Page 1 of 6

Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 1:37 pm
by karlhungis
We rank 104th in scoring defense, 119th in passing defense, 106th in total defense and a downright respectable 53rd in rushing defense. Now, I know..I know... we have played a murderers row of opponents like Eastern Washington and Georgia State but I just can't get myself to shake this terrible feeling that we just may not be very good. Surely, even those of you that look through the greenest of green tinted glasses can admit that we have a problem. Right? Or are we still somehow shrugging this off and blaming it on the offenses that we have faced?

So, what do you chalk this ineptitude up to? Is it the coaching, the players, bad luck, our offense....?

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 1:49 pm
by pezsez1
Our defense has totally taken a step back from last year... but we've also shown enough potential to be optimistic about the season.

Our worst game was against EWU. I'd say our best game was against MSU, given that the Spartans are actually a really good team, and our defense kept us in the game for three quarters until our offense finally decided to show up. Georgia State started off good, with two turnovers and just one TD allowed in the first half, and the fourth quarter was garbage time for both teams... but that third quarter was a total letdown, and that can't happen in Pac-12 play.

I think it's too early to call it a coaching issue... and, honestly, I don't think it is.

I think the bigger issue is our secondary just isn't very good right now, mainly because they're extremely inexperienced. I don't think we've had such youth in the secondary since 2002 -- and that turned out to be the start of a couple of really painful years.

I've seen so many plays already this season where our corners just get pushed around and beat. I've seen the secondary run themselves out of tackling angles, and we've already seen the Ducks give up more big plays than they have in recent memories (usually as a result of poor tackling in the secondary). Oregon's past defensive schemes have flourished when we force our opponents to really work their way down the field, creating more opportunities for turnovers, which is partly why we've consistently been among the nation's best in turnover margins. However, the whole scheme falls apart of we're giving up so many big plays.

Also, as pointed out in another thread, Pellum isn't taking enough risks, which is something Aliotti did very well. However, that may also be a result of the cornerbacks not being ready to be left alone on islands. Back in 2002, NA didn't adjust his schemes when we had those young corners, and as a result we got absolutely lit up through the air just about every weekend.

Others have mentioned how our corners aren't playing press coverage on the receivers... and I wonder if this, too, is a result of our corners just not being very good right now, and Pellum is trying to do what he can to keep them from getting beat on long pass plays.

Bringing more heat worked better against Georgia State -- and I think everyone would like to see that approach tested against Utah -- but the fact remains that our secondary is currently a huge liability, and in a game like football, that's likely going to hurt the overall defensive performance until the game slows down a bit for those guys.
Or are we still somehow shrugging this off and blaming it on the offenses that we have faced?
To be fair, our first two opponents did have very good offenses. But the problem right now isn't statistics (because, as you know, Oregon's "total defense" stats are always skewed toward looking bad)... the problem now is what's actually happening on the field. As I said, our secondary is just flat-out getting beat.
We rank 104th in scoring defense
This concerns me the most. For years, Oregon's D has buckled down well in the redzone, and you'd think our secondary should have an easier time defending passing plays on a short field. Still, though, I feel like we've already seen too many TD passes against us that look way too easy.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 4:58 pm
by northbeachsf
Agree with Pezsez here. I understand that people are pissed about our linebacker play and DB play, but look at what we are dealing with! There are a number of issues going on and this is not just a coaching issue. Some things to consider:

1) Oregon has whiffed during recruiting on some big time defensive prospects over the past several years. Our defense will not be as good as the top tier programs until Oregon is able to start landing some of that talent. I do feel like we are making progress here. However, can you imagine what Budda Baker would do for us right now? There are tons of other examples here we can discuss if you want to get into the weeds. This was going on long before Pellum took over.

2) Our DBs are extremely inexperienced and we are extremely thin. I am not at all shocked that we are getting lit up right now. When a converted QB makes the 2-deep one week after switching positions and the coaches are basically begging Nelson to switch sides, it is pretty clear that we do not have the talent or depth at that position to perform at a high level right now.

3) We have suffered a huge amount of fallout of the past few years at the LB and DB positions (Robinson, Dunmore, Harrison, Amoako X2, Wallace, Cassell, etc.) That is a lot of players that we were depending on to contribute in some fashion as upperclassmen this year. Just didn't happen for us.

4) Yeah, the coaching is not perfect, BUT WE WERE IN THE NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP GAME LAST YEAR! Let's not get crazy and start firing people. That usually makes things worse.

5) Just to bring things back into perspective, Oregon has ONE top 10 recruiting class in the HISTORY of the program. The fact that we are even competing with the best teams in the country is flat out amazing. Our coaches do not get enough credit for what they have accomplished.

Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 5:24 pm
by UofDuck
I find it frustrating how so many Duck fans make so many excuses for our obvious weaknesses. They are glaring on defense. The thing is, we have done remarkable well in spite of subpar defenses, but you won't win it all without a quality defense. The best we've had in years took us to the final play against Auburn in the natty. Last year's was a step back, but we had an amazing QB who carried our team.

Couple thoughts, our recruiting on defense has not been bad, and even if it was, THATS ON THE COACHES TOO. We locked down some serious talent. Teams like Boise State have superior defenses to Oregon year in and year out and they aren't even close to us in terms of recruits. I watch Boston College play some solid defense last week and they too are not even close to us in terms of talent.

I don't get why it's so hard for some of you to admit/see what teams like GA ST did to us. Did you see the number of drops they had AND they still put 28 points on us. This is a team who can go a whole season without a win. 4 wins in 6 seasons.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 5:53 pm
by pezsez1
I don't get why it's so hard for some of you to admit/see what teams like GA ST did to us. Did you see the number of drops they had AND they still put 28 points on us. This is a team who can go a whole season without a win. 4 wins in 6 seasons.
Perspective, though... most of those points came in an abysmal third quarter. That could have just been a letdown. That said, the "woulda, coulda, shoulda" train runs both ways. Our defense could have played better in the first half, sure. And maybe GSU left some yards on the field, sure. But the bottom line is our defense held a pass-heavy team to one score in the first half, while also getting two turnovers. It's not the doomsday scenario it's being made out to be.

Recruiting overall has been good, but northbeachsf brought up a great point -- we have definitely whiffed on some big-time linebacker and secondary recruits in recent years, and we've also had guys leave the program. And it's definitely a huge red flag when a quarterback can switch to CB and immediately crack the two-deep. That's fact. If we had quality depth, then there would be absolutely no way for that to happen. Do you think a fifth-string QB for Alabama or Ohio State could crack the two-deep at CB after two weeks? Hell no. Simply no way.

UofDuck, you don't come right out and say it, but you seem to blame this year's struggles on the coaches -- and you're not alone. I, for one, would sincerely like to hear more of the scheme-based reasons why are coaches are responsible for what's happening, given the amount of inexperience in our secondary positions. And I honestly, genuinely don't mean that in a bad way... I'd seriously like to learn more of the schematic-driven reasoning behind this dislike of Don Pellum and/or other position coaches.

But to say things like "our defenses are always bad" (which you didn't say, but others do) just makes it hard to take these conversations seriously. I really wish we could just focus on this year's team and this year's defense, which I'm sure EVERYONE AGREES HAS PROBLEMS THAT NEED TO BE FIXED.

I was thorough in my take on what the problem is, and why solving through anything other than reps/time might be difficult.

I would love to hear some equally fleshed out analysis from people who are more critical of the coaches.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 7:04 pm
by UOducksTK1
northbeachsf wrote:Agree with Pezsez here. I understand that people are pissed about our linebacker play and DB play, but look at what we are dealing with! There are a number of issues going on and this is not just a coaching issue. Some things to consider:

1) Oregon has whiffed during recruiting on some big time defensive prospects over the past several years. Our defense will not be as good as the top tier programs until Oregon is able to start landing some of that talent. I do feel like we are making progress here. However, can you imagine what Budda Baker would do for us right now? There are tons of other examples here we can discuss if you want to get into the weeds. This was going on long before Pellum took over.
This is a meh excuse. Most of our DBs are 4-star or top recruits on our board. Missing on one guy doesn't make or break this team.

2) Our DBs are extremely inexperienced and we are extremely thin. I am not at all shocked that we are getting lit up right now. When a converted QB makes the 2-deep one week after switching positions and the coaches are basically begging Nelson to switch sides, it is pretty clear that we do not have the talent or depth at that position to perform at a high level right now.
It's true our DB group is a little thin, but that isn't even the main problem. We don't get any pressure and the QB has 3+ seconds to throw. Our LBs have missed more tackles in a 3-game span than I can ever remember. DBs will get it together, I'm less worried about them than our more experienced group.

3) We have suffered a huge amount of fallout of the past few years at the LB and DB positions (Robinson, Dunmore, Harrison, Amoako X2, Wallace, Cassell, etc.) That is a lot of players that we were depending on to contribute in some fashion as upperclassmen this year. Just didn't happen for us.
I thought missing out on big recruits was our problem. Other than Robinson, all those guys were 2/3 star guys. I think Wallace would have been graduated by now btw. Plus their voids means some JC guys like Walker, Ragin, Bostick, Heard, etc. Other than Robinson, I doubt any of these losses would have had a significant impact on how we are playing right now.

4) Yeah, the coaching is not perfect, BUT WE WERE IN THE NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP GAME LAST YEAR! Let's not get crazy and start firing people. That usually makes things worse.

5) Just to bring things back into perspective, Oregon has ONE top 10 recruiting class in the HISTORY of the program. The fact that we are even competing with the best teams in the country is flat out amazing. Our coaches do not get enough credit for what they have accomplished.
While this is definitely true, our recruiting classes have been top 20 the last 6+ years. That means we should have a top 25 defense.
My 2 cents. Some decent points, but overall it's excuses. There's no reason with our talent, we shouldn't be at least a top 50 defense. I know our offense owns the TOP, but that's no excuse for how poorly we've played to date. Hopefully our players/coaches figure it out and get things turned around.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 7:59 pm
by northbeachsf
Some great discussion here. Don't get me wrong. I am not completely excusing Pellum. He obviously has some responsibility for the results we are seeing right now. However, I just think it is too early for all this "fire him" stuff. Last year we started out by giving up a lot of points too and Pellum eventually got the defense playing well enough to make the Championship game.

Let's look at last year really quick. I don't think you can look at total defensive stats because they are skewed by the number of drives by our opponent and the time of possession. In addition, how many times did we give up scores and/or huge chunks of yards during garbage time?

If you look at the Fremeau Efficiency Index (FEI), our defense was actually solid in 2014. The FEI considers each of the nearly 20,000 possessions every season in major college football. All drives are filtered to eliminate first-half clock-kills and end-of-game garbage drives and scores. A scoring rate analysis of the remaining possessions then determines the baseline possession efficiency expectations against which each team is measured.

Oregon's defensive FEI rank last year? No. 14.
Basically, that means WHEN IN MATTERED in games, Oregon was in the Top 15 for preventing their opponent from scoring.



.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 8:06 pm
by Jaw327
But the bottom line is our defense held a pass-heavy team to one score in the first half, while also getting two turnovers. It's not the doomsday scenario it's being made out to be.
I don't get why people keep saying this - about Georgia State, about EWU - Let's not act like we were playing good teams. We weren't. This is not impressive.
These are, an FCS team and a team that has been in existence for 6 years and has won a total of 4 games. Oregon is supposed to be one of the premiere teams in the country, one of the very best (and we have been). We paid both of these schools close to 1 million dollars a piece to come here to play us and honestly, even though we won, they embarrassed us.

To me the biggest issue is the attitude, the culture. The coaches always talk about a "culture of excellence" but on Defense it's a culture of mediocrity, just listen to the coaches talk about it

Helfrich - "uhh, well you know, yes and no, some good some bad, some, some uhh some really positive things and just a bunch of little things we need to work on"
Pellum - Sheepish grin and some mumbling about fundamentals.


I'll just never get why people are so eager to make excuses for and accept what is statistically a terrible defense. We rank dead last in the Pac-12 in scoring Defense, Passing Defense and Total Defense. Think about that. We all want this team to be great. We all know that we having nothing to do with the team, we are just message board commenters after all. But how some people will make excuses for the D, well, I'll just never get it.

That being said, lets all hope we (the team) turns it around and goes out and kicks some ass.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 8:14 pm
by fpsduck
After 3 games, it's pretty awful. Although our scoring defense continues to improve every game.

I'm hoping Pellum and Co. can get things turned around sooner rather than later.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 8:15 pm
by northbeachsf
I really don't think people are trying to make excuses. I think we can all agree that the defense needs to play better, but I am just in the camp of thinking that we don't need to fly off the handle and start firing people right now. Pellum's defense was solid last year when it mattered. He is dealing with inexpereinced DBs and LBs who lack talent (as outlined in my post above). Oregon runs a defense that expects DBs to be able to cover one on one and expects LBs to fill gaps and make tackles. Right now, we don't have the talent / experience to be able to do that consistently.

It is not just a coaching problem. It is a coaching + talent + experience problem.


Jaw327 wrote:
But the bottom line is our defense held a pass-heavy team to one score in the first half, while also getting two turnovers. It's not the doomsday scenario it's being made out to be.
I don't get why people keep saying this - about Georgia State, about EWU - Let's not act like we were playing good teams. We weren't. This is not impressive.
These are, an FCS team and a team that has been in existence for 6 years and has won a total of 4 games. Oregon is supposed to be one of the premiere teams in the country, one of the very best (and we have been). We paid both of these schools close to 1 million dollars a piece to come here to play us and honestly, even though we won, they embarrassed us.

To me the biggest issue is the attitude, the culture. The coaches always talk about a "culture of excellence" but on Defense it's a culture of mediocrity, just listen to the coaches talk about it

Helfrich - "uhh, well you know, yes and no, some good some bad, some, some uhh some really positive things and just a bunch of little things we need to work on"
Pellum - Sheepish grin and some mumbling about fundamentals.


I'll just never get why people are so eager to make excuses for and accept what is statistically a terrible defense. We rank dead last in the Pac-12 in scoring Defense, Passing Defense and Total Defense. Think about that. We all want this team to be great. We all know that we having nothing to do with the team, we are just message board commenters after all. But how some people will make excuses for the D, well, I'll just never get it.

That being said, lets all hope we (the team) turns it around and goes out and kicks some ass.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Mon Sep 21, 2015 8:40 pm
by pezsez1
What North beach said.

This is a thread to discuss what is wrong with the defense. Not a thread to make sweeping generizations and dismiss discussion as making excuses.

I would still love to hear more analysis of possible failures in our schemes

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2015 9:02 am
by THETADUCK
UOducksTK1 wrote:
northbeachsf wrote:Agree with Pezsez here. I understand that people are pissed about our linebacker play and DB play, but look at what we are dealing with! There are a number of issues going on and this is not just a coaching issue. Some things to consider:

1) Oregon has whiffed during recruiting on some big time defensive prospects over the past several years. Our defense will not be as good as the top tier programs until Oregon is able to start landing some of that talent. I do feel like we are making progress here. However, can you imagine what Budda Baker would do for us right now? There are tons of other examples here we can discuss if you want to get into the weeds. This was going on long before Pellum took over.
This is a meh excuse. Most of our DBs are 4-star or top recruits on our board. Missing on one guy doesn't make or break this team.

Is this true? According to scout: CB Seisey=3-star; CB Amadi=3-star; S Bostic= 3-star; S/CB Kane=3-star; S Oliver=3-star; S McGraw=3-star; CB/S Ihenacho=3 star; Griffin=converted QB; S Williams=3-star. CB Springs & S Robinson are both 4-star recruits, but are both underclassmen and need reps. S Daniels was a 4-star and probably has the most experience. So, we currently have 12 DBs and only 3 were 4-star recruits and only one has more than 2 years of experience. Missing on a couple key recruits combined with the defections is huge right now IMO.

2) Our DBs are extremely inexperienced and we are extremely thin. I am not at all shocked that we are getting lit up right now. When a converted QB makes the 2-deep one week after switching positions and the coaches are basically begging Nelson to switch sides, it is pretty clear that we do not have the talent or depth at that position to perform at a high level right now.
It's true our DB group is a little thin, but that isn't even the main problem. We don't get any pressure and the QB has 3+ seconds to throw. Our LBs have missed more tackles in a 3-game span than I can ever remember. DBs will get it together, I'm less worried about them than our more experienced group.

I totally agree here. We have a lot of young talent in Springs, Seisey, Amadi, Robinson, etc. They will improve quickly with more reps as the season goes on. I am also more worried about the LB situation. Our starting LBs are all upperclassmen and there is probably not a ton of room for improvement. Walker is a good run stopper, but gets exposed in passing situations. Hardrick is the opposite. Prevot and French are both athletic, but probably don't have the right body type to be as successful as Washington or Jordan. I don't think there is a motivation / coaching issue here, it is just lack of talent to get the job done. I really like what I am seeing out of Swain and I am thinking he is going to start getting on the field more. He looks to be solid.

3) We have suffered a huge amount of fallout of the past few years at the LB and DB positions (Robinson, Dunmore, Harrison, Amoako X2, Wallace, Cassell, etc.) That is a lot of players that we were depending on to contribute in some fashion as upperclassmen this year. Just didn't happen for us.
I thought missing out on big recruits was our problem. Other than Robinson, all those guys were 2/3 star guys. I think Wallace would have been graduated by now btw. Plus their voids means some JC guys like Walker, Ragin, Bostick, Heard, etc. Other than Robinson, I doubt any of these losses would have had a significant impact on how we are playing right now.

Fair enough. The thought here is that these guys would all be upperclassmen and that someone likely would have stepped up. Sometimes reps can be more important than talent. Wallace was the same class as Hardrick, but Hardrick used a redshirt, so maybe he would be gone.

4) Yeah, the coaching is not perfect, BUT WE WERE IN THE NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP GAME LAST YEAR! Let's not get crazy and start firing people. That usually makes things worse.

5) Just to bring things back into perspective, Oregon has ONE top 10 recruiting class in the HISTORY of the program. The fact that we are even competing with the best teams in the country is flat out amazing. Our coaches do not get enough credit for what they have accomplished.
While this is definitely true, our recruiting classes have been top 20 the last 6+ years. That means we should have a top 25 defense.

Top 25 measured how? If you measure by yards or points allowed, they will never rank in the Top 25 just due to the fact that they are typically on the field 2/3 of the game. If you look at the DEFI, which was touched on in another post, Oregon has been in the Top 15 in the country since 2010. There is not enough data for this year, but I am guessing that we have slipped a bunch. I do expect us to clean that up here quickly. We are not going to continue to give up 500 yards passing. DBs will get better.

My 2 cents. Some decent points, but overall it's excuses. There's no reason with our talent, we shouldn't be at least a top 50 defense. I know our offense owns the TOP, but that's no excuse for how poorly we've played to date. Hopefully our players/coaches figure it out and get things turned around.

With our talent level and inexperience combined with the amount of time the defense is on the field, I think we would be lucky to Rank in the Top 50 in TOTAL defense. But who really cares about that?? If we can crack the Top 20 in the DFEI, I guarantee we will win the North. We have some work to do in order to make that happen, but I think we will get it done. If we can just get past Utah, we are going to get some good experience against the soft part of our schedule before we have ASU, Stanford, Cal, and USC all in a row.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2015 9:26 am
by karlhungis
fpsduck wrote:After 3 games, it's pretty awful. Although our scoring defense continues to improve every game.

I'm hoping Pellum and Co. can get things turned around sooner rather than later.
I disagree that week 3 was an improvement. I still can't get over the fact that their offensive line managed to get more push during the game than our D, especially when they punched it into the end zone on that goal line stand. That showed me a lot about what our defense is and the only word that came to mind is "soft." We get pushed around by FCS opponents, wiff on arm tackles and can't pressure the QB.

While yes, I agree that things could be worse and Pellum has shown that he can get the team up for a game when it matters..... I am tired of that being acceptable. What happened to Win The Day? What happened to the faceless opponent? Now it's "meh, they are a shitty team so we don't have to worry about it." "We won right?"

I think our defense is unacceptable and it infuriates me that the coaches don't seem to own up to any of it.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2015 9:54 am
by pezsez1
With our talent level and inexperience combined with the amount of time the defense is on the field, I think we would be lucky to Rank in the Top 50 in TOTAL defense. But who really cares about that?? If we can crack the Top 20 in the DFEI, I guarantee we will win the North. We have some work to do in order to make that happen, but I think we will get it done. If we can just get past Utah, we are going to get some good experience against the soft part of our schedule before we have ASU, Stanford, Cal, and USC all in a row.
Pretty much how I feel... but at this point, I'm not sure if we'll honestly improve enough this season to crack that Top 20.

This upcoming Utah game will be interesting. I've read several times in the past (in interviews with coaches) that players tend to improve the most over the course of their first three games. If that's true, then Utah will give us a really good indication of what we can generally expect from our secondary for the rest of the year. There's no denying that our guys looked much better last weekend than they did against EWU, but they still weren't consistent enough against GSU to pull their weight against pass-happy Pac-12 opponents.

Re: Let's talk about that DEFENSE baby!

Posted: Tue Sep 22, 2015 10:07 am
by duckfan22
it will be interesting to see Oregon against Utah. Do we see the Ducks play a 4-3 that i have heard they
have worked on in practice? Will they bring the linebackers up closer? I think because Utah is a better
running team then passing do we dare them to pass? Booker is the real deal at running back. We need to
keep him in check the best we can. Utah likes to use play action also and booker is dangerouse out of the
back field. This weekend i think the linebackers have to show up and play better. We need to be more aggresive
especially on 3rd down. If Utah's QB gets comfortable back there then it may be a longer day. I just dont see
dropping eight back as the best way to stop Utah..Just my take on the D. Not very impressed with it right now.
Thought the D line would play better then they have. They dont seem to get the push as in past years.