UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Moderators: greenyellow, Autzenoise, UOducksTK1

buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by buckmarkduck »

duck58 wrote:
Biggus Duckus wrote:Most white Southerners were not against slavery, least of all Robert E. Lee. I'm not sure where you get your info.

It's hilarious how upset people are getting about this change.
After surrendering, Lee stated," At least we can rejoice that slavery has ended." That can be found in many sources, including newspapers at the time.

Doesn't mean he wanted to free any slaves. He sued his father in law, just so he could keep the slaves.
User avatar
Quietduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 623
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:43 pm

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by Quietduck »

Not quite. Lee was the executor or his father in law estate. He went to court to amend the provisions of the will due to the financial state of the property. You can still say it counts against him but lets be accurate.
buckmarkduck
All-American
Posts: 11020
Joined: Sun Jan 11, 2009 12:22 am
Contact:

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by buckmarkduck »

https://apnews.com/afs:Content:9009420680

CLAIM: Gen. Robert E. Lee, who led the Confederate States Army in the Civil War, “opposed both secession and slavery.” He did not own slaves.

AP’S ASSESSMENT: False. According to historians, not only did Lee own slaves, but he also fought in court to keep working slaves from his father-in-law’s estate. Claims casting Lee as an anti-slavery figure are tied to a false narrative known as the Lost Cause, which says the Confederate experience in the Civil War was not about slavery, but state’s rights.

THE FACTS: As protests following the death of George Floyd lead to a reexamination of historical injustice, there’s been a campaign calling for monuments celebrating the Confederacy to be taken down. False posts emerged on Facebook claiming that Lee “opposed both slavery and secession.” The false post was shared tens of thousands of times".

So I read that wrong the first time. But the point remains, he had slaves, and fought to keep them. Let's not cast any southerner with means, as someone who didn't want to keep slaves. If they hadn't, they would have fought to free the slaves.
User avatar
dd10snoop28
All Pac-12
Posts: 5046
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 12:06 am
GM: New Jersey Nets GM
Location: Portland, Oregon

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by dd10snoop28 »

The motivating factors of the civil war are much more complicated than simply being a slavery issue. Lee was an imperfect man, but cared about his country and fought for what he held to be right (and I'm not talking about slavery since his views on it personally/publicly seem to contradict). We like to simplify issues retrospectively to paint people as fitting on the side of evil or good; republican or democrat; racist or not. All of which are lazy opinions that don't give credence to the historical context of the time. It's not as simple as it seems. Thus, why Lee's statements can seem to be contradictory regarding how he held slavery.
Image
User avatar
Quietduck
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 623
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 11:43 pm

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by Quietduck »

Buck while your conclusion may or may not be right if you read the documents of the time period before the war was won or lost most read in a very interesting way. Slavery was indeed the pivot point but the issue that drove the war to most of the soldiers (the great majority not slaveholders) was the rights of their states to decide the issue for themselves. Their view, right or wrong, was the people of the state had the right to decide whether Slavery was legal or not.
squintsdd
Senior
Posts: 2109
Joined: Mon Jan 12, 2009 12:39 am

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by squintsdd »

Honestly I don't give two shits about the statues so long as history does not get erased. Let the history books and museums state the facts about what it was, and put up more statues of Rocky Balboa
User avatar
pezsez1
All Pac-12
Posts: 6461
Joined: Sat Jan 10, 2009 10:30 pm
Location: RIP CITY

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by pezsez1 »

I think this is a mistake, as it creates a divisive issue where there wasn't one. Now if I say "You getting tickets to the civil war this year?" it will feel as if I'm trying to cause a controversy. I don't care for controversy. I just like feeling like I'm part of a community and enjoy beating Oregon State every single year.
Stevens, not quoting you because I have any real problem with anything you said... agreed with most of what you said and this is just the one thing I wanted to respond to.

I'd urge people to remember that this doesn't really cause controversy with anyone except for aging football fans in Oregon. Most of us are middle-aged or older white guys and we live in a state that's pretty insulated from actual racial issues because of our heavily white population.

I think if we read the tea leaves, then this is a change that makes less sense now than it will in a few years from now. And who knows? Maybe without this change, players speak up and it gives our program a bad name. Isn't it in Mississippi where a star RB said he'd sit out of the state didn't remove the Confederate symbol from its state flag? This may not seem like as big of a deal to a bunch of older white dudes, but to young Black men coming of age in the year 2020, especially with all the other **** they've had thrown at them over the past few years?

I loved the Civil War name and it wasn't even on my radar that this might be changed... but I do think the University is doing the right thing. I don't see this as "being PC" as much as I see this as being smart and staying on the right side of our real target audience -- recruits.

Most people here know that I'm definitely liberal in my politics. But one of my unlikely "heroes" is a guy named Frank Luntz, a longtime GOP linguistics strategist who gave us terms like "death tax" instead of "estate tax" or "energy exploration" instead of "oil drilling" or "climate change" instead of "global warming." I'm fascinated by his ability to find just the right words to shape the entire country's dialogue on monumental issues. His philosophy is "It's not what you say, it's what people hear." Changing the name of the rivalry isn't about us -- and we need to remember that. It's not about what we want to call it. It's about what others hear.
Willie Taggart is a dick.
duck58
Four Star Recruit
Posts: 666
Joined: Tue Feb 10, 2009 7:56 pm

Re: UO-OSU dropping Civil War name

Post by duck58 »

Anatinae wrote:
duck58 wrote:
Biggus Duckus wrote:Most white Southerners were not against slavery, least of all Robert E. Lee. I'm not sure where you get your info.

It's hilarious how upset people are getting about this change.
After surrendering, Lee stated," At least we can rejoice that slavery has ended." That can be found in many sources, including newspapers at the time.
https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2 ... position-/
Do a fact check on politfact and you will find they are not an unbiased source and many of their facts have been shown not to be true. But I regret bringing it up. Back to the the point of the name change. I could care less what they do with the name. The Ducks use to be the Webfoots. Still the same team I root for. As long as we win the game who cares.
Post Reply