I'm looking for reasons for hope of avoiding another 91 yard game
Found a nice clip of highlights from Anthony Brown on YouTube from a Virginia Tech game. Of course generally everyone looks good in a highlight clip, but AB did show great poise and an ability to push the ball down the field.
OrTDuck wrote:I'm looking for reasons for hope of avoiding another 91 yard game
Found a nice clip of highlights from Anthony Brown on YouTube from a Virginia Tech game. Of course generally everyone looks good in a highlight clip, but AB did show great poise and an ability to push the ball down the field.
Yea, he's not a superstar, just to be clear. But he did improve every year at BC, and was playing really good ball right before he went down with an injury. He makes boneheaded mistakes, but he plays winning football- he pushes the ball down-field, rises to the moment, and doesn't get rattled. He's incredibly Darron Thomas-esque. I guess I'm of the belief that you go with a guy like that unless someone else is a burgeoning star.
I guess this is a message board so "random speculation" is ok? And not intended as criticism exactly?
I'd imagine Moorhead sort of inherited Tyler Shough and while probably not explicitly told what to do, has been encouraged to follow the set plan - which does appear to have been Shough after Herbert if he can. So, Moorhead to a degree, has been "trying to fit a square peg in a round hole".
If you look at the three kids Moorhead brought in at Mississippi State:
Jayden Mayden (#361): 6-2 215. #20 Dual QB, #2 Dual QB in Texas. 2,170 passing, 784 rushing yards as a senior.
Garrett Schrader (#238): 6-4.5 215. #8 Dual QB. 2,564 passing, 799 rushing as a senior.
Tommy Stevens (#647): 6-5 235. #22 Dual QB. Penn State grad transfer. 304 yards passing, 506 yards rushing as primarily a back-up. Some injuries at MSU but 934 yards passing, 310 yards rushing.
Moorhead had been OC about 2 and 1/2 months before Anthony Brown picked Oregon. One would expect he had some input into which transfers Oregon was most interested in. 6-2 225. (#798) #23 Dual QB. 2,298 pass/604 rush as a HS senior. 4,747 pass/423 rush in 28 games at BC (not in a Moorhead offense). Ty Thompson, while listed as a PRO is a sturdy 6-4 200 kid who added 1150 rushing yards and 20 rush TDs to his 10,000 career passing yards.
Moorhead appears to want to work with a bigger/sturdy dual threat QB, not necessarily a more traditional pro style passer. Shough (#140, #7 PRO QB). 6-4.5 187, does have some wheels - but to my eyes is definitely in a PRO style mode. I believe he rushed for about 100 yards a season as both a junior and senior.
It may be a case of (struggles) of an OC trying to work with a different style player than he would normally pick - as well as struggles from a kid trying to fit into an offense he probably wouldn't now be recruited to? The suggestion Moorhead could dial up a plan for AB that takes advantage of both his skill set and experience as well as "fits" better into Moorhead's preferred offensive approach doesn't seem crazy. Moorhead mentions he looks for a QB who "beats you with his arm, his feet, and his brain", multiple, creative, explosive.
I get the idea if possible you play the younger guy and the thought before Covid - AB would be a "one and done", but it doesn't seem impossible he might return (with an extra year) if indeed it looked like he would play and not sit. It wouldn't be crazy to run AB in 2021 and run Thompson or Butterfield as rFR in 2022.
(I suppose I'm posting too much QB talk on a game thread. I'll try to dial it back)
^ I hope Brown comes back. He doesn’t count against the 85 limit and would be very well seasoned.
Something of note/to remember is that Brown tore his knee last season and was non-contact until at least August. I’m hopeful that we see him on the 2nd and he will be even more explosive in 2021 when fully recovered and healthy
Are you guys going to play both of those QB's? How are they different? Seems you don't care much for that Slough character so why isn't the other guy starting?
ISU_Fan wrote:Are you guys going to play both of those QB's? How are they different? Seems you don't care much for that Slough character so why isn't the other guy starting?
They're quite similar. Both are guys with good but not great arms (Shough has perhaps slightly better arm talent in a practice setting, but only shows flashes of it in games), and both guys who can get a first down with their feet but not a lot more. Difference is that Shough, the younger guy who has more years in the program, is easily rattled. Once there's either defensive pressure or pressure to make a play, he looks like he just walked into a bear den. Brown looks more like a guy who's been there, done that. Otherwise, they're both solid but not outstanding football players.
ISU_Fan wrote:Are you guys going to play both of those QB's? How are they different? Seems you don't care much for that Slough character so why isn't the other guy starting?
They're quite similar. Both are guys with good but not great arms (Shough has perhaps slightly better arm talent in a practice setting, but only shows flashes of it in games), and both guys who can get a first down with their feet but not a lot more. Difference is that Shough, the younger guy who has more years in the program, is easily rattled. Once there's either defensive pressure or pressure to make a play, he looks like he just walked into a bear den. Brown looks more like a guy who's been there, done that. Otherwise, they're both solid but not outstanding football players.
ISU_Fan wrote:Are you guys going to play both of those QB's? How are they different? Seems you don't care much for that Slough character so why isn't the other guy starting?
We just don't know about how much they'll play. Shough, the young guy, has started the whole year, but over the last couple games there's been more and more pressure to put in the backup, Brown. The coaches finally let Brown play maybe ~25% of the snaps in the conference championship game (a very rough estimate based on my initial watch), and he looked good. As you can see, there are plenty of fans, maybe more than ever, who want to lean more on Brown. But the coaches haven't tipped their hand yet and I'm not sure they will before kickoff.
I don't think Mario played Brown because of increased pressure. He's been hinting all year that he was going to get him involved. He also stated pretty clearly that Shough is still the starter. So like it or not, I think Shough will still be getting most of the snaps. It might be bad for this one bowl game, but in terms of setting up for next year, it makes sense. If Shough does well, then his improvement will carry into the spring. If he doesn't do well, it's a great excuse to transition into the next guy with conscience clear.
I am hopeful that the improved DL play we have seen over the past couple of games continues. I'm a little worried that Oregon won't be able to exploit Iowa State's weaknesses though. It seems like the way to beat them is to pass down the field, and Shough has been too scared to even look down the field. Hopefully the next few weeks of practice give him more confidence.
Yeah I didn't mean to say Cristobal was bowing to fan pressure, I was just giving a sense of what the perspective has been for us fans. I think he played Brown mostly because Shough's been underwhelming.
Phalanx wrote:I don't think Mario played Brown because of increased pressure. He's been hinting all year that he was going to get him involved. He also stated pretty clearly that Shough is still the starter. So like it or not, I think Shough will still be getting most of the snaps. It might be bad for this one bowl game, but in terms of setting up for next year, it makes sense. If Shough does well, then his improvement will carry into the spring. If he doesn't do well, it's a great excuse to transition into the next guy with conscience clear.
I am hopeful that the improved DL play we have seen over the past couple of games continues. I'm a little worried that Oregon won't be able to exploit Iowa State's weaknesses though. It seems like the way to beat them is to pass down the field, and Shough has been too scared to even look down the field. Hopefully the next few weeks of practice give him more confidence.
The way to beat us to dink and dunk through the zone. There will be spaces the defense gives you. Our DC changes our defense based on what you show him the first 2-3 drives. Which is why you will often see teams get a lead on us and then don't do much of anything the second half of the game, like the Sooners in the conf. champ. game. Score early, continue to to chop wood through the zone and look for a special teams gaffe by us (this is likely) and that's your recipe to win.
It seems like there is some weakness in the Iowa State pass defense. Unfortunately, I'm not sure the Ducks are in a position to exploit it. I guess we'll see.
One thought I might also throw out about AB is that in his time at Boston College, BC went 20-18, had a 2019 four year recruiting rating of #63 out of #130 (SBNation 2/7/19), went through a couple of OCs, and was hurt (knee 2017, leg 2019).
It might be interesting to see what he might do if healthy in a Moorhead offense with Oregon's skill guys (and overall bump in talent) around him (obviously we can't see Shough in the 2017-2019 BC offense).
Phalanx wrote:I don't think Mario played Brown because of increased pressure. He's been hinting all year that he was going to get him involved. He also stated pretty clearly that Shough is still the starter. So like it or not, I think Shough will still be getting most of the snaps. It might be bad for this one bowl game, but in terms of setting up for next year, it makes sense. If Shough does well, then his improvement will carry into the spring. If he doesn't do well, it's a great excuse to transition into the next guy with conscience clear.
I am hopeful that the improved DL play we have seen over the past couple of games continues. I'm a little worried that Oregon won't be able to exploit Iowa State's weaknesses though. It seems like the way to beat them is to pass down the field, and Shough has been too scared to even look down the field. Hopefully the next few weeks of practice give him more confidence.
This is how I feel even if I disagree with Mario's rationale or the last part about how it sets us up for next year since Anthony Brown could do that too until Thompson wins the job.
If we win and Shough looks like a different QB I'll gladly eat crow but there hasn't been anything to suggest that step-up will occur unfortunately.