Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Moderators: greenyellow, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
damascusduck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 252
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 1:01 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by damascusduck »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
damascusduck wrote:
greenyellow wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:No offense to Benoit, but this is a reach..
I'd say so. If Oregon can retain both Wilson and Tyner, then I'm okay with the RB depth. Benoit would just be garbage-time filler once Oregon got other RBs the next couple seasons.
That's a stupid statment on many levels.
How so? I don't think it's that far-fetched of a statement. You really think he will get carries over Tyner and Wilson and Marshall? And on top of that, we will probably pull in another four/five star RB after that.

The road for him to see playing time will be extremely thin. But if he's up for the challenge and doesn't mind then so be it. I think because he is a bit bigger back, he might see some time in different formations, or goal line plays (or whatever his stlye fits). But ultimately, dude will be playing 4th quarters most likely.
My comment was meant for greenyellow. I'll bite on your follow up though. None of you internet recruiting experts know how these guys will do if/when they get on campus and in pads. Ever heard of Lache Seastrunk? If this Benoit guy gets an offer, I'll trust the coaches evaluation over you star watchers. Do you really think they would play Tyner over him or another player just based on his rating? LOL I didn't think so.

Triva question. What do Doug Martin, Alex Green, Ryan Matthews and Ronnie Hillman have in common? Cue Jeopardy theme music here.....All low rated, low offered MWC star RBs in the NFL. Ever heard of Chris Johnson? A 2 "star" recruit who picked East Carloina over Eastern Kentucky and UConn. How about 2 "star" Matt Forte who settled on mid major Tulane? Or current Detroit Lion Kevin Smith who's only offer was from mid major Central Florida, where he was a consensus All American his last year. I could go on but you get my point. Oh, speaking about Kenyon Barner. The only school that recruited him as a RB was little old UTEP. :lol:
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40727
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by UOducksTK1 »

damascusduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
damascusduck wrote:
greenyellow wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:No offense to Benoit, but this is a reach..
I'd say so. If Oregon can retain both Wilson and Tyner, then I'm okay with the RB depth. Benoit would just be garbage-time filler once Oregon got other RBs the next couple seasons.
That's a stupid statment on many levels.
How so? I don't think it's that far-fetched of a statement. You really think he will get carries over Tyner and Wilson and Marshall? And on top of that, we will probably pull in another four/five star RB after that.

The road for him to see playing time will be extremely thin. But if he's up for the challenge and doesn't mind then so be it. I think because he is a bit bigger back, he might see some time in different formations, or goal line plays (or whatever his stlye fits). But ultimately, dude will be playing 4th quarters most likely.
My comment was meant for greenyellow. I'll bite on your follow up though. None of you internet recruiting experts know how these guys will do if/when they get on campus and in pads. Ever heard of Lache Seastrunk? If this Benoit guy gets an offer, I'll trust the coaches evaluation over you star watchers. Do you really think they would play Tyner over him or another player just based on his rating? LOL I didn't think so.

Triva question. What do Doug Martin, Alex Green, Ryan Matthews and Ronnie Hillman have in common? Cue Jeopardy theme music here.....All low rated, low offered MWC star RBs in the NFL. Ever heard of Chris Johnson? A 2 "star" recruit who picked East Carloina over Eastern Kentucky and UConn. How about 2 "star" Matt Forte who settled on mid major Tulane? Or current Detroit Lion Kevin Smith who's only offer was from mid major Central Florida, where he was a consensus All American his last year. I could go on but you get my point. Oh, speaking about Kenyon Barner. The only school that recruited him as a RB was little old UTEP. :lol:
No I don't think they would play Tyner over him based on rating. Rather I think they'll take him over Benoit because he has world class speed, broke HS records, was offered before any other 2013 recruit, because he was recruited by other serious BCS schools, etc.

And of course we can come up with 2 star examples that turned out with studs. But the fact that the Ducks went from Johnson to Childs to other RBs then to Benoit just makes me think we are settling for a half decent RB who can be a filler.

And honestly, Lache is a bad example because he's killing it at Baylor. If anything, that strengthens my argument about the talent here at UO. And it'll be difficult for a guy with no BCS offers to track into our lineup.

And Barner is another poor example, because we recruited him to play DB. In fact the year he redshirted, he practiced on defense: "Defensive scout team award for preparations ahead of USC game." The reason he got bumped up because we lacked depth. Coaches move guys around a lot. But ASU recruited Barner for the exact same reasons we recruited Barner. Rivals also had Barner as the #38 RB, hardly a 2 star back. Although I don't care about stars more so than the fact Benoit is completely a fall back option.

And not to come off as rude, but laughing and typing "lol" isn't going to make your points more valid than they are.

Fact is Benoit will be coming into one of the most difficult situations in college football. I'd rather save the scholarship for next year to space things between our RBs more and try to find someone more fitting. Rather than striking out on 3 or 4 other RBs before settling for Benoit.

Barner also committed in October. We are asking Benoit to visit during the last day of college and just in case either Wilson or Johnson don't come.

Fall back option, and I think there are enough facts to prove it. Because this is the case, I'd rather save it for next year as opposed to settling.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40727
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by UOducksTK1 »

And all the other 2/3 star examples you gave are players at smaller schools. I never said these kind of kids won't pan out to be great player. 2/3 star RBs make it to the NFL, no doubt. But this is Oregon, this isn't Central Florida or Boise State. I'm just saying to grab a kid like this with everyone else who is on the Ducks roster and is supposed to be on the roster next year, it seems like an unwise decision. I doubt he'll play a lot outside of 4th quarter.

There's a reason our coaches offered Dontre Wilson and Thomas Tyner practically when they were still in their JR football years. Freaking studs. And I understand not all your players can be studs because someone will walk (Lache, Dontae, etc). BUT! The fact we've already tried to get like 3 or 4 other RBs out for a visit and failed, is full on proof that Benoit is more of a filler than anything else. Which is fine, but I think Forde and Bassett will suffice as fillers, and we should save it for next year.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
User avatar
TheMaehlMan
Junior
Posts: 1874
Joined: Sat Jan 15, 2011 4:21 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by TheMaehlMan »

NCDucks09 wrote: Whoah buddy, I highly disagree with you here. I think JJ would have given Barner a good run for his money and Marshall hasn't proven anything yet. DAT is not a true RB, he won't carry the rock 31 times a game, so it's hard to compare him to JJ. JJ has a couple of the most impressive runs I've ever seen.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWhvFsttcqY

Nuff Said.
Before JJ's ACL tear I would definitely take him over Barner. He was so dynamic, and had a filthy stiff arm. Barner was a great back at Oregon, so it doesn't bother me if others disagree with my thoughts.

As for Benoit, I am inclined to believe that he gets an offer if Wilson de-commits. Oregon has wanted 3 back for almost the entire recruiting cycle so I could be wrong.
Image

Going to miss the Maehl Man
damascusduck
Three Star Recruit
Posts: 252
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 1:01 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by damascusduck »

Wrong. Seastruck is a perfect example. A highly rated guy who didn't pan out. He would have been 4th string this year. He only cracked the lineup at Baylor the last few games....Barner is a good example because his only RB interest was from UTEP.

My point being, making comments like filler, garabage time, special teams guy is only speculation. Most my examples were of current NFL players who were mid major 2 star recruits. Only to blow up in college and become NFL caliber players.

The star system is an unexact science at best. Why do you think Chip Kelly always made fun of it? There are about 30-40 no brainers in the counrty every year. Maybe less. After that it's all about evaluation, coaching and the players ability to get better. Just think what the star gazers would have said about this guy if he was a last second visitor. http://oregon.scout.com/a.z?s=128&p=8&c=1&nid=2526012
User avatar
brich75
Senior
Posts: 4054
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 5:27 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by brich75 »

damascusduck wrote:Wrong. Seastruck is a perfect example. A highly rated guy who didn't pan out. He would have been 4th string this year. He only cracked the lineup at Baylor the last few games....Barner is a good example because his only RB interest was from UTEP.

My point being, making comments like filler, garabage time, special teams guy is only speculation. Most my examples were of current NFL players who were mid major 2 star recruits. Only to blow up in college and become NFL caliber players.

The star system is an unexact science at best. Why do you think Chip Kelly always made fun of it? There are about 30-40 no brainers in the counrty every year. Maybe less. After that it's all about evaluation, coaching and the players ability to get better. Just think what the star gazers would have said about this guy if he was a last second visitor. http://oregon.scout.com/a.z?s=128&p=8&c=1&nid=2526012
Doug Martin was the first guy I thought of when I was trying to think of low rated star guys! He is a monster! Benoit seems to have a decent burst but not great top end speed. Decent athlete though think the coaches can find a spot for him though.
Image
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40727
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by UOducksTK1 »

damascusduck wrote:Wrong. Seastruck is a perfect example. A highly rated guy who didn't pan out. He would have been 4th string this year. He only cracked the lineup at Baylor the last few games....Barner is a good example because his only RB interest was from UTEP.

My point being, making comments like filler, garabage time, special teams guy is only speculation. Most my examples were of current NFL players who were mid major 2 star recruits. Only to blow up in college and become NFL caliber players.

The star system is an unexact science at best. Why do you think Chip Kelly always made fun of it? There are about 30-40 no brainers in the counrty every year. Maybe less. After that it's all about evaluation, coaching and the players ability to get better. Just think what the star gazers would have said about this guy if he was a last second visitor. http://oregon.scout.com/a.z?s=128&p=8&c=1&nid=2526012
Fair enough, but I respectfully disagree. And I gave examples above where it's not just because of his star ranking, but because of a lot of other factors.

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
roleplay3r1
One Star Recruit
Posts: 61
Joined: Wed Nov 10, 2010 11:50 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by roleplay3r1 »

UOducksTK1 wrote:
damascusduck wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:
damascusduck wrote:
greenyellow wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:No offense to Benoit, but this is a reach..
I'd say so. If Oregon can retain both Wilson and Tyner, then I'm okay with the RB depth. Benoit would just be garbage-time filler once Oregon got other RBs the next couple seasons.
That's a stupid statment on many levels.
How so? I don't think it's that far-fetched of a statement. You really think he will get carries over Tyner and Wilson and Marshall? And on top of that, we will probably pull in another four/five star RB after that.

The road for him to see playing time will be extremely thin. But if he's up for the challenge and doesn't mind then so be it. I think because he is a bit bigger back, he might see some time in different formations, or goal line plays (or whatever his stlye fits). But ultimately, dude will be playing 4th quarters most likely.
My comment was meant for greenyellow. I'll bite on your follow up though. None of you internet recruiting experts know how these guys will do if/when they get on campus and in pads. Ever heard of Lache Seastrunk? If this Benoit guy gets an offer, I'll trust the coaches evaluation over you star watchers. Do you really think they would play Tyner over him or another player just based on his rating? LOL I didn't think so.

Triva question. What do Doug Martin, Alex Green, Ryan Matthews and Ronnie Hillman have in common? Cue Jeopardy theme music here.....All low rated, low offered MWC star RBs in the NFL. Ever heard of Chris Johnson? A 2 "star" recruit who picked East Carloina over Eastern Kentucky and UConn. How about 2 "star" Matt Forte who settled on mid major Tulane? Or current Detroit Lion Kevin Smith who's only offer was from mid major Central Florida, where he was a consensus All American his last year. I could go on but you get my point. Oh, speaking about Kenyon Barner. The only school that recruited him as a RB was little old UTEP. :lol:
No I don't think they would play Tyner over him based on rating. Rather I think they'll take him over Benoit because he has world class speed, broke HS records, was offered before any other 2013 recruit, because he was recruited by other serious BCS schools, etc.

Fall back option, and I think there are enough facts to prove it. Because this is the case, I'd rather save it for next year as opposed to settling.
Regarding the first point, I understand that those are plenty of reasons why they would recruit Tyner over Benoit. None of those, however, have legitimate bearing on their performance once on campus. Plenty of people have had world class speed, set high school records, and been heavily recruited. None of those things sealed their fate as college superstars.

I would also be interested to see the facts that point to Benoit being a fall back option, primarily because the term "fall back" is being used quite loosely lately. Some on this board act like they know how a recruit will impact a program before they step on the field, let alone that the coaches know the same thing. They don't have a crystal ball; for all we know, they had a list of 5 RB's with suitable skills they they contacted for visits. Maybe there are more. Maybe less. We have no idea the talent evaluations that the coaches have stamped on these kids. If we don't know that, how are we to know who is a "fall back" or who simply did not work out. Even the recruiting insiders spew BS 23 hours a day. That's because they're not calling the shots, why act like they are? I understand that there have been "reports" indicating trips and cancelled trips by other RB's. I would hardly call that proof that Benoit is a fall back option. Would I be open to seeing some proof that explains how Benoit's place on the team is contingent on X, Y and Z either committing or moving on? Absolutely. Not sure who is going to be able to provide that information, however. For now, I'll just watch the action until NSD and then start itching to see our new recruits in uniform!
User avatar
UofDuck
Senior
Posts: 3970
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:51 pm

Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by UofDuck »

The argument of stars versus outcomes is as old as this forum. It surfaces every year about this time. It must be therapeutic, because we all know that some two stars become superstars and some five stars become nobodies. We also know that four and five-star kids get these rankings because they are studs, generally speaking.

My simplistic view on the matter is if the kid gets an offer, that that pretty much says all I need to know about the kid. I don't like the term "fallback" because it gives a rather negative spin on the kid, but I understand it. And getting offered late the game probably does indicate something. But none of us really know what that something is. It could actually mean something good came to light late in the recruit. A true diamond in the rough.... It's all really just speculation on our part regarding the offer. Anyway, all that really matters is that the Oregon football staff determines if a kid is worthy of an offer, the rest is just noise and speculation entertainment.
duckfan96
Senior
Posts: 2717
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by duckfan96 »

I am pretty sure the coaches see something in the kid they like. As for someone sayin JJ would have a hard time findin pt on this team....hahahhaha.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6482
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by pezsez1 »

As for someone sayin JJ would have a hard time findin pt on this team....hahahhaha.
Agreed. JJ was a monster, and he was perfect for our kind of offense.

JJ, Barner and Maurice Morris are my favorite Oregon RBs. I liked Maurice because he just always seemed like a real nice, humble person. JJ & Barner, though, I always respected how they put up fantastic numbers despite spending their careers in the shadows of other guys (even though both proved to be more than good enough to stand on their own).
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
NCDucks09
Senior
Posts: 2265
Joined: Wed Jan 28, 2009 10:37 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by NCDucks09 »

After re-watching JJ's highlights, I realized what a physical runner he was. He would break contact and physical arm tackles on big runs, sometimes 2, 3, and 4 times. That's something that an Oregon running back hasn't had in quite some time. LMJ was fierce, but JJ was strong enough to stiff arm, run through, and sluff off arm tackles. Hopefully Tyner and Marshall can bring that back to the table.
2012 Rose Bowl Champions
2013 Fiesta Bowl Champions

Still Dedicated to the Ducks Winning the Natty!
duckfan96
Senior
Posts: 2717
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by duckfan96 »

The two long runs JJ had in the cw. Awesome. Nooooooooooo. One of the best highlights ever
User avatar
AutzenMember
Five Star Recruit
Posts: 1097
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:47 pm
Location: Hockinson, WA

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by AutzenMember »

Reuben Droughns! That game at UCLA...172 yds on a broken freakin fibula! Stud!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=63MK-YpA8nE
duckfan96
Senior
Posts: 2717
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:58 pm

Re: Kani Benoit visiting Oregon

Post by duckfan96 »

True!
Post Reply