Page 1 of 3
2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:05 am
by vagusnerve
So it appears that after the excitement of the past couple of weeks, the Ducks are left with the same commitments they had before the new year. All those Texas guys and Cal commits that were possibilities are gone... and Kelly and staff don't really seem to be in it for their top targets at WR, LB, DB, OL and DL.
Now we're seeing offers to guys like Bryan Harper and possibly other guys who have talent and may fare well in the Pac12, but they're obviously not at the top of the coaches' board.
The Ducks have a good solid class with some outstanding guys. But there are no headliners like a Cliff Harris, DeAnthony Thomas, or Curtis White/Lache Seastrunk.
I kind of see this class as finishing out with some guys that are lower on the coaches' board. Guys who get offered at the last minute... Bryan Harper is a guy like that, along with a guy I saw yesterday (RB Robert Lewis? can't remember)... guys with offers from schools like San Diego State and such. I saw OL Poutasi was in the mix again and he is highly rated buy we'll see.
I just don't see any of the last minute surprises this year where the coaches get quality players at the last minute. I hope I'm wrong.
Either way, this class has some solid talent and will contribute on the field without a doubt. I'm starting to wonder, though, if the core of guys that got us here today (LMJ, KM, DT, Harris, Boyett, Clay) is more of an anomaly... I think once those guys graduate we may not see replacements that are nearly as good, and we may have been taking for granted that the coaches recruited some really talented players that we haven't appreciated enough.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:11 am
by jimmy12
Dude-- go outside. Get out of that dark depressing room.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:12 am
by Phenom
vagusnerve wrote:Either way, this class has some solid talent and will contribute on the field without a doubt. I'm starting to wonder, though, if the core of guys that got us here today (LMJ, KM, DT, Harris, Boyett, Clay) is more of an anomaly... I think once those guys graduate we may not see replacements that are nearly as good, and we may have been taking for granted that the coaches recruited some really talented players that we haven't appreciated enough.
Lol how can you say that? We're getting more and more talented every year. That doesn't mean that we're going to automatically replace the production of those guys, but at this point in our program we don't rebuild, we reload.
You have absolutely no basis for what you're saying.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:14 am
by ncduck
I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.
This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.
We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.
However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:14 am
by alabamaduck
vagusnerve wrote:
But there are no headliners like a Cliff Harris, DeAnthony Thomas, or Curtis White/Lache Seastrunk.
I see your point but think it's funny that the examples you give other than DAT are a guy who has been kicked out of school after multiple suspensions, one who's never seen the field due to injury and one who transferred without playing a down.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:50 am
by duckfan22
rivals has this class at #11 in the whole country. I'd say the coaches are
doing very well. They go after kids that fit their system. Kids that fit in
a team chemistry. They also recruit for a certain need on the team. Remember
this is a young team and deep. Some just don't get it.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:54 am
by karlhungis
But there are no headliners like a Cliff Harris, DeAnthony Thomas, or Curtis White/Lache Seastrunk.
Cliff Harris.... a 4* CB that played for 1 year. He wasn't a headliner and we have commitments from several 4* players on D already.
DAT - A freak, last minute surprise. We aren't likely to land a DAT every year, or even every decade for that matter. That being said, it isn't the last minute yet. If you posted this same thing last year at this time, we weren't in the running for DAT either.
Seastrunk..... 5* RB that didn't do anything and ended up transferring. Wasn't he also a bit of a last minute surprise as well? We have a commitment from the top RB on the west coast. We also have a nice stable of RB's already on the roster.
You are jumping the gun.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:55 am
by karlhungis
duckfan22 wrote:rivals has this class at #11 in the whole country. I'd say the coaches are
doing very well. They go after kids that fit their system. Kids that fit in
a team chemistry. They also recruit for a certain need on the team. Remember
this is a young team and deep. Some just don't get it.
I see us listed at 17 on rivals.
http://footballrecruiting.rivals.com/
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 11:58 am
by brich75
duckfan22 wrote:rivals has this class at #11 in the whole country. I'd say the coaches are
doing very well. They go after kids that fit their system. Kids that fit in
a team chemistry. They also recruit for a certain need on the team. Remember
this is a young team and deep. Some just don't get it.
And scout has us at 10, This is a good class. Instead of finishing with the big bang we did it through the entire recruiting year. That's what good schools do. You dont see the Texas, USC, and Florida's of college football make their class in the last days. They get good or great players through the entire process. That's what we did.
We have a great class right now, and it's not over. Anything we get from here on out is icing on a great cake!
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 12:03 pm
by brich75
Oh and before anyone goes and jumps off a bridge. We happen to get a commitment from a 5 star running back this year by the name of Thomas Tyner. Though he wont count until next years class. Pretty solid start!
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 12:04 pm
by duckfan22
oops i was thinking rivals when it was actually scout i meant. My bad carry on..
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 12:07 pm
by UOducksTK1
alabamaduck wrote:vagusnerve wrote:
But there are no headliners like a Cliff Harris, DeAnthony Thomas, or Curtis White/Lache Seastrunk.
I see your point but think it's funny that the examples you give other than DAT are a guy who has been kicked out of school after multiple suspensions, one who's never seen the field due to injury and one who transferred without playing a down.
+1, all these 5 star guys are either boom or bust. Lots of these guys have baggage with them.
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 12:18 pm
by squintsdd
Cool story bro
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 12:46 pm
by mijaha
ncduck wrote:I don't think it's fair to the guys on our roster and the guys who are in this class to suggest we did well the past few years due to an anomaly.
This class includes an elite 11 qb (JR), one of the best rbs on the west coast (Marshall), and the killer B's in Bafaro, Bair, Balducci, Buckner, Baylis, and Brown.
We have a lot of talent in this class, just like the '07 class had a lot of talent.
However, I'm a little surprised at the fact that we have only one OL that is known to have committed at this point, but this is a really good class.
How did we do with our offensive line recruits last year...i believe we had one of the best classes in the country??
In Chip I trust
Re: 2012 Recruiting
Posted: Wed Jan 18, 2012 1:08 pm
by headshottzzzz
This is ridiculous, and sounds like whining.