Page 1 of 1

How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:10 pm
by NastyNora
I think we got an excellent class this year. I think we missed filling some potential needs by not using a scouting service for the first time in years. When Kelly was asked why he didn't use a scouting service this year, he said, "I'm not going down that road again".

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:13 pm
by lukeyrid13
You don't need a scouting service to know that guys like: Shaq, Murphy, Thomas Johnson etc are all good. They just liked other schools better

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:16 pm
by NastyNora
lukeyrid13 wrote:You don't need a scouting service to know that guys like: Shaq, Murphy, Thomas Johnson etc are all good. They just liked other schools better

Umm, yeah. A scouting service is for the players that aren't as well known, not for the one's that everyone knows about. That's kind of the point.

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:17 pm
by QuackininBama
Good response by Chip. Lesson learned, lets move on.

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:19 pm
by lukeyrid13
NastyNora wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:You don't need a scouting service to know that guys like: Shaq, Murphy, Thomas Johnson etc are all good. They just liked other schools better

Umm, yeah. A scouting service is for the players that aren't as well known, not for the one's that everyone knows about. That's kind of the point.
and what hidden gems did we miss on? We got 10 4 star guys and barely missed on about 4-5 others. Do we really need the hidden 2 star guys anymore?

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:37 pm
by ncduck
It's impossible to know what oregon missed out on by not using one of those services. Could have missed out on a huge star. Could have missed out on a kid with loads of potential that might not have ever seen the field. We may seen a three star that would have fit perfectly at some position.

Truly unknowable.

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 5:48 pm
by roleplay3r1
lukeyrid13 wrote:
NastyNora wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:You don't need a scouting service to know that guys like: Shaq, Murphy, Thomas Johnson etc are all good. They just liked other schools better

Umm, yeah. A scouting service is for the players that aren't as well known, not for the one's that everyone knows about. That's kind of the point.
and what hidden gems did we miss on? We got 10 4 star guys and barely missed on about 4-5 others. Do we really need the hidden 2 star guys anymore?
Not necessarily. However, under the radar recruits will(and should) continue to be a large part of Oregon's continued NCAAF success. That doesn't mean they need to pick out a handful of 2 star recruits every year. But why would you want to abandon some of what has made this program so successful as of late?

If many of the top programs in the country are ignoring Reggie Daniels or Stetzon Bair, etc. and CK and the staff thinks they can play a huge role in the future of the team, why not add them to the mix? Just because a guy has 2 or 3 stars next to his name doesn't mean he's necessarily less athletic, or less intelligent than a 4 or 5 star. Guys can earn stars or lose out on them for any number of reasons. Bair played one year of CC after being a higher rated recruit a few years ago coming out of HS. Just because he's a 2 star doesn't mean he doesn't have talent. I would expect to look back on this class in 3-4 years and see at least of couple of our 4 stars not working out and either battling injuries, getting buried on the depth chart, transferring, etc. And almost every year we see a huge contributor to the team emerge after being an under the radar recruit out of HS. How many of us jumped up and down after John Boyett committed to Oregon a few years ago? He's going to be drafted next year and play football for a living.

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 6:15 pm
by uodux1212
roleplay3r1 wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:
NastyNora wrote:
lukeyrid13 wrote:You don't need a scouting service to know that guys like: Shaq, Murphy, Thomas Johnson etc are all good. They just liked other schools better

Umm, yeah. A scouting service is for the players that aren't as well known, not for the one's that everyone knows about. That's kind of the point.
and what hidden gems did we miss on? We got 10 4 star guys and barely missed on about 4-5 others. Do we really need the hidden 2 star guys anymore?
Not necessarily. However, under the radar recruits will(and should) continue to be a large part of Oregon's continued NCAAF success. That doesn't mean they need to pick out a handful of 2 star recruits every year. But why would you want to abandon some of what has made this program so successful as of late?

If many of the top programs in the country are ignoring Reggie Daniels or Stetzon Bair, etc. and CK and the staff thinks they can play a huge role in the future of the team, why not add them to the mix? Just because a guy has 2 or 3 stars next to his name doesn't mean he's necessarily less athletic, or less intelligent than a 4 or 5 star. Guys can earn stars or lose out on them for any number of reasons. Bair played one year of CC after being a higher rated recruit a few years ago coming out of HS. Just because he's a 2 star doesn't mean he doesn't have talent. I would expect to look back on this class in 3-4 years and see at least of couple of our 4 stars not working out and either battling injuries, getting buried on the depth chart, transferring, etc. And almost every year we see a huge contributor to the team emerge after being an under the radar recruit out of HS. How many of us jumped up and down after John Boyett committed to Oregon a few years ago? He's going to be drafted next year and play football for a living.
Bellotti recently said that 65-70% is an average number of kids/recruits that stick it out for the 4 expected years (including early entrees to nfl draft). Interesting.

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 6:28 pm
by Duck07
I don't think the investigation really hurt us, and if it did, I guess it serves us right for being naive in the past by using Lyles/Flenory. We are in a truly gray area for the ncaa to rule on because they are trying to create new rules to prevent this type of situation again, but they can't hammer us for violating a rule that didn't exist at the time. In essence, this new rule might end up being referred to as the Oregon Rule but we'll be the ones to get off easy. I also believe this is why its taking so long is because they are going to release their conclusion and the new rules at the same time.

The NCAA really wants to keep these people like Brian Butler, Willie Lyles et al away from the kids and schools because only they are supposed to be making $ off the kids and schools. biebers, poodles, shorthorns and spoiled children will all be upset by the fact that we'll get something light for violating the spirit of the rules (or whatever bs reason they used with our comic books, plane rides etc (well, the plane thing was a legitimate gripe)) but that we won't get as hurt as we would have had the new rules been in place.

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 7:03 pm
by buckmarkduck
Who said we didn't use a service?

Re: How the NCAA investigation really hurt us

Posted: Wed Feb 01, 2012 7:10 pm
by greenyellow
buckmarkduck wrote:Who said we didn't use a service?
Chip was asked during his press conference today about it. Said just a video service, not a scouting service.