Page 1 of 1
QB recruiting
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 7:39 pm
by maxduck
Did Oregon look at any JC QB's last year?
They knew MM was declaring for the draft, they had to know what they had in Lockie (if they didn't that is even worse) and yet I don't remember any JC kids even visiting. Not sure when Adams cam into the conversation but even I know you need more than one capable QB over the course of a season. Shouldn't Scott Frost visit every JC in the country looking for a player that can throw the ball more than 10 yards?
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 7:55 pm
by rentdodger1
maxduck wrote:Did Oregon look at any JC QB's last year?
They knew MM was declaring for the draft, they had to know what they had in Lockie (if they didn't that is even worse) and yet I don't remember any JC kids even visiting. Not sure when Adams cam into the conversation but even I know you need more than one capable QB over the course of a season. Shouldn't Scott Frost visit every JC in the country looking for a player that can throw the ball more than 10 yards?
The coaches had 2 years to bring in a top flight guy. Part of coaching is creating that pipeline to maintain. This is a huge fail and there is no excuse for a top 5 program to put guys on the field(Lockie and Alie) that could not start in the Big Sky. The sad part is even with these guys at QB and a decent defense, this is an 8 win team.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 9:45 pm
by hjpop
Our QB Recruiting:
2011: Marcus Mariota, Johnny Manziel (To A&M)
2012: Jeff Lockie, Jake Rodriguez (To SDSU?)
2013: Damien Hobbs (Left to...?)
2014: Morgan Mahalak (M.I.A. right now)
2015: Travis Waller/Jonsen (Injury), Vernon Adams
Doesn't really inspire confidence in our ability to get a decent top-flight guy out here.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 10:05 pm
by lukeyrid13
Missing on kyler Murray last year was massive for our program.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 10:17 pm
by DmoneyDuck
This year is bad but at least Adams will come back shortly ... Next year, next year is what truly scares me. It's apparent Lockie and Alie are not PAC12 caliber quarterbacks. That leaves MM, Jonsen and two true Freshman. We're really going to have to hope that MM or TJ make huge strides this offseason or I'm afriad we're in for another season like this.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sat Oct 10, 2015 10:21 pm
by hjpop
TJ looked good in the Spring game (not indicative of anything, I know) but I have to wonder if MM is gone at the end of this year. Alie has moments of brilliance but it's not consistent enough and Lockie has a confidence problem that won't go away. I really have to wonder how the coaches could whiff on so many guys considering what would likely happen after MM left. That was pretty much a given starting the recruiting for last year.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 12:23 am
by greenyellow
With how poor the QB play has been, it makes you wonder if Mariota scared off many of the good QBs they went after because they wanted early playing time and didn't want to sit behind him for 2-3 years.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 6:52 am
by SuperDuck
hjpop wrote:Our QB Recruiting:
2011: Marcus Mariota, Johnny Manziel (To A&M)
2012: Jeff Lockie, Jake Rodriguez (To SDSU?)
2013: Damien Hobbs (Left to...?)
2014: Morgan Mahalak (M.I.A. right now)
2015: Travis Waller/Jonsen (Injury), Vernon Adams
Doesn't really inspire confidence in our ability to get a decent top-flight guy out here.
2011: Excellent
2012: Excellent, at least on paper. Both Lockie and JakeRod were 4 star recruits.
2013: Questionable. I'm not sure the staff looked at QB as being a real position of need when they took him and thought they might get a diamond in the rough.
2014: Mahalak's lack of work ethic and not picking up the system quickly is on him - NOT the staff! He's another 4 star recruit. An ex-player on ESPN touched on why highly regarded QBs fail half the time. They're primadonna's in high school and get to college with a sense of entitlement. Many lack the work ethic necessary to make it at the next level. Mahalak may very well fall into that category.
2015: I think we can attribute much of our troubles this season on that one EWU player that hit VA late, giving him a concussion and broken finger. If VA had played every game at 100% we'd be 5-1 right now. I think the UO should hire "Guido & Vinnie" to go get some payback. (Teasing, of course) That one play may have cost the school dearly this season.
I think Travis Waller/Jonsen is the QB of the future. Everything I've read about this kid raves on about his born leadership and work ethic. Unless we can bring in a super QB recruit this year I don't see much in the cupboard.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 7:07 am
by buckmarkduck
How do you include Manziel? He was committed for all of a month. Randall was a commit for 9 months before not being able to get into UO, now is sucks at Arizona.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 7:21 am
by Alan
Superduck beat me to the punch and stated what I was thinking. To me it sounds like Mahalek is a spoiled primadonna, top dog in high school, nationally recruited and now a also ran. I wonder how many of the highly rated, highly publicized kids in high school can make the mental adjustment to not being the guy in a college program.
Look at Mariota, he never started at QB in high school until his senior year. He had two big college offers, the Ducks and Washington. He never had to make that mental adjustment, he came to Oregon hungry and ready to compete.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 7:28 am
by buckmarkduck
One issue Alan, Morgan, like Marcus didn't start until his sr year. He sat behind a guy by the name of Goff for 3 years. I think his work ethic has nothing to do with being the man in HS, it's just who he has been since arriving at UO.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Sun Oct 11, 2015 7:35 am
by Alan
buckmarkduck wrote:One issue Alan, Morgan, like Marcus didn't start until his sr year. He sat behind a guy by the name of Goff for 3 years. I think his work ethic has nothing to do with being the man in HS, it's just who he has been since arriving at UO.
Why can't he dig into the play book? Also my thought on Mahalek's attitude is only an opinion not fact.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 12:52 pm
by UOducksTK1
SuperDuck wrote:hjpop wrote:Our QB Recruiting:
2011: Marcus Mariota, Johnny Manziel (To A&M)
2012: Jeff Lockie, Jake Rodriguez (To SDSU?)
2013: Damien Hobbs (Left to...?)
2014: Morgan Mahalak (M.I.A. right now)
2015: Travis Waller/Jonsen (Injury), Vernon Adams
Doesn't really inspire confidence in our ability to get a decent top-flight guy out here.
2011: Excellent
2012: Excellent, at least on paper. Both Lockie and JakeRod were 4 star recruits.
2013: Questionable. I'm not sure the staff looked at QB as being a real position of need when they took him and thought they might get a diamond in the rough.
2014: Mahalak's lack of work ethic and not picking up the system quickly is on him - NOT the staff! He's another 4 star recruit. An ex-player on ESPN touched on why highly regarded QBs fail half the time. They're primadonna's in high school and get to college with a sense of entitlement. Many lack the work ethic necessary to make it at the next level. Mahalak may very well fall into that category.
2015: I think we can attribute much of our troubles this season on that one EWU player that hit VA late, giving him a concussion and broken finger. If VA had played every game at 100% we'd be 5-1 right now. I think the UO should hire "Guido & Vinnie" to go get some payback. (Teasing, of course) That one play may have cost the school dearly this season.
I think Travis Waller/Jonsen is the QB of the future. Everything I've read about this kid raves on about his born leadership and work ethic. Unless we can bring in a super QB recruit this year I don't see much in the cupboard.
Jeff Lockie wasn't a four star. He was a 3-star on all the sites, and Rivals had him as our 5th worst recruit of our 21 commits in that class. His only offers were San Diego State and Oregon:
http://sports.yahoo.com/ncaa/football/r ... kie-119925
http://247sports.com/Player/Jeff-Lockie ... tion=27249
http://www.scout.com/player/152283-jeff ... 2011&s=128
I was pretty excited about Rodrigues when he committed, but that didn't work out either.
Re: QB recruiting
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 7:51 pm
by StevensTechU
To answer maxduck's question, yes, they did look into a JC. They came close to offering a dual-threat kid named Trenton Hosick out of Arizona Western. His backstory is he originally signed with Missouri but ultimately ended up at a JC. It's actually a good thing they didn't, because apparently he followed up a pretty respectable first year with a clunker this year, and he's been benched in favor of another kid.
As far as this year's group of JUCO QBs, there's no no-brainers like Jake Waters, Chad Kelly or Cam Newton. 247 doesn't rate a single QB in the top 40 JUCO prospects. From what I can tell, the best dual threat is former uw QB Troy Williams. Williams is in his last year at a JC and would be an adequate pickup for the Ducks, IMO. His performance as a redshirt freshman at uw doesn't scream "All-Conference" but I have little doubt he'd be better than Lockie and Alie.
http://cccaasports.org/sports/fball/201 ... lliamszspw