Page 1 of 2
Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 1:10 pm
by UOducksTK1
I think not. In fact, I think this just shows us how unprepared our coaches are and how bad our defense is. Whether you like to admit it or not, Mariota made Frost (and even Helf) look like fantastic coaches. Drop in average QBs, and you have an offense that is average by Pac-12 standards. If it weren't for perhaps the best RB in the country, we'd be under .500 right now. Coaches show no creativity or adjustment skills. We're stuck right now.
And then there's defense. An average offense just shows how bad DP and the defense really is. We've been utterly exposed. And while I probably don't need stats to justify my claim or defend myself, here's a few defensive stats for giggles. There are 128 teams in the NCAA. Oregon ranks 113th in YPG. 125th in Passing YPG. 116th in PPG.
Given our record and stats so far, we aren't just bad, but we are one of the worst in the Pac-12. Like I said, we shouldn't blame Alie or Lockie (Or Mariota for leaving early). All they've done is shown our coaching staff's true colors. I'd like to think things have changed, but given our performances the last three games, I see almost no adjustments to help us win more games.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 2:03 pm
by karlhungis
I look at them similar to how I look at the defense, I think a different coaching staff could make them more productive than they are right now. I don't think either of them would be amazing anywhere but I do think they could be a lot better than they are. It is mind boggling that neither of them seem capable of hitting anything deeper than 10 yards down the field.
I don't think our coaching staff has set them up for success.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 2:09 pm
by StevensTechU
You're implying the poor results are attributable to one thing.
Alie/Lockie aren't good. The DBs aren't good. But everything ultimately falls on the coaches (because they recruit, prepare, and call the game), so it's the staff that gets the blame at the end of the day. But probably won't stop me from saying Lockie stinks.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 2:32 pm
by UOducksTK1
StevensTechU wrote:You're implying the poor results are attributable to one thing.
Alie/Lockie aren't good. The DBs aren't good. But everything ultimately falls on the coaches (because they recruit, prepare, and call the game), so it's the staff that gets the blame at the end of the day. But probably won't stop me from saying Lockie stinks.
No I'm implying the lack of a real QB really shows how many holes we have. We were able to hide behind Mariota the last couple years (even the defense). No longer is this possible, and now we see we have more problems than we knew previously.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 3:04 pm
by OregonFan4Life
I agree 100%. I said before the year that I was worried about the coaches. I used the play against MSU when Oregon was down and Mariota made a crazy play this resulted in the win. The MSU defensive staff literally knew what play was coming and Gruden pointed out how they were yelling it out on the sidelines, but Mariota pulled off magic per usual and led the team to a big win. Mariota was literally that amazing, the most valuable player in college football history.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 3:32 pm
by rockthief
One would expect the coaches to plan plays that fit the QBs skills and attributes. That only makes sense. But they seem to put a QB out their hoping one of them finally gets it whatever it is. Coaches need work, some hard looks at themselves and their methods.
GO DUCKS!
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 3:39 pm
by thomas time
Why not play Ty at qb till Vernon comes back, is he really as bad as these two guys
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 4:11 pm
by QuackininBama
UOducksTK1 wrote:(Or Mariota for leaving early)
To be more accurate, he did graduate so its not really leaving early

Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 6:56 pm
by StevensTechU
thomas time wrote:Why not play Ty at qb till Vernon comes back, is he really as bad as these two guys
Yes. When you're a QB that gets moved to cornerback, you have to be pretty bad.
I don't fully get the 'maximize the talents you have' case, because to me it really seems like they're trying. When VA plays, I think they run him too much, but when Lockie is out there they try to give him short routes and dump options on every pass, he just can't even do that somehow.
On the flip side of your point at the start of the thread, what stinks is the QB/DB play is so bad that it covers up some real bright spots, too. I think the DL and outside linebacker play has actually been pretty darn good, but it's all for not. Oregon had 7 sacks and 13 total TFLs against Wazzu. If anyone told me we'd get 13 TFL's and would rush for over 300 yards, I'd think that's a guaranteed victory.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 7:13 pm
by DAT_man_again
Manziel and RG3 didn't go to national championship games. One guy, no matter how special, can not get you to a title game without coaching. Plus Helfrich FOUND MM. I still have faith in Helf and Frost. We lost because we are on our second and third string quarterbacks and our defense is terrible. It's not Helfs fault that VA broke his finger. What if Marcus missed three games last year? Still think we would have gone 13-1? Not comparing VA to Marcus but the fact is we would be 5-1 if VA hadn't broken his finger with the only loss to Utah. And then nobody would be calling for Helf's head.
The only coaching I would point to is DP. This defense is way too talented to be this bad. And nobody is hurt. That points to coaching.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 7:23 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
DAT_man_again wrote:Manziel and RG3 didn't go to national championship games. One guy, no matter how special, can not get you to a title game without coaching. Plus Helfrich FOUND MM. I still have faith in Helf and Frost. We lost because we are on our second and third string quarterbacks and our defense is terrible. It's not Helfs fault that VA broke his finger. What if Marcus missed three games last year? Still think we would have gone 13-1? Not comparing VA to Marcus but the fact is we would be 5-1 if VA hadn't broken his finger with the only loss to Utah. And then nobody would be calling for Helf's head.
The only coaching I would point to is DP. This defense is way too talented to be this bad. And nobody is hurt. That points to coaching.
Agreed. I just posted something similar in another thread.
There's way more evidence that supports Helf being a good coach than there is pointing to the opposite. I like that you brought up that he was the one who found Mariota too. In all the talk about Mariota making Helf look good, people seem to forget that Helf if the one who found him, recruited him and developed him.
And again, if VA's healthy we are 5-1. And none of these conversations are happening. The mast majority of team in the country would be in a bad way if they lost their starter.
Pellum has to go though. The defense needs a total rehaul.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 7:40 pm
by FlDuckFan
dthomas=ddixon wrote:DAT_man_again wrote:Manziel and RG3 didn't go to national championship games. One guy, no matter how special, can not get you to a title game without coaching. Plus Helfrich FOUND MM. I still have faith in Helf and Frost. We lost because we are on our second and third string quarterbacks and our defense is terrible. It's not Helfs fault that VA broke his finger. What if Marcus missed three games last year? Still think we would have gone 13-1? Not comparing VA to Marcus but the fact is we would be 5-1 if VA hadn't broken his finger with the only loss to Utah. And then nobody would be calling for Helf's head.
The only coaching I would point to is DP. This defense is way too talented to be this bad. And nobody is hurt. That points to coaching.
Agreed. I just posted something similar in another thread.
There's way more evidence that supports Helf being a good coach than there is pointing to the opposite. I like that you brought up that he was the one who found Mariota too.
In all the talk about Mariota making Helf look good, people seem to forget that Helf if the one who found him, recruited him and developed him.
And again, if VA's healthy we are 5-1. And none of these conversations are happening. The mast majority of team in the country would be in a bad way if they lost their starter.
Pellum has to go though. The defense needs a total rehaul.
To bad he couldn't develop anyone else aside from Mariota. Lockie not being able to throw it 10+ yds down field, seems to me he may have gotten lucky.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Mon Oct 12, 2015 8:06 pm
by DAT_man_again
FlDuckFan wrote:dthomas=ddixon wrote:DAT_man_again wrote:Manziel and RG3 didn't go to national championship games. One guy, no matter how special, can not get you to a title game without coaching. Plus Helfrich FOUND MM. I still have faith in Helf and Frost. We lost because we are on our second and third string quarterbacks and our defense is terrible. It's not Helfs fault that VA broke his finger. What if Marcus missed three games last year? Still think we would have gone 13-1? Not comparing VA to Marcus but the fact is we would be 5-1 if VA hadn't broken his finger with the only loss to Utah. And then nobody would be calling for Helf's head.
The only coaching I would point to is DP. This defense is way too talented to be this bad. And nobody is hurt. That points to coaching.
Agreed. I just posted something similar in another thread.
There's way more evidence that supports Helf being a good coach than there is pointing to the opposite. I like that you brought up that he was the one who found Mariota too.
In all the talk about Mariota making Helf look good, people seem to forget that Helf if the one who found him, recruited him and developed him.
And again, if VA's healthy we are 5-1. And none of these conversations are happening. The mast majority of team in the country would be in a bad way if they lost their starter.
Pellum has to go though. The defense needs a total rehaul.
To bad he couldn't develop anyone else aside from Mariota. Lockie not being able to throw it 10+ yds down field, seems to me he may have gotten lucky.
Why is it not the other way around? Why isn't he unlucky that the 4 star QB turned out to suck, the real starter is hurt and the redshirt prodigy is out for the year?
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2015 6:23 am
by UofDuck
But part of Helf showing he's a good head coach is taking care of his business. If our D coordinator is sub par, he needs to deal with that. It really is that simple. CEO's have to make the tough calls.
Re: Is this Lockie/Alie's fault?
Posted: Tue Oct 13, 2015 8:19 am
by dthomas=ddixon
I also want to add that this idea that we could fire Helf and go out and get whoever we want is fantasy. For one, there isn't that many great coaches out there. And secondly, if they are great they're already coaching somewhere. So unless you get really lucky you end up taking a huge risk on a relatively unproven coach.