Page 1 of 2

Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:04 am
by bigfootlebowski
I have found in the past i have been disappointed with our recruiting classes, say back in the MB era...and this class isnt going to be ranked in the top 5 this year anyway, top 20 but not top 10 (well see where it is when they rerank it 4 years from now, oh wait the worlds ending this year, maybe thats why chip didnt take the job). It seems like we got a guy we wanted at most positions including the punter, BA is perfect for the TZR position, BM looks like hell be a fanatastic RB, 2 QBs that fit our mold, the New Tall Firs will hold down the defensive line, and so on...Seems to me for the CK system we got we needed and wanted, oh sure a few more of those 5* defensive tackles would have been nice, but i think from top to bottom i am very happy with the results, the coaches got the athletes they need, now lets just hope most em of em make it to playing in games.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:15 am
by Duck07
bigfootlebowski wrote:I have found in the past i have been disappointed with our recruiting classes, say back in the MB era...and this class isnt going to be ranked in the top 5 this year anyway, top 20 but not top 10 (well see where it is when they rerank it 4 years from now, oh wait the worlds ending this year, maybe thats why chip didnt take the job). It seems like we got a guy we wanted at most positions including the punter, BA is perfect for the TZR position, BM looks like hell be a fanatastic RB, 2 QBs that fit our mold, the New Tall Firs will hold down the defensive line, and so on...Seems to me for the CK system we got we needed and wanted, oh sure a few more of those 5* defensive tackles would have been nice, but i think from top to bottom i am very happy with the results, the coaches got the athletes they need, now lets just hope most em of em make it to playing in games.
Balducci in 2 years imo.

As Chip said about this class to Jenn Brown: "It's a good one...Actually, it's stupendous"

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:30 am
by gogreen55
The only complete failure (can't really blame the coaches for Castro/Cottrell leaving them high and dry) was the Ducks inability to land a single high school offensive lineman, in a year of extremely deep offensive line talent on the West Coast. They struck out on the highest rated guys, and even struck out on some guys that weren't all that highly rated. I am shocked and baffled to be honest. Greatwood had developed a bit of a reputation as being one of the Ducks better recruiters. There should never, ever be a year that not a single high school offensive lineman is signed. Period.

Granted, this isn't the end of the world. The Ducks had a great offensive line haul in the previous class, and can hopefully load up on more next class. Regardless, for the sake of balancing the classes and getting guys immersed in the system, it would have been much better to land a couple offensive linemen in this class and only have to sign 3 in the next class, rather than now having to sign 4-5 next class to make up for this failure.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:54 am
by neezy3
Stole this from duck territory but it will give you and idea of our numbers and what we need to look at next year.

http://oregon.247sports.com/Board/45/Sc ... -7479253/1

As recruiting has evolved to a year-round process, signing day signals the start of the new cycle as much as the close of the last one. To start of 2013, I figured I'd take a look at the scholarship depth chart and determine just how many scholarships we'll have available for the 2013 class. With another very young team again in 2012, the 2013 class will likely be even smaller than this past year.

The breakdown below is the total scholarships used by position; total seniors in ():
Offense - 38 total scholarships
WR - 11 (1)
QB - 4
RB - 4 (1)
TE - 5
OL - 14 (4)

Defense - 39 total scholarships
DL - 15 (2)
LB - 10 (2)
DB - 15 (1)

Specialists - 5
K - 2 (1)
P - 2 (1)
LS - 1

This comes to 82 total scholarships used; not including the possible Julian brooks addition, which would take it to 83. Assuming his addition we will be going into the season with 2 available scholarships. Add that to 13 departing seniors and our current available scholarship total for next year's class stands at 15.

Naturally there will be some attrition, but considering how much of our depth chart actually contributes I'd say that our eventual class size for next season will likely be <20.

Now start with those 2013 wish lists...Go Ducks!

Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:26 pm
by Mcbronsh
Any high school OL who thinks he's good enough to play right away wasn't going to sign with us this year because he'd be stuck behind 2-3 classes of solid OL recruits already competing for starting spots. We got Kyle long, who can start next year so we got everything we wanted out of OL in this class, not to mention that by us getting long and not USC, coupled with kalil declaring for the draft and scolly suspensions it's a triple whammy in our favor. Same thing with AA.

The talk of how we need a run stuffing dt is mostly bogus as well. We need lb's who can play violent in the hole and we have that right now. Our 3-4 calls for dl to penetrate and lb's to fill. It's a hybrid scheme and buckner, bair, cc and aa are going to be terrors.

But if you want our recruiting classes to look like Stanford, USC and Alabama then you'll always be disappointed and you don't understand what chip is looking for.

This is an amazing class. Wait till you see the finished product. It's lethal across the board. We got OUR guys. Let the uw, Stanford and USC people pat themselves on the back, but know that when we put up 70 points on Alabama in the coming years, when chip does to the perception of sec supremacy what he did to Pete Carroll and USC on fright night it will finally sink in that we got a top 5 class this year.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:32 pm
by MFRDuckFan
Mcbronsh wrote:Any high school OL who thinks he's good enough to play right away wasn't going to sign with us this year because he'd be stuck behind 2-3 classes of solid OL recruits already competing for starting spots. We got Kyle long, who can start next year so we got everything we wanted out of OL in this class, not to mention that by us getting long and not USC, coupled with kalil declaring for the draft and scolly suspensions it's a triple whammy in our favor. Same thing with AA.

The talk of how we need a run stuffing dt is mostly bogus as well. We need lb's who can play violent in the hole and we have that right now. Our 3-4 calls for dl to penetrate and lb's to fill. It's a hybrid scheme and buckner, bair, cc and aa are going to be terrors.

But if you want our recruiting classes to look like Stanford, USC and Alabama then you'll always be disappointed and you don't understand what chip is looking for.

This is an amazing class. Wait till you see the finished product. It's lethal across the board. We got OUR guys. Let the uw, Stanford and USC people pat themselves on the back, but know that when we put up 70 points on Alabama in the coming years, when chip does to the perception of sec supremacy what he did to Pete Carroll and USC on fright night it will finally sink in that we got a top 5 class this year.
+1000

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 6:34 pm
by buckmarkduck
Balducci and Armstead will both end up as DT sometime at UO. Armstead is already over 290, at the very least he will move between the two spots.

Oh and before this class graduates in 4-5 years, Carringer and Daniels will be stars at DE. They are the Barners of this class. 4 years ago everyone talked about Chris Harper, but it's little know 3* RB KB who has turned into a star.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Thu Feb 02, 2012 9:14 pm
by canaduck
I loved Chip's comments about Carriger - it got me really excited about this recruit. Him and Daniels are the two guys I really want to see, because the recruiting sites make it seem like we're the only schools in the country that even had these guys on our radar.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 12:16 am
by uostudent
Mcbronsh wrote:Any high school OL who thinks he's good enough to play right away wasn't going to sign with us this year because he'd be stuck behind 2-3 classes of solid OL recruits already competing for starting spots. We got Kyle long, who can start next year so we got everything we wanted out of OL in this class, not to mention that by us getting long and not USC, coupled with kalil declaring for the draft and scolly suspensions it's a triple whammy in our favor. Same thing with AA.

The talk of how we need a run stuffing dt is mostly bogus as well. We need lb's who can play violent in the hole and we have that right now. Our 3-4 calls for dl to penetrate and lb's to fill. It's a hybrid scheme and buckner, bair, cc and aa are going to be terrors.

But if you want our recruiting classes to look like Stanford, USC and Alabama then you'll always be disappointed and you don't understand what chip is looking for.

This is an amazing class. Wait till you see the finished product. It's lethal across the board. We got OUR guys. Let the uw, Stanford and USC people pat themselves on the back, but know that when we put up 70 points on Alabama in the coming years, when chip does to the perception of sec supremacy what he did to Pete Carroll and USC on fright night it will finally sink in that we got a top 5 class this year.
This. Oregon is going to need to load up on linebackers in 2013. Losing Bryce Cottrell definitely hurt.

Anthony Wallace looked impressive. Rodney Hardrick obviously has some talent. Cassell, and Coleman have good speed, but really need to bulk up. Garrick is a kind of a mystery. Looks like he's put on a lot of weight, which is nice.

MLB is huge in the 3-4. Overall, 2012 was a pretty weak MLB class and there weren't many good ones from the West Coast. Missing out on Ryan McDaniel was disappointing. He's going to be a stud for the huskies.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 2:33 am
by wheaton4prez
Last year someone had put together a web page with all of our players organized by position, with star rankings. Was a nice tool to see our depth by position. Anyone have the link or know if there's a new version?

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 7:19 am
by buckmarkduck
I don't think UO missed out on him student since we didn't offer him.

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 7:47 am
by gogreen55
Mcbronsh wrote:We got Kyle long, who can start next year so we got everything we wanted out of OL in this class...
Huh? While I appreciated your attempt to be positive despite the reality of the situation, the above quote is categorically false. Did you think the coaches were just offering high school offensive linemen and bringing them in for visits for the fun of it? Obviously, they were hoping to sign at least one, or probably more, of them. Watch the extended version of Chip Kelly's signing day press conference. He himself specifically says he wished the Ducks could have signed more at offensive line and linebacker.

Overall, there is a lot to be excited about with this class, but there is really no way to spin the fact that offensive line recruiting specifically was an abject failure this go around. Excuses for it ring hollow as well. If the Ducks, or any other top programs in the country, could only land recruits that see an easy path to starting as a true freshman, their recruiting classes would be virtually nonexistent at every position. It isn't like the Ducks were only offering top guys that would even be of the mindset to come in and start as true freshman either. I realize that things don't always go according to plan with recruiting, but that doesn't make it any less of a failure.

Anyway, not trying to be a NegaDuck, just keeping it real. As I said before, this isn't a doomsday scenario. The Ducks can mask this failure to a certain degree in the next recruiting class, hopefully.
Mcbronsh wrote:Let the uw, Stanford and USC people pat themselves on the back, but know that when we put up 70 points on Alabama in the coming years, when chip does to the perception of sec supremacy what he did to Pete Carroll and USC on fright night it will finally sink in that we got a top 5 class this year.
Forgive me if I don't hold my breath waiting for the Ducks to score 70 points against Alabama at any point during my lifetime. :-)

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Fri Feb 03, 2012 8:34 am
by UofO8
Mcbronsh wrote:
but know that when we put up 70 points on Alabama
Hahaha. This is a joke, right?

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Sat Feb 04, 2012 11:36 am
by bigfootlebowski
UofO8 wrote:
Mcbronsh wrote:
but know that when we put up 70 points on Alabama
Hahaha. This is a joke, right?

maybe he was referring to the cumulative total after the next three BCS championship games we play in against alabama ;)

Re: Is it just me?

Posted: Sat Feb 04, 2012 11:44 am
by Duck07
[quote="bigfootlebowski"][/quote]
Just saw that Jackie Treehorn passed. Sad times for Malibu...