Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:
The offense did enough for us to win. The defense didn't. And never does in big games.
I read this and I think we didn't even watch the same game. The offense was MIA for three quarters and committed two turnovers during that time.

Also, the offense did not score 28 points; it scored 21. That's not good enough. We can't count on special teams bailing out the offense in every game. And if you're going to start counting special teams play as offensive production, then I'd better see you give equal consideration to botched special teams play working against our defense -- which, again, I never see here (reference last year's Cal game, when our defense was put on several short fields thanks to offensive turnovers and special teams miscues).

The defense did enough for us to beat MSU, and the offense totally choked. Sadly, this is what has happened in some of Oregon's biggest games over the past few years... such as our home loss to Stanford that cost us a natty berth, and also our national championship game against Auburn.

But yeah, keep blaming the defense for the offense's awesome 21 points.
The defense was given a 28 point cushion to work with. I don't care how it came about, they just needed to hold the other team below 28 and they couldn't.

They also couldn't tackle. I'm still waiting for someone to come up with a reason why our defenders couldn't tackle at a basic level. Which would made a massive difference in the game. Much more of a difference than anything our offense didn't do and something that should NEVER happen.

Our offense struggled but they also happened to be facing a top 5 team with a great defense. That's a legit excuse. Not being able to tackle: No excuse. See the difference?
Image
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

THETADUCK wrote:Disagree completely. Against MSU, the defense was hung out to dry all game. Do you really think it is unreasonable that we gave up 31 points to the No. 5 team in the country when we shanked two punts and gave them the ball on our side of the field and turned it over six times (four on downs and two INTs)? Here is a summary of our offensive possessions in the first half:
TD
Punt - 3 plays, 1 yard
Punt - 3 plays, -1 yard
INT - 2 plays, 3 yard
Downs - 10 plays, 82 yards
INT - 4 plays, 29 yards
Downs - 6 plays, 17 yards

TERRIBLE.

That loss is 100% on the offense and the kicking game.
dthomas=ddixon wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:
432 yards and 28 points (yes, a ST score counts) against a top 5 team on the road is somehow considered "anemic".
These numbers are meaningless in the same way that "total defense" numbers are meaningless.

I've never seen a football game where the winner is determined by who gets the most yards. It's all about points. And, for three quarters against MSU, our offense only put up 7 points... that is terrible. And the comment above is why I don't understand the double standard between discussing our offense and defense.

Again, everyone here agrees this year's defense has problems. Nobody is making "excuses" for anything. At the same time, it's silly to be offended by the fact that our offense left our defense out to dry against MSU. Seriously, our offense for most of that game was terrible, terrible, terrible. Just seven points with two turnovers (plus a third turnover on downs at the goal line) in three quarters of play... and people would STILL rather rant about the defense in that game while giving the offense a free pass? Sheesh, talk about making excuses.
Total points is a meaningless stat?

I don't disagree that our offense wasn't good for a majority of the game. But they scored 28 points and held the ball for 28+ minutes. The defense was not completely hung out to dry. If the defense just tackles like any decent D-1 team does we win easily.

The offense provided some excuses for the defenses, like always. But the tackling by the defense was INEXCUSABLE. And was every bit of why we lost the game as anything else.

The offense did enough for us to win. The defense didn't. And never does in big games.
There it is. Once again the offense is to blame for the defense lacking a fundamental part of football from the opening snap.

Our offense starting slow is not a new thing. The defensive staff should have adjusted. They actually did during the Chip era but that's evaporated.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

They also couldn't tackle. I'm still waiting for someone to come up with a reason why our defenders couldn't tackle at a basic level. Which would made a massive difference in the game. Much more of a difference than anything our offense didn't do and something that should NEVER happen.

Our offense struggled but they also happened to be facing a top 5 team with a great defense. That's a legit excuse. Not being able to tackle: No excuse. See the difference?
Our offense scoring just 7 points through three quarters is not at all a legit excuse. Seriously, it's just not. Fortunately, that isn't the norm for our offense, so I don't worry about that happening week in and week out... but to say that's a "legit" excuse is just absurd. And we'd probably finish with a very poor Pac-12 record if our offense only scored 21 points per game, including so many quick three and outs (as opposed to lengthy, time-consuming "Stanford-style" drives) that only serve to wind our defense.

Did you look at the first-half drive data for our offense? Did you see all those three-and-outs, putting our D right back on the field against a very physical MSU offense? And did you realize our D followed that up by playing all but 1:30 of the entire third quarter?

Seriously... the offense screwed the pooch against MSU, hard. It's really not even debatable.
TD
Punt - 3 plays, 1 yard
Punt - 3 plays, -1 yard
INT - 2 plays, 3 yard
Downs - 10 plays, 82 yards
INT - 4 plays, 29 yards
Downs - 6 plays, 17 yards
Seriously, SCREWED. THE. POOCH.

As for the bad tackling of our secondary, you must have missed my earlier post in which I compared this year's squad to the squad of 2002, which is the only other Duck defensive unit I can recall that had such inexperience in its secondary. Inexperience is a legit reason for players not being up to par. That's why good defensive units tend to not have lots of inexperienced players as starters.

I'd recommend you go back and read my first post (very early in this thread) before making more assumptions as to what I was saying... otherwise, you might just end up putting words in my mouth, which doesn't help the conversation.

Inexperience is a big deal. It's why, despite how our offense choked against MSU, I'm not pulling my hair out and thinking our offense is going to be a liability all year... because our offensive players have lots of experience, and they'll get things figured out. But our defensive secondary is incredibly inexperienced, and sometimes guys simply need time/reps to get better. And if that's the case (which none of us really know, since we can't watch practices), then there isn't going to be a magic fix to make these guys significantly better more than reps/time will.

Yes, schematic changes can help, and I'm thinking that's what we saw in the changes made against GSU... but that's not going to mean our secondary gets worlds better as quickly as some people would like... it just means we might take more risks with pressure/blitzing and play a higher risk/reward game.
Last edited by pezsez1 on Tue Sep 22, 2015 12:08 pm, edited 3 times in total.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

"The defensive staff should have adjusted. They actually did during the Chip era but that's evaporated."

You mean the defense with 5 NFL caliber players on it? Do you see any NFL talent on our defense besides Buckner right now?
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by Jaw327 »

THETADUCK wrote:"The defensive staff should have adjusted. They actually did during the Chip era but that's evaporated."

You mean the defense with 5 NFL caliber players on it? Do you see any NFL talent on our defense besides Buckner right now?
uhh what. What does having NFL calibre players have to do with making adjustments? And my god, if we need to be stacked with NFL ready players to stop a "powerhouse school" like Georgia State then we are in even worse shape than I though.
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by Jaw327 »

I just, ugh, yarggh dude.

It's like people have forgotten that the whole point of the Defense is to stop the opposing team. Stop them from scoring points, stop them from running the ball, from passing the ball, from converting third and 1 and third and 15, just stop them.

When people say that our defensive philosophy is to create turnovers I just cringe. And if that's the coaches mindset then that mindset needs to change.
Its a stupid philosophy and one that can't survive over time. Turnovers are great, but they have just as much to do with the other team as they do the defense.
Lets not pretend that at least half of the turnovers against Florida State weren't unforced.
None of the turnovers against Ohio State were forced by the Ducks.
The pick 6 against Georgia State had everything to do with Georgia State being a shitty team and almost nothing to do with the Ducks.

What happens when we come up against a team that doesn't turn the ball over, that is disciplined?

Our offense has always been great, it's what makes Oregon football fun. And normally the offense masks just how terrible our defense has been. We can usually put up big numbers on anyone but when we come up against a strong defense that does it's job, aka stops the offense, or we have an injured QB and can't put up big points thats when we need a defense that does what it's supposed to, stop the other team, not wait back and hope they fumble the ball.

Look, when Mike Belotti is calling out the Ducks D, then you know there is a problem.
User avatar
greenyellow
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 39397
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:54 pm
Location: Eugene, OR

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by greenyellow »

How exactly were none of Oregon's takeaways not forced? A sack fumble is the definition of a forced turnover. As are fumbles caused by getting your hand/shoulder/helmet on the ball. Most interceptions are also forced, mainly by good coverage or causing some sort of deflection. You argument about turnovers is just plain bunk.

Also, Bellotti was noting the youth and inexperience in the secondary causing the defensive problems, not the entire defense being bad. Plus, it's his job to see things unbiased like that, not be a cheerleader for the program.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

Lets not pretend that at least half of the turnovers against Florida State weren't unforced.
None of the turnovers against Ohio State were forced by the Ducks.
The pick 6 against Georgia State had everything to do with Georgia State being a shitty team and almost nothing to do with the Ducks.
You do realize that it's not like Oregon's players were out just randomly standing around, and receivers on the other teams just walked up and handed them the ball, right?

The very reason we drop so many people into coverage is to capitalize on bad throws... which, I know isn't a popular way to play defense, but it's not like those interceptions happened by accident.

And the turnovers against FSU? You're saying we didn't force those? I think you need to rewatch the game. I remember Jameis losing the ball as he panicked in the face of an oncoming pass rush, and a tipped ball leading to an interception, and balls being dislodged from ball carriers during tackles... those turnovers were not accidents. I mean, virtually all turnovers require a mistake to by made by the offense (not holding the ball tight enough, a ball being overthrown, etc)... but most of those mistakes happen as a result of defensive contact, pressure or schemes designed to confuse quarterbacks (as was the case against Ohio State).

Look, we get it... some of you here are FURIOUS about our defense, and you haven't agreed with our defensive playcalling for a VERY LONG TIME.

But at least be real when talking about these things.

Stop ignoring when our offense leaves our defense out to try. And stop trying to discredit strong performances by our defense just because it doesn't fit with your narrative.

Everyone here agrees that THIS YEAR'S DEFENSE has problems. Why can't people just focus on this year?
Also, Bellotti was noting the youth and inexperience in the secondary causing the defensive problems, not the entire defense being bad. Plus, it's his job to see things unbiased like that, not be a cheerleader for the program.
Context is everything. Bellotti was our coach during that 2002 season I've now referred to several times, so he knows first-hand just how difficult working with an inexperienced secondary can be. Fortunately, Connor Cook didn't set a school record in passing against us, so that's a good sign that this year won't be as bad as that dreadful season.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

Jaw327 wrote: It's like people have forgotten that the whole point of the Defense is to stop the opposing team. Stop them from scoring points
This is all you need to say. Oregon has been in the Top 15 in each of the last 5 seasons doing exactly that, both with and without Pellum leading the show.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

Jaw327 wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:"The defensive staff should have adjusted. They actually did during the Chip era but that's evaporated."

You mean the defense with 5 NFL caliber players on it? Do you see any NFL talent on our defense besides Buckner right now?
uhh what. What does having NFL calibre players have to do with making adjustments? And my god, if we need to be stacked with NFL ready players to stop a "powerhouse school" like Georgia State then we are in even worse shape than I though.
It has everything to do with it.

When you have Kiko who has the athletic ability to cover a TE one on one....or when you have a corner like Ifo who can shut down one side of the field, it allows you to be much more flexible with adjustments. Right now, we are trying to mask talent and experience problems.

BTW...Jaw. This is a great discussion and you do bring up some great points. I am not saying we are "all-world" and we do need to improve. I am just not in the camp that believes that Pellum should be fired.
Last edited by THETADUCK on Tue Sep 22, 2015 1:33 pm, edited 2 times in total.
User avatar
fpsduck
Senior
Posts: 2862
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:10 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by fpsduck »

karlhungis wrote:
fpsduck wrote:After 3 games, it's pretty awful. Although our scoring defense continues to improve every game.

I'm hoping Pellum and Co. can get things turned around sooner rather than later.
I disagree that week 3 was an improvement. I still can't get over the fact that their offensive line managed to get more push during the game than our D, especially when they punched it into the end zone on that goal line stand. That showed me a lot about what our defense is and the only word that came to mind is "soft." We get pushed around by FCS opponents, wiff on arm tackles and can't pressure the QB.

While yes, I agree that things could be worse and Pellum has shown that he can get the team up for a game when it matters..... I am tired of that being acceptable. What happened to Win The Day? What happened to the faceless opponent? Now it's "meh, they are a shitty team so we don't have to worry about it." "We won right?"

I think our defense is unacceptable and it infuriates me that the coaches don't seem to own up to any of it.

I'm not saying that the defense has improved, I'm only saying that statistically our "scoring" defense has improved.
karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by karlhungis »

THETADUCK wrote:
Jaw327 wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:"The defensive staff should have adjusted. They actually did during the Chip era but that's evaporated."

You mean the defense with 5 NFL caliber players on it? Do you see any NFL talent on our defense besides Buckner right now?
uhh what. What does having NFL calibre players have to do with making adjustments? And my god, if we need to be stacked with NFL ready players to stop a "powerhouse school" like Georgia State then we are in even worse shape than I though.
It has everything to do with it.

When you have Kiko who has the athletic ability to cover a TE one on one....or when you have a corner like Ifo who can shut down one side of the field, it allows you to be much more flexible with adjustments. Right now, we are trying to mask talent and experience problems.

BTW...Jaw. This is a great discussion and you do bring up some great points. I am not saying we are "all-world" and we do need to improve. I am just not in the camp that believes that Pellum should be fired.
We have enough talent to field a decent defense. We shouldn't have to wait until we have NFL caliber players all over the field in order for the system to work. If your system only works once or twice a decade, when you luck into having the talent to run it.... then your system sucks. Mold the system around your talent, don't force your lack of talent into a losing situation.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

If your system only works once or twice a decade, when you luck into having the talent to run it.... then your system sucks.
Good thing we've never had a system like that! That would be crazy... we'd never even sniff being among the nation's best in categories like scoring defense, yards per play and turnover margins.

Even I'd be climbing the walls if our system only worked once or twice per decade.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
THETADUCK
One Star Recruit
Posts: 50
Joined: Wed Aug 05, 2015 12:58 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by THETADUCK »

karlhungis wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:
Jaw327 wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:"The defensive staff should have adjusted. They actually did during the Chip era but that's evaporated."

You mean the defense with 5 NFL caliber players on it? Do you see any NFL talent on our defense besides Buckner right now?
uhh what. What does having NFL calibre players have to do with making adjustments? And my god, if we need to be stacked with NFL ready players to stop a "powerhouse school" like Georgia State then we are in even worse shape than I though.
It has everything to do with it.

When you have Kiko who has the athletic ability to cover a TE one on one....or when you have a corner like Ifo who can shut down one side of the field, it allows you to be much more flexible with adjustments. Right now, we are trying to mask talent and experience problems.

BTW...Jaw. This is a great discussion and you do bring up some great points. I am not saying we are "all-world" and we do need to improve. I am just not in the camp that believes that Pellum should be fired.
We have enough talent to field a decent defense. We shouldn't have to wait until we have NFL caliber players all over the field in order for the system to work. If your system only works once or twice a decade, when you luck into having the talent to run it.... then your system sucks. Mold the system around your talent, don't force your lack of talent into a losing situation.
Oregon had the No.14 ranked defense in the FEI last season. So our huge drop this year is only due to coaching? Huh?
Sorry...not buying it.
lmduck

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by lmduck »

Theta- you make some excellent points. This week will be a big test and we'll see how it goes.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Post Reply