Page 1 of 3

Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2012 4:43 pm
by uofo627
and the tradition of pay sites hating on Duck commits continues... Darren Carrington got bumped to 4* though.

http://rivals.yahoo.com/oregon/football ... ner-117565

Ah well, stars have never mattered anyways.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2012 5:23 pm
by neezy3
He's had a couple injuries the last year and didn't attend any of the camps or combines this summer. If he has a monster senior year he will have chance to move back up.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Tue Aug 21, 2012 6:11 pm
by thomas time
Oregonlive.com has an article on Tyner but I can't find it, talking about how healthy he is now and looking foward to this season.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 8:59 am
by UOducksTK1
Really excited to see how he does this year. Aloha's OL is as strong as ever.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 11:18 am
by Braveheart
It's not just the injuries. As Neezy said, he attended no camps (Rivals is really big on camps, more than the other big 3 sites), and plus his stock was going down even before he hurt his hammy. People have questions about his game (including myself).

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 12:02 pm
by RanDux
Still a 5 star on Scout but Scout tends to lag behind the other sites.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 12:44 pm
by Braveheart
RanDux wrote:Still a 5 star on Scout but Scout tends to lag behind the other sites.
And they are the most generous when it comes to giving prospects 5 stars.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 2:23 pm
by TheMaehlMan
Honestly, Rivals' rating of Tyner shows how much talent they think he has. He's still the number two RB in the nation, and he missed significant time during last season, and didn't do anything this summer.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 2:46 pm
by cmmadness
We already know that Tyner is a stud and his issues have largely been nagging but not overly troublesome injuries. I'm not concerned about the drop to four stars. The addition of Carrington and Redmond into the four star category is far more encouraging. Stars don't win games but moving up the ladder on Rivals overall list is good to see.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 4:11 pm
by chapelhillduck
Can someone who is concerned please explain why (aside from bragging rights), hopefully this is no one

He's the exact same player he was when rated 5 stars

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 5:11 pm
by Braveheart
chapelhillduck wrote:Can someone who is concerned please explain why (aside from bragging rights), hopefully this is no one

He's the exact same player he was when rated 5 stars



He has incredible track speed, but that speed doesn't seem to translate on the field 100% (IMO). Running backs are rarely running in a straight line for more than a couple yards. I'm assuming this might be the reason he doesn't really explode on film/tape. Maybe running in pads hinder his speed (I remember seeing Usain Bolt have a bit a difficulty running in pads)? His change of direction and elusiveness are just decent. I'm not sure if that's a physical limitation (due to his muscular and rocked up physique), or just his running-style. I'm not really concerned about the hammy issue atm.

This doesn't mean he's not a stud prospect. His measurables make him a top 5 guy at RB no matter what. I still think he has the highest upside out of all the RB's this cycle, just not a sure thing.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 6:12 pm
by chapelhillduck
Braveheart wrote:
chapelhillduck wrote:Can someone who is concerned please explain why (aside from bragging rights), hopefully this is no one

He's the exact same player he was when rated 5 stars



He has incredible track speed, but that speed doesn't seem to translate on the field 100% (IMO). Running backs are rarely running in a straight line for more than a couple yards. I'm assuming this might be the reason he doesn't really explode on film/tape. Maybe running in pads hinder his speed (I remember seeing Usain Bolt have a bit a difficulty running in pads)? His change of direction and elusiveness are just decent. I'm not sure if that's a physical limitation (due to his muscular and rocked up physique), or just his running-style. I'm not really concerned about the hammy issue atm.

This doesn't mean he's not a stud prospect. His measurables make him a top 5 guy at RB no matter what. I still think he has the highest upside out of all the RB's this cycle, just not a sure thing.
Totally on board with those comments. I'm not complaining that he's a 4 star I just don't know why it matters to people aside from bragging rights because he's always been the guy you describe Braveheart (even when he was a 5 star)

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 7:43 pm
by duxball
I agree as well. One other major fella who agrees. The head ball coach and he knows his stuff

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Wed Aug 22, 2012 10:36 pm
by Braveheart
I think the worse case-scenario for Tyner at UO is that he would become a niche one-cut big back. He doesn't have the power (or elusiveness) of Blount or J-Stew, but he will probably play a similar role.

Re: Thomas Tyner now a 4* on rivals

Posted: Thu Aug 23, 2012 12:12 am
by Boom
Braveheart wrote:I think the worse case-scenario for Tyner at UO is that he would become a niche one-cut big back. He doesn't have the power (or elusiveness) of Blount or J-Stew, but he will probably play a similar role.
Neither J-Stew or Blount were very elusive. Hard to tell from youtube, but I think Tyner's elusiveness is at least comparable.