Page 1 of 3
I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:04 am
by DAT_man_again
How come the coaches didn't at least try and go with VA again later on the game? Not when it was 48-13 and on but before that. They gave VA one quarter and he was bad. Then they gave Lockie 3 quarters and he was terrible. I am going to be very irked if it's Lockie that we run out there against Colorado. He is Brady Leaf reimagined.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:09 am
by MFRDuckFan
Adams can't throw due to that finger. He is one dimensional and Lockie is all we have at this point.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:11 am
by pdxduck2013
To be honest, I don't think any QB (Aaron Rodgers included) would have looked good behind that O-Line last night. If they had continued to block like they did on that first Lockie drive, I think people would have been calling for him to permanently be the starter after the game, even if we still lost.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:11 am
by OregonFan4Life
It was clear VA didn't WANT to play. He should never have started in my opinion, he was in no way comfortable and when he told Lockie before the game "Be ready" it showed that he didn't want to be playing nor was he ready to.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:18 am
by Alan
Lockie only looked good on his first drive, VA looked terrible. VA couldn't pass, couldn't scramble and only saved being sacked a few more times by being able to fall just across the line of scrimmage. I still question if VA is able to see over the line very well...... We'll know when he gets healthy.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:20 am
by QuackininBama
VA looked totally clueless out there. Confused, making poor decisions, not reading the defense...........nothing I saw had anything to do with his finger.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:28 am
by Brophdog88
QuackininBama wrote:VA looked totally clueless out there. Confused, making poor decisions, not reading the defense...........nothing I saw had anything to do with his finger.
well, except that having no confidence in your ability to control the ball can make you hesitate as to throwing the actual pass itself.
He may have seen many throws but had no confidence he could actually make them.
I'll be honest, I'd rather he NOT throw the ball than throw gifts to the other team like Lockie did 3 times (though only two were actually accepted)
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:30 am
by MFRDuckFan
I keep thinking back to the Michigan State game because this team CAN compete. We came so close to winning that game even with VA's broken finger. The pieces are there.
Coaches have got to stop game planning like Marcus is still here. Go back to what Chip taught ya - design plays around the personnel you have. Make sure guys understand their job. Lockie & the O-line were trying to do too much. When you don't pay attention to your own job & are trying to do someone else's, you fail.
Marcus was Marcus and they could rely on him to bail them out (they got spoiled just as much as we did), but now it's time for the coaches to earn their paychecks. Here is where the rubber meets the road. Gut check time.
I would like to hear the input from those who can pinpoint specific deficiencies (not generalities) and really give constructive criticism along with good discussion about solutions. Not just "he sucks" or "fire him", etc. Can this be fixed? I think so, but I'm not an expert.
I don't think a coach pep talk will solve this. This loss is totally on the coaches.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 9:56 am
by pezsez1
I keep thinking back to the Michigan State game because this team CAN compete. We came so close to winning that game even with VA's broken finger. The pieces are there.
Coaches have got to stop game planning like Marcus is still here. Go back to what Chip taught ya - design plays around the personnel you have. Make sure guys understand their job. Lockie & the O-line were trying to do too much. When you don't pay attention to your own job & are trying to do someone else's, you fail.
Marcus was Marcus and they could rely on him to bail them out (they got spoiled just as much as we did), but now it's time for the coaches to earn their paychecks. Here is where the rubber meets the road. Gut check time.
I would like to hear the input from those who can pinpoint specific deficiencies (not generalities) and really give constructive criticism along with good discussion about solutions. Not just "he sucks" or "fire him", etc. Can this be fixed? I think so, but I'm not an expert.
I don't think a coach pep talk will solve this. This loss is totally on the coaches.
My thoughts exactly.
I'm honestly more worried about the offense right now than I am the defense. I mean, the defense is BAD... but at least with the defense, there's that element of inexperience as well as the coaching issues. On offense, though, there's no reason (like the inexperience on the defense) to be taking such a huge step back. Even without Marcus, we have the personnel and coaching knowledge to light up just about anyone in the land.
So where is it?
Chip was a master at crafting a gameplan to match his personnel, whether that means short QBs like Masoli, scat backs like LaMichael, bruisers like Jonathan Stewart, or even previously bad QBs with potential (Dennis Dixon). And if our QB couldn't throw, then we ran more dynamically, using more pitches, options, zone read, etc. And when we did get a guy who could throw, then we transitioned to be more of a passing team.
I'm not seeing ANY evolution of our offense right now. It's as if they're running the same plays we ran with Marcus, even though whoever we have at QB is a completely different cat.
It's crazy.
My one hope is that the coaching staff was as much in denial as we were about just how important Marcus was to last year's offensive system. But the loss to Utah needs to be a big-time wakeup call that last year's plays won't work anymore.
This was a concern I had BEFORE the Utah game, but I didn't want to make a big deal about it because the talk of last week was the defense... and also, because the one-game sample size of MSU wasn't enough to have valid concerns.
But now... damn. Threat level red.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 10:11 am
by DAT_man_again
pezsez1 wrote:I keep thinking back to the Michigan State game because this team CAN compete. We came so close to winning that game even with VA's broken finger. The pieces are there.
Coaches have got to stop game planning like Marcus is still here. Go back to what Chip taught ya - design plays around the personnel you have. Make sure guys understand their job. Lockie & the O-line were trying to do too much. When you don't pay attention to your own job & are trying to do someone else's, you fail.
Marcus was Marcus and they could rely on him to bail them out (they got spoiled just as much as we did), but now it's time for the coaches to earn their paychecks. Here is where the rubber meets the road. Gut check time.
I would like to hear the input from those who can pinpoint specific deficiencies (not generalities) and really give constructive criticism along with good discussion about solutions. Not just "he sucks" or "fire him", etc. Can this be fixed? I think so, but I'm not an expert.
I don't think a coach pep talk will solve this. This loss is totally on the coaches.
My thoughts exactly.
I'm honestly more worried about the offense right now than I am the defense. I mean, the defense is BAD... but at least with the defense, there's that element of inexperience as well as the coaching issues. On offense, though, there's no reason (like the inexperience on the defense) to be taking such a huge step back. Even without Marcus, we have the personnel and coaching knowledge to light up just about anyone in the land.
So where is it?
Chip was a master at crafting a gameplan to match his personnel, whether that means short QBs like Masoli, scat backs like LaMichael, bruisers like Jonathan Stewart, or even previously bad QBs with potential (Dennis Dixon). And if our QB couldn't throw, then we ran more dynamically, using more pitches, options, zone read, etc. And when we did get a guy who could throw, then we transitioned to be more of a passing team.
I'm not seeing ANY evolution of our offense right now. It's as if they're running the same plays we ran with Marcus, even though whoever we have at QB is a completely different cat.
It's crazy.
My one hope is that the coaching staff was as much in denial as we were about just how important Marcus was to last year's offensive system. But the loss to Utah needs to be a big-time wakeup call that last year's plays won't work anymore.
This was a concern I had BEFORE the Utah game, but I didn't want to make a big deal about it because the talk of last week was the defense... and also, because the one-game sample size of MSU wasn't enough to have valid concerns.
But now... damn. Threat level red.
There is no way that can be true. Our defense is arguably the worst in the power 5 conferences. I am worried about our offense too, but at least they have shown flashes that they can be what they were. With VA at the helm at least. The defense has not shown any flashes that they can stop a nosebleed.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 10:23 am
by vegasdom
This is a running offense and it needs a qb who is a threat to run at any time. Sit Adams until he is healthy and give Alie a shot. Running and short passes is what the Ducks do. Get the play-makers the ball. Defense is a total loss with its current schemes. I think another D-lineman is needed up front (4-3) because the linebackers are getting mauled by opposing O-linemen.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 10:23 am
by pezsez1
There is no way that can be true. Our defense is arguably the worst in the power 5 conferences. I am worried about our offense too, but at least they have shown flashes that they can be what they were.
I'm more worried about the offense because they are absolutely not living up to their sky-high potential.
This defense is bad, yes... but we're talking about a unit that probably only has the potential to be average this season, even with good coaching. Inexperience in the secondary like we have is just killer... we've seen it before. This was a worry I had before the start of the season, and I honestly can't say I'm blindsided. And our defense has also shown flashes of someday being a good unit, with a decent showing on the road against Michigan State.
But our offense should still be among the best in the land, and right now, it's... not even close. It's terrible, too. And there's literally not a single reason or excuse for that, given all the weapons & experience we have. This offense should be way beyond showing flashes of potential.
Especially with such a bad defense, our offense simply can't afford to go three-and-out on so many possessions. It seemed like Utah started each of its drives near midfield. Especially this year, we can't keep putting our defense in that position and expect anything good to come up it. Our D needs all the help it can get, and our O should be good enough to at least win the field position battle more often. That's such a minimal expectation.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 10:53 am
by maxduck
Doesn't quarterback recruiting and development fall on Scott Frost? Isn't he responsible for developing the offensive game plan?
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 10:55 am
by UOducksTK1
vegasdom wrote:This is a running offense and it needs a qb who is a threat to run at any time.
Very good point. We are totally losing a dimension with the QBs we have on our roster. We almost never run an option anymore, expect a standing read option. We've tried adjusting our play calls to fit our QBs, but it's not working. We need QBs who fit our system.
Re: I know VA was bad, but Lockie was worse
Posted: Sun Sep 27, 2015 1:18 pm
by FlDuckFan
Why not give Morgan a look?