Page 1 of 4

Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 11:13 am
by Iluvmydux

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 12:03 pm
by Phenom
It's happening...JHop just changed his pick too. Then again, we thought the same about Juju.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 12:54 pm
by gosterman01
I want Murray and his WR's!

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 1:37 pm
by squintsdd
Anyone know when he's expected to announce? Unless they promised that he would be the only quarterback recruit taken in this class I see no reason to not offer Waller at this point, especially if he's holding out until the end of the season.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 2:00 pm
by Phenom
squintsdd wrote:Anyone know when he's expected to announce? Unless they promised that he would be the only quarterback recruit taken in this class I see no reason to not offer Waller at this point, especially if he's holding out until the end of the season.
The 28th.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 2:06 pm
by Mcbronsh
I thought of Murray when I saw the qb transfer news last week.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 2:10 pm
by GoDucksIn09
Ok I wanted to weigh in on this. First of all I think all Jhop is doing is fishing for hits on his board. He has done this many times to get people to come read his stuff. I might browse and read it but I do not give much credibility to him saying these things. If people think back to when Murray visited he was telling people that Texas A&M was still his leader. This was right after he visited. I would suspect if Oregon made an impact on him you would see a boost right after he visited. It has been about a month since he visited. I am just not buying it. I noticed in reading the comments someone pointed out that Jhop had not changed his crystal ball prediction... only a few posts later he did. Jhop wants to keep people coming to his website. From a business standpoint can understand that. From a fan's perspective of him though I am not biting. I have not seen any indication from anyone except him who thinks he is learning more towards Oregon.

On a side note. A few comments about Cowart. I noticed a few skeptics on that board. Pretty much the same thing as here. If Oregon is not on Cece's radar and they do truly end up playing together then is no way Oregon gets him. Cowart is supposedly waiting to see how Florida does this year. Interesting considering he had tweeted that would be playing football in college a long ways from home. I am not sure how everyone's else's definition of long ways away is, but I would guess most of us would think that Alabama or Oregon is longer ways from his hs than what Gainesville is.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 5:11 pm
by squintsdd
GoDucksIn09 wrote:Ok I wanted to weigh in on this. First of all I think all Jhop is doing is fishing for hits on his board. He has done this many times to get people to come read his stuff. I might browse and read it but I do not give much credibility to him saying these things. If people think back to when Murray visited he was telling people that Texas A&M was still his leader. This was right after he visited. I would suspect if Oregon made an impact on him you would see a boost right after he visited. It has been about a month since he visited. I am just not buying it. I noticed in reading the comments someone pointed out that Jhop had not changed his crystal ball prediction... only a few posts later he did. Jhop wants to keep people coming to his website. From a business standpoint can understand that. From a fan's perspective of him though I am not biting. I have not seen any indication from anyone except him who thinks he is learning more towards Oregon.

On a side note. A few comments about Cowart. I noticed a few skeptics on that board. Pretty much the same thing as here. If Oregon is not on Cece's radar and they do truly end up playing together then is no way Oregon gets him. Cowart is supposedly waiting to see how Florida does this year. Interesting considering he had tweeted that would be playing football in college a long ways from home. I am not sure how everyone's else's definition of long ways away is, but I would guess most of us would think that Alabama or Oregon is longer ways from his hs than what Gainesville is.
I agree about Murray, I'm not sold, and jhop does have a known history for creating articles just for hits.that being said, it is possible that Murray changed his mind based on the fact that the depth chart would be significantly smaller than it would've before.

As far as cowart, I'm more sold on his genuine interest, but for some of these kids a long ways from home could mean only 30 miles. I don't take the part about playing with a friend very seriously since a lot of recruits say that every year, and it rarely ends up happening.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 9:31 pm
by UOducksTK1
A few other guys changed their CB to Oregon too btw fwiw. I think there could be some substance to this, but we aren't even in June... I bet he will switch back and forth a few times. And it wouldn't shock me if he commits and then decommits later.

It's awesome if it's true that we lead for Murray, but we've already heard a couple times that a&m was the leader, then Oregon. Recruits like these, I try to wait until January/February to get too invested emotionally lol.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 9:44 pm
by lukeyrid13
^ Yeah after a few years of really following recruiting it just kind of burned me out of the process. I will follow guys on our commit list and look at their highlights then but we only get 20% of the guys that we offer every year so it's like watching baseball expecting your team to get a hit every at bat, you'll just end up disappointed far more often than not.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 10:15 pm
by ljginger
WRONG!!! Justin is one of the most unbiased mods on the 247 site...he doesn't like to change his pic unless he's certain because it hurts his prediction scores for all the mods...Matt is a bit more biased then Justin but still nothin compared to Loy of ND or Schrader of SC!

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Tue May 20, 2014 10:50 pm
by Phenom
ljginger wrote:WRONG!!! Justin is one of the most unbiased mods on the 247 site...he doesn't like to change his pic unless he's certain because it hurts his prediction scores for all the mods...Matt is a bit more biased then Justin but still nothin compared to Loy of ND or Schrader of SC!
I agree with this. JHop is really good.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Wed May 21, 2014 8:17 am
by Elduderino
Phenom wrote:
ljginger wrote:WRONG!!! Justin is one of the most unbiased mods on the 247 site...he doesn't like to change his pic unless he's certain because it hurts his prediction scores for all the mods...Matt is a bit more biased then Justin but still nothin compared to Loy of ND or Schrader of SC!
I agree with this. JHop is really good.
Eh, he's probably a good dude (from what I can tell) and I do think he's one of the better ones out there. The recruiting business is a pretty shady one though, and I'm an admitted subscriber. Their whole business model is built around subscriptions and page views, so there is inherent value in drumming up interest in stories. It is obvious that it happens, and happens routinely; even with our beloved Duck sites. It's just smart business. This is secondary to the notion that many of these "analysts", especially at the local level, are nothing more than fans. Many have never played, coached, or been involved in these sports past a junior high/mid-high school level and their interactions with recruits walk a very fine line between appropriate and violations; especially with the boom in twitter land recently. For an example, see ND fans' opinions of JHop's interactions with the Barnett family.

That being said, I'm a college football junkie. Businesses like JHop's exist because of people like me. He's hitting a need, that fans like me create. Hard to pass too much judgement with that in mind.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Wed May 21, 2014 10:26 am
by Duck07
Elduderino wrote: Eh, he's probably a good dude (from what I can tell) and I do think he's one of the better ones out there. The recruiting business is a pretty shady one though, and I'm an admitted subscriber. Their whole business model is built around subscriptions and page views, so there is inherent value in drumming up interest in stories. It is obvious that it happens, and happens routinely; even with our beloved Duck sites. It's just smart business. This is secondary to the notion that many of these "analysts", especially at the local level, are nothing more than fans. Many have never played, coached, or been involved in these sports past a junior high/mid-high school level and their interactions with recruits walk a very fine line between appropriate and violations; especially with the boom in twitter land recently. For an example, see ND fans' opinions of JHop's interactions with the Barnett family.

That being said, I'm a college football junkie. Businesses like JHop's exist because of people like me. He's hitting a need, that fans like me create. Hard to pass too much judgement with that in mind.
I've gotten away from following recruiting too closely as its becoming too despicable to me. From the coaches to the fans, the behavior that so many show is so boorish its not even funny. We've got people on this board who will hound these kids on twitter because they think they are going to "mentor" them.

Side note about Murray, his school (Allen HS) won't be able to play in their 60$ Million Stadium that is 3 years old because of cracking in the cement. I wonder what greater good would have come from that 60$M than a HS football stadium.

Re: Ducks Lead For Murray?

Posted: Wed May 21, 2014 10:49 am
by Elduderino
Duck07 wrote:
Elduderino wrote: Eh, he's probably a good dude (from what I can tell) and I do think he's one of the better ones out there. The recruiting business is a pretty shady one though, and I'm an admitted subscriber. Their whole business model is built around subscriptions and page views, so there is inherent value in drumming up interest in stories. It is obvious that it happens, and happens routinely; even with our beloved Duck sites. It's just smart business. This is secondary to the notion that many of these "analysts", especially at the local level, are nothing more than fans. Many have never played, coached, or been involved in these sports past a junior high/mid-high school level and their interactions with recruits walk a very fine line between appropriate and violations; especially with the boom in twitter land recently. For an example, see ND fans' opinions of JHop's interactions with the Barnett family.

That being said, I'm a college football junkie. Businesses like JHop's exist because of people like me. He's hitting a need, that fans like me create. Hard to pass too much judgement with that in mind.
I've gotten away from following recruiting too closely as its becoming too despicable to me. From the coaches to the fans, the behavior that so many show is so boorish its not even funny. We've got people on this board who will hound these kids on twitter because they think they are going to "mentor" them.

Side note about Murray, his school (Allen HS) won't be able to play in their 60$ Million Stadium that is 3 years old because of cracking in the cement. I wonder what greater good would have come from that 60$M than a HS football stadium.
Recruiting is a slimy business. This is as good a time as ever to remind people: DO NOT TWEET AT RECRUITS. It's creepy for one, and secondly it is a violation.