Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

karlhungis
All Pac-12
Posts: 7990
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:08 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by karlhungis »

pezsez1 wrote:
3. You say all of those teams on that list have less talent than our defense... but is that true? I'm going to contradict myself here a bit, but if Uconn has a defense of mostly experience 2-3* recruits, and we have a defense of mostly 4* recruits -- but most of our starters in the secondary are getting their first real playing time -- then can you honestly say we have more talent right now, or do we simply have more potential once those guys get experience?
I am also too lazy to look up the youth stats of all 100+ teams that are ranked ahead of us but I don't believe that we have the youngest team in the country. I also don't think that is a valid excuse but it is one that our team has constantly had to rely on. It's part of what drives me crazy about our defense. Other schools can field a serviceable defense, even if it is young but for some reason ours can not.


And FWIW, I'm not angry. Sorry for coming across as such.
OregonFan4life -
My source just said Chip is officially back!
It will be announced at Autzen press conference tomorrow afternoon!
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:Why is that happening?

THAT should be the conversation happening here, not the same tired circular conversation that happens every year (which nobody will ever agree on, because some people value certain metrics more than others).
I've been getting caught up in the details of the arguments but I've been addressing that from the beginning.

There is a defensive philosophy in place that is outdated and IMO fundamentally flawed. Additionally, under Pellum it is badly run and the result is a defense that performed well in.. two games?

Defense should be simple. When you have the athletes that we have and have had for quite a few years you should be able to run a simple, aggressive, attacking defense. Instead we are still running a system that is notoriously complex and hard for players to grasp. It also happens to be very passive and essentially "allows" opposing offenses to gain yardage with the hope of tightening up in the red zone. Yet there is an aggressive aspect where we try to cause chaos and confusion and force a lot of turnovers. This is where the fundamental flaw is IMO. We run a defensive paradox. You can't cultivate an aggressive and sound defense when the foundation is to purposefully give up yards by playing off WRs, allowing the "easy stuff", and being afraid of giving up the big play. Our defensive philosophy limits us more than it does opposing offenses.
Image
duckfan22
Senior
Posts: 2698
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:48 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by duckfan22 »

sound defense when the foundation is to purposefully give up yards by playing off WRs, allowing the "easy stuff", and being afraid of giving up the big play. Our defensive philosophy limits us more than it does opposing offenses.

Also the problem is playing off receivers and allowing the easy stuff is we cant tackle which
then turns into more problems.
Greenblood
Senior
Posts: 3466
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:16 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by Greenblood »

GrandpaDuck wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:....... if you look at points allowed per "meaningful" possession.
Points per meaningful possession is the most significant stat in comparing tempo and non-tempo team's defenses. Where are you getting the data though? I would love to find a good site for that data both NCAA and NFL.
The "analytical" site I go to is http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/fei, and then go to the dropdowns (you do have to choose a year). Unfortunately, it'll be awhile before they start putting out the numbers for this season. But you can read about both the FEI and the S&P and see if they have what you're after.
Jaw327
One Star Recruit
Posts: 81
Joined: Mon Aug 10, 2015 8:57 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by Jaw327 »

dthomas=ddixon wrote:
pezsez1 wrote:Why is that happening?

THAT should be the conversation happening here, not the same tired circular conversation that happens every year (which nobody will ever agree on, because some people value certain metrics more than others).
I've been getting caught up in the details of the arguments but I've been addressing that from the beginning.

There is a defensive philosophy in place that is outdated and IMO fundamentally flawed. Additionally, under Pellum it is badly run and the result is a defense that performed well in.. two games?

Defense should be simple. When you have the athletes that we have and have had for quite a few years you should be able to run a simple, aggressive, attacking defense. Instead we are still running a system that is notoriously complex and hard for players to grasp. It also happens to be very passive and essentially "allows" opposing offenses to gain yardage with the hope of tightening up in the red zone. Yet there is an aggressive aspect where we try to cause chaos and confusion and force a lot of turnovers. This is where the fundamental flaw is IMO. We run a defensive paradox. You can't cultivate an aggressive and sound defense when the foundation is to purposefully give up yards by playing off WRs, allowing the "easy stuff", and being afraid of giving up the big play. Our defensive philosophy limits us more than it does opposing offenses.
yes to all of this, this is exactly right and incredibly well said.
I just want to add, if the thought is that Oregon can outscore anyone (and that is typically the case) then we shouldn't be afraid of giving up an explosion play every once in a while. The problem always comes when an opponent is able to hold on to the ball for prolonged periods and eat away the clock. It throws our Offensive rhythm out of sync, it tires out the defense and makes it imperative that we score 7 whenever we do get the ball.

But if we play aggressive, if we god forbid, press the receivers at the line and we get beat for a long TD throw, ohh well, we can go out there and get it back. Our defense isn't exhausted and our offense is able to do what they do best. And honestly, playing aggressive, jamming receivers at the line gives a better chance of putting pressure on the QB because he doesn't immediately have someone open to throw to and creates more chance for turnovers by not letting the receiver run a comfortable route.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

But if we get beat more often on long pass plays, CAN we just go out and get it back? We certainly couldn't against MSU. Maybe when Marcus was here, yeah... but against the only good defense we've faced this season, our offense was pretty inept for most of the game. Our running game was especially bad... our yards per carry against the Spartans was just 2.9, and that's definitely not a good sign.

Again, the sky isn't falling, and I think our offense will be fine.... but I don't think it's safe to sleep on explosion plays and figure our offense will just get it back.

This comes back to the issue of inexperience...

What will the vibe on this forum be on Sunday if we do play more press coverage against Utah, and it just results in us getting beat on more deep passes with no real positive results?

This Utah game will be very interesting. I think we'll learn a lot about the Ducks on both sides of the ball.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
User avatar
ncduck
Senior
Posts: 2189
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:14 am
Location: Rancho Palos Verdes, CA

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by ncduck »

I didn't get to see the last game, did we have our full slate of defensive starters playing the third quarter when we gave up the 21 points? Also, was our D obviously vanilla like EWU game?

I'm curious what another D system would look like on this team. I wonder what the best D system would be for the program.
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

We definitely brought more pressure than usual, at least for the first half -- so no, not nearly as vanilla as with EWU. I honestly don't remember if we kept it up in the second half. I know we had lots of backups during the fourth quarter. Seisay didn't play at all. Royce Freeman was held out for the second half, and I'm not sure if any defensive starters were held out, either (if any of our starting linemen were held out, that would help account for GSU having more time to complete passes, as opposed to being on the run more often in the first half).
Willie Taggart is a dick.
GrandpaDuck
Senior
Posts: 3317
Joined: Sat Mar 07, 2009 3:48 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by GrandpaDuck »

Greenblood wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:....... if you look at points allowed per "meaningful" possession.
Points per meaningful possession is the most significant stat in comparing tempo and non-tempo team's defenses. Where are you getting the data though? I would love to find a good site for that data both NCAA and NFL.
The "analytical" site I go to is http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/fei, and then go to the dropdowns (you do have to choose a year). Unfortunately, it'll be awhile before they start putting out the numbers for this season. But you can read about both the FEI and the S&P and see if they have what you're after.
Thanks, I have been going to that site for years and am aware of FEI and S&P, but I have never found Points per Possession, let alone per meaningful possession. Have you found that there?
northbeachsf
Freshman
Posts: 1494
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by northbeachsf »

GrandpaDuck wrote:
Greenblood wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:....... if you look at points allowed per "meaningful" possession.
Points per meaningful possession is the most significant stat in comparing tempo and non-tempo team's defenses. Where are you getting the data though? I would love to find a good site for that data both NCAA and NFL.
The "analytical" site I go to is http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/fei, and then go to the dropdowns (you do have to choose a year). Unfortunately, it'll be awhile before they start putting out the numbers for this season. But you can read about both the FEI and the S&P and see if they have what you're after.
Thanks, I have been going to that site for years and am aware of FEI and S&P, but I have never found Points per Possession, let alone per meaningful possession. Have you found that there?
Check out the DFEI, which is a scoring defense by-possession metric that adjusts for garbage time and field position. Basically, if you are up 5 scores and give up a TD in the 4th quarter with your walk-ons in, your defense does not get penalized for that. Or if you punter $hits the bed and has a 5 yard punt from his own end zone, giving the opponent a 3 yard field to score, it scales that as to not penalize the defense as much as a legit 80 yard drive. Also, I believe it weighted for the strength of your opponent. For example, if Vanderbilt scores on an 80-yard drive, the defense gets penalized more than if Ohio State scores on an 80-yard drive.

Overall, I believe it is about as true of a measure as you can get to evaluate defenses. Oregon has actually been extremely solid over the past 5 seasons "when it matters".

However, this year looks a little different so far. The defense has given up 14 TDs already and probably 12 of those were not "garbage time". There is not a way to get a true measure of where we stand because the DFEI doesn't take into account FCS teams.
northbeachsf
Freshman
Posts: 1494
Joined: Tue Jan 13, 2009 12:54 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by northbeachsf »

Going to add something else here to think about. I keep hearing people say that Utah's defense is great, yet they gave up almost 100 points in the last two games against Oregon. Last year our backs averaged about five and a half yards per carry. That is not "awesome defense".

Why does Utah's "all-world" defense get a pass when they get smoked by a top ranked team, but ours does not?

Sometimes it is difficult to defend teams with great offensive talent. Alabama, Ohio State, FSU, LSU, etc. all have great athletes and good defensive coaches, yet they have all given up 40+ points to good teams over the past few seasons.

I don't take any stock in what happened against the two FCS teams because we knew we could score on every possession if we needed to. The defense actually played well at MSU considering the position it was in. I am holding judgment until I see what happens against Utah. I suspect we will see a much better effort this week.
GoDucksIn09
Senior
Posts: 3086
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 11:15 am

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by GoDucksIn09 »

I guess my main question in this debate about the defense is this... if the defense continues to give up 30 plus points a game and we lose when do the people that are supporting the defense begin saying we need changes. I have no problem in saying that against Michigan State our offense did not do their job. I think a lot on here would concur with that. I guess I just wonder when we get some accountability from the defense. How many times have we heard the same excuses that need to tackle better or the offense scores to fast... yada yada yada.... I have yet to hear Pellum take any responsibility. This is 2 yrs in a row we been having these same issues. I think that speaks for itself.
Greenblood
Senior
Posts: 3466
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:16 pm

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by Greenblood »

GrandpaDuck wrote:
Greenblood wrote:
GrandpaDuck wrote:
THETADUCK wrote:....... if you look at points allowed per "meaningful" possession.
Points per meaningful possession is the most significant stat in comparing tempo and non-tempo team's defenses. Where are you getting the data though? I would love to find a good site for that data both NCAA and NFL.
The "analytical" site I go to is http://www.footballoutsiders.com/stats/fei, and then go to the dropdowns (you do have to choose a year). Unfortunately, it'll be awhile before they start putting out the numbers for this season. But you can read about both the FEI and the S&P and see if they have what you're after.
Thanks, I have been going to that site for years and am aware of FEI and S&P, but I have never found Points per Possession, let alone per meaningful possession. Have you found that there?
I'm happy to let Northbeach lead the way on that stuff, as he seems much more on top of how it works than I am. I'll also mention (which I suspect you're also aware of) the https://www.teamrankings.com/ncf/team-stats/ site, which supplies more than yards and points per game, but also things like yards per point, points per play, yards per play, etc. (the kinds of stats which I suspect are also incorporated into FEI/S&P to some degree), which allows one to see different levels of offensive and defensive "efficiency."
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6495
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by pezsez1 »

if the defense continues to give up 30 plus points a game and we lose when do the people that are supporting the defense begin saying we need changes.
Herein lies the rift that exists between people on each side of this argument.

For people who think in terms of the FEI as opposed to flat, unadjusted stats, overall point totals aren't as important as percentages of possessions that end in points. And yes, we do think in terms of what the defense is doing both when the game is close and when the offense has clearly pulled away (such as when coaches go into prevent mode just to remove the threat of quick scores that might help opponents catch up without eating clock).

When I watch games -- last year's Cal game was a great example -- I also strongly consider whether the defense was given good field position by the offense or special teams. If our kicker shanks a punt, or if we lose the ball deep in our own territory to an INT or fumble, then I don't pull my hair out of the defense gives up a score on a short field. In my opinion, it's not really fair to the defense to judge them as harshly for giving up a 30-yard scoring drive as opposed to an 80-yard scoring drive. I believe offense and defense are symbiotic, and both must do their jobs for each unit to thrive.

And usually, both units do their jobs. Our defense is usually solid in the category of redzone offense and takeaways, and our offense is usually solid in either scoring points or not putting our defense right up against its own endzone.

I'll start getting more upset about the defense when it continually shows that it is failing to do its job. That didn't happen last year; after some problems early in the season (partially because our offense could barely stay on the field with our massive O-line issues), the defense stabilized against UCLA and played solid against just about everyone left except for Cal and Ohio State (and, as I said above, that Cal game is very divisive... I think the D was just average in that game, if you actually look at the context of the game; but if you only look at flat stats, then yeah, it looked bad). And the Ohio State game is another good example of the relationship between offense and defense. Our offense started off good, and so did the defense; but our offense stalled a couple times, and our defense started getting a little winded, then everything seemed to crumble on both sides of the ball.

Anyway...

This is a tough question to answer, especially on this forum, because so many people have already made up their minds that our defense has been bad for a long time... just like I've watched the same games and seen the defense usually doing its job and even being above average. It's all a matter of interpretation, based on what each of us think constitutes a good performance.

I'm a big-time context guy. For me, the end results always matter less than the context. In football, perhaps the more popular mindset is to flip that around, and say end results are all that matter, context be damned (no excuses for anything ever!). Personally, though, I believe that if you worry about context first, then the good end results will follow... and not the other way around.

This is also a tough question to answer because of the inexperience in our secondary. It's very rare to have this much youth in the defensive backfield's two-deep... not just in our program, but in any elite program. As frustrating as this season may turn out to be, I personally take issue with blaming the coaches on guys being young and needing time to develop.

I know I didn't really answer your question, but that's just because the inexperience of this secondary makes this a difficult year for me to pass judgement. I need to see how things unfold.

EDIT: I could just as easily ask, "How many seasons will it take for the defense to do its job and repeatedly keep us in position to win games (and blow other teams out of the water) before people realize our unit is usually pretty good?"

It really is a circular discussion. Different folks measure success according to different metrics, which is why this goes around and around. I personally prefer an analytical approach like the FEI, but not everyone does, which means agreement on this is impossible.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
dthomas=ddixon
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 8832
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:42 pm
Location: McMinnville, Oregon

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Post by dthomas=ddixon »

pezsez1 wrote:But if we get beat more often on long pass plays, CAN we just go out and get it back? We certainly couldn't against MSU. Maybe when Marcus was here, yeah... but against the only good defense we've faced this season, our offense was pretty inept for most of the game. Our running game was especially bad... our yards per carry against the Spartans was just 2.9, and that's definitely not a good sign.

Again, the sky isn't falling, and I think our offense will be fine.... but I don't think it's safe to sleep on explosion plays and figure our offense will just get it back.

This comes back to the issue of inexperience...

What will the vibe on this forum be on Sunday if we do play more press coverage against Utah, and it just results in us getting beat on more deep passes with no real positive results?

This Utah game will be very interesting. I think we'll learn a lot about the Ducks on both sides of the ball.
I answered your question and your response was to ignore it and dive right back into the same tired circular conversation.
Image
Post Reply