote:Agreed, D needs work on wrapping up and tackling but Slough cost us the game, possibly more than then the D did, with his two sloppy int’s.Duck07 wrote:Herbert took a whole lot more risks than Shough did but he had the arm to get away with it. That people are looking for ways that Shough is somehow better than Herbert is hilarious to me.GrantDuck wrote:Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
The 2nd INT cost us big-time and yes, the Defense is soft as yogurt but Shough can't read a defense to keep drives alive.
Also to quote Tom Hanks.... there’s no crying in football..... we lost, move on.
Last edited by duck023 on Sat Nov 28, 2020 9:38 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)
I think Shough takes what the defense gives him but I've made this argument before years ago when I said I'd rather have Darren Thomas then Herbert because Herbert always killed drives trying to fit it into a tight window instead of taking the easy 5 yard wide open pass. I love Herbert for what he is. Herbert was the most talented quarterback that let the defense do most of the work but once in a while looked like an NFL quarterback. However I love Darron Thomas and Shough for their ability to take what the defense gives them and score a bunch of points. I agree the Offensive Coordinator does seem better but there is no way that there is that big of gap between them in play calling. I've seen many times where Herbert passed up a easy throw for a throw down the field.Duck07 wrote:duck023 wrote:
I get that Herbert has a big arm and everything physically you want in a quarterback but that doesn't score points. Herbert always underperformed when it came to scoring points. Last year against OSU he could barely score and relied on Verdell having a 200 yard game just to score 24 points. I get some of you guy's are Herbert fans but you have to face the reality that he Trent Dilfered his way to winning a Rose Bowl. Shough doesn't have half the defense that Herbert did. Also Herbert threw those over the middle interceptions too.![]()
I love how you ignore Arroyo and Moorhead in any analysis too when it comes to the Offense as if somehow an actual Top 10 QB in the world right now would be less than Shough in this offense. Trent Dilfer...We get it you love Shough.
Last edited by duck023 on Sat Nov 28, 2020 9:37 am, edited 2 times in total.