Page 1 of 3

Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 11:48 am
by gregspechtismyhero
The saga ends today. Cowherd tweeted this morning: "Silas Redd deletes Twitter acct. Jump to own conclusions.... "
Likely bracing for impact. Great pickup for the Trojans tho

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:00 pm
by Braveheart
Yeah, I knew it was game set match when locals spotted him with Lane Kiffin, Robert Woods, and Matt Barkley at Roscoe's the other day ago. Roscoe's has helped USC out recruiting so much it's an extension of USC's facilities (IMO). :lol:


btw, there was a thread regarding PSU transfers right here.

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=13337

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:04 pm
by UOducksTK1
Braveheart wrote:Yeah, I knew it was game set match when locals spotted him with Lane Kiffin, Robert Woods, and Matt Barkley at Roscoe's the other day ago. Roscoe's has helped USC out recruiting so much it's an extension of USC's facilities (IMO). :lol:


btw, there was a thread regarding PSU transfers right here.

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=13337
Same my girlfriend's ex-brother in law was actually at the restaurant where Redd and the coaches were. He said that Redd told the coaches he'd be going to SC.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:21 pm
by gregspechtismyhero
Braveheart wrote:Yeah, I knew it was game set match when locals spotted him with Lane Kiffin, Robert Woods, and Matt Barkley at Roscoe's the other day ago. Roscoe's has helped USC out recruiting so much it's an extension of USC's facilities (IMO). :lol:


btw, there was a thread regarding PSU transfers right here.

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=13337
I know, thought this deserved its own though considering this decision has a huge impact on both Oregon and SC for next year

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:37 pm
by squintsdd
I believe USC has to drop a recruit if Redd is indeed transferring

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:45 pm
by greenyellow
squintsdd wrote:I believe USC has to drop a recruit if Redd is indeed transferring
I don't think so since he said he's going to enter the NFL Draft after this season, which means his scholarship spot would be open for a member of the 2013 class.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:53 pm
by squintsdd
greenyellow wrote:
squintsdd wrote:I believe USC has to drop a recruit if Redd is indeed transferring
I don't think so since he said he's going to enter the NFL Draft after this season, which means his scholarship spot would be open for a member of the 2013 class.
From my understanding teams can go over their scholarship limits if they pick up a Penn State transfer, but get one less scholarship to hand out next year; however, teams that have fewer scholarships due to sanctions are not allowed to go over the limit for this years recruiting class.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 12:56 pm
by SuperDuck
squintsdd wrote:I believe USC has to drop a recruit if Redd is indeed transferring
They don't have to drop a recruit, they have to drop a scholarship. I just saw on College Football Live where they said they spoke to Lane Kiffin and they have two options:

#1. They get an open spot if one of the new recruits doesn't qualify academically.

#2. They can pull a schollie from one of three walk-on's that Kiffin put on scholarship. He already told them that it would be a "year to year" thing. Actually, I just read who it would be yesterday, but I forgot. The kid said he'd be "devastated" to lose it after working so hard, but he'd still remain on the team.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 1:02 pm
by squintsdd
SuperDuck wrote:
squintsdd wrote:I believe USC has to drop a recruit if Redd is indeed transferring
They don't have to drop a recruit, they have to drop a scholarship. I just saw on College Football Live where they said they spoke to Lane Kiffin and they have two options:

#1. They get an open spot if one of the new recruits doesn't qualify academically.

#2. They can pull a schollie from one of three walk-on's that Kiffin put on scholarship. He already told them that it would be a "year to year" thing. Actually, I just read who it would be yesterday, but I forgot. The kid said he'd be "devastated" to lose it after working so hard, but he'd still remain on the team.
Interesting. The article I read said that USC is not allowed to go over the limits specified by its infractions ruling.

http://espn.go.com/blog/bigten/post/_/i ... -transfers

It uses the total scholarship limit as an example, but if it holds true that they can't go over any limits set by infractions, then they can't exceed their limit for the recruiting class either

Braveheart, can you clarify?

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 1:10 pm
by pezsez1
#2. They can pull a schollie from one of three walk-on's that Kiffin put on scholarship. He already told them that it would be a "year to year" thing. Actually, I just read who it would be yesterday, but I forgot. The kid said he'd be "devastated" to lose it after working so hard, but he'd still remain on the team.
I read this as well.

Man, what an awful thing for whichever walk-on has to take it in the ass for Redd.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 2:15 pm
by Braveheart
squintsdd wrote:
SuperDuck wrote:
squintsdd wrote:I believe USC has to drop a recruit if Redd is indeed transferring
They don't have to drop a recruit, they have to drop a scholarship. I just saw on College Football Live where they said they spoke to Lane Kiffin and they have two options:

#1. They get an open spot if one of the new recruits doesn't qualify academically.

#2. They can pull a schollie from one of three walk-on's that Kiffin put on scholarship. He already told them that it would be a "year to year" thing. Actually, I just read who it would be yesterday, but I forgot. The kid said he'd be "devastated" to lose it after working so hard, but he'd still remain on the team.
Interesting. The article I read said that USC is not allowed to go over the limits specified by its infractions ruling.

http://espn.go.com/blog/bigten/post/_/i ... -transfers

It uses the total scholarship limit as an example, but if it holds true that they can't go over any limits set by infractions, then they can't exceed their limit for the recruiting class either

Braveheart, can you clarify?
What SuperDuck said is true. It's most likely going to be option 2. I know this because there were two silent commits USC got on Saturday (one of them was Torrodney Prevot who went public the other day ago). The remaining silent commit said he wouldn't publicly commit until Darreus Rogers' (the '12 commit who's academic qualification is sketchy) situation is official.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 2:21 pm
by lukeyrid13
That'd be really dirty if that's the road they went down

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 2:45 pm
by KeenanHowry15
If the Trojans want to beat us this year they will have to do so with Matt Barkley's arm and our own mistakes, IMO I don't think the addition of Redd will have a very big impact come November 4th.

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 2:58 pm
by uostudent
Braveheart wrote:Yeah, I knew it was game set match when locals spotted him with Lane Kiffin, Robert Woods, and Matt Barkley at Roscoe's the other day ago. Roscoe's has helped USC out recruiting so much it's an extension of USC's facilities (IMO). :lol:


btw, there was a thread regarding PSU transfers right here.

viewtopic.php?f=6&t=13337
I can attest to the fact that Roscoe's is a huge sell. Papa's Soul Food is like KFC compared to Roscoe's and I was definitely a fan of "Papa's".

Re: Silas Redd

Posted: Tue Jul 31, 2012 3:04 pm
by Braveheart
KeenanHowry15 wrote:If the Trojans want to beat us this year they will have to do so with Matt Barkley's arm and our own mistakes, IMO I don't think the addition of Redd will have a very big impact come November 4th.
I have to respectfully disagree with this. Redd gives USC a proven player who can churn out tough yards, and will keep Moody McNeal fresh. One of the main keys to beating Oregon is keeping their offense off the field. How do you do that...you run the ball. Also USC is run first play-action team. When USC runs the ball well, the passing game is more effective. When Moody is not in the game USC has no (proven) runner who can go straight up the gut and get the "Three yards and a cloud of dust".

And that's just being modest about his abilities.