It worries me that Cristobal is so afraid to play Ty Thompson and Butterfield because I assumed this year was all about buying time so that Ty Thompson could play towards the end of the season. The fact that Cristobal still doesn't think Ty Thompson is the guy worries me as far as the development goes.droop10 wrote:Do you really see talent not developing? You don’t see any improvement from this team based on last year’s 4-4 squad? The way football is these days, you can only go as far as your QB and we see the limitations there. I think the Herbert years had 2 effects: 1) he was entrenched as starter as a true freshman. Hard to get elite QB prospects to your school these days if they don’t see an opportunity to play in the near future. So when he left the QB room was thin. The guys that were here had to learn a new offense in a weird Covid year, and the most experienced one transferred out. 2) fans think all guys can come in as a true freshman and be ready to go. Herbert was the exception, not the rule. Also, he had the benefit of getting to develop in a lost season where there were no expectations. Brown is frustrating to watch, but I trust if there was a better option they would have gone with it. The coaches kind of want to win too, ya know? Now that there’s no playoff on the line, I wish they’d move on from him, but I know they won’t because they still want to shoot for the PAC-12 title. I’d personally prioritize development over another worthless Rose Bowl win.UofDuck wrote:
It’s not about blowouts. It’s about trending. Also, my expectations are not based on Chip, they’re based on consecutive years of superb recruiting. We have the kind of talent to be elite and we simply aren’t. Its painfully obvious we have a lot of warts that seem to repeat themselves every year. My two biggest issues with MC are lack of talent development. It missing in almost all facets. And Mario’s stubborn focus on the old style SEC play of 3 yards and a cloud of dust smash mouth football. It’s never going to take us to the promise land and that is disappointing. I’m not totally anti Mario, but the dude refuses to evolve. Even his mentor Saban has evolved.
#4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39362
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
I think part of it is also them trying to preserve both Thompson and Butterfield's redshirt years. I believe Thompson is at 3 game appearances so far so he can only play in one more before he burns his redshirt. Butterfield has one game appearance but I don't think they trust him to start right now. The COVID year really screwed things up in spacing out the QB depth chart and getting adequate development for Ashford and Butterfield.

-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
I have to disagree, Chip made it look easy but the Pac 12 was one of the best conferences back then. I can't say that right now. Stanford was a team that went to back to back BCS bowls when Chip was at his best. USC had that 10-2 team that beat Oregon when Lebron was there jinxing Oregon. Also Oregon beat a top 5 USC team in Chip's first year. I also think USC was ranked during the Will Ferrell game. Stanford with Luck and USC with Barkley were much better than Utah and ASU teams this year.droop10 wrote:I’m not sure. I think the conference was awful during the Chip years. I remember playing UCLA in that first PAC-12 championship game and they were awful. I believe those were the years that had awful bottom feeders like UW going 0-12, Wazzu not being much better, Colorado was atrocious. I think the bottom of the conference was much worse then than it is now, and there weren’t really any threats at the top either.duck023 wrote:The first team's I watched were the Harrington teams. It made no sense to me why Oregon dropped off so much after those years. Also I'd argue the conference is worse now than the Chip Kelly years which is one of the reason's my expectations are high. I feel like Florida could run the table in this conference. USC and Stanford were both solid teams in the Chip Kelly era they are both under 500 right now.greenyellow wrote:That's almost exactly when I attended school (2003-07) so I certainly understand how up and down those seasons were. I think fans really forget how bad the conference was during the majority of Chip's tenure, which made those seasons look really easy in comparison to how the conference is now.droop10 wrote:Eh, the 4 years after Harrington were when I attended the school, and those were lean years. They had the 10-2 Clemens year which was cool, but overall fans were just happy with wins, and weren’t expecting to blow out every team and were pretty happy with 8-9 wins. It’s the Chip years that brought aboard unrealistic expectations of what should be considered a routine Oregon season. Fans now expect to blow everyone out and win 10+ games every year. One would think the post-Kelly years would have reset some expectations, but apparently not. People that are unhappy with Cristobal don’t understand that there are very few coaches that Oregon can realistically get that would do significantly better.
- greenyellow
- Moderator

- Posts: 39362
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
- Location: Eugene, OR
-
OrTDuck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 291
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2020 6:39 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
Arizona lost to Northern Arizona
ASU lost to BYU
UCLA lost to Fresno State
Colorado lost to Minnesota 30-0
Utah lost to BYU and San Diego State
Washington lost to Montana State
Cal lost to Nevada
WSU lost to Utah State
Stanford lost to Kansas State 24-7
OSU lost to Purdue
USC and Oregon are the only two teams who didn't get whipped OOC, and USC just gave up 62 to UCLA.
The conference was arguably down during the Chip years.
Right now it's approaching a different level. As many as 6 MWC teams might be battling at 0.500 or better in the Pac-12, and a decent but not world beating BYU team probably is running away with this conference (and they lost to Boise State).
Chip never had it this easy.
Shoot, Stanford in 2010, 2011, and 2012, USC in 2011 were actually good.
ASU lost to BYU
UCLA lost to Fresno State
Colorado lost to Minnesota 30-0
Utah lost to BYU and San Diego State
Washington lost to Montana State
Cal lost to Nevada
WSU lost to Utah State
Stanford lost to Kansas State 24-7
OSU lost to Purdue
USC and Oregon are the only two teams who didn't get whipped OOC, and USC just gave up 62 to UCLA.
The conference was arguably down during the Chip years.
Right now it's approaching a different level. As many as 6 MWC teams might be battling at 0.500 or better in the Pac-12, and a decent but not world beating BYU team probably is running away with this conference (and they lost to Boise State).
Chip never had it this easy.
Shoot, Stanford in 2010, 2011, and 2012, USC in 2011 were actually good.
-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
I hope that is the case. See I'm already assuming that Thompson is leaving before his senior year so I'm not that concerned with his redshirt but maybe Cristobal sees him as a guy who will play all 5 years.greenyellow wrote:I think part of it is also them trying to preserve both Thompson and Butterfield's redshirt years. I believe Thompson is at 3 game appearances so far so he can only play in one more before he burns his redshirt. Butterfield has one game appearance but I don't think they trust him to start right now. The COVID year really screwed things up in spacing out the QB depth chart and getting adequate development for Ashford and Butterfield.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15428
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
This, the fact that people think the conference is comparable to when Chip was the coach is laughable. Chip and Harbaugh/Early Shaw Stanford teams would walk through this conference with ease. There were other good teams too, Nick Foles Zona teams, ASU had a solid defense, USC had really good years and firing Kiffin was a huge mistake. There were some bad teams but the amount of awful teams the PAC-12 has this season makes it a historically bad season for the conference. Oregon faced two conference opponents that lost to FCS teams and others that have had embarrassingly bad losses, Oregon’s strength of schedule is really low and that’s entirely due to the PAC-12.OrTDuck wrote:Arizona lost to Northern Arizona
ASU lost to BYU
UCLA lost to Fresno State
Colorado lost to Minnesota 30-0
Utah lost to BYU and San Diego State
Washington lost to Montana State
Cal lost to Nevada
WSU lost to Utah State
Stanford lost to Kansas State 24-7
OSU lost to Purdue
USC and Oregon are the only two teams who didn't get whipped OOC, and USC just gave up 62 to UCLA.
The conference was arguably down during the Chip years.
Right now it's approaching a different level. As many as 6 MWC teams might be battling at 0.500 or better in the Pac-12, and a decent but not world beating BYU team probably is running away with this conference (and they lost to Boise State).
Chip never had it this easy.
Shoot, Stanford in 2010, 2011, and 2012, USC in 2011 were actually good.

- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
I didn't see the game today as I was at other games but I can understand losing and the defense not playing well but the offense only scoring 7 is something that shouldn't be happening.
Once the game was out of hand, it was a great chance to let Butterfield get actual reps and alternate the backups so they'd believe in an actual competition in the Fall. One of the major question marks about this season going in was QB development and it's an F grade wise for Mario and it will be a serious question mark again in the Fall.
Once the game was out of hand, it was a great chance to let Butterfield get actual reps and alternate the backups so they'd believe in an actual competition in the Fall. One of the major question marks about this season going in was QB development and it's an F grade wise for Mario and it will be a serious question mark again in the Fall.

-
duck023
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 809
- Joined: Tue Jan 21, 2020 3:32 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
I agree with everything you said. Although I will defend UCLA a little bit. UCLA's win against LSU meant more than their loss against Fresno State. The moment LSU found out the Rose Bowl wasn't Tiger Stadium was one of the few moments of pride I had for the Pac 12 other than Oregon beating Ohio State.OrTDuck wrote:Arizona lost to Northern Arizona
ASU lost to BYU
UCLA lost to Fresno State
Colorado lost to Minnesota 30-0
Utah lost to BYU and San Diego State
Washington lost to Montana State
Cal lost to Nevada
WSU lost to Utah State
Stanford lost to Kansas State 24-7
OSU lost to Purdue
USC and Oregon are the only two teams who didn't get whipped OOC, and USC just gave up 62 to UCLA.
The conference was arguably down during the Chip years.
Right now it's approaching a different level. As many as 6 MWC teams might be battling at 0.500 or better in the Pac-12, and a decent but not world beating BYU team probably is running away with this conference (and they lost to Boise State).
Chip never had it this easy.
Shoot, Stanford in 2010, 2011, and 2012, USC in 2011 were actually good.
You are right during Chip's day's I wasn't worried about the reputation of the Pac 12 I just rooted for Oregon. Right now I'm worried about the reputation of the Pac 12.
-
snapt
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 588
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:02 pm
- Location: Behind the potato curtain
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
I keep waiting for Brown to get hurt to truly see where Ty is. I don't think you run AB 20 times last game without having confidence in Ty with a #3 ranking. Time will tell. AB tossed some decent balls down the field then fell apart under throwing and throwing behind receivers all game. Dude isn't a playoff QB. Justin Roper would have this offense moving the ball better.
Remember the Belloti years where we'd start 6-0, get roughed up by USC, then slide down the stretch?
Remember the Belloti years where we'd start 6-0, get roughed up by USC, then slide down the stretch?
BOOF it!
- pezsez1
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 6457
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
- Location: RIP CITY
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
The problem with Brown is he's only effective when the offense is constantly moving forward. He's fantastic with reliably getting chunks of 3-6 yards, and in plenty of games that powers us to dominant (yet lower-scoring) games.
That said, his success rate plummets once we're in second-and-long, and any drive with a penalty is basically over.
That said, his success rate plummets once we're in second-and-long, and any drive with a penalty is basically over.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
-
dthomas=ddixon
- Moderator

- Posts: 8816
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
- Location: McMinnville, Oregon
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
Yep, he’s barely a QB. We’re trying to win games with a QB who can legitimately only complete a handful of real passes a game.pezsez1 wrote:The problem with Brown is he's only effective when the offense is constantly moving forward. He's fantastic with reliably getting chunks of 3-6 yards, and in plenty of games that powers us to dominant (yet lower-scoring) games.
That said, his success rate plummets once we're in second-and-long, and any drive with a penalty is basically over.
I keep getting flashbacks to the 2007 season when Dixon and Leaf went down. The game where we rotated Cody Kempt and Justin Roper was some of the hardest to watch offense of my life… and that’s what AB and this offense remind me of at times. Just ineptitude.
If that’s what you’re going to roll out there every week, you think a team like Utah wasn’t going to be able to take advantage of such a glaring weakness? Tonight was bound to happen, we just hadn’t faced a team good enough to make us pay.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

-
hjpop
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 823
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:52 pm
- Location: Salem, OR
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
With JJ and Redd out for the season and Pittman gone, I wonder what MC is going to do with his QB room now. Saving TT's redshirt, I get that. Why not Butterfield? Ashford's still not ready (doubt he will be, think he's gone this year if Baseball doesn't work out for him). I'm still having a hard time believing that we don't have SOMEONE ready to step up and challenge Brown.
-
alxtw
- Freshman
- Posts: 1278
- Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:46 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
Exactly! O-line whisperer my a**. I'd be very surprised and ecstatic if banks stills to his Oregon commitment.OfaFeather wrote:One thing I get upset about is that the coach talks about physicality, but Utah dominated them on all sides of the ball, in all phases, for four quarters. If your Identity is physicality, then this was a bad showing of it. Oregon got owned this game.
But lets not kid ourselves. We would have got slaughtered in a playoff game. We re no where near a championship team (our end goal). We caught Ohio state on their worst performance while we were playing our best ball. Ever since that game, we ve dropped to our bar while ohio state has risen to their usual self.
-
OrTDuck
- Three Star Recruit
- Posts: 291
- Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2020 6:39 pm
Re: #4 Oregon @ #24 Utah (Nov. 20, Sat 4:30 PM ABC)
Funny when the discussion turns to all time worse single Duck games in my memory, that is the one I tend to think of also (UCLA 2007). The 2015 TCU Alamo Bowl at least had a decent Duck first half.
Coming off that incredible 2007 run prior to the Dixon injury, on that day 6-5 UCLA beat Oregon 16-0.
Oregon punted 12 times for 505 yards, had 3 interceptions and 1 lost fumble. UCLA itself had 10 punts for 464 yards and 2 interceptions.
The Ducks had 182 yards of offense, and UCLA 245 yards of offense. Oregon crossed the field into UCLA territory 3 times in the game, the furthest getting to the UCLA 34 yard line.
The QB stats were:
Kempt: 6-23 for 52 yards with 0 TDs and 2 INT (QB rating: 3.4)
Roper: 1-5 for 8 yards with 0TDs and 1 INT (QB rating: 1.5)
Leaf: 4-11 for 45 yards with 0TDs and 0 INT (QB rating: 47.0).
11-39 for 139 yards with 0 TDs and 3 INT
Stewart was the leading rusher with 13 carries for 33 yards (2.5 ypc) and for the game the Ducks averaged:
1.1 yards per carry
2.7 yards per pass attempt
And Oregon was credited with 15 offensive plays that lost one yard or more.
ESPN lists Oregon's drive chart as:
4 plays: 4 yards PUNT
6 plays: 12 yards FUMBLE
3 plays: 1 yard PUNT
11 plays: 40 yards PUNT
3 plays: 3 yards PUNT
3 plays: -5 yards PUNT
3 plays: 4 yards INT
4 plays: 16 yards PUNT
5 plays: 15 yards PUNT
3 plays: 15 yards PUNT
3 plays: 5 yards PUNT
3 plays: -4 yards PUNT
3 plays: -2 yards INT
3 plays: -2 yards PUNT
8 plays: 28 yards INT
3 plays: -17 yards PUNT
7 plays: 24 yards DOWNS
4 plays: 9 yards DOWNS
ESPN lists yards gained per play for Oregon:
Inc, 9, inc, 8, 3, -3, inc, 20, -11 (fumble), 1, inc, inc, inc, 5, 7, 11, 11, -3, -2, -2, inc, -8, 21, -4, 4, 3, -6, 3, -2, 3, 1, INT, 12, 3, 1, inc, 5, 9, inc, 1, inc, inc, inc, inc
5, inc, inc, -4, inc, inc, -3, 6, INT, 3, 2, -7, 4, 1, 3, 7, inc, INT, 8, 5, inc, -8, -9, inc, 5, 12, -7, inc, inc, 14, inc, inc, inc, 9
I guess the defense didn't play terrible that game given the offense's struggles, but UCLA wasn't too great that year, finishing 6-7 with a loss to BYU in the Vegas Bowl. They finished averaging 3.1 ypc and 3.8 yards per pass that day, with both teams each having 1 play over 20 yards.
Coming off that incredible 2007 run prior to the Dixon injury, on that day 6-5 UCLA beat Oregon 16-0.
Oregon punted 12 times for 505 yards, had 3 interceptions and 1 lost fumble. UCLA itself had 10 punts for 464 yards and 2 interceptions.
The Ducks had 182 yards of offense, and UCLA 245 yards of offense. Oregon crossed the field into UCLA territory 3 times in the game, the furthest getting to the UCLA 34 yard line.
The QB stats were:
Kempt: 6-23 for 52 yards with 0 TDs and 2 INT (QB rating: 3.4)
Roper: 1-5 for 8 yards with 0TDs and 1 INT (QB rating: 1.5)
Leaf: 4-11 for 45 yards with 0TDs and 0 INT (QB rating: 47.0).
11-39 for 139 yards with 0 TDs and 3 INT
Stewart was the leading rusher with 13 carries for 33 yards (2.5 ypc) and for the game the Ducks averaged:
1.1 yards per carry
2.7 yards per pass attempt
And Oregon was credited with 15 offensive plays that lost one yard or more.
ESPN lists Oregon's drive chart as:
4 plays: 4 yards PUNT
6 plays: 12 yards FUMBLE
3 plays: 1 yard PUNT
11 plays: 40 yards PUNT
3 plays: 3 yards PUNT
3 plays: -5 yards PUNT
3 plays: 4 yards INT
4 plays: 16 yards PUNT
5 plays: 15 yards PUNT
3 plays: 15 yards PUNT
3 plays: 5 yards PUNT
3 plays: -4 yards PUNT
3 plays: -2 yards INT
3 plays: -2 yards PUNT
8 plays: 28 yards INT
3 plays: -17 yards PUNT
7 plays: 24 yards DOWNS
4 plays: 9 yards DOWNS
ESPN lists yards gained per play for Oregon:
Inc, 9, inc, 8, 3, -3, inc, 20, -11 (fumble), 1, inc, inc, inc, 5, 7, 11, 11, -3, -2, -2, inc, -8, 21, -4, 4, 3, -6, 3, -2, 3, 1, INT, 12, 3, 1, inc, 5, 9, inc, 1, inc, inc, inc, inc
5, inc, inc, -4, inc, inc, -3, 6, INT, 3, 2, -7, 4, 1, 3, 7, inc, INT, 8, 5, inc, -8, -9, inc, 5, 12, -7, inc, inc, 14, inc, inc, inc, 9
I guess the defense didn't play terrible that game given the offense's struggles, but UCLA wasn't too great that year, finishing 6-7 with a loss to BYU in the Vegas Bowl. They finished averaging 3.1 ypc and 3.8 yards per pass that day, with both teams each having 1 play over 20 yards.