It's odd how so many write off Shough. Many are the same people that were calling for Herbert to be benched last year.
Kid has played half a weird season.
I do think there's legitimate concerns about him getting rattled and not going through his progressions, and making dumb turnovers. That said, to suggest he can't improve next year or in the offseason is crazy talk.
As far as Brown returning..that's up to him. I'm fine with a Shough/Ty Thompson battle next season.
GrantDuck wrote:It's odd how so many write off Shough. Many are the same people that were calling for Herbert to be benched last year.
Kid has played half a weird season.
I do think there's legitimate concerns about him getting rattled and not going through his progressions, and making dumb turnovers. That said, to suggest he can't improve next year or in the offseason is crazy talk.
As far as Brown returning..that's up to him. I'm fine with a Shough/Ty Thompson battle next season.
I'm pretty sure I hold the honor of being the first poster to suggest benching him during the 1st half against WSU and you will find zero posts of mine ever suggesting we bench Herbert for competitive reasons, much less many others. You probably would find some posts suggesting we bench Herbert late to give actual reps to Shough and that's a Mario problem to be so stubborn.
All it attempts to do is deflect from talking about the real problems he's had at the most basic of things. More than many other programs, we know better than most what great QB play looks like and that's what the bar is. Go play the next guy like Butterfield so we can find out who the gamers are on this team.
GrantDuck wrote:It's odd how so many write off Shough. Many are the same people that were calling for Herbert to be benched last year.
Kid has played half a weird season.
I do think there's legitimate concerns about him getting rattled and not going through his progressions, and making dumb turnovers. That said, to suggest he can't improve next year or in the offseason is crazy talk.
As far as Brown returning..that's up to him. I'm fine with a Shough/Ty Thompson battle next season.
Where is this fictional land where people were calling for Herbert to be benched?
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
There was a lot of Herbert criticism. A few times some of the more emotional posters would call for it in game threads...but there was a lot of criticism for Herbert not taking any chances on throws and taking too many sacks, as well as him locking in on his first read (especially in 2018 with Mitchell).