Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

Post Reply
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8830
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

Bigwaved wrote:
dthomas=ddixon wrote: The fact is that our offense at the start of the season wouldn't have set the school record for yards in a game. Our defense looked better against Cal because they were barely on the field. And when they were they were playing with a lead the majority of the game and were facing an offense who was forced into playing one-dimensionally because they were losing. Just the like old days.

If our defense doesn't pull out a miracle performance Furd will take the air out the ball and keep our offense off the field all game. But they won't score a ton of points so the defensive apologists will still be able to convince themselves that the defense played "good enough to win" and that our offense let us down.
I looked up a few game stats on Cal to see if those comments were factual or just how you felt. In the SC game, Cal did lose the TOP by a wide margin. They ran the ball 30 times and threw it 31 times. In the Utah game, they again lost the TOP by a wide margin. They ran the ball 28 times and threw it 47 times. Against UCLA, they were close to even in TOP. They threw it 53 times and ran it 35 times. Against us, they lost TOP. Ran it 24 times, threw it 42 times. All were losses for Cal. Some games they were close until the end, some they were trailing for a lot of the game. They did not seem to significantly abandon the run in any of those games compared to another. So, your premise that our defense was just purely lucky because they did not see the field much and had the lead may be more feeling than fact from just a cursory look.
My premise is not that they were purely lucky. My premise is that our very bad defense isn't suddenly improving. Our offense is. Which makes our defense look serviceable because they are back to playing with a lead and facing an offense that has been forced to be one-dimensional and press because our offense puts so much pressure on them to keep up.

This isn't some sort of conspiracy theory, its fairly basic stuff.
Image
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by Duck24 »

UOducksTK1 wrote:Heading down this evening to Palo Alto! Hope to see a few of ya'll there!
Flying out this afternoon and it sounds like we will be well represented down there. Weather is supposed to be great tomorrow. Let's hope the coaches and players all well prepared and bring their A games. As many times as Stanford has ruined our season, it would be nice to repay the favor.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by pezsez1 »

My premise is not that they were purely lucky. My premise is that our very bad defense isn't suddenly improving. Our offense is.
Our offense has definitely improved, no doubt about that.

But our defense has certainly improved too. Again, that doesn't mean we have a good defense, but the D is certainly better. Robinson is a huge upgrade at corner over Umadi, and Nelson is a big upgrade at safety. Also, Springs seems to really be finding his rhythm, and our D-line will keep doing what it has been doing.

It's also worth noting that while the offense is finally playing well, we're still not producing at the level we have in years past. Even in the Cal game... yeah, we rolled up 700+ yards offense... but only 40-something points. This offense still struggles in the redzone, and Vernon Adams is still a bit of a liability with turnovers.

Cal was in this game until late in the third quarter; that's why they weren't panicking and becoming completely one-dimensional. Weren't they only down by 9 at one point? That's nothing, especially with a defense that has been as bad as ours.

Anyway, this D deserves at least a little credit for playing a quality game against a good offensive opponent.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by UOducksTK1 »

Duck24 wrote:
UOducksTK1 wrote:Heading down this evening to Palo Alto! Hope to see a few of ya'll there!
Flying out this afternoon and it sounds like we will be well represented down there. Weather is supposed to be great tomorrow. Let's hope the coaches and players all well prepared and bring their A games. As many times as Stanford has ruined our season, it would be nice to repay the favor.
+1

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
Greenblood
Senior
Posts: 3465
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:16 pm

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by Greenblood »

Two more reasons why I so desperately want the Ducks to win tomorrow, beyond simply being a Duck fan.

(1) Should the Cardinal win, they will be in position to have the distinction of being the first Pac-12 team in the Pac-12 era to go through the conference season undefeated. I don't want them to have that distinction.

(2) A Cardinal win would also set up a scenario where it's quite possible, maybe even likely, that the winner of the ND @ Stanford game late this month would be "in" (the College Football Playoff). If you're like me, that's a true no-win scenario. (Would I actually root for ND??)
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by Duck07 »

I don't mind if Stanford went on to the CFP, (I prefer Utah but that keeps looking less likely as the season goes on) but boy I'd sure love to see our offense put up 50+ and win a shoot-out like we did when Gerhart was toting the rock. Make just enough plays, especially our 3rd down defense and pray that VA scrambles out of enough tackles to make some big plays.
Image
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8830
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:
My premise is not that they were purely lucky. My premise is that our very bad defense isn't suddenly improving. Our offense is.
Our offense has definitely improved, no doubt about that.

But our defense has certainly improved too. Again, that doesn't mean we have a good defense, but the D is certainly better. Robinson is a huge upgrade at corner over Umadi, and Nelson is a big upgrade at safety. Also, Springs seems to really be finding his rhythm, and our D-line will keep doing what it has been doing.

It's also worth noting that while the offense is finally playing well, we're still not producing at the level we have in years past. Even in the Cal game... yeah, we rolled up 700+ yards offense... but only 40-something points. This offense still struggles in the redzone, and Vernon Adams is still a bit of a liability with turnovers.

Cal was in this game until late in the third quarter; that's why they weren't panicking and becoming completely one-dimensional. Weren't they only down by 9 at one point? That's nothing, especially with a defense that has been as bad as ours.

Anyway, this D deserves at least a little credit for playing a quality game against a good offensive opponent.
I agree that individual players are playing better. Which has caused our defense to improve, but I think it's marginal at best.

Cal certainly wasn't panicking but they were playing catch-up all game and were only within striking distance for brief moments, before our offense got the ball back and immediately scored again. There's no doubt that a team plays differently in that situation than they do when they are leading or in a tight game; players play different, coaches call the game different, etc., etc. All these things are quite beneficial to the opposing defense and makes their job much easier.

And you can't discount how much of an impact racking up 777 yards AND winning the TOP battle is, regardless of "only" scoring 44 points. We're always excusing our defense because they're on the field so much and our offense is quick strike but in this game they got the benefit of BOTH. Our offense moved the ball at will, put up 44 points AND they won TOP by a decent margin. Cal managed to stay in the game because our defense couldn't such the door. Not because the offense wasn't absolutely perfect. Which seems to be what is required for us to put any kind of expectation on our poor, oppressed defense. I'm thinking about referring to our offense as the privileged white males from now on. :lol:
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by pezsez1 »

Cal managed to stay in the game because our defense couldn't such the door.
Your making it sound like our defense was failing to stop Cal, and we only held them below 30 thanks to our offense.

Let's actually look at Cal's possessions so we can all be on the same page:

1st Half

7 plays, 38 yards, TD (started with great field position after blocked punt)
9 plays, 70 yards, TD (after VA's first interception)
3 plays, 6 yards, PUNT
3 plays, 7 yards, PUNT
8 plays, 28 yards, PUNT
3 plays, 9 yards, PUNT
9 plays, 63 yards, Defense gets stop in redzone.

2nd half

7 plays, 44 yards, FG
6 plays, 45 yards, TD
4 plays, 13 yards, PUNT
5 plays, 9 yards, PUNT
1 play, 80 yards, TD (following VA's interception, and off deflection from near INT by UO defense)
3 plays, 36 yards, INT

Those aren't stellar defensive numbers, but they're not at all bad, either. Cal only had three drives all game with more than seven plays, and we got stops on 8/13 possessions, and that was maybe a knuckle away from being 9/13.

Your argument would have a lot more weight had the defense struggled & made this a closer game. But the numbers don't lie -- the defense held its own.

Traditionally, it's not a matter of our defense doing well only if our offense does. It's more a matter of our offense and defense feeding off of each other. Often, when our defense sucks, then our offense can't get back on the field fast enough to find its rhythm, and it suffers. And when our offense sucks (going three-and-out rapidly), then our D collapses.

Against Cal, the Ducks came to play on both sides of the ball, which is why -- for the first time this season -- these looked like the Ducks we've come to expect over the past several years.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8830
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:
Cal managed to stay in the game because our defense couldn't such the door.
Your making it sound like our defense was failing to stop Cal, and we only held them below 30 thanks to our offense.

Let's actually look at Cal's possessions so we can all be on the same page:

1st Half

7 plays, 38 yards, TD (started with great field position after blocked punt)
9 plays, 70 yards, TD (after VA's first interception)
3 plays, 6 yards, PUNT
3 plays, 7 yards, PUNT
8 plays, 28 yards, PUNT
3 plays, 9 yards, PUNT
9 plays, 63 yards, Defense gets stop in redzone.

2nd half

7 plays, 44 yards, FG
6 plays, 45 yards, TD
4 plays, 13 yards, PUNT
5 plays, 9 yards, PUNT
1 play, 80 yards, TD (following VA's interception, and off deflection from near INT by UO defense)
3 plays, 36 yards, INT

Those aren't stellar defensive numbers, but they're not at all bad, either. Cal only had three drives all game with more than seven plays, and we got stops on 8/13 possessions, and that was maybe a knuckle away from being 9/13.

Your argument would have a lot more weight had the defense struggled & made this a closer game. But the numbers don't lie -- the defense held its own.

Traditionally, it's not a matter of our defense doing well only if our offense does. It's more a matter of our offense and defense feeding off of each other. Often, when our defense sucks, then our offense can't get back on the field fast enough to find its rhythm, and it suffers. And when our offense sucks (going three-and-out rapidly), then our D collapses.

Against Cal, the Ducks came to play on both sides of the ball, which is why -- for the first time this season -- these looked like the Ducks we've come to expect over the past several years.
I never made the argument that our defense struggled in this game, I said they looked improved earlier in this thread. You just cherry picked the one sentence from my post that you could argue as you're wont to do. My point is that it had a lot to do with them facing an offense for the first time all season that was having to face the impossible task of keeping up with our record setting offense.

And the bold statement is exactly why our discussions never get anywhere. We do not win unless our offense plays quite well. Which, of course, is the offenses fault because our defense can't play well unless the offense does, right? Like you said, our defense collapses when our offense doesn't play well. Which is pretty much my entire point regarding the defense.
Image
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by pezsez1 »

You just cherry picked the one sentence from my post that you could argue as you're wont to do. My point is that it had a lot to do with them facing an offense for the first time all season that was having to face the impossible task of keeping up with our record setting offense.
Actually, I didn't cherry pick anything. Your argument is flawed because our offense is still struggling in the redzone when compared with recent years. In fact, our offense only put up 16 points in the entire second half against Cal -- and I'm not trying to discount the offense in any way, but this is still not the juggernaut offense that you seem to be inferring it is. Moving the ball on the ground is really nice, but points matter more than anything else... kind of like total defense vs. scoring defense. Your argument is also flawed because you're completely discounting the fact that the defense actually played well against Cal, which gave our offense more opportunities to keep control of the game.

The offense was better against Cal that it has been all year, sure.. but so was the defense. Had our defense been bad, our offense wouldn't have had the chance to roll up so many yards, and the game would have been much closer.
And the bold statement is exactly why our discussions never get anywhere. We do not win unless our offense plays quite well.
Which is kind of true, but the completely true statement is that in years past, we've usually won when we play well on both sides of the ball.

This year -- which is an anomaly when compared to recent years -- we've won games in which the offense did well and the D sucks (ASU), and when the D did well and the offense sucked (Washington).

Both sides played well against Cal. Acknowledging this doesn't need to change anyone's big-picture feelings about the defense or our coaching.

Also, you do realize that the bolded part of your statement here is essentially the same thing you're accusing me of cherry picking? By standing on that belief, you are claiming that our defense is completely irrelevant to our success, even though (as we've gone around and around about in past threads) in recent years we regularly have held opponents to around 20 points or less while feeding turnovers to the offense (like against Florida State).

I don't want to get too much into what's happened in recent years, because none of that is relevant to this season. But you don't get to have your cake and eat it too.
I looked up a few game stats on Cal to see if those comments were factual or just how you felt. In the SC game, Cal did lose the TOP by a wide margin. They ran the ball 30 times and threw it 31 times. In the Utah game, they again lost the TOP by a wide margin. They ran the ball 28 times and threw it 47 times. Against UCLA, they were close to even in TOP. They threw it 53 times and ran it 35 times. Against us, they lost TOP. Ran it 24 times, threw it 42 times. All were losses for Cal. Some games they were close until the end, some they were trailing for a lot of the game. They did not seem to significantly abandon the run in any of those games compared to another. So, your premise that our defense was just purely lucky because they did not see the field much and had the lead may be more feeling than fact from just a cursory look.
Good data. Thanks for showing those numbers.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
Duck07
All-American
Posts: 17123
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
Location: Parts Unknown

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by Duck07 »

The easiest way to sum up both of your arguments is to simply say that by bringing four rushers on a consistent basis, it has allowed us to create more pressure, which has in turn had an effect on the QB's passes, which has made our secondary look much more improved.
Image
User avatar
Bigwaved
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 673
Joined: Mon Feb 07, 2011 7:22 pm

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by Bigwaved »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:
Bigwaved wrote:
dthomas=ddixon wrote: The fact is that our offense at the start of the season wouldn't have set the school record for yards in a game. Our defense looked better against Cal because they were barely on the field. And when they were they were playing with a lead the majority of the game and were facing an offense who was forced into playing one-dimensionally because they were losing. Just the like old days.

If our defense doesn't pull out a miracle performance Furd will take the air out the ball and keep our offense off the field all game. But they won't score a ton of points so the defensive apologists will still be able to convince themselves that the defense played "good enough to win" and that our offense let us down.
I looked up a few game stats on Cal to see if those comments were factual or just how you felt. In the SC game, Cal did lose the TOP by a wide margin. They ran the ball 30 times and threw it 31 times. In the Utah game, they again lost the TOP by a wide margin. They ran the ball 28 times and threw it 47 times. Against UCLA, they were close to even in TOP. They threw it 53 times and ran it 35 times. Against us, they lost TOP. Ran it 24 times, threw it 42 times. All were losses for Cal. Some games they were close until the end, some they were trailing for a lot of the game. They did not seem to significantly abandon the run in any of those games compared to another. So, your premise that our defense was just purely lucky because they did not see the field much and had the lead may be more feeling than fact from just a cursory look.
My premise is not that they were purely lucky. My premise is that our very bad defense isn't suddenly improving. Our offense is. Which makes our defense look serviceable because they are back to playing with a lead and facing an offense that has been forced to be one-dimensional and press because our offense puts so much pressure on them to keep up.

This isn't some sort of conspiracy theory, its fairly basic stuff.
It sort of reads that you want to dismiss what I posted as a conspiracy theory. I believe I added real numbers from those games to illustrate that your premise of our defense being lucky does not seem to hold water at a glance. It is that basic. I do not recall ever alluding to a conspiracy, let alone that crossing my mind. That smells more like a red herring to me. If you want me to add my feelings to match yours, then here you go:

I think the LBs, specifically the two in the middle, cause our defense all kinds of issues. Hardrick even was directly responsible for allowing the first punt block. That guy just doesn't execute his responsibilities a lot when I watch him out there. The DBs in this game seemed to have fewer miscommunications as a unit. I still saw coverage mistakes, but this time the QB either just missed the throw or the pass rush was able to hide the mistake by pressuring Goff into not seeing that opportunity. I did not see the Bad News Bears version of the Duck defense. They are not all world during this game imo, but they were not a putrid as you would like to present them as either.
Last edited by Bigwaved on Sat Nov 14, 2015 3:28 pm, edited 1 time in total.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I think over the last few months it has become pretty evident that Pez will never ever say that Pillow Pellum needs to go. Stanford USC and Oregon state could put up 70 points a game on them and Pez would say it was because the offense did not do their job. The argument about the defense which has penetrated a lot of the threads here this year has clearly defined his view of Pellum. He continues to argue in support of Pellum and I doubt is very little that can be said over the next 3 weeks or 3 months that will change his view. To be fair... I think the defense has improved some. I still though want Pellum gone after the year and to get fresh new blood into the program. That means do not hire Neal.... I think he has showed to be a valuable coach. I just am not convinced that he would just bring more of the same.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by pezsez1 »

I think over the last few months it has become pretty evident that Pez will never ever say that Pillow Pellum needs to go. Stanford USC and Oregon state could put up 70 points a game on them and Pez would say it was because the offense did not do their job. The argument about the defense which has penetrated a lot of the threads here this year has clearly defined his view of Pellum. He continues to argue in support of Pellum and I doubt is very little that can be said over the next 3 weeks or 3 months that will change his view.
Woah, dude.

I haven't said jack about whether the coaches should stay/go in probably around a month -- and that's by design. Because I don't want narrow-minded people like you putting words in my mouth and trying to pigeonhole how I view this team.

Please, point to any of my recent posts where I've posted a legit defense of Pellum. I dare you.

Get off your high horse. If you're going to "call me out," you'd best have your ducks in a row. You are 100 percent dead wrong and completely out of line.

If you are intentionally ignoring improvement by the defense (for one game) because you're afraid that could interfere with YOUR views on the team, then that's your issue to work out, not mine. Maybe you should start a thread about how your views are so fragile that you're afraid of entertaining new thoughts. But seriously, dude. WTF. Did a 12-year-old hack your account and write that post for you?

As for me, you won't know what I think about the coaching staff until MAYBE after the season, which is when I personally find it relevant to discuss such things. That, right there, is all you can claim to know about my views.

I don't owe anyone any further qualifier on that, especially when you guys act like assholes.

You're welcome.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
UOducksTK1
Site Admin
Site Admin
Posts: 40742
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 11:28 pm
GM: Boston Celtics GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: Oregon @ Stanford (Sat 4:30 PM FOX)

Post by UOducksTK1 »

pezsez1 wrote:
Cal managed to stay in the game because our defense couldn't such the door.
Your making it sound like our defense was failing to stop Cal, and we only held them below 30 thanks to our offense.

Let's actually look at Cal's possessions so we can all be on the same page:

1st Half

7 plays, 38 yards, TD (started with great field position after blocked punt)
9 plays, 70 yards, TD (after VA's first interception)
3 plays, 6 yards, PUNT
3 plays, 7 yards, PUNT
8 plays, 28 yards, PUNT
3 plays, 9 yards, PUNT
9 plays, 63 yards, Defense gets stop in redzone.

2nd half

7 plays, 44 yards, FG
6 plays, 45 yards, TD
4 plays, 13 yards, PUNT
5 plays, 9 yards, PUNT
1 play, 80 yards, TD (following VA's interception, and off deflection from near INT by UO defense)
3 plays, 36 yards, INT

Those aren't stellar defensive numbers, but they're not at all bad, either. Cal only had three drives all game with more than seven plays, and we got stops on 8/13 possessions, and that was maybe a knuckle away from being 9/13.

Your argument would have a lot more weight had the defense struggled & made this a closer game. But the numbers don't lie -- the defense held its own.

Traditionally, it's not a matter of our defense doing well only if our offense does. It's more a matter of our offense and defense feeding off of each other. Often, when our defense sucks, then our offense can't get back on the field fast enough to find its rhythm, and it suffers. And when our offense sucks (going three-and-out rapidly), then our D collapses.

Against Cal, the Ducks came to play on both sides of the ball, which is why -- for the first time this season -- these looked like the Ducks we've come to expect over the past several years.
How many drives ended from dropped passes due to the rain, though?

Do Not Fear. Isaiah 41:13
Post Reply