Sorry I didn't make it clear. Was disagreeing with Willie being a 8-4 and 9-3 coach. I'm not saying 10-11 wins every year and playoff just curious how you can come to that conclusion when he hasn't even gotten his guys in on a team lacking expirenced talent on both sides of the ball.
Its not a conclusion, that is a final assessment. More of a speculation. I can only speculate from his past career and what I've seen since he has taken over. His overall coaching record would suggest his one season over 8 wins might have been more his QB then him. He strikes me as conservative, a sports science and advanced stat sceptic. The anti-Chip. He hired a line coach/run game coordinator who was a head coach for 6 years and his teams had really crappy run games. So then I see this line play and run scheme, through all 4 games and wonder how you're going to be a 10-11 game winner in the PAC trying to use a run heavy offense with crappy o-line play, even with a really good defense. So you might need to adapt but I don't see it. He seems to stick to what he thinks should work rather than what is and isn't working. The Freeman overuse Benoit underuse thing also gives me pause.
Hopefully my prediction is wrong, I'm good at being wrong and even take pride in pointing it out and eating crow. I wanted DP fired and left on a tarmac in 2014 thru the Arizona game but was glad to acknowledge the turnaround starting at UCLA the next week thru the championship game.
Sorry I didn't make it clear. Was disagreeing with Willie being a 8-4 and 9-3 coach. I'm not saying 10-11 wins every year and playoff just curious how you can come to that conclusion when he hasn't even gotten his guys in on a team lacking expirenced talent on both sides of the ball.
Its not a conclusion, that is a final assessment. More of a speculation. I can only speculate from his past career and what I've seen since he has taken over. His overall coaching record would suggest his one season over 8 wins might have been more his QB then him. He strikes me as conservative, a sports science and advanced stat sceptic. The anti-Chip. He hired a line coach/run game coordinator who was a head coach for 6 years and his teams had really crappy run games. So then I see this line play and run scheme, through all 4 games and wonder how you're going to be a 10-11 game winner in the PAC trying to use a run heavy offense with crappy o-line play, even with a really good defense. So you might need to adapt but I don't see it. He seems to stick to what he thinks should work rather than what is and isn't working. The Freeman overuse Benoit underuse thing also gives me pause.
Hopefully my prediction is wrong, I'm good at being wrong and even take pride in pointing it out and eating crow. I wanted DP fired and left on a tarmac in 2014 thru the Arizona game but was glad to acknowledge the turnaround starting at UCLA the next week thru the championship game.
Okay fair enough Insee why you would think that now.
GrandpaDuck: By the way the offense line is a veteran and talented group that is underperforming and has regressed from last year despite the insertion of a massive talent this year in Crosby. Few college lines can boost as many career starts as these guys have as a group.
Grandpa, most of what you say I'm in perfect lock-step with you. Apelu (sp?) and Robinson are huge liabilities and hurt this team over and over. And I do see the D-coaches are good coaches and O coaches as possibly better recruiters than coaches (time will tell), but t I take some exception to your assertion that this line is a veteran and talented group who has regressed. First of all, they were VERY young last year, making them young this year. And they struggled last year, so struggling this year is not regressing. I do agree that Crosby coming back should help, and has on pass blocking, but we are not an uber talented line.
My take:
Offense:
QB: we have a future NFL QB. He is still very young (he was in high-school a little over a year ago) and he had a poor game. His wrs did not particularly help him either.
RB: Royce is a good back, but he is not what Willey is trying to make him, a tough between the tackles running back. We have guys who are very talented, but they have to get the ball in space and it isn't happening. That is on the coaches and they need to find ways to make this happen.
OLine: We've been decent at pass protection and terrible at run blocking. Mario needs to get these guys to start blowing holes open.
WR: I feel like we have a bunch of small quick guys cut out of a similar mold. We need some more size and we need to learn how to catch the long ball. I'd like to also see better blocking out of these guys. Of all of our positions, the WRs and OLine have been our biggest liabilities.
TE: I feel like we only have one; Breeland. He's been pretty good, but not great.
Defense:
DLine is playing above their heads. I could not be more proud of them.
LBs: A work in progress, but I see effort. Apelu does not belong. He is simply a massive liability and hast to cheat to try to make up his inability and gets penalized for it at the worst possible time, over and over. He gets swallowed up on blocks and trucked. Dye is a future star that needs to put on 15 more pounds of muscle.We need to recruit some more talent at LB
DBs - mixed bag here. Springs and Graham as pretty good, but very inconsistent. Springs had a great game and Graham struggled. Our safety play is generally weak, but we are banged up and playing a lot of youth. I think the future is bright with the kids coming in next year and getting Brady Breeze healthy should help
Coaching:
Overall, pretty good. We are thin at key positions. We are 3-1 and we are recruiting WAY above our standard. The great coach Peterson had a few bad years at UW before getting his scheme and players playing well. It takes a little time. In this game, we were the better team and looked poor and I suspect there will be games when we are underdogs and we will over perform. We have enough talent to compete in every game, but need to play very well in all facets to get Ws. The biggest issue I have right now is too conservative on offense. No imagination. I'd like to see more option and pitching to get our players to the edge quicker were they can do damage More swing passes to the RBs. I also HATE not going for it on 4th down inside the opponents half of the field. What are we gaining on punts? 20 yards - minus what we might have gained running a play? It just doesn't pencil. And if you play call with the thought that you have two plays to get a first down, and not only one play, you can be less predictable in play calling. Willey needs to get this figured out .
GrandpaDuck wrote:I think the defensive coaching staff can coach.
I think the offensive coaching staff can recruit.
I think Willy Taggart would not even have gotten a sniff at this job if it wasn't for Quentin Flowers and one 10-2 season.
I think we replaced two people hugely responsible for making Oregon football elite (Greatwood and Rad) with old school dinosaur thinkers that will keep Oregon's O-line old fashioned and mediocre.
I don't know how long the staff will hang around but suspect Willie will be around or a long time, perhaps recruiting well enough to get us to 8-5 and 9-4 in the good years.
This is not a reaction to this game as it is what I thought going into it.
I have been appalled at the blocking all season. I was very afraid that if you get stuffed for 3 yards or less on over 50% of your runs and close to 60% on first down against 3 of your 4 least talented opponents, what is going to happen against PAC-12 teams. We saw that tonight. Lot's of 3rd and long where they new you were going to pass and a horrible conversion percentage. Rushing yardage under 200 per game.
This is what I think, but unlike with Helf where I thought he could be replaced with the right coach and we have a shot at contending I think they blew that opportunity we're stuck with middle of the PAC for years so I'm not going to get upset about it, just lower my expectations and enjoy any win, and "oh well" every loss because we are a Track, Softball and Basketball school anyway, right?
Sorry I didn't make it clear. Was disagreeing with Willie being a 8-4 and 9-3 coach. I'm not saying 10-11 wins every year and playoff just curious how you can come to that conclusion when he hasn't even gotten his guys in on a team lacking expirenced talent on both sides of the ball.
Its not a conclusion, that is a final assessment. More of a speculation. I can only speculate from his past career and what I've seen since he has taken over. His overall coaching record would suggest his one season over 8 wins might have been more his QB then him. He strikes me as conservative, a sports science and advanced stat sceptic. The anti-Chip. He hired a line coach/run game coordinator who was a head coach for 6 years and his teams had really crappy run games. So then I see this line play and run scheme, through all 4 games and wonder how you're going to be a 10-11 game winner in the PAC trying to use a run heavy offense with crappy o-line play, even with a really good defense. So you might need to adapt but I don't see it. He seems to stick to what he thinks should work rather than what is and isn't working. The Freeman overuse Benoit underuse thing also gives me pause.
Hopefully my prediction is wrong, I'm good at being wrong and even take pride in pointing it out and eating crow. I wanted DP fired and left on a tarmac in 2014 thru the Arizona game but was glad to acknowledge the turnaround starting at UCLA the next week thru the championship game.
I think this is fair. And our offensive coaches certainly got out-coached last night. And it's probably going to be a problem all season because right now the coaches seem a little lost as to what to do. So I don't know that there will be quick fixes. But our offensive line has not been good, and they weren't great last year. I can tell if it's youth or talent or size or coaching. I think that unit has been hyped beyond what they've actually produced. I think Herbert has been hyped way beyond what he's produced. He has no one to throw to. Our defense has huge holes. And I would say, after watching that game last night, that ASU has talent in the ballpark with us. When our current sophomores are seniors, and we have 3 full Taggart recruiting classes, then we'll see what our offensive coaches are made of. But you are right to be concerned.
Last edited by Groundswell on Sun Sep 24, 2017 10:32 am, edited 1 time in total.
As long as playcalling improves, penalties go down, and recruiting stays on the course it is on... no reason not to be optimistic. They're already light years ahead of the previous staff.
It is funny how the defense now has to bail out an offense that has always been a juggernaut.
GrandpaDuck wrote:
I think we replaced two people hugely responsible for making Oregon football elite (Greatwood and Rad) with old school dinosaur thinkers that will keep Oregon's O-line old fashioned and mediocre.
The only person responsible for making Oregon football elite was Chip. You could argue for Phil but frankly we've been a good but not great program outside of the Chip years. This overreaction stuff is so pathetic that I'm a little ashamed I've even posted in this thread.
GrandpaDuck wrote:
I think we replaced two people hugely responsible for making Oregon football elite (Greatwood and Rad) with old school dinosaur thinkers that will keep Oregon's O-line old fashioned and mediocre.
The only person responsible for making Oregon football elite was Chip. You could argue for Phil but frankly we've been a good but not great program outside of the Chip years. This overreaction stuff is so pathetic that I'm a little ashamed I've even posted in this thread.
Exactly. Greatwood and Rad had a window where they really helped Chip build what he built but I don't see how you can look at our team from last year and have ANY praise for O Line play or our strength and conditioning.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
Where's the love for Gary Campbell? If it wasn't for his amazing development of RB's Chip wouldn't have been so successful. Really wish Willie kept him around.
I'd be curious what everyone thought of chip after a few games. We were a 4 win team last year and have 5 true frosh starting or playing a majority of the time on defense( Graham, Pickett, Scott, faloui, lenoir) and a walk on at MLB in apelu. We also returned 6 total career receptions on offense outside of Nelson who didn't play yesterday. I still think we should have won, but if the team we had last night played the 07, 10, 12 or 14 version of the ducks they'd have lost by 35+. We are nowhere close to a finished product, and that's ok.
lukeyrid13 wrote:I'd be curious what everyone thought of chip after a few games. We were a 4 win team last year and have 5 true frosh starting or playing a majority of the time on defense( Graham, Pickett, Scott, faloui, lenoir) and a walk on at MLB in apelu. We also returned 6 total career receptions on offense outside of Nelson who didn't play yesterday. I still think we should have won, but if the team we had last night played the 07, 10, 12 or 14 version of the ducks they'd have lost by 35+. We are nowhere close to a finished product, and that's ok.
I've been silent on the topic, mostly because I had a fellow duck fan call me a sick during the game because I pointed out who was who. He kept thinking ASU would go after #4 and I pointed out on one play that was actually arrion springs #1. The bar asked me if he needed to be kicked out and I told them no, he's just a fan that's mad at the team for losing a game we should win. He really wasn't ever mad at me, I was just the target of his frustration.
That said, this team is young and going through the rebuilding pains. It will get better but they all, coaches and players, need to gel. How about everyone take a deep breathe and let's see how they respond against Cal. If they shut the bed on that one, then we as fans should be vocal about Tagger and Co making better adjustments. We are already better than we were last year.
"And I can be the warrior for those who are frail and weak,
And I can be the compass for those that search and seek." ~Lem Absher
Rad is wayyyyyy overrated by UO fans. He was certainly part of the problem and not the solution going forward. His bullets over boulders was fine with Chip telling him what to do, but like most everyone they needed Chip to micromanage them. Because the team became weak and slow the last couple years.
As for our OL being so "veteran", you have to remember they were all recruited for a zone blocking scheme, (square peg round hole theory) and are now being asked to be much more physical. They aren't up to it, particularly Hanson and Pisarcik. Hanson has been bad when asked to pull on screens or plays that ask him to block one guy alone and if he makes it it springs the RB for a big play.
As for our QB, he played really badly, if you watch with an open mind, he just looked scarred didn't make good reads, and seemed dead set on what WR he was going to before a lot of plays. That's going to have to be coached out of him, don't compound one mistake with another, forget it and move on. He's got all the tools, now he just needs the metal part of the game.
Last edited by buckmarkduck on Sun Sep 24, 2017 2:40 pm, edited 1 time in total.
ASU might not have been playing well but they're very talented, especially offensively. I would say that there's not a huge difference in talent in between the teams.
Phenom wrote:ASU might not have been playing well but they're very talented, especially offensively. I would say that there's not a huge difference in talent in between the teams.
Yeah I'd kill to have their WR corp and I'd take their LB over ours anyday. But after all that Wilkins just made more plays then Herbert, plain and simple. Herbert missed a lot of open guys, lots he didn't even throw the ball to.