Pac-12 Player Strike
Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1
-
maxduck
- Senior
- Posts: 3763
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 4:37 pm
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
One of the WSU players who opted out appears to have a legitimate reason
When Woods was a freshman, athletic trainers discovered he possessed the sickle cell trait – something that could cause complications if Woods was ever exposed to COVID-19, or even worse, contracted the virus himself.
The redshirt sophomore maintains the Pac-12 hasn’t done enough to address health and safety concerns since inviting players back to campus for voluntary workouts, and worries he’ll be compromised when the Cougars travel to play games outside of Pullman.
“Because I do have sickle cell trait, and with this COVID it affects the respiratory system, so I just wasn’t comfortable playing at all,” Woods told The Spokesman-Review on Sunday. “And I haven’t heard any plans ensuring we’d be safe.”
And WSU may have valid concerns for their actions.
A source close to the situation assured Woods’ scholarship would not be revoked if he opted out of the season, but that WSU, mainly for health and liability reasons, wouldn’t allow him to participate in workouts and other football-related activities.
Like everything else with Covid it's complicated.
https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2020/ ... -unless-c/
When Woods was a freshman, athletic trainers discovered he possessed the sickle cell trait – something that could cause complications if Woods was ever exposed to COVID-19, or even worse, contracted the virus himself.
The redshirt sophomore maintains the Pac-12 hasn’t done enough to address health and safety concerns since inviting players back to campus for voluntary workouts, and worries he’ll be compromised when the Cougars travel to play games outside of Pullman.
“Because I do have sickle cell trait, and with this COVID it affects the respiratory system, so I just wasn’t comfortable playing at all,” Woods told The Spokesman-Review on Sunday. “And I haven’t heard any plans ensuring we’d be safe.”
And WSU may have valid concerns for their actions.
A source close to the situation assured Woods’ scholarship would not be revoked if he opted out of the season, but that WSU, mainly for health and liability reasons, wouldn’t allow him to participate in workouts and other football-related activities.
Like everything else with Covid it's complicated.
https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2020/ ... -unless-c/
-
woundedknees
- All-American
- Posts: 12826
- Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:06 pm
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
AmenGoDucksIn09 wrote:When I was in college, I was not from a rich family, not from a poor family, I was not gifted academically or athletically and I had to pay for school myself. I wish I had half the talent these athletes do, or the brains the smart ones do, but that was not me. I had to take out student loans and I am white. These athletes seem to not understand how fortunate they are. The free education, free meals, access to trainers that nobody else has access to for free. It must be rough to have so much talent that schools want you to play for them. If you are one of the very select few that make it to the next level then you get all of this plus millions of dollars that 80% of the population does not get. It must be really rough. I would have no problem schools kicking these kids off the teams. I get the concerns about the Covid Virus. I truly do. In regards to the poor black students, I would counter that with what about all the poor students. I simply refuse to make this a black vs white issue. I want equality for ALL STUDENTS. Not just the black students, not just the white students, not just the latino students, not just the asian students. I am fed up with these students thinking somehow they are not getting enough. It is the every day students who do not have the academics or athleticism that comes from poor families that need the help.
Autzen Stadium... Where great teams go to die...Hard!


-
ducks5ever
- Four Star Recruit
- Posts: 936
- Joined: Tue Jan 10, 2017 12:15 pm
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
It's so sad that these players with such bright futures are destroying their careers before they even start. Sewell, Holland, and Graham are headed to the NFL, but this has got to hurt their stock, especially if they sit out this season. Which team will spend a pick in the first 3 rounds on someone who might not play just cuz? There are risks and benefits to everything. No one is forcing any of the football players to play football. If they feel that the risks associated with football are greater than the potential benefits, no one is stopping them from calling it quits. At least the CFP committee won't face much scrutiny over the selection process this year despite all the challenges..... and the PAC continues to fall into irrelevancy. Coach Cristobal is in such a tough spot..... guys like Avalos and Cristobal who want to just play ball now have legitimate reasons to look elsewhere.
-
alxtw
- Freshman
- Posts: 1279
- Joined: Sun Dec 19, 2010 10:46 pm
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
The media and social media has been pushing the issue of NCAA football making billions and players not receiving any of it in the players face for years. With the addition of covid, the media is making it an even bigger issue to the players. They should receive some form of extra health benefits, security, insurance policies, and incentives to play this year because of the situation and circumstances have changed.
However, the list that the Pac-12 players have demanded in order to play this season is ridiculous. Not only is every universities' situation unique, but every players' background and future potentials are very different.
Aside from Larry Scott's ludicrous package, Pac12 coaches are one of the lowest paid coaches compared to other conference coaches. The many pac12 facilities were built from funds of private donors, who were willing to donate to the construction of those facilities. Also, almost every job in the country offers performance bonuses or perks when you delivered good results, so why should it be any different for the staff.
It seems like the idiot that wrote this list went to every player in the pact to ask what they wanted from Santa (the pac12) this year, and combined everyone's wishes into one long list thinking its going to be Christmas.
I've always been very supportive of the players getting paid, but that demand list is just ridiculous...
However, the list that the Pac-12 players have demanded in order to play this season is ridiculous. Not only is every universities' situation unique, but every players' background and future potentials are very different.
Aside from Larry Scott's ludicrous package, Pac12 coaches are one of the lowest paid coaches compared to other conference coaches. The many pac12 facilities were built from funds of private donors, who were willing to donate to the construction of those facilities. Also, almost every job in the country offers performance bonuses or perks when you delivered good results, so why should it be any different for the staff.
It seems like the idiot that wrote this list went to every player in the pact to ask what they wanted from Santa (the pac12) this year, and combined everyone's wishes into one long list thinking its going to be Christmas.
I've always been very supportive of the players getting paid, but that demand list is just ridiculous...
-
OregonVato
- One Star Recruit
- Posts: 62
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 3:48 am
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
This will get buried because I won't respond afterward, but many of us left this board when it became a far-right echo chamber. A bunch of washed-up old white dudes trying to tell a bunch of supremely-talented Black men how to handle their business is a complete joke.
A friendly reminder:
A friendly reminder:
- 1. Women don't need you to tell them how and when to reproduce
2. Black folx don't need you to tell them how to protest
3. Athletes don't need you to tell them how to protect their futures
- StevensTechU
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7116
- Joined: Mon Aug 03, 2015 6:25 am
- Location: Hoboken, NJ
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
OregonVato, as a left-leaning civilian (on most issues, far-left on environmental issues), I want to say your broad-based post that comes out of left field on several things and doesn't directly respond to anything anyone has said, doesn't advance the conversation. Your heart is in a good place but your tactic was awful and only going to make people think less of you, and with it, likely less of the issues you're raising. Also, to take something out on you, Black people, save for perhaps a handful who make their money from droves of white people following them on twitter, don't call themselves "folx." That's some ginned up white people s***. If you're not comfortable saying "black folks" because it feels like appropriation of their term, then just say "Black people" or "the Black community."
Now back to the subject at hand.
The 50% revenue share by the start of the season is a complete non-starter. I feel like I probably don't have to explain, but I prefer my posts to be substantive, so I guess I'll wade in. Universities, not just athletic departments, are going to be deep in the red this fall and this year, and have contractual obligations that they have to meet no matter what. Within the athletic department, the only way to suck up this loss would be to lay off the full football and basketball staffs. Full stop to consider that point. So then that would have to sucked up by the academic institution, which means subsidizing sports by directly harming the educational mission of the school. So less kids on scholarships, essentially, because the athletes wanted to get paid RIGHT NOW. Also, paying student-athletes in 2020 will still disqualify you with the NCAA....
To that point, my second issue is the suggestion that they should take away from the school's endowment to subsidize sports. Stanford is a unique case where they have multitudes more money than anyone else in the conference, but even then, how do you justify suggesting they should use those funds on football players instead of cancer research or scholarships for needy students? Get the F out of here with that.
I have and continue to support the concept of coaching salary caps. I think it's entirely reasonable for a team with many players making below their free market rate to be annoyed when they see coaching salaries skyrocket. I also understand faculty and administrators being bothered by that. So I think the NCAA legitimately needs to come in and say "ADs can only make up do $X, football teams can only spend $Y, and basketball teams can only spend $Z annually," so that way schools don't spend themselves into deep debt (Cal) and the money gets diverted to the institution for things that are frankly more important than sports. And as 99% of this board agrees, I'm pretty sure, players should be free to profit from their name and likeness without restraint.
The requests on health and safety are completely justified, and probably reason to not have a season at all this year. Also, the requests to have more time outside of football is also justified. Someone brought up how many student-athletes are sociology majors -- this is in large part because they get steered toward that and a few other majors because it's most conducive to their football schedule. For any of us who had group projects with athletes from team sports, we know that their athletic obligations were conducive to only doing essentially the bare minimum academically.
I planned to speak to the requests made by the United group that the conference doesn't control (extra eligibility and whatnot), but this post was long enough.
Now back to the subject at hand.
The 50% revenue share by the start of the season is a complete non-starter. I feel like I probably don't have to explain, but I prefer my posts to be substantive, so I guess I'll wade in. Universities, not just athletic departments, are going to be deep in the red this fall and this year, and have contractual obligations that they have to meet no matter what. Within the athletic department, the only way to suck up this loss would be to lay off the full football and basketball staffs. Full stop to consider that point. So then that would have to sucked up by the academic institution, which means subsidizing sports by directly harming the educational mission of the school. So less kids on scholarships, essentially, because the athletes wanted to get paid RIGHT NOW. Also, paying student-athletes in 2020 will still disqualify you with the NCAA....
To that point, my second issue is the suggestion that they should take away from the school's endowment to subsidize sports. Stanford is a unique case where they have multitudes more money than anyone else in the conference, but even then, how do you justify suggesting they should use those funds on football players instead of cancer research or scholarships for needy students? Get the F out of here with that.
I have and continue to support the concept of coaching salary caps. I think it's entirely reasonable for a team with many players making below their free market rate to be annoyed when they see coaching salaries skyrocket. I also understand faculty and administrators being bothered by that. So I think the NCAA legitimately needs to come in and say "ADs can only make up do $X, football teams can only spend $Y, and basketball teams can only spend $Z annually," so that way schools don't spend themselves into deep debt (Cal) and the money gets diverted to the institution for things that are frankly more important than sports. And as 99% of this board agrees, I'm pretty sure, players should be free to profit from their name and likeness without restraint.
The requests on health and safety are completely justified, and probably reason to not have a season at all this year. Also, the requests to have more time outside of football is also justified. Someone brought up how many student-athletes are sociology majors -- this is in large part because they get steered toward that and a few other majors because it's most conducive to their football schedule. For any of us who had group projects with athletes from team sports, we know that their athletic obligations were conducive to only doing essentially the bare minimum academically.
I planned to speak to the requests made by the United group that the conference doesn't control (extra eligibility and whatnot), but this post was long enough.
Last edited by StevensTechU on Mon Aug 03, 2020 8:03 am, edited 1 time in total.
- lukeyrid13
- All-American
- Posts: 10475
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:58 am
- GM: Portland TrailBlazers
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
I’m not trying to be combative, but I will respectfully disagree on a few things.OregonVato wrote:This will get buried because I won't respond afterward, but many of us left this board when it became a far-right echo chamber. A bunch of washed-up old white dudes trying to tell a bunch of supremely-talented Black men how to handle their business is a complete joke.
A friendly reminder:These Men and Women of Oregon do not exist for your entertainment.
- 1. Women don't need you to tell them how and when to reproduce
2. Black folx don't need you to tell them how to protest
3. Athletes don't need you to tell them how to protect their futures
1. We don’t know anyone’s race on here, you brought up race.
2. Always decrying “racist!” And then shutting down dialogue is a massive problem in our society.
3. We are a country built on diversity; which includes diversity of thought
4. I would say that while individuals, who should have their opinion, Oregon football players collectively are for our entertainment. If you took a backup LB and removed the Oregon brand, what would he be able to obtain on the open market? It wouldn’t be better than: free education, free food, free housing, free gear, a monthly stipend and a platform that gives them a great networking platform post grad.
-
mrpd21
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1177
- Joined: Mon Nov 02, 2009 6:04 am
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
OregonVato wrote:This will get buried because I won't respond afterward, but many of us left this board when it became a far-right echo chamber. A bunch of washed-up old white dudes trying to tell a bunch of supremely-talented Black men how to handle their business is a complete joke.
A friendly reminder:These Men and Women of Oregon do not exist for your entertainment.
- 1. Women don't need you to tell them how and when to reproduce
2. Black folx don't need you to tell them how to protest
3. Athletes don't need you to tell them how to protect their futures
OK, so this guy showed up with a pre-loaded narrative. While predictable I understand your points. Here's what you fail to consider...
First off, it's ridiculous (IMO) that anyone "famous" (athletes, actors, etc. CEOs are a whole additional conversation...I am focusing on entertainment) makes as much as they do in the highest ranks. They only make that much because the industry is popular and has been so to the point where it's become incredibly over-bloated revenue wise. That's because of people who have invested their time and hard-earned money into the enjoyment of such entertainment. While this includes many channels of investment (tv time, ticket purchases, fan gear, gambling, etc) from people of all types and races, it does indeed include the "bunch of washed-up old white dudes" you mention.
Whether you like it or not, and whether it has anything to do with race or not, people can choose to spend their time, money and energy into other things and render the entertainment fields to a point of irrelevancy if they so chose. While it is a business it is clearly a non-essential one. I personally have missed sports but honestly I have found more time to connect with my family, get more done around the house, and enjoy more of the outdoors than I typically would. For me it's honestly been refreshing for my soul and it has really made me nearly indifferent on watching any sports outside of the Ducks (at least for the moment). When people choose to take a stand, draw lines in the sand or blend in things such as politics and religion, it begs a reaction from the masses. I do support getting paid off of likeness and image. Some of the other demands are either crazy but they know it and are looking to compromise somewhere in the middle, or just plain dumb and if they sacrifice their CFP playing days and potential career over it...I think they're too emotionally invested and need to be wiser in their approach.
It gets said a lot but people often look to entertainment as an outlet of the stresses in life. Many of the things bleeding more into sports are some of the things people want to evade while watching football. Watching the WNBA players literally leave the court during the national anthem was, to me, very aggressive and pretty much begging people to walk away from the sport. Viewership has buying power and the people who choose to walk away due to the politicizing of sports either temporarily or permanently have the 100% right to do so, whether you and I like it or not. So while the athletes can definitely demand action and take a stand as they are their own persons and entity (and the reason sports are so entertaining), fans can respond by choosing to make their presence or absence speak for their personal stance on the matter (they're the reason sports are so successful and revenue rich).
Any response in any direction right now is incredibly volatile...this nation is a house of cards no matter what side you are on.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
A few people who tend to hold more Libertarian values on this board does not make it a far-right echo chamber, LOL. The only Echo on this board is "Go-Ducks."OregonVato wrote:This will get buried because I won't respond afterward, but many of us left this board when it became a far-right echo chamber. A bunch of washed-up old white dudes trying to tell a bunch of supremely-talented Black men how to handle their business is a complete joke.
A friendly reminder:These Men and Women of Oregon do not exist for your entertainment.
- 1. Women don't need you to tell them how and when to reproduce
2. Black folx don't need you to tell them how to protest
3. Athletes don't need you to tell them how to protect their futures

-
mrpd21
- Five Star Recruit
- Posts: 1177
- Joined: Mon Nov 02, 2009 6:04 am
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
Appreciate everyone else's response to this guy. We can have differences of opinion, nice to see people come together when someone comes in hot with a take that gaslights an entire collective of persons. Pretty racist to force a racist narrative onto persons you not only don't know, you assume fit the profile you force upon them.
- Duck07
- All-American
- Posts: 17123
- Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 8:36 am
- Location: Parts Unknown
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
Penei doesn't need to play this season to be the first Tackle drafted; Jevon and Thomas would drop but likely not that far.ducks5ever wrote:It's so sad that these players with such bright futures are destroying their careers before they even start. Sewell, Holland, and Graham are headed to the NFL, but this has got to hurt their stock, especially if they sit out this season. Which team will spend a pick in the first 3 rounds on someone who might not play just cuz? There are risks and benefits to everything. No one is forcing any of the football players to play football. If they feel that the risks associated with football are greater than the potential benefits, no one is stopping them from calling it quits. At least the CFP committee won't face much scrutiny over the selection process this year despite all the challenges..... and the PAC continues to fall into irrelevancy. Coach Cristobal is in such a tough spot..... guys like Avalos and Cristobal who want to just play ball now have legitimate reasons to look elsewhere.
The NFL has shown it doesn't give a hoot if talented players bail on their teams so NO, they aren't even close to hurting their professional careers. With Covid, its an even larger "mulligan" year for players to bail for their health and a legit argument can be made that by staying away, they are in fact protecting themselves.
The issue that this primarily affects however is for every player who will never even set foot in an NFL facility. The majority of Ducks that pass through Autzen never go on to be Pro's and this Strike could see those 97% of players miss out.
As to Cristobal and Avalos leaving because of this, there's too much uncertainty for anyone to leave right now as you could find yourself quickly in a "grass isn't greener" situation. Any repercussions for the P12 likely hits other leagues too. A fair number of basketball recruits are deciding they'd rather play a year at a HBCU rather than big-time programs.

-
buckmarkduck
- All-American
- Posts: 11020
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
- Contact:
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
Thomas Graham posted a link that showed the 50% would be around $100k a year per player. But take out the cost of school, food etc, and it works out to about $23k a year. Is that worth sitting out the year for?
Onto the insurance issue. It took the NFL players 20 years to get health care beyond their playing days from the NFL, but I hope these kids can make some progress in getting it for ncaa athletes.
Onto the insurance issue. It took the NFL players 20 years to get health care beyond their playing days from the NFL, but I hope these kids can make some progress in getting it for ncaa athletes.
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15429
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
Very ironic that you make a sterotype about people on this board, express an opinion on that stereotype, then accuse those with opposing views to this strike as the prejudice ones. Also, nobody brought up women and protesting, so you're also assuming that anyone who is opposed to this strike is also opposed to women's rights and BLM protests which is absurd. Maybe realize your point of view doesn't give you a moral high ground compared to others with opposing views and try actually making legit arguments, it might take you farther.OregonVato wrote:This will get buried because I won't respond afterward, but many of us left this board when it became a far-right echo chamber. A bunch of washed-up old white dudes trying to tell a bunch of supremely-talented Black men how to handle their business is a complete joke.
A friendly reminder:These Men and Women of Oregon do not exist for your entertainment.
- 1. Women don't need you to tell them how and when to reproduce
2. Black folx don't need you to tell them how to protest
3. Athletes don't need you to tell them how to protect their futures
Also, congrats, you probably got it right calling us white men (at least I am), on a college football forum (a sport mostly watched by men), in one of the most white states in the country. I bet you're also bold enough to go to a forum for Hallmark Christmas movies and call them a bunch of white women or Karens.

-
karlhungis
- All Pac-12
- Posts: 7990
- Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
This precedent has already been set and if you have enough talent, the NFL will still draft you. And, they aren't sitting out "just cuz." I am pretty sure that a global pandemic where the long term effects of the virus aren't even known yet is a pretty sufficient reason to sit out if a person is concerned about their health.ducks5ever wrote:It's so sad that these players with such bright futures are destroying their careers before they even start. Sewell, Holland, and Graham are headed to the NFL, but this has got to hurt their stock, especially if they sit out this season. Which team will spend a pick in the first 3 rounds on someone who might not play just cuz?
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
- OregonFan4Life
- All-American
- Posts: 15429
- Joined: Thu Aug 26, 2010 5:32 pm
Re: Pac-12 Player Strike
Another thing I wanted to say about this strike, and it relates to other aspects of this generation, is they are filled with a lot of fight, and their fight isn't necessarily wrong, but it's completely directed towards the wrong arenas. Whether it's BLM going after Republicans and cops instead of Hollywood (I will leave it at that since this is a sports forum, not a political one) or Pac-12 athletes going after schools, they need to understand where they really should take their fight to. Asking the universities to pay them when they already operate in the red and will struggle a lot this year is unreasonable and doesn't make sense. Their fight should be with the NCAA, allowing them to make money off of their likeness so Nike, Adidas, whoever can put college athletes' last names on their jerseys. Same with EA, let players get played to have their likeness on the game. Also let players sale their gear while in college if they choose to. I think that's where their main fight for getting paid should be, not the universities that honestly can't afford it. And like Stu said, asking for money to be redirected from other important programs is stupid, and like he said, the idea of Stanford redirecting money from cancer research to football players is offensive, especially for someone like my wife who lost her mom to cancer when she was a young teen then 10 years later had to watch her dad fight cancer where he was treated at Stanford (and they were tremendous and probably saved his life). Just sucks to see these kids take their fight to the wrong places.
With that said, I still think these athletes are acting spoiled and don't realize how privileged they are to receive the benefits they do from being an athlete. I know people who are physically disabled that would do anything to switch with any one of them for just one day.
With that said, I still think these athletes are acting spoiled and don't realize how privileged they are to receive the benefits they do from being an athlete. I know people who are physically disabled that would do anything to switch with any one of them for just one day.
