Page 1 of 3
Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 2:15 pm
by GrantDuck
Wish it would happen tomorrow.
He's the worst coordinator I've seen since Stubler.
Good LBer coach, awful coordinator. Old school and absolutely clueless.
I encourage all true duck fans to let the Athletic Department know he's not up to the standard of the rest of the program.
We've had our worst defensive #'s in over 10+ seasons with this guy as DC and we have WAY more talent than a lot of those teams.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 2:22 pm
by UOducksTK1
Definitely not look so good so far, but we were struggling defensively last year, and really pulled it together the 2nd half of the season. I'm just hoping we'll get things figured out soon.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 2:22 pm
by Phenom
The terrible LB play is on him, too. he's the LB coach....
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 2:30 pm
by GrantDuck
UOducksTK1 wrote:Definitely not look so good so far, but we were struggling defensively last year, and really pulled it together the 2nd half of the season. I'm just hoping we'll get things figured out soon.
We pulled it together against Arizona(2nd time) and Oregon State. Overall we had our worst defensive #'s in 10+ seasons. With 2 NFL defensive lineman(armstead, buckner), Ifo/Hill(2 excellent corners). That's pretty awful.
That was about it.
The guy is a joke of a coordinator with the talent we have on defense.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 4:34 pm
by SuperDuck
GrantDuck wrote:UOducksTK1 wrote:Definitely not look so good so far, but we were struggling defensively last year, and really pulled it together the 2nd half of the season. I'm just hoping we'll get things figured out soon.
We pulled it together against Arizona(2nd time) and Oregon State. Overall we had our worst defensive #'s in 10+ seasons. With 2 NFL defensive lineman(armstead, buckner), Ifo/Hill(2 excellent corners). That's pretty awful.
That was about it.
The guy is a joke of a coordinator with the talent we have on defense.
I'm frustrated, too. I already posted about it in the game thread. However, that statement you made just made me realize that in all reality, we're not necessarily as talented as we have been in past years on defense. Yes, the D-Line shouldn't have much or any drop off, but our linebackers weren't that deep last year. That's why we struggled against the run so much. This year we have 3 new starters in the secondary. Granted, Robinson and Seisay do have game experience, but Umadi is still a true freshman.
I'm not saying that some tweaks don't need to be made. They obviously need a lot of work, but they're also younger and less experienced than they've been in years. When Nick Aliotti was coaching under Chip Kelly he had as many as 18 players rotating in regularly on defense without a huge drop off. Well, we're already starting a true freshman at corner, so there's obviously not a lot of depth there yet, right? The coaching staff is high on Ty Griffin, but he's still learning the position.
Fortunately, we have the easier part of our conference schedule on the front end, so we might just be fortunate enough to get past Utah, Colorado, UW and WSU, but then we play Cal. Sheesh...even WSU may pass for 500 yards! As long as we win.
I guess what I'm going to do is try to be patient and hope we don't lose any games that we shouldn't lose.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 4:38 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
Pellum is definitely worse than Allioti but this isnt exactly a new thing. We had a defensive backfield of Byrd, Thurmond, Chung, and Ward paired with one of the best sackers in the conference in Nick Reed and were consistently torched through the air.
The defense needs a change in philosophy. They never should have promoted Pellum. We needed someone who was a proven coordinator that would have brought in an entirely new mentality on that side of the ball. The defense actually stopping anyone is an afterthought. They've built in excuses because of the pace of the offense and the idea that they get all the talent (the opposite is true) and the result is a staff and players that have very low expectations and hold themselves to a very low standard. There is no sense of urgency from the D, they play with a passive weak mentality that starts at the top.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 4:49 pm
by Oregonian
dthomas=ddixon wrote:Pellum is definitely worse than Allioti but this isnt exactly a new thing. We had a defensive backfield of Byrd, Thurmond, Chung, and Ward paired with one of the best sackers in the conference in Nick Reed and were consistently torched through the air.
The defense needs a change in philosophy. They never should have promoted Pellum. We needed someone who was a proven coordinator that would have brought in an entirely new mentality on that side of the ball. The defense actually stopping anyone is an afterthought. They've built in excuses because of the pace of the offense and the idea that they get all the talent (the opposite is true) and the result is a staff and players that have very low expectations and hold themselves to a very low standard. There is no sense of urgency from the D, they play with a passive weak mentality that starts at the top.
This, thank you. It's absolutely perplexing to me how viscerally this fan base dislikes Pellum when he's clearly just a continuation of his predecessor, who gets large amounts of respect from this fanbase. This team has had defenses critically underperform their talent levels for the past decade plus, the D-Boyz being the most obvious example. Alliotti absolutely milked the success of the early 2000's and just got lucky he was still around by the time Chip came around and the offense could cover up the consistent failings of "bend don't break".
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 4:50 pm
by fpsduck
I would love to see him back to coaching just LBs, but I don't see him going anywhere any time soon.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 5:13 pm
by OregonFan4Life
I'm not saying fire him but he needs to feel pressure. I hear some fans just blame the players for not playing well, but the coaches gotta prepare the players and play the right ones. Has he been in the booth all season? Just noticed that today.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 5:23 pm
by Alan
Oregonian wrote:dthomas=ddixon wrote:Pellum is definitely worse than Allioti but this isnt exactly a new thing. We had a defensive backfield of Byrd, Thurmond, Chung, and Ward paired with one of the best sackers in the conference in Nick Reed and were consistently torched through the air.
The defense needs a change in philosophy. They never should have promoted Pellum. We needed someone who was a proven coordinator that would have brought in an entirely new mentality on that side of the ball. The defense actually stopping anyone is an afterthought. They've built in excuses because of the pace of the offense and the idea that they get all the talent (the opposite is true) and the result is a staff and players that have very low expectations and hold themselves to a very low standard. There is no sense of urgency from the D, they play with a passive weak mentality that starts at the top.
This, thank you. It's absolutely perplexing to me how viscerally this fan base dislikes Pellum when he's clearly just a continuation of his predecessor, who gets large amounts of respect from this fanbase. This team has had defenses critically underperform their talent levels for the past decade plus, the D-Boyz being the most obvious example. Alliotti absolutely milked the success of the early 2000's and just got lucky he was still around by the time Chip came around and the offense could cover up the consistent failings of "bend don't break".
These are, IMO, the two most intelligent comments posted yet. Lots of Fire DP now! Without thinking about what comes next. Ducks for years have had weak DB's. I agree we need to change our defense, we just don't get enough pressure on the QB. Our D line does not interrupt the backfield enough and it puts too much pressure on our LB's and DB's. That said we have the worse DB's we have had in years, their young but weak. Our DB's are the problem and well cost us a couple of games. That said Pellam needs to sharpen his pencil and get things better, our problems are worse then just the DB's, but they are the root of the problem other than a good old fashion 4-3.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 5:32 pm
by SuperDuck
Now that I think of it, I seem to recall PezSez and I posting about this last season. There were stats that had the Ducks defense in the Top 25-50 nationally in scoring defense for the past few years until last year, and even then we were just outside the Top-25.
Look at some of the teams ahead of us, Michigan State, Stanford, Washington(!), etc. We beat them ALL last year!
I get tired of the craziness, too, but the results don't lie. We've been in the Holiday Bowl, 3 BCS Bowl games, the first ever playoffs and 2 national championship games since 2009 using a similar system to what we're using now. I believe we're 4-3 in those games, having beaten Kansas State, Wisconsin, Texas and previously unbeaten Florida State. I suppose there are some things that we're going to have to get used to if we want to remain relevant.
By the way, I know that Alabama is ranked super high, but they're not exposed to the spread offenses and air attacks in the SEC on a regular basis like we are.
https://www.teamrankings.com/college-fo ... 2015-01-12
After reviewing this I feel much better.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 5:50 pm
by pezsez1
Our defense this year has definitely taken a step back. I think our young secondary is the bigger problem right now... These guys are often in position to make plays and they simply get beat. I do think it is crazy that people STILL bash Alliotti, who put up salty, attacking defenses during most of his time at Oregon. That D boys team wasn't very functional, and as we are seeing now, the D is symbiotic.. Doesn't matter how good your corners are if another defensive unit is a weak link.
I would like to think this season will be like last year, when the D settled down at the UCLA game and playedbsolidly the rest of the year.... But last year we didn't have a unit that was clearly as green as this secondary. The coaches can only do so much, but fact is, these guys just might need time to grow and improve.
I kind of hope Pellum stays with the scheme he ran today. If our secondary is that weak, then we might as well try to create chaos up front if our corners are so vulnerable anyway.
But Pellum had good enough results on the field last year to not be on the hotseat. I think a lot of us drank the kool aid from Mosely's practice reports and thought these young guys would be better than they are. Turns out, they aren't superhuman underclassmen, and they are going through some growing pains.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 5:55 pm
by buckmarkduck
Problem is though, our pass d wasn't great last year with two sr corners, and one who would have been a first round pick. People forget we let schools like WSU pass all over the field last year as well.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 5:57 pm
by QuackininBama
After todays game I will say, this is the first year we take a step back. I actually now do think we lose 3 games. Our defense just isn't good enough and as much as I like VA, he isn't good enough to overcome our defense.
Re: Pellum can't step down or be fired soon enough
Posted: Sat Sep 19, 2015 6:01 pm
by Oregonian
I don't know if average opponent scoring really tells the whole picture of this defense last season - of course the averages are going to be pulled down by holding teams like South Dakota, Wyoming, and Colorado to 13, 14, and 10, respectively. Absent those, our regular season average is closer to 27 points per game. We really stepped up twice last season to teams with quality offenses: Arizona in the Pac-12 title game, and FSU in the Rose Bowl. Granted, those are great times to step up, but the general regular season trend still continues and we're not even holding down the "gimme" teams like we did last year.