Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head Coach

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3315
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Duck24 wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
Duck24 wrote:
duckfan22 wrote:the biggest thing for me with Kiffin is first how he left Tennessee after one year. 2nd is when at
Tennessee and USC he was guilty of some minor recruiting infractions and always played like
he didnt know. Had no idea it was against the rules to have recruits at his house for a bar-b-que.
I just cant trust him.. He may have changed and i actually think hes a decent coach.
You know Coach Campbell helped forge a recruits LOI? Did you have any problems trusting him? Hell, Chip got a freaking show cause penalty and everyone would welcome him back with open arms. Kiffin's violations are pittance compared to Chip and Coach Campbell.

Surrounded by the right staff and assuming he has grown up, Joey Freshwater could make Oregon very successful. He'd slay his fair share of co-ed's for sure but you can't deny his appeal as a coach if you are a recruit.
There is no evidence he could make Oregon successful. He got fired at the airport for trashing a team with an All-Star coaching staff and more 5 stars on the roster then Oregon has every had combined. Zero evidence that he can be a good head coach. A ton of evidence he is a sneaky weasel.
There's no evidence any coach we are taking about could succeed at Oregon. Which one of these coaches we are after has led a Power 5 school with a history of top 10 finishes that has no natural recruiting base? Coaching searches are an absolute crap shoot which is why so many of them go wrong.
This is all true, but how about eliminating the ones have failed, bailed and failed already in spectacular style as opposed to ones who have known nothing but success at granted lower levels. Still a gamble, but I like the odds better.
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by Duck24 »

GrandpaDuck wrote:
Duck24 wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
Duck24 wrote:
duckfan22 wrote:the biggest thing for me with Kiffin is first how he left Tennessee after one year. 2nd is when at
Tennessee and USC he was guilty of some minor recruiting infractions and always played like
he didnt know. Had no idea it was against the rules to have recruits at his house for a bar-b-que.
I just cant trust him.. He may have changed and i actually think hes a decent coach.
You know Coach Campbell helped forge a recruits LOI? Did you have any problems trusting him? Hell, Chip got a freaking show cause penalty and everyone would welcome him back with open arms. Kiffin's violations are pittance compared to Chip and Coach Campbell.

Surrounded by the right staff and assuming he has grown up, Joey Freshwater could make Oregon very successful. He'd slay his fair share of co-ed's for sure but you can't deny his appeal as a coach if you are a recruit.
There is no evidence he could make Oregon successful. He got fired at the airport for trashing a team with an All-Star coaching staff and more 5 stars on the roster then Oregon has every had combined. Zero evidence that he can be a good head coach. A ton of evidence he is a sneaky weasel.
There's no evidence any coach we are taking about could succeed at Oregon. Which one of these coaches we are after has led a Power 5 school with a history of top 10 finishes that has no natural recruiting base? Coaching searches are an absolute crap shoot which is why so many of them go wrong.
This is all true, but how about eliminating the ones have failed, bailed and failed already in spectacular style as opposed to ones who have known nothing but success at granted lower levels. Still a gamble, but I like the odds better.
I should clarify that I'm not pining for Kiffin and disparaging Fleck. My point is that they shouldn't eliminate anyone who they believe could be an asset to the program. I think Kiffin could kill at Oregon but I could also see him failing miserably and the same can be said for Fleck. The 'conventional' hire in these situations is rarely the right one, at least in my opinion.
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3315
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Fair enough Duck24.

Besides it appears Kiffen is in the process of trying to steal Alabama commits to his new unannounced job at LSU. Ed O maybe putting the gang back together.

If this turns out to be true. Kiff will set some kind of record for being the most reviled ex-coach by the fan base at 4 consecutive jobs.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by duckfan22 »

Another midwest job opened up today at Indiana...
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by Duck24 »

duckfan22 wrote:Another midwest job opened up today at Indiana...
They have already hired their DC as the new coach on a full time basis.
User avatar
FlDuckFan
All Pac-12
Posts: 5068
Joined: Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:45 am
GM: Orlando Magic GM
Location: Florida

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by FlDuckFan »

Duck24 wrote:
duckfan22 wrote:Another midwest job opened up today at Indiana...
They have already hired their DC as the new coach on a full time basis.
Reddit post says Purdue found their coach and it's not Fleck but Brohm .
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by duckfan22 »

Duck24 wrote:
duckfan22 wrote:Another midwest job opened up today at Indiana...
They have already hired their DC as the new coach on a full time basis.
ok had not seen that..only articale on the firing thanks
Duck24
Senior
Posts: 4744
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:36 am
Location: Portland, OR

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by Duck24 »

FlDuckFan wrote:
Duck24 wrote:
duckfan22 wrote:Another midwest job opened up today at Indiana...
They have already hired their DC as the new coach on a full time basis.
Reddit post says Purdue found their coach and it's not Fleck but Brohm .
That's a damn good hire if true. Brohm is going to end up at a premiere job in the not too distant future IMO.
rsbgduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 672
Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 9:42 am
Location: Roseburg, OR
Contact:

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by rsbgduck »

Handsome Dan wrote:Look here's the deal with Kiffin. Young rich people who get things handed to them generally behave like massive assholes, but only some of them are irredeemable assholes, while others are simply acting that way because of shitty parenting or a lack of corrective discipline elsewhere. None of us are sure which one it is for Kiffin, but what we do know is that his previous mentor (Pete Carroll) is the type to enable such shitty immature behavior, while Nick Saban is the complete opposite.Thus if there's any chance that Kiffin is actually a decent human being underneath the veneer of douchery we were exposed to during his time at Tennessee and USC, his humiliating firing and subsequent time under Saban should have brought it out. Obviously they need to see through thorough evaluation if he actually has changed, but if he has, I don't think his behavior as we know of it now ever really rose to the level of unforgivable.

Briles and Kelly, as middle aged men, on the other hand...

Not to sound preachy, there is a difference between forgiving and forgetting. I have forgiven lots of people who did wrong to me in one way or another, including an ex-wife (many of whom said her actions were unforgivable) granted that one took longer than most, but I have never forgotten the lesson each one taught me.
I'm not speaking for anyone else on this board but for me when it comes to Lane Kiffen it's a matter of trust or the lack of. The reason for this is from his previous actions, performance and lack of success as a OC and HC. The first year at Bama his actions were still questionable at times until Saben got a big enough choke collar to keep him in line over the following 2 years. He has continued to pad his resume at OC where he has always been successful to my knowledge. From that perspective he has earned some trust back. As for him earning any trust back or proving he's now ready to be a HC and take over IMO a top 15-20 HC job? Maybe in some situations but not Oregon's, I think it's to big of a risk with a huge down side. With the right hire I see the Ducks competing for the PAC12 Championship the year after next. With Kiffen's history (I'm sorry but even with the sanctions he should of won more games at USC) of how badly damaged he leaves a program regardless if he was terminated or taking another job Oregon would be devastated and I'm guessing anywhere from 6-10 years before they were a 8 or 9 win team all dependent on how that HC does with recruiting. Look at Tennessee and they are in prime recruiting grounds unlike or Ducks. I understand that the problems at USC are not all on Kiffen but IMO he made that situation much worse than it had to be. I think he needs to earn that trust and prove himself as a HC at another school, preferably a non power 5 conference school. He's just not worth the risk IMO.

Go Ducks!!!
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6490
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by pezsez1 »

I'm against Kiffen because tigers don't change their stripes.

Oregon didn't fire Helfrich because he's a bad coach with bad schemes and a shitty attitude. He got canned because he couldn't motivate guys enough to lock down Oregon's culture.

Ball deflations and other shenanigans aside, Kiffen just isn't that "high energy" guy we're looking for. He's young, yes. He's somewhat likeable, yes. But again, we didn't just fire Helfrich because he wasn't likeable enough -- that was never the problem. We need a guy who brings more fire to the locker room, and that someone won't ever be Lane Kiffin. Am I the only one who remembers him at USC, always standing by himself with his head buried in his clipboard? People here criticized Helfrich for being too much of a beta, and what is Kiffen other than a younger, less-likeable beta who has shown much thinner convictions?

I'll pass.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
duckphanatic23
One Star Recruit
Posts: 84
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:27 pm

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by duckphanatic23 »

We made a gamble on Chip Kelly from New Hampshire. Given it was for a different role. It just feels like we'll make the gamble to get Fleck. Row the Boat and Win the Day? Sounds like Chip 2.0. Watch WMUs game tomorrow and you'll see how hard his kids play. Doesn't make sense to go with a completely different style coach like Schiano. I'd take him at DC and I'm sure Phil would pay for it (only...$600K). Not happening. We have an offensive product with Nike to put on the field. I think this would a be a home run hire if we get Fleck. He'll be a winner wherever he ends up.
rsbgduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 672
Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2009 9:42 am
Location: Roseburg, OR
Contact:

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by rsbgduck »

duckphanatic23 wrote:We made a gamble on Chip Kelly from New Hampshire. Given it was for a different role. It just feels like we'll make the gamble to get Fleck. Row the Boat and Win the Day? Sounds like Chip 2.0. Watch WMUs game tomorrow and you'll see how hard his kids play. Doesn't make sense to go with a completely different style coach like Schiano. I'd take him at DC and I'm sure Phil would pay for it (only...$600K). Not happening. We have an offensive product with Nike to put on the field. I think this would a be a home run hire if we get Fleck. He'll be a winner wherever he ends up.
I think it is a big role difference between gambling on a OC vs. HC plus all the guy's you mentioned don't come close to the baggage Kiffen would bring along. A gamble with Kiffen would be like putting a few million on one slot machine pull. Fleck would be more like putting down a few million on a blackjack table. I agree with you about Schiano, I don't think it would be a bad hire but could see it going like the Michigan Brady Hoke story.

I am in agreement with a few other posters here that Fleck as HC and Schiano at DC would be about as good as it gets right now. Like you said though, the money would be the first hurdle, second would be getting Schiano to make a lateral move even if you through a bunch of money at him, plus if he is successful IMO he would be gone in a couple yrs.
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Strong Evidence that Schiano or Fleck is the next Head C

Post by duckfan22 »

Regardless the dead period begins 12/14/16 and lasts 5 weeks. No contact with recruits. Who ever is selected is going to need to hit the road running
Post Reply