Page 1 of 2

TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 11:46 am
by Braveheart
http://www.theringer.com/Article/News/1 ... k-Rankings

We aren't finished with the database, and the rankings will change/update every here and there. Also, I had no part in the J-Stew/Tyner comparison. :lol: Good number of you guys are up on your stuff, so I'd like to hear your opinions.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 3:12 pm
by hines
size wise, no RB compares to Snoop on that list. Snoop was 5-10 220 out of HS. The only real comparison is that Snoop and Tyner are ranked roughly the same in HS.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 3:44 pm
by Braveheart
hines wrote:size wise, no RB compares to Snoop on that list. Snoop was 5-10 220 out of HS. The only real comparison is that Snoop and Tyner are ranked roughly the same in HS.
You know what, I agree with you there. Who would you compare to Tyner?

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 5:53 pm
by hines
Braveheart wrote:
hines wrote:size wise, no RB compares to Snoop on that list. Snoop was 5-10 220 out of HS. The only real comparison is that Snoop and Tyner are ranked roughly the same in HS.
You know what, I agree with you there. Who would you compare to Tyner?
i don't know. i've seen very little of him on video so i don't have any type of comparison. our last tall and sorta lean rb was droughns (and MoMo). LGB was taller and heavier. most our RB's are in the 5-9ish 200lb category. tra was bigger but he's gone. i'm trying to stick w/ starters, not back-ups

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 6:25 pm
by Braveheart
hines wrote:
Braveheart wrote:
hines wrote:size wise, no RB compares to Snoop on that list. Snoop was 5-10 220 out of HS. The only real comparison is that Snoop and Tyner are ranked roughly the same in HS.
You know what, I agree with you there. Who would you compare to Tyner?
i don't know. i've seen very little of him on video so i don't have any type of comparison. our last tall and sorta lean rb was droughns (and MoMo). LGB was taller and heavier. most our RB's are in the 5-9ish 200lb category. tra was bigger but he's gone. i'm trying to stick w/ starters, not back-ups
It doesn't have to be a UO back, just somebody in the NFL that you think compares favorably to Tyner. Even though he'll run track at UO, you have to expect him to get in the 220+ range, right? He's already 210+ from what I understand, and once he get's in a college strength and conditioning program he'll eventually put more onto his frame. It's also hard to gauge how fast he really is on the field. While he has elite speed on the track, it doesn't look like all of his speed is translates when the pads are on.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 6:29 pm
by Pontius
Braveheart wrote:
hines wrote:
Braveheart wrote:
hines wrote:size wise, no RB compares to Snoop on that list. Snoop was 5-10 220 out of HS. The only real comparison is that Snoop and Tyner are ranked roughly the same in HS.
You know what, I agree with you there. Who would you compare to Tyner?
i don't know. i've seen very little of him on video so i don't have any type of comparison. our last tall and sorta lean rb was droughns (and MoMo). LGB was taller and heavier. most our RB's are in the 5-9ish 200lb category. tra was bigger but he's gone. i'm trying to stick w/ starters, not back-ups
It doesn't have to be a UO back, just somebody in the NFL that you think compares favorably to Tyner. Even though he'll run track at UO, you have to expect him to get in the 220+ range, right? He's already 210+ from what I understand, and once he get's in a college strength and conditioning program he'll eventually put more onto his frame. It's also hard to gauge how fast he really is on the field. While he has elite speed on the track, it doesn't look like all of his speed is translates when the pads are on.

Michael Bennett against Oregon in the year 2000.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 6:39 pm
by gogreen55
Braveheart wrote:It doesn't have to be a UO back, just somebody in the NFL that you think compares favorably to Tyner.
Adrian Peterson.

Not that it is likely that Tyner will become as good as Peterson, but both are tallish running backs that were/are a freakish combination of size and speed coming out of high school.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 8:25 pm
by Braveheart
gogreen55 wrote:
Braveheart wrote:It doesn't have to be a UO back, just somebody in the NFL that you think compares favorably to Tyner.
Adrian Peterson.

Not that it is likely that Tyner will become as good as Peterson, but both are tallish running backs that were/are a freakish combination of size and speed coming out of high school.
I dunno, AD wasn't as thick as Tyner is now, and he was much more agile, elusive and powerful. Look at AD's HS highlights, and look at Tyner's.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 8:29 pm
by hines
I thought of AD too but I didn't list him because he's so much bigger than Tyner. For those who don't recall, Adrian lined up about 8 yards behind the line of scrimmage and was at full speed by the time he hit the line. Never seen that done since.

For Your Consideration, I offer....

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 9:47 pm
by kahaste
......Maurice Jones-Drew.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 9:59 pm
by Braveheart
hines wrote:I thought of AD too but I didn't list him because he's so much bigger than Tyner. For those who don't recall, Adrian lined up about 8 yards behind the line of scrimmage and was at full speed by the time he hit the line. Never seen that done since.
Do you know Tyner's actual height and weight? If he's really 6'0" 210+ like some say, then he's not really far off from Peterson. His running style is different than AD's, so I guess that's where the comparisons stop. As for the list, how did ya'll feel about the list? Anybody you feel should be higher, anybody that should be lower, somebody you think should've been on the list, somebody who shouldn't be on the list, etc...

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Sun Apr 08, 2012 10:31 pm
by hines
huh, i always thought AD was 6-2 230 or so. he's actually 6-1 217 which is kinda stunning to me. Maybe it's because his thigh pads are so damn big that it made me think he's physically bigger. my bad. http://www.nfl.com/player/adrianpeterso ... 64/profile

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Mon Apr 09, 2012 7:07 am
by gogreen55
Braveheart wrote:I dunno, AD wasn't as thick as Tyner is now, and he was much more agile, elusive and powerful. Look at AD's HS highlights, and look at Tyner's.
Peterson was listed at 205 pounds on his recruiting profile coming out of high school. Very similar body build to Tyner at that age and similar running styles. However, like I said, it is unlikely Tyner will ever become as good as Peterson since Peterson was a better prospect when he was at the stage Tyner is at now, in my opinion.

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Mon Apr 09, 2012 9:02 am
by Braveheart
Any thoughts on the list, or any thoughts not regarding Tyner?

Re: TR's Initial 2013 Runningback Rankings

Posted: Mon Apr 09, 2012 9:34 am
by uodux1212
Cool article, good info. I don't subscribe to any recruiting pay sites and pretty much get all my info on recruits here. Is nic to read something besides the usual stuff on the main recruiting sites.

I can't comment on the validity of the list or the info provided (I'm by no means an expert) but I liked the layout and info provided in the article, I especially liked the NFL comparison.

Good work.