Page 1 of 2

Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 10:33 pm
by bigsugarduck
Marcus winning the Heisman will obviously have a positive recruiting impact, but how much?

I would anticipate that recruiting top level polynesian kids just got a ton easier at the very least.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Sun Dec 14, 2014 10:46 pm
by mdm0302
bigsugarduck wrote:Marcus winning the Heisman will obviously have a positive recruiting impact, but how much?

I would anticipate that recruiting top level polynesian kids just got a ton easier at the very least.
I would say it will GREATLY impact recruiting polysiam kids and QBs. It will have the next most impact on skill positions and then after that it will have a slight impact on the rest of the positions.

Recruiting poly kids and QBs has got to be much easier for the coaches now

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 10:06 am
by Duck07
IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 11:25 am
by pudgejeff
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
I think the biggest impact it will have is to counter negative recruiting. But we probably won't see that until Marcus has been successful in the NFL for a few years.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 11:31 am
by karlhungis
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
It seems like we never really get the recruiting bump that other teams see following any sort of success on the field.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 6:47 pm
by whosyourwally
karlhungis wrote:
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
It seems like we never really get the recruiting bump that other teams see following any sort of success on the field.
Maybe its just that it's been gradual, but there's absolutely been a recruiting bump. Look at who we were recruiting in the doldrums of the mid 00's, after we had squandered our success from the early 00's. 4-star guys were celebrated as a coup, as were all players outside of the Pacific Northwest. Back in the day, we snuck 3-Star LaMichael James out before Texas found him, and then we just straight out-recruited Texas for Lache Seastrunk a few years later. There are several kids we've brought in over the last 3-4 seasons that, while we were excited about them, would have had 50 pages threads in their honor in the past.

Just think about the fanfare that Chris Harper came with, and realize that it felt like we settled for Travis Waller this year.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 7:11 pm
by karlhungis
whosyourwally wrote:
karlhungis wrote:
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
It seems like we never really get the recruiting bump that other teams see following any sort of success on the field.
Maybe its just that it's been gradual, but there's absolutely been a recruiting bump. Look at who we were recruiting in the doldrums of the mid 00's, after we had squandered our success from the early 00's. 4-star guys were celebrated as a coup, as were all players outside of the Pacific Northwest. Back in the day, we snuck 3-Star LaMichael James out before Texas found him, and then we just straight out-recruited Texas for Lache Seastrunk a few years later. There are several kids we've brought in over the last 3-4 seasons that, while we were excited about them, would have had 50 pages threads in their honor in the past.

Just think about the fanfare that Chris Harper came with, and realize that it felt like we settled for Travis Waller this year.
Yeah, I realize that we are recruiting at a much higher level than we used to. I'm just saying we never seem to get that perceived "bump" that comes with a good season.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 7:27 pm
by SuperDuck
karlhungis wrote:
whosyourwally wrote:
karlhungis wrote:
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
It seems like we never really get the recruiting bump that other teams see following any sort of success on the field.
Maybe its just that it's been gradual, but there's absolutely been a recruiting bump. Look at who we were recruiting in the doldrums of the mid 00's, after we had squandered our success from the early 00's. 4-star guys were celebrated as a coup, as were all players outside of the Pacific Northwest. Back in the day, we snuck 3-Star LaMichael James out before Texas found him, and then we just straight out-recruited Texas for Lache Seastrunk a few years later. There are several kids we've brought in over the last 3-4 seasons that, while we were excited about them, would have had 50 pages threads in their honor in the past.

Just think about the fanfare that Chris Harper came with, and realize that it felt like we settled for Travis Waller this year.
Yeah, I realize that we are recruiting at a much higher level than we used to. I'm just saying we never seem to get that perceived "bump" that comes with a good season.
I understand where you're coming from, but think about this. Alabama has had the #1 or #2 recruiting class for the past few years now, while Oregon's best class has been #11 around 5-6 years ago. Still, the Ducks have the second best winning percentage next to Alabama over the last 5 years. They've been to 4 BCS Bowls, including a national title game, the Alamo Bowl and the national semifinals in the last 6 years, including this year. They have a Heisman Trophy winner and a Doak Walker winner, LaMichael James.

My point is, even though it may not seem like it, mostly because we haven't won that elusive national championship - yet, Oregon has been as dominant as any team in college football.

The good news is that we're showing no signs of slowing down anytime soon, either.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Mon Dec 15, 2014 7:47 pm
by Duck07
whosyourwally wrote:
karlhungis wrote:
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
It seems like we never really get the recruiting bump that other teams see following any sort of success on the field.
Maybe its just that it's been gradual, but there's absolutely been a recruiting bump. Look at who we were recruiting in the doldrums of the mid 00's, after we had squandered our success from the early 00's. 4-star guys were celebrated as a coup, as were all players outside of the Pacific Northwest. Back in the day, we snuck 3-Star LaMichael James out before Texas found him, and then we just straight out-recruited Texas for Lache Seastrunk a few years later. There are several kids we've brought in over the last 3-4 seasons that, while we were excited about them, would have had 50 pages threads in their honor in the past.

Just think about the fanfare that Chris Harper came with, and realize that it felt like we settled for Travis Waller this year.
Pretty sure we've seen the same amount of 5*s that saw the field back then as we do now. Haloti, Cam and Snoop all played as true freshman until they left compared to DAT, Colt and Arik. The 2005 roster had the most NFL talent on it until about the last 2 years teams and we won't know that for sure until 5 years from now.

We were bringing in top flight DBs like Ryan Gilliam from Florida and while he'd eventually transfer back home, he was much better than the "Le'Affair de Lyles" trouble that we went through. Dennis Dixon was an Elite 11 QB. Kellen Clemens was a HS AA.

Where we've gotten better is that we've raised our base level of recruits up as we get a lot more 4* now. We don't see 2 stars anymore like Pat Chung and Max Unger. As a result, when a 4* OL like Charlie Carmichael doesn't pan out due to injuries, the collective sigh isn't the same as 4* OL Aaron Klovas.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2014 8:40 pm
by polyduck
MM8 came to Eugene as a 3* recruit that no major college scholarship offers. Now he's leaving the U of O for the NFL as the reigning 2014 Heisman Trophy winner. What matters is that the U of O coaching staff saw the potential in this kid, and what they saw was a 5* human being that had all the physical tools, attitude and and aptitude to take CK's offense to the next level. I'll take 3* kids all day....with 5* character!

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2014 11:17 pm
by woundedknees
IMO, part of having 5 star character is cultivating a 6 star work ethic.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Tue Dec 16, 2014 11:34 pm
by Everythingsducky
Duck07 wrote:IDK, I think it will have minimal impact frankly.
I might agree on overall recruiting, but in regards to Poly recruiting, I disagree. I just spoke with a client in Kona, and was told his 3 middle school kids all have Mariota jerseys, and their friends often come over to their home sporting UO gear. While this may not have an immediate effect (other than Tua), seeds have been planted. This really was huge in Hawaii. I bet you don't find many residents of Hawaii that don't know of Marcus, let alone players of all ages.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2014 7:03 am
by vagusnerve
polyduck wrote:MM8 came to Eugene as a 3* recruit that no major college scholarship offers. Now he's leaving the U of O for the NFL as the reigning 2014 Heisman Trophy winner. What matters is that the U of O coaching staff saw the potential in this kid, and what they saw was a 5* human being that had all the physical tools, attitude and and aptitude to take CK's offense to the next level. I'll take 3* kids all day....with 5* character!
Mariota was a four star with 247 I believe.

Either way, he most certainly did have many, many more offers when he signed his NLI. You can't just go around making stuff up. Lots of kids are under scouted before their senior season starts.

The UO coaches put in way more work in recruiting than most. Overall, our classes are much better top to bottom.

Someone mentioned chris Harper, I remember we got both harper and DT in the same class. People were stoked. Today, neither of those guys highlight tapes would have drawn much excitement.

William Wallace anyone? That guy was on the team forever. Today, we're getting highly recruited three stars with offers from all over and four stars. We only take a few flyers on guys that are underatted but we know that the coaches have good track record.

I think the next step is we do start to haul in the occasional national five star recruit. Nor cal is ours, do Hawaii and the mountain states, and hopefully firm up Arizona.

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2014 7:18 am
by jimmy12
Here's a reality check for star hunters.... Texas has had a top 5 class nearly every year, as has Michigan.... Oh man, I am happy choosing some 3 and 4* guys over 5* guys.

While I do love when we get them, I am also aware that there is a reason we don't go after a lot of them Mixon? That guy is a thug. The kid from Ok St? Thug.

I would like to believe we are selective out of choice not out of necessity. (any longer)

Re: Heisman recruiting impact

Posted: Wed Dec 17, 2014 9:59 am
by damascusduck
They may have made him a 4 star later on. Never was originally. Marcus had 3 offers. Memphis St, Washington, Oregon.
vagusnerve wrote:
polyduck wrote:MM8 came to Eugene as a 3* recruit that no major college scholarship offers. Now he's leaving the U of O for the NFL as the reigning 2014 Heisman Trophy winner. What matters is that the U of O coaching staff saw the potential in this kid, and what they saw was a 5* human being that had all the physical tools, attitude and and aptitude to take CK's offense to the next level. I'll take 3* kids all day....with 5* character!
Mariota was a four star with 247 I believe.

Either way, he most certainly did have many, many more offers when he signed his NLI. You can't just go around making stuff up. Lots of kids are under scouted before their senior season starts.

The UO coaches put in way more work in recruiting than most. Overall, our classes are much better top to bottom.

Someone mentioned chris Harper, I remember we got both harper and DT in the same class. People were stoked. Today, neither of those guys highlight tapes would have drawn much excitement.

William Wallace anyone? That guy was on the team forever. Today, we're getting highly recruited three stars with offers from all over and four stars. We only take a few flyers on guys that are underatted but we know that the coaches have good track record.

I think the next step is we do start to haul in the occasional national five star recruit. Nor cal is ours, do Hawaii and the mountain states, and hopefully firm up Arizona.