Which is a terribly flawed defensive philosophy.
But it is true.
When our offense sucks despite being given extra opportunities, we tend to lose, especially given the speed at which our offense can go three-and-out when struggling.
And our losses tend to be against really good teams -- and usually, you aren't going to beat those teams by scoring 20 points. That's kind of common sense.
Also, because I'm a context guy, let's look at those five Helfrich-era losses:
2013
Lost 26-20 on the road to Stanford (only 13 points by the offense)
Lost 42-16 on the road to Arizona
2014
Lost 34-24 at home to Arizona
Lost 42-20 at a neutral site to Ohio State
2015
31-28 on the road to MSU (only 21 points by the offense)
A few other stats to immediately pull from that:
- Oregon's offense failed to score more than 21 points in four of our five losses...
- Only one of those five losses was at home...
Immediately, you can start to see how this isn't a clear-cut defensive issue.
And what actually happened in those games?
2013
Lost 26-20 on the road to Stanford: Offense was scoreless until the fourth quarter -- with three-and-outs aplenty and multiple turnovers -- and needed late special teams plays to even sniff a possible comeback. Defense couldn't stop the power play.
Verdict: Offense and defense stunk it up.
Lost 42-16 on the road to Arizona: Defense couldn't stop 'Zona, and Oregon's offense... well, 16 points. The Ducks could have held Arizona well below its season average and STILL lost.
Verdict: Offense and defense stunk it up.
2014
Lost 34-24 at home to Arizona: Offensive line was a mess. Defense got beat in the third quarter, and the offense couldn't keep up. Key defensive penalty and an offensive turnover iced the game.
Verdict: This game was a relatively low-scoring slugfest, considering the high-powered offenses of these two teams. Oregon actually held Arizona to its scoring average of 34 points per game. But both the offense and defense blew it on dumb plays late.
Lost 42-20 at a neutral site to Ohio State: Offense couldn't stay on the field, couldn't capitalize on turnovers... and the defense got winded & got ran over.
Verdict: Offense and defense stunk it up.
2015
31-28 on the road to MSU: Offense only scored once through the fourth quarter. Defense played most of the second and third quarters, failed to stop a quick strike by MSU in the fourth before locking down the rest of the game. Offense failed to convert key downs down the stretch and failed to capitalize on two first-half turnovers.
Verdict: Defense faltered just enough in the fourth, but the offense choked for most of the game.
Honestly, you'll find better examples of the defense hanging the offense out to dry if you examine some of our wins. Our narrow Civil War win a couple years ago is a great example of a bad game by the defense, and I'd even say our Rose Bowl win (not in the Helfrich era) was an overall bad defensive performance (we did get a couple huge turnovers, but never could get separation like we do in most games).
But none of our five losses can be pinned squarely on the defense, which is why THE STAT is so useless.
And if you went back just a little bit further, you'd have these two games in which the defense was good, but the offense cost us the game:
2011: Auburn wins, 22-19
2012: Stanford wins, 17-14
So that kind of blows up the whole notion that the offense has never been solely to blame for losing a big game...