#9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Alan
Senior
Posts: 4359
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2014 2:17 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by Alan »

duck023 wrote:
Alan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.

The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
Herbert took a whole lot more risks than Shough did but he had the arm to get away with it. That people are looking for ways that Shough is somehow better than Herbert is hilarious to me.

The 2nd INT cost us big-time and yes, the Defense is soft as yogurt but Shough can't read a defense to keep drives alive.
Agreed, D needs work on wrapping up and tackling but Slough cost us the game, possibly more than then the D did, with his two sloppy int’s.

Also to quote Tom Hanks.... there’s no crying in football..... we lost, move on.
How is Shough to blame when he scored 14 more points then the Herbert did last year? The defense going from 10 points given up to 41 points given up is too blame. Lets not pretend Herbert didn't have games where he did absolutely nothing but throw interceptions and the defense bailed him out. The only game Herbert played great in last year was against USC but Shough also had his best game against USC.
Wow, not going to debate your argument, Herbert is a POS, that is how he was the sixth overall draft choice, because of his Mediocre play, potentially ROY because of how he developed at Oregon, even with the complete cluster the Ducks coaching staff was during his years there. Shough two pics killed us! The D is just as responsible for the loss as well.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

duck023 wrote: How is Shough to blame when he scored 14 more points then the Herbert did last year? The defense going from 10 points given up to 41 points given up is too blame. Lets not pretend Herbert didn't have games where he did absolutely nothing but throw interceptions and the defense bailed him out. The only game Herbert played great in last year was against USC but Shough also had his best game against USC.
Last year doesn't have anything to do with last night - that you keep bringing it up is telling that you don't actually have any good reasons for what you keep saying. Start talking specifically about what Shough does that makes him such a great QB because right now I don't see it. I see an offense that makes things very easy for the QB and he is still struggling and that says nothing of his ability to read the defense with his route tree and go to the right spot.

Let's not pretend either like the Arroyo and Moorhead offenses are that comparable even if they line up in the Pistol.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40719
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by UOducksTK1 »

GoDucksTroll wrote:If this is what it takes to have a good kicker I don’t want it anymore.
Lol

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

Alan wrote:
duck023 wrote:
Alan wrote:
Duck07 wrote:
GrantDuck wrote:
duck023 wrote:I will say there is one positive that I saw in the game but I'm not sure a lot of people agree with me. Shough had a much easier time moving then ball against Oregon State then Herbert did. Remember Herbert only scored 24 points last year and actually threw for 100 less yards then Shough did this year against Oregon St. Maybe Oregon St just has a really good defense. However what really upsets me and makes me worried about next season is that the defense went from giving up 10 points to Oregon St to giving up 41 points to them
Herbert didn't take risks like Shough does both running the ball and taking hits and in terms of risky throws. It's been a double edged sword because we've had more big plays, but turnovers. I'll live with that as Shough learns, hopefully he makes less of those mistakes.

The defense falling off though to this level is just inexcusable and I'm absolutely at a loss for why it's happened other than it being pretty damn clear that the defensive line didn't take offseason conditioning seriously. They all look doughy as hell and lost muscle mass.
Herbert took a whole lot more risks than Shough did but he had the arm to get away with it. That people are looking for ways that Shough is somehow better than Herbert is hilarious to me.

The 2nd INT cost us big-time and yes, the Defense is soft as yogurt but Shough can't read a defense to keep drives alive.
Agreed, D needs work on wrapping up and tackling but Slough cost us the game, possibly more than then the D did, with his two sloppy int’s.

Also to quote Tom Hanks.... there’s no crying in football..... we lost, move on.
How is Shough to blame when he scored 14 more points then the Herbert did last year? The defense going from 10 points given up to 41 points given up is too blame. Lets not pretend Herbert didn't have games where he did absolutely nothing but throw interceptions and the defense bailed him out. The only game Herbert played great in last year was against USC but Shough also had his best game against USC.
Wow, not going to debate your argument, Herbert is a POS, that is how he was the sixth overall draft choice, because of his Mediocre play, potentially ROY because of how he developed at Oregon, even with the complete cluster the Ducks coaching staff was during his years there. slough two pics killed us! The D is just as responsible for the loss as well.
I wouldn't expect a lot of you guy's to. You guy's never wanted to debate Herbert when he was playing here let alone now. See I debate what Herbert did and you guy's always debate who he is. I admit he is a big talented, strong armed quarterback with underrated speed that didn't score a 4th quarter touchdown until halfway through his last year.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

Duck07 wrote:
duck023 wrote: How is Shough to blame when he scored 14 more points then the Herbert did last year? The defense going from 10 points given up to 41 points given up is too blame. Lets not pretend Herbert didn't have games where he did absolutely nothing but throw interceptions and the defense bailed him out. The only game Herbert played great in last year was against USC but Shough also had his best game against USC.
Last year doesn't have anything to do with last night - that you keep bringing it up is telling that you don't actually have any good reasons for what you keep saying. Start talking specifically about what Shough does that makes him such a great QB because right now I don't see it. I see an offense that makes things very easy for the QB and he is still struggling and that says nothing of his ability to read the defense with his route tree and go to the right spot.

Let's not pretend either like the Arroyo and Moorhead offenses are that comparable even if they line up in the Pistol.
I don't think Shough is as good as Herbert yet and I do agree Moorhead seems like a much better coach. Basically what I'm saying is Herbert/Arroyo = Shough/Moorhead so its definitely the defense and the running games fault. However you can't blame Arroyo for all of the tightness in late game situations Herbert had because Herbert's still sort of doing that with the Chargers. In the first half there is nobody better than Herbert even Mariota but Herbert would get nervous in the 2nd half. Some people say it was all because of play calling but I have a hard time believing its all Arroyo's fault. In Herbert's defense I do think the first year with Helfrich did mess with his mind because he sort of got used to losing and had to learn how to win over his 4 years while Shough was already on a winning team.
Last edited by duck023 on Sat Nov 28, 2020 10:52 am, edited 1 time in total.
RanDux
Senior
Posts: 2840
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:19 pm
Location: Happy Valley, OR

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by RanDux »

GoDucksTroll wrote:That was so horrible.

When Shough threw that poop pass attempt on third down when you needed a first down to win the game I knew Oregon State was winning it. The ultimate sign of no confidence, when the game is still in your control and you know what the result is going to be.

He had a man wide open well beyond the marker. That one play or the offense itself isn’t what lost the game, just upset at all the facets and not just this worthless defense.
Two other receivers wide open and he throws it side-armed to the nearest receiver who was covered and can't get it to him. One of the open receivers was open because his defender fell down, and the WR jumped up and down after Shough didn't take advantage of the situation. Shough just doesn't see the field very well. That one play, more than any other, lost the game. Make the pass to the wide open WR and you get the first down and run out the clock.
User avatar
QuackininBama
All Pac-12
Posts: 5736
Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by QuackininBama »

This loss was embarrassing, but that is the extent of it.

With Covid, and Scott shutting down the Pac, then the SEC deciding to play, our fate was sealed, regardless. We have to play near flawless football every single week to even get a sniff at the playoffs and hoping the most mediocre SEC team slips up so there is a spot open, this year was never in the cards regardless. Not to even mention losing some great players who quit playing this year, lets just agree to call this entire season a wash and hope it doesn't affect recruiting to much.


But...daaaannnggg, the Beavs tore our D a new A$$! Ouch!
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6461
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by pezsez1 »

Nobody should be surprised by what happened here. Both teams should have been 2-1, and OSU should have been coming off of a two-game win streak. I watched OSU's last two games and saw a team that was less talented but playing at the peak of its potential, led by an experienced starting QB, a powerful RB, and a scrappy defense that played with pride. Oregon, on the other hand, looks ultra talented but dangerously young. Yesterday, to me, seemed like the first time the teams lined up as equals since 2009. Might be another 11 years before that happens again, but man -- I saw this one coming from a mile away.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

QuackininBama wrote:This loss was embarrassing, but that is the extent of it.

With Covid, and Scott shutting down the Pac, then the SEC deciding to play, our fate was sealed, regardless. We have to play near flawless football every single week to even get a sniff at the playoffs and hoping the most mediocre SEC team slips up so there is a spot open, this year was never in the cards regardless. Not to even mention losing some great players who quit playing this year, lets just agree to call this entire season a wash and hope it doesn't affect recruiting to much.


But...daaaannnggg, the Beavs tore our D a new A$$! Ouch!
Not everything is about the playoffs. I was hoping for a Cotton Bowl with an undefeated season because that would lead to great momentum for next year. Also the media mainly decides the playoffs so getting a nice preseason ranking is huge but Oregon won't be ranked if they go 4-2 on an easy schedule and have zero momentum for next season. I can already see the pattern people will call next year a rebuilding year too at this rate.
User avatar
QuackininBama
All Pac-12
Posts: 5736
Joined: Sat Sep 10, 2011 8:55 am

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by QuackininBama »

duck023 wrote:
QuackininBama wrote:This loss was embarrassing, but that is the extent of it.

With Covid, and Scott shutting down the Pac, then the SEC deciding to play, our fate was sealed, regardless. We have to play near flawless football every single week to even get a sniff at the playoffs and hoping the most mediocre SEC team slips up so there is a spot open, this year was never in the cards regardless. Not to even mention losing some great players who quit playing this year, lets just agree to call this entire season a wash and hope it doesn't affect recruiting to much.


But...daaaannnggg, the Beavs tore our D a new A$$! Ouch!
Not everything is about the playoffs. I was hoping for a Cotton Bowl with an undefeated season because that would lead to great momentum for next year. Also the media mainly decides the playoffs so getting a nice preseason ranking is huge but Oregon won't be ranked if they go 4-2 on an easy schedule and have zero momentum for next season. I can already see the pattern people will call next year a rebuilding year too at this rate.
I see what you're saying, however the players we recruit do not come to Oregon to play in the Cotton Bowl. The Ducks are just a hair under the elite teams. The players we are recruiting expect a Pac-12 championship and a spot in the CFP, at the very least! I was just thinking long term.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

pezsez1 wrote:Nobody should be surprised by what happened here. Both teams should have been 2-1, and OSU should have been coming off of a two-game win streak. I watched OSU's last two games and saw a team that was less talented but playing at the peak of its potential, led by an experienced starting QB, a powerful RB, and a scrappy defense that played with pride. Oregon, on the other hand, looks ultra talented but dangerously young. Yesterday, to me, seemed like the first time the teams lined up as equals since 2009. Might be another 11 years before that happens again, but man -- I saw this one coming from a mile away.
I like how you said you saw this coming from a mile away and then just dismiss the Beavers for the next 11 years. You pretty much admitted the Beavers are coaching their young guy's better. I hope you are right but I don't see Oregon all of a sudden being way better and OSU getting way worse next year.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by Duck07 »

duck023 wrote: I wouldn't expect a lot of you guy's to. You guy's never wanted to debate Herbert when he was playing here let alone now. See I debate what Herbert did and you guy's always debate who he is. I admit he is a big talented, strong armed quarterback with underrated speed that didn't score a 4th quarter touchdown until halfway through his last year.
You weren't even a member of this board when Herbert played here so yes, nobody was going to debate you on it. What's your debate argument though? That Shough should have started over Herbert last year? That he's a superior college QB?
Image
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

QuackininBama wrote:
duck023 wrote:
QuackininBama wrote:This loss was embarrassing, but that is the extent of it.

With Covid, and Scott shutting down the Pac, then the SEC deciding to play, our fate was sealed, regardless. We have to play near flawless football every single week to even get a sniff at the playoffs and hoping the most mediocre SEC team slips up so there is a spot open, this year was never in the cards regardless. Not to even mention losing some great players who quit playing this year, lets just agree to call this entire season a wash and hope it doesn't affect recruiting to much.


But...daaaannnggg, the Beavs tore our D a new A$$! Ouch!
Not everything is about the playoffs. I was hoping for a Cotton Bowl with an undefeated season because that would lead to great momentum for next year. Also the media mainly decides the playoffs so getting a nice preseason ranking is huge but Oregon won't be ranked if they go 4-2 on an easy schedule and have zero momentum for next season. I can already see the pattern people will call next year a rebuilding year too at this rate.
I see what you're saying, however the players we recruit do not come to Oregon to play in the Cotton Bowl. The Ducks are just a hair under the elite teams. The players we are recruiting expect a Pac-12 championship and a spot in the CFP, at the very least! I was just thinking long term.
I'm getting 2013 flashbacks of when Huff said he was tired of playing in the Rose Bowl and ended up in the Alamo Bowl. Even if Oregon wins multiple national championships we'll never be above the Cotton Bowl and definitely not the Rose Bowl. Don't get me wrong though I do think as fans we need to hold Oregon to a high standard but the Cotton Bowl, Sugar Bowl and Orange Bowl would be pretty cool for the Ducks to win. I'd understand you thinking this about the Alamo Bowl. I'd actually rather go to the Sun Bowl just because I think the Sun Bowl is a cooler name.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

If the defense does not figure out how to tackle, it will not matter who the quarterback is. All week they heard about their running back. It did not do one bit of good. They still sucked. They were told repeatedly and still did not do the job. Offense puts up 30 plus points and the defense basically says nope, have to put up 50 then might win the game. I want the players to take accountability for playing so bad. I want them to come out the next 2 weeks and be super aggressive and show that they really do deserve to be starters and set the tone early the next 2 weeks. I am not seeing it though. I hear them say we have to do better, welllll um no kidding Sherlock. Thanks for stating the obvious. The defense is ranked near the bottom in most categories. Chew on that for awhile. It is the players not the coaches.
duck023
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 809
Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm

Re: #9 Oregon @ Oregon State (Nov. 27 Fri 4:30 PM ESPN)

Post by duck023 »

Duck07 wrote:
duck023 wrote: I wouldn't expect a lot of you guy's to. You guy's never wanted to debate Herbert when he was playing here let alone now. See I debate what Herbert did and you guy's always debate who he is. I admit he is a big talented, strong armed quarterback with underrated speed that didn't score a 4th quarter touchdown until halfway through his last year.
You weren't even a member of this board when Herbert played here so yes, nobody was going to debate you on it. What's your debate argument though? That Shough should have started over Herbert last year? That he's a superior college QB?
I forgot my old password it happens. Trust me I remember the arguments of how it was all the Offensive Coordinator's and Receivers fault. Now with Shough we have the best receivers and offensive coordinator I guess.
Post Reply