Page 1 of 2
My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 4:18 pm
by QuackininBama
Yes, it's perplexing how it appears Cal is dominating recruiting, and Oregon, despite our on the field success isn't necessarily translating to better recruits.
No, I don't think their cheating, and I have no doubt our facilities are far superior, and obviously our win/loss record speaks for itself. What Oregon can't sell to these kids is personal recognition, national awards etc.
These are for the most part, extremely arrogant, selfish, me first players. You put that 4th an 5th star next to their name, you take a kid who's already used to being showered with attention and accolades and stardom in high school and his local community and he starts thinking he's above the system, he is on a different level then the rest of the team, and he wants that affirmation that he's the best, he's the focus of the team.This kind of kid wants to hear his name on ESPN every single week and wants his highlights on at halftime shows.
However, this isn't how Chip Kelly coached teams operate. No one player is more important then another. And unlike the SEC, Chip don't give a flying f&*k if your close to a personal award or a Heisman candidate, your not getting one more minute of playing time then the gameplan requires. Living in the south I can't tell you how many times I watched Auburn with a 20+ point lead at the end of games keep Cam in to punch in 1-2 more scores to pad his stats. It's how they roll down here. For OTHER schools, it's about the final stat line more then just winning games.
Also with the fast paced offense, players on both the offense and defense are regularly rotated to keep then fresh. This provides less opportunity for players to have have impressive statistics to garner national attention. And the fact we blow out at least half of our opponents, most of the 1st team O&D are done for the day by halftime. Again, the stat line won't impress anyone.
My opinion is, if Chip had wanted to, he could have easily got James in a better position for Heisman attention. He cared, I know he did, but James wasn't bigger then the team, so despite the ability Chip had to get James some just STUPID games(maybe 27rushes 275yds 4td's), instead, he rested him and made sure he minimized the chance of injury, thus his stat line just wasn't blowing people away.
Sorry to be long winded, but this is why I think kids gravitate to a Cal or USC. For them, it's about THEM more then the team. Chip will release a kid before he bows to a kids demands for more playing time to pad stats. Just my opinion. Lets Cal have em, in Eugene, it's about the T.E.A.M. And has a fan, I couldn't be more pleased with the results!
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 4:26 pm
by buckmarkduck
We are ranked #13 by scout and rivals, 15 by 247, and still have 5 spots left. Not only are we getting studs in this class, we are getting hard workers. Alex B was going 100% every play in practice this week a the Army game and people noticed.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 4:28 pm
by uostudent
If Chris Petersen becomes Cal's coach, I'll be worried. Fortunately, Tedford sucks. Would much rather see top recruits going to Cal than USC, UW, and Arizona (schools with very good coaching staffs).
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 4:35 pm
by MFRDuckFan
Tedford has been there for 10 years & consistently underachieved. I only found 2 seasons (2004 & 2008) where he got 10 wins. Nothing better than that.
In 2007 when they had Jahvid Best, DeSean Jackson & Justin Forsett, their record was 7-6.
He may have top notch recruits but he doesn't seem to be able to lift the program with them at all. They do get guys into the NFL so maybe that's what their recruits really want. Unfortunately, that doesn't help your college program very much when everyone is out for #1.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 4:50 pm
by mijaha
Well said, and I'll take our coaching staff over Cal's and SC's everyday of the week. Some players either refuse to, or are incapable of operating within a system. It's a me first attitude. Some past Ducks who come to mind are Onterrio Smith, Derrick Jones, and Cliff Harris. They would rather read their press clippings than accept coaching and the discipline it takes to make a winning TEAM. As has been said over and over again here, where has the talent gotten Cal football. For every Aaron Rodgers out there, and if he's such a great QB which he is, why didn't Cal win it all(10-1 in 2004 but lost Bowl game) while he was there, there's a DeSean Jackson who is constantly running afoul with the league. So my take is, Chip is recruiting players who are willing to be coached, and fit within his system. Be it a non-ranked player to a five star athlete. In Chip I trust
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 5:38 pm
by maxduck
Cal has a good story to tell and good visual progress in facilities to sell recruits. Take a look.
http://www.californiagoldenblogs.com/20 ... art-3-of-3
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 5:43 pm
by pezsez1
Kind of sucks that we seem to lose so many recruits to Cal, but at the same time, we always get the job done come signing day. I absolutely love our Ducks! I think Cal just beats us on some of the recruits we happen to know about. Obviously, though, we get the right people for our system, whereas Cal has (and will) continue to flounder.
In other words, who cares about recruits who go to Cal? At the end of the day, we'll still win the game.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 5:50 pm
by Duck07
QuackininBama wrote:Yes, it's perplexing how it appears Cal is dominating recruiting, and Oregon, despite our on the field success isn't necessarily translating to better recruits.
No, I don't think their cheating, and I have no doubt our facilities are far superior, and obviously our win/loss record speaks for itself. What Oregon can't sell to these kids is personal recognition, national awards etc.
These are for the most part, extremely arrogant, selfish, me first players.
Also with the fast paced offense, players on both the offense and defense are regularly rotated to keep then fresh. This provides less opportunity for players to have have impressive statistics to garner national attention. And the fact we blow out at least half of our opponents, most of the 1st team O&D are done for the day by halftime. Again, the stat line won't impress anyone.
My opinion is, if Chip had wanted to, he could have easily got James in a better position for Heisman attention. He cared, I know he did, but James wasn't bigger then the team, so despite the ability Chip had to get James some just STUPID games(maybe 27rushes 275yds 4td's), instead, he rested him and made sure he minimized the chance of injury, thus his stat line just wasn't blowing people away.
Sorry to be long winded, but this is why I think kids gravitate to a Cal or USC. For them, it's about THEM more then the team. Chip will release a kid before he bows to a kids demands for more playing time to pad stats. Just my opinion. Lets Cal have em, in Eugene, it's about the T.E.A.M. And has a fan, I couldn't be more pleased with the results!
Oh man. Go take a quick toke bud, it's gonna be alright
Now, few things:
-You don't want to know what Cal's recruiting would look like if they had our facilities. Nick Saban would make inquiries about Cal if they had our facilities. An accurate asssesment of Cal's facilities is poor compared to the "big" schools.
-I wouldn't be too harsh in making personal judgements of 17 year old kids, some of whom are simply doing this for the attention that WE give them for it.
-Um, perhaps you forgot that whole dislocated elbow thing or maybe you just thought he wore that bulky brace because it looked cool?

Seriously though, LMJ wasn't going to beat the undefeated dual-threat QB from the SEC who led his team, not with Luck stealing LMJ's votes too. That said, he did win the Doak and was an unanimous AA. This year, had he not injured himself, would have rushed for another 200 yards against Colorado and probably had over 1000 yards rushing in 4 games alone. So, if he doesn't get injured and we don't lose to USC, LMJ probably does win the Heisman as he would have easily had over 2000 rushing yards and quite a few more TDs too. The injury took him out of it right when he was making a move towards front-runner status.
Lastly, this happen every year. If its not Cal poaching an "unheard of" number of recruits (or at a position) its USC. If its not USC its UCLA. If its not UCLA its some other school with
good recruiters who close on recruits. The only thing I'm truly concerned with in regards to recruiting is that we continue to rise in the "star rankings" of our commitments while also focusing on getting the right players. Perhaps that means we don't make the top 10 (or ever grab a #1 class) but as we all know, it won't preclude us from kicking ass. As Cassius Clay once said "Float like a butterfly, sting like a bee; your hands can't hit, what your eyes can't see." We're moving past ludicrous speed and it won't matter much who Cal recruits under Tedford.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 6:08 pm
by Boom
We will never consistently out recruit the Californian schools (except Standford due to their academic standards)
Like it or not.. there will always be more kids that would prefer to stay in state than to leave.
USC's scholarship restrictions means that there are more kids for Cal & UCLA to choose from. UCLA has a new head coach and a late start in the recruiting this year.
Tedford better enjoy it while it lasts.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 6:16 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
^What boom & duck07 said. There's a ton of overreaction gong on over Cal's class. It's one recruiting class, we've out recruited them every other year. And hey, maybe they're just getting started & will sustain this for a few years. But at some point they will have to have the on field results, their pitch is all about the future of Cal. If they don't do something with it will ring hollow after awhile.
It wasnt that long ago that Cal was loaded with nfl talent & stil didnt really do much with it. It took them having Aaron freaking Rodgers to have a good season. As long as Tedford is there I don't see them ever breaking through. They will be a tough out & will probably beat us every once in awhile but that is all. We'll keep going to BCS games.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 7:25 pm
by uostudent
dthomas=ddixon wrote:^What boom & duck07 said. There's a ton of overreaction gong on over Cal's class. It's one recruiting class, we've out recruited them every other year. And hey, maybe they're just getting started & will sustain this for a few years. But at some point they will have to have the on field results, their pitch is all about the future of Cal. If they don't do something with it will ring hollow after awhile.
It wasnt that long ago that Cal was loaded with nfl talent & stil didnt really do much with it. It took them having Aaron freaking Rodgers to have a good season. As long as Tedford is there I don't see them ever breaking through. They will be a tough out & will probably beat us every once in awhile but that is all. We'll keep going to BCS games.
Agree, there's a reason why the coaches have been recruiting Arizona and Texas so much. It's difficult to pull kids away from Southern California who have offers from USC and UCLA (even though UCLA sucks, the location is awesome).
In terms of weather, it's actually an advantage when recruiting kids from Texas and Arizona. A lot of the Arizona kids want to escape the heat and the Texas kids hate the humidity.
This year, two of Oregon's best recruits are from Ohio (Stanford and Brown). One of the biggest impact recruits from last year's class was Jake Fisher (from Michigan). Oregon will continue to recruit kids from the Midwest who show a genuine interest in playing in Eugene.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 8:15 pm
by lukeyrid13
Honestly I don't mind losing kids to USC but I do mind with Cal. I understand why kids go to USC. It kinda sucks having to hear about how awesome USC is but we can't just cover our eyes and ears and think that USC is some slouch. When Seymour commit to the Trojans today I completely understood why he wanted to. When all the other guys committed to Cal I was just left wondering why exactly
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 8:37 pm
by Bigducker
lukeyrid13 wrote:Honestly I don't mind losing kids to USC but I do mind with Cal. I understand why kids go to USC. It kinda sucks having to hear about how awesome USC is but we can't just cover our eyes and ears and think that USC is some slouch. When Seymour commit to the Trojans today I completely understood why he wanted to. When all the other guys committed to Cal I was just left wondering why exactly
One name... Tosh Lupoi The guy can flat out recruit ! Without him they'd only be getting average recruiting classes. They better count their lucky stars he doesn't get offered a better gig somewhere else soon.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 9:01 pm
by MacDuck
Bigducker wrote:lukeyrid13 wrote:Honestly I don't mind losing kids to USC but I do mind with Cal. I understand why kids go to USC. It kinda sucks having to hear about how awesome USC is but we can't just cover our eyes and ears and think that USC is some slouch. When Seymour commit to the Trojans today I completely understood why he wanted to. When all the other guys committed to Cal I was just left wondering why exactly
One name... Tosh Lupoi The guy can flat out recruit ! Without him they'd only be getting average recruiting classes. They better count their lucky stars he doesn't get offered a better gig somewhere else soon.
My guess is Lupoi has been told he's in line for their DC job if Pendergast ever goes. They know they have to do everything in their power to keep him in Berkeley. The interesting thing will be how long will it take before some big name school offers Tosh their DC job primarily to land him as a recruiter. Would Cal drop Clancy P to keep Tosh in town. I just can't see his status staying the same much longer.
Re: My take on the Cal recruitment
Posted: Sat Jan 07, 2012 9:45 pm
by buckmarkduck
Let me ask you guys. If you had had a choice to go to UO or any other school to play football what would your choice had been? Unfortunately Oregon just doesn't have 4-5* recruits everywhere in the state. A lot of these kids are just like Oregon kids, they grow up dreaming of playing for Cal or SC, and our coaches are going against that.