Open Season on PSU players

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

User avatar
Juice
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 685
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:19 am
Location: Seattle

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Juice »

uostudent wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:I'm not going to pretend to know how many scholly players SC has, but I do know you've taken a ton of recruits the last couple years plus the players you already had. If you not at 75 I'm shocked.

That said, reports are that Redd is staying at Penn St and will go to the NFL after this year.
Rather than playing in a new system, living in a vastly different environment and going to a new school - that would be the safe thing to do.

However, there have been conflicting reports. It does sound like USC has one scholarship available. If his only goal is to prepare for the NFL, then staying at Penn State is probably the right move. USC is enticing though because he would immediately become the number 1 RB in a powerful offense on a team that will be a national championship contender.
Would he really just jump McNeal that easy? Idk about that one...
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Braveheart »

swagnatic101 wrote:
uostudent wrote:
buckmarkduck wrote:I'm not going to pretend to know how many scholly players SC has, but I do know you've taken a ton of recruits the last couple years plus the players you already had. If you not at 75 I'm shocked.

That said, reports are that Redd is staying at Penn St and will go to the NFL after this year.
Rather than playing in a new system, living in a vastly different environment and going to a new school - that would be the safe thing to do.

However, there have been conflicting reports. It does sound like USC has one scholarship available. If his only goal is to prepare for the NFL, then staying at Penn State is probably the right move. USC is enticing though because he would immediately become the number 1 RB in a powerful offense on a team that will be a national championship contender.
Would he really just jump McNeal that easy? Idk about that one...
He wouldn't. He's got more size and talent, but he doesn't know the playbook, and Moody McNeal was damn good in his own right. He and Moody would by a nice 1-2 punch. Best USC has seen since Thunder&Lightning.
Image
User avatar
Boom
All Pac-12
Posts: 5816
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
GM: Houston Rockets

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Boom »

I don't understand all of this hype over the Penn St. RB

Is he really suppose to be some type of a game changer?

I would imagine any top 20 program has a starting RB at his level.

Obviously we have some what of a depth issue due to our multiple transfers.

But I seriously doubt this kid would want to come here to compete against Bryon Marshall for carries behind KB & DAT.
User avatar
brich75
Senior
Posts: 4054
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by brich75 »

Boom wrote:I don't understand all of this hype over the Penn St. RB

Is he really suppose to be some type of a game changer?

I would imagine any top 20 program has a starting RB at his level.

Obviously we have some what of a depth issue due to our multiple transfers.

But I seriously doubt this kid would want to come here to compete against Bryon Marshall for carries behind KB & DAT.

Is Oregon even talking to this kid? Everything I have seen is USC talking to Redd, and Redd talking to USC. I haven't seen or heard one thing about Oregon being in contact with him, did I miss something?
Image
User avatar
Boom
All Pac-12
Posts: 5816
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:32 pm
GM: Houston Rockets

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Boom »

brich75 wrote:
Boom wrote:I don't understand all of this hype over the Penn St. RB

Is he really suppose to be some type of a game changer?

I would imagine any top 20 program has a starting RB at his level.

Obviously we have some what of a depth issue due to our multiple transfers.

But I seriously doubt this kid would want to come here to compete against Bryon Marshall for carries behind KB & DAT.

Is Oregon even talking to this kid? Everything I have seen is USC talking to Redd, and Redd talking to USC. I haven't seen or heard one thing about Oregon being in contact with him, did I miss something?
No, I was mostly responding to the orignal post "Any chance anybody takes a look at the ducks?"

And their RB has been the most hyped by the media/fan base.

It doesn't surprise me at all that Kiffin is aggressively recruiting him though.
User avatar
brich75
Senior
Posts: 4054
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by brich75 »

Boom wrote:
brich75 wrote:
Boom wrote:I don't understand all of this hype over the Penn St. RB

Is he really suppose to be some type of a game changer?

I would imagine any top 20 program has a starting RB at his level.

Obviously we have some what of a depth issue due to our multiple transfers.

But I seriously doubt this kid would want to come here to compete against Bryon Marshall for carries behind KB & DAT.

Is Oregon even talking to this kid? Everything I have seen is USC talking to Redd, and Redd talking to USC. I haven't seen or heard one thing about Oregon being in contact with him, did I miss something?
No, I was mostly responding to the orignal post "Any chance anybody takes a look at the ducks?"

And their RB has been the most hyped by the media/fan base.

It doesn't surprise me at all that Kiffin is aggressively recruiting him though.

Damn i was really hoping i missed something
Image
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Braveheart »

Silas Redd (IMO) is better than any of USC or UO's current tail-backs (excluding De'Anthony Thomas who's special at whatever position he's officially at).
Image
uodux1212
Senior
Posts: 3965
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:44 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by uodux1212 »

I find it a bit ironic that Lane sat up on the podium during P12 media days and expressed how hard it was to recruit after the sanctions were handed down at SC and not only did he have to recruit HS players he had to recruit his OWN players to stay. And look who's in the front of the line to swoop one of PSU's best players.

Im not saying I wouldnt be on the first flight to LA if I were Silas (I would be), Im just sayin....
Image

"How do we go from nine to one?" - Chip Kelly

“Our expectations are to win every game we play." - CK
bellsduck
Senior
Posts: 3863
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:40 am
GM: Utah Jazz

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by bellsduck »

I don't think I'd be on that plane. Leave a sure starting position to go and share carries just so I can go to a bowl game? Last I checked, going to a bowl game did not ensure a high draft status in the NFL draft. Penn State's still playing the big boys in CFB, still on TV - probably watched by more people than ever, and don't have to worry about moving and lifestyle change.
User avatar
OregonFan4Life
All-American
Posts: 15429
Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by OregonFan4Life »

Braveheart wrote:Silas Redd (IMO) is better than any of USC or UO's current tail-backs (excluding De'Anthony Thomas who's special at whatever position he's officially at).
I'd take Kenjon Barner over him.
Image
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Braveheart »

OregonFan4Life wrote:
Braveheart wrote:Silas Redd (IMO) is better than any of USC or UO's current tail-backs (excluding De'Anthony Thomas who's special at whatever position he's officially at).
I'd take Kenjon Barner over him.
Barner is better for Oregon's system, but you'd be hard-pressed to find anybody (outside of UO fans) that believe Barner is the better runningback.
Image
uostudent
Senior
Posts: 3561
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:03 pm
Location: Los Angeles

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by uostudent »

Braveheart wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:
Braveheart wrote:Silas Redd (IMO) is better than any of USC or UO's current tail-backs (excluding De'Anthony Thomas who's special at whatever position he's officially at).
I'd take Kenjon Barner over him.
Barner is better for Oregon's system, but you'd be hard-pressed to find anybody (outside of UO fans) that believe Barner is the better runningback.
In a pro style offense, Redd is quite a bit better. Unlike Barner, Redd is very strong in pass protection. Redd is also an everydown back who can handle 30+ carries a game.

Barner is a far better receiver and a much better fit in Oregon's spread offense.

Redd would be a huge pick up for USC. I do think that Redd would pass up McNeal on USC's depth chart. Let's just say that Kiffin isn't selling Redd on coming to USC to be 2nd on the depth chart.
“If everybody in this room just want to be real with themselves, this game could have went either way,” he said. “We turned the ball over a lot. We beat ourself. Just be real with yourself right now. We beat ourself.”
-Jameis Winston after Oregon's decisive 59-20 victory over Florida State in the Rose Bowl
Braveheart
Sophomore
Posts: 1549
Joined: Thu Jan 13, 2011 1:46 am

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by Braveheart »

uostudent wrote:
Braveheart wrote:
OregonFan4Life wrote:
Braveheart wrote:Silas Redd (IMO) is better than any of USC or UO's current tail-backs (excluding De'Anthony Thomas who's special at whatever position he's officially at).
I'd take Kenjon Barner over him.
Barner is better for Oregon's system, but you'd be hard-pressed to find anybody (outside of UO fans) that believe Barner is the better runningback.
In a pro style offense, Redd is quite a bit better. Unlike Barner, Redd is very strong in pass protection. Redd is also an everydown back who can handle 30+ carries a game.

Barner is a far better receiver and a much better fit in Oregon's spread offense.

Redd would be a huge pick up for USC. I do think that Redd would pass up McNeal on USC's depth chart. Let's just say that Kiffin isn't selling Redd on coming to USC to be 2nd on the depth chart.
There's enough carries for them both. USC needed another guy to take the load off of Moody. I do expect Redd to pass him up during the season.
Image
uodux1212
Senior
Posts: 3965
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 2:44 pm
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by uodux1212 »

bellsduck wrote:I don't think I'd be on that plane. Leave a sure starting position to go and share carries just so I can go to a bowl game? Last I checked, going to a bowl game did not ensure a high draft status in the NFL draft. Penn State's still playing the big boys in CFB, still on TV - probably watched by more people than ever, and don't have to worry about moving and lifestyle change.
Not just a bowl game... They have a totally legitimate shot at the NCG. IMO (unless they totally s*** the bed) they'll be playing in a BCS game in January. There's so much hype at SC this season he'd be getting tons of attention and play in games that have national appeal and be on TV every week. Or stay in Happy Valley and wallow in the misery.

No. Brainer.
Image

"How do we go from nine to one?" - Chip Kelly

“Our expectations are to win every game we play." - CK
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: Open Season on PSU players

Post by buckmarkduck »

uodux1212 wrote:
bellsduck wrote:I don't think I'd be on that plane. Leave a sure starting position to go and share carries just so I can go to a bowl game? Last I checked, going to a bowl game did not ensure a high draft status in the NFL draft. Penn State's still playing the big boys in CFB, still on TV - probably watched by more people than ever, and don't have to worry about moving and lifestyle change.
Not just a bowl game... They have a totally legitimate shot at the NCG. IMO (unless they totally s*** the bed) they'll be playing in a BCS game in January. There's so much hype at SC this season he'd be getting tons of attention and play in games that have national appeal and be on TV every week. Or stay in Happy Valley and wallow in the misery.

No. Brainer.
:roll: When's the last PSU RB to live up to what they looked like while in school? I bet, if he ends up actually going to SC, he never lives up to the hype SC fans are putting on him. I also don't see SC living up to the hype either. Remember Thomas had WR's open most of the night, he just missed them. Like the last drive if he throws a even ok ball DAT walks into the end zone and we aren't having to deal with the SC hype machine.
Post Reply