Page 1 of 1

Hey Helf, it's obvious, "if it walks like a Duck......

Posted: Mon Sep 28, 2015 2:07 pm
by srsmiley007
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, than it's probably a duck.

Helf, I know we're all simple uneducated fans but this fact is true, gap control defense with DL absorbing blocks doesn't work. When can you take a step back and see the obvious. I look at our DLineman stance and contrast that with SEC defenses or even BSU and it's a guaranteed 3 yards for anyone who can rush the ball. When was the last time we stopped a 3rd and 1. Ugh, can you say almost never.....

Here's the obvious (and I coached):

1.) DL absorbing blocks doesn't work against power running teams. Sorry to burst your bubble but a 230 LB, 5 yards deep, isn't going to stop a solid RB and pulling guard in short yardage situations.

2.) Pass rush is weaker unless it's an obvious passing down. The transition from space eater to pass rush cost's them roughly .5 seconds which is why none of our DL ever mount much in the way of sack totals.

3.) Surprise a "Pressure D" can also generate Turnovers. You don't have to drop 8 in confusing coverages. Oh, and it tends to stuff the running game as well.

4.) Receivers have to be challenged. They can't have free reign for 15 yards. If you had a pressure D, you could press, slow up the route, and
the pressure generated would result in either a bad throw, sack or no gain.

5.) Question: How many times has an Oregon D held a quality Power 5 competitor to less than 10 points in the last decade? There's your answer... Alabama does that every year, even USC does it. How about us? Do we do it,,, no... At least since Pellum took over. He at least had an excuse, we didn't have the talent on the DL. Can we get BSU's DC or anyone that is a pressure architect.

6.) Question: How many elite Defensive players come here (Neal is exempt here). Again why (and Armstead was a 5* OL not DL)? Theres another answer.... We almost never score a 5* DL or LB? Why? Certainly Pellum's recruiting skills won't be missed...:)

Comments:
Jameis wasn't all that off when he said they beat themselves. If not for silly turnovers and the best QB in school history we would have lost. They were trucking our D. He's taken an average Aliotti defense and actually made it worse. I saw multiple plays where they had 6 blockers to 5 in the box and Blitz schemes with absolutely no coverage or free release without press or man. The most retarded was trying to drop Defo deep into coverage to defend a streak from his DL position on the blitz, not hook -to- curl in place of the MLB, but actually man on the slot receiver. WTF??

We have the talent to at least field a top 30 defense and yet to have one. At least Aliotti could scheme for the big games.

Pellum is a fool. All he does is bumble about with a vanilla scheme and talk about communication and pad level which is football 101. Our blitzing is uncreative, twists and the pass rush don't work on anything but 3rd and long and with our talent that's a joke.... Bend but don't break and pray for a turnover... Sorry but that doesn't work well unless you have the best QB in the nation and actually get a INT every so often putting teams on their heals and taking the power game away from them.

NOTE: HOW MANY ELITE LB'S AND DL HAS OREGON PUT OUT IN THE LAST 15 YEARS= NOT MANY...)
Kiko Alonso is their only LB success story in 10 years and that was for 1 year only before his body blew up. Jordan is a bust and no one else at the LB position has amounted to much more than a backup or 1-2 year starter(Matthews) in the NFL. Time to gooooo..... This is the reason we can't get good DL and LB talent. The scheme is not a springboard to the pro's.

Re: Hey Helf, it's obvious, "if it walks like a Duck......

Posted: Mon Sep 28, 2015 2:15 pm
by OregonFan4Life
Wow, bravo, one heck of a post. Well done, very educated and thorough, I'm very impressed! The only thing, last time Oregon held a Power 5 conference for to under 10 points, AZ in 2012, but they had a bunch of bad miscues so that helped.

Re: Hey Helf, it's obvious, "if it walks like a Duck......

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2015 12:04 pm
by srsmiley007
OregonFan4Life wrote:Wow, bravo, one heck of a post. Well done, very educated and thorough, I'm very impressed! The only thing, last time Oregon held a Power 5 conference for to under 10 points, AZ in 2012, but they had a bunch of bad miscues so that helped.
Yeah, I said "He" but meant to say Alliotti. He mastered scheme adjustment and just didn't have the talent to pursue quite as much aggression as I think he may have had he stayed. Our ability to get significant DL talent here I believe dictated some of the scheme along with the pass orientation of our conference. However, that's just an assumption. In either instance, it was clear that the scheme that is being deployed isn't working. There's no way it should be so difficult that you can't assimilate a strong understanding of the scheme after both fall and spring ball.

Also, hearing the coach "BS" at MH's conference was ridiculous. He has all the talent, if they can't pick up a scheme after this much time than there's a problem. It's either that or the scheme doesn't work. I'm a fan of the latter and I believe some other Pac 10 coaches have substantiated this as well. When your peers start bagging on you in the media than you know it's clearly bad. I was hoping that he was hiding something in the first game and saving it for the MSU game. Whoops, my bad. My hope for Pellum is completely dashed at this juncture. We saw it for 12 months last year and his sampling this year. Simply put, he's not a good coach.... The only way we have won is with turnovers. They appeared to be the precipice for this defense but again, that's a dangerous philosophy to bend the entire defense around; We'll give up yards and hope for a turnover." We have to be able to stop a team in 1 series. We can't accomplish this the way we play. Fast offense or not, a 3 down defensive series is the best way to defeat both power and passing teams. That will not get accomplished with this scheme...Ever....

My concern for DP is his only exposure to defensive philosophy has been derived solely from the Oregon experience. Guys like Orlando or others have traveled around and been exposed with different teams whereas DP only knows NA's core defense. Additionally, he doesn't have the ability to adapt schematically like NA could. NA adjusted the D every week and utilized tactical adjustment to address some of the bend-don't-break flaws. We do none of that now. From what I can see, it looks like Neal did that last year but DP didn't. TIME TO RETIRE!!!!

Re: Hey Helf, it's obvious, "if it walks like a Duck......

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2015 1:35 pm
by timberduck
Canton Kaumatule and Arrion Springs were both 5-stars.

Re: Hey Helf, it's obvious, "if it walks like a Duck......

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2015 2:02 pm
by UOducksTK1
timberduck wrote:Canton Kaumatule and Arrion Springs were both 5-stars.
Springs was actually rated a four star by 247 and scout, and a three star by rivals.

Re: Hey Helf, it's obvious, "if it walks like a Duck......

Posted: Tue Sep 29, 2015 2:43 pm
by timberduck
UOducksTK1 wrote:
timberduck wrote:Canton Kaumatule and Arrion Springs were both 5-stars.
Springs was actually rated a four star by 247 and scout, and a three star by rivals.
I could have sworn that he had a 5-star at one point.