Page 1 of 3
Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 7:59 am
by StevensTechU
Based on feedback, maybe I'll do this on a semi-regular basis, but I just want to write a summary of observations of what & how Oregon is doing on the football recruiting trail. There is so much information -- 247, Scout, Rivals, Oregonlive, ESPN, social media -- and so many targets, that it can get confusing pretty easily. Not only that, but teenagers change their minds often, and those reporting can sometimes skew the real picture so they can satisfy fanbases (their customers) and also not damage relationships with recruits (their suppliers).
The Past: Oregon has 14 commitments, which excludes Seth Green (QB). Why exclude Green? What we can gleam from the available information is that Oregon's staff, while thinking Green was a great get initially, significantly cooled on his prospects when he moved to Texas and was beat out for the starting job at Allen HS by a much less physically gifted, younger QB. Green visited Oregon on 9/26, and it appears Oregon's coaches pitched the idea of him moving to tight end so they could make room for another QB commitment, and the two sides parted ways. The QB the UO staff wanted to make room for is local product Justin Herbert of Sheldon HS, who has since committed to the Ducks.
Most Recent Commitment: Bryson Young (Clovis, CA), Drop End. 4*. Young has long been an Oregon lean, and it just took an official visit to seal the deal. That gives Oregon 2 drop end commits, though Bryson Young might grow into a defensive end, and Hunter Kampmoyer could potentially move inside or to the offensive side to play tight end.
Who's Next: So much to be said here. Arguably Oregon's top target is Nigel Knott, a cornerback out of Mississippi whose father played for John Neal in the 90s. The younger Knott is arguably the top cornerback in the country, and while not overly imposing physically, has tremendous athleticism and a quiet confidence about him. After his visit, Knott postponed a planned commitment ceremony, and started following (on twitter) a video production coordinator from Bleacher Report who has made a number of commitment videos for other recruits (Naseir Upshur, Iman Marshall, et al). While Knott doesn't say a lot, the activity of him following Oregon commitments and them following back gives quite a bit of reason for optimism that he could 'quack.'
Anything to be Worried About (see update on page 2): Oregon's top overall commit is Jared Mayden, a CB from Sachse, TX. Mayden has visited Michigan and Georgia since committing to the Ducks, and while his whole family likes Oregon, he seems to still want to see what other options are out there. Coach Neal seems to have given him an ultimatum: Stay committed but stop taking visits, or decommit and keep visiting other schools. Seems he's set to make a decision this week on that, and I'd say it's 50/50 which way it will go.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 8:21 am
by StevensTechU
As this is the first time doing this, there is a bit more to cover than what I imagine a routine update would look like (above), particularly on what could be coming on the horizon.
Who's Next (Part 2): Being overlooked is Brandon Bowen, a 6'5, 230 lb drop end from Texas and nephew of former San Antonio Spur Bruce Bowen. Brandon visited Eugene in September (
http://www.scout.com/college/oregon/sto ... regon-trip), and continues to show interest in the Ducks based on twitter activity, recently following position coach Erik Chinander and the University of Oregon general account. While he's a hard pull to get away from Baylor, Oregon's scheme is a huge advantage here. If Bowen wants to play at Baylor, he'll need to add approximately 40-60 lbs to become a defensive end in their 4-3 scheme. As noted above, there could be a logjam at drop end, but Bowen is by far the most athletic of Young, Kampmoyer, and himself. It's high praise, but Bowen athletically compares to Christian French and Dion Jordan.
Visiting this last weekend that could become Ducks are linebacker Keith Simms (Bethesda, MD), who has always liked the Ducks and seems to have loved the visit, and Calvin Bundage, a safety from Oklahoma who could be the biggest punisher in the defensive backfield since John Boyett. At this point in time, Oregon has to be viewed as the front runner for Simms, and he could end his recruitment any time. Bundage is likely to take some more visits, but Oregon will remain in the game for a while. It's worth noting that Oregon may have put themselves solidly in the #2 spot for highly-regarded Caleb Kelly. If something dramatic happens at Oklahoma, he could end up at Oregon, but for now they have a sizable lead.
From Oregon's View: With 14 commitments, 2 'likely' commitments, and a few more potential quacks, Oregon has to choose wisely from here on out. The 2016 class is likely going to end up in the 17-20 range, so they need to look hard at what they need. That could mean 1 or zero defensive linemen after a big haul in 2015, and it could mean only 1 more wide receiver (2 total). The murkiest positions remain the defensive backfield, where there are potential commitments and decommitments, and linebacker, where Pellum/Chinander have taken somewhat of a 'throw s*** at the wall and see what sticks' approach.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 9:15 am
by srsmiley007
StevensTechU wrote:As this is the first time doing this, there is a bit more to cover than what I imagine a routine update would look like (above), particularly on what could be coming on the horizon.
Who's Next (Part 2): Being overlooked is Brandon Bowen, a 6'5, 230 lb drop end from Texas and nephew of former San Antonio Spur Bruce Bowen. Brandon visited Eugene in September (
http://www.scout.com/college/oregon/sto ... regon-trip), and continues to show interest in the Ducks based on twitter activity, recently following position coach Erik Chinander and the University of Oregon general account. While he's a hard pull to get away from Baylor, Oregon's scheme is a huge advantage here. If Bowen wants to play at Baylor, he'll need to add approximately 40-60 lbs to become a defensive end in their 4-3 scheme. As noted above, there could be a logjam at drop end, but Bowen is by far the most athletic of Young, Kampmoyer, and himself. It's high praise, but Bowen athletically compares to Christian French and Dion Jordan.
Visiting this last weekend that could become Ducks are linebacker Keith Simms (Bethesda, MD), who has always liked the Ducks and seems to have loved the visit, and Calvin Bundage, a safety from Oklahoma who could be the biggest punisher in the defensive backfield since John Boyett. At this point in time, Oregon has to be viewed as the front runner for Simms, and he could end his recruitment any time. Bundage is likely to take some more visits, but Oregon will remain in the game for a while. It's worth noting that Oregon may have put themselves solidly in the #2 spot for highly-regarded Caleb Kelly. If something dramatic happens at Oklahoma, he could end up at Oregon, but for now they have a sizable lead.
From Oregon's View: With 14 commitments, 2 'likely' commitments, and a few more potential quacks, Oregon has to choose wisely from here on out. The 2016 class is likely going to end up in the 17-20 range, so they need to look hard at what they need. That could mean 1 or zero defensive linemen after a big haul in 2015, and it could mean only 1 more wide receiver (2 total). The murkiest positions remain the defensive backfield, where there are potential commitments and decommitments, and linebacker, where Pellum/Chinander have taken somewhat of a 'throw s*** at the wall and see what sticks' approach.
Great job and summary. Extremely helpful for those of us without access to DT (bolts), Scout and Rivals. This is the kind of inside info that's appreciated and welcome. Thanks a ton for posting this. It clears up a number of factors..... Let's hope Oklahoma tanks and our offense kicks into gear and we get Knott,Kelly, Bundage, Simms(Oh Please) and Bowen. Would like to keep Mayden but if I had to trade would gladly take Knott. Also, from what I saw of Kelly he can play inside and out based upon his quickness, size, etc.
Let's hope we can tie these kids up, sign them, than Pellum retires and someone who understands defense takes over.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 9:16 am
by jimmy12
Well done. Thanks for this effort.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 9:50 am
by mrpd21
I really appreciate you taking the time to compile this along with your thoughtful analysis. Thank you! If you enjoy doing it, I'll definitely enjoy continuing to read.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:20 am
by dthomas=ddixon
Great job man. Thanks for taking the time to post all of that.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:24 am
by UOducksTK1
StevensTechU wrote:Based on feedback, maybe I'll do this on a semi-regular basis, but I just want to write a summary of observations of what & how Oregon is doing on the football recruiting trail. There is so much information -- 247, Scout, Rivals, Oregonlive, ESPN, social media -- and so many targets, that it can get confusing pretty easily. Not only that, but teenagers change their minds often, and those reporting can sometimes skew the real picture so they can satisfy fanbases (their customers) and also not damage relationships with recruits (their suppliers).
The Past: Oregon has 14 commitments, which excludes Seth Green (QB). Why exclude Green? What we can gleam from the available information is that Oregon's staff, while thinking Green was a great get initially, significantly cooled on his prospects when he moved to Texas and was beat out for the starting job at Allen HS by a much less physically gifted, younger QB. Green visited Oregon on 9/26, and it appears Oregon's coaches pitched the idea of him moving to tight end so they could make room for another QB commitment, and the two sides parted ways. The QB the UO staff wanted to make room for is local product Justin Herbert of Sheldon HS, who has since committed to the Ducks.
Most Recent Commitment: Bryson Young (Clovis, CA), Drop End. 4*. Young has long been an Oregon lean, and it just took an official visit to seal the deal. That gives Oregon 2 drop end commits, though Bryson Young might grow into a defensive end, and Hunter Kampmoyer could potentially move inside or to the offensive side to play tight end.
Who's Next: So much to be said here. Arguably Oregon's top target is Nigel Knott, a cornerback out of Mississippi whose father played for John Neal in the 90s. The younger Knott is arguably the top cornerback in the country, and while not overly imposing physically, has tremendous athleticism and a quiet confidence about him. After his visit, Knott postponed a planned commitment ceremony, and started following (on twitter) a video production coordinator from Bleacher Report who has made a number of commitment videos for other recruits (Naseir Upshur, Iman Marshall, et al). While Knott doesn't say a lot, the activity of him following Oregon commitments and them following back gives quite a bit of reason for optimism that he could 'quack.'
Anything to be Worried About: Oregon's top overall commit is Jared Mayden, a CB from Sachse, TX. Mayden has visited Michigan and Georgia since committing to the Ducks, and while his whole family likes Oregon, he seems to still want to see what other options are out there. Coach Neal seems to have given him an ultimatum: Stay committed but stop taking visits, or decommit and keep visiting other schools. Seems he's set to make a decision this week on that, and I'd say it's 50/50 which way it will go.
The Green situation is interesting. He's taken over starting duties at QB for Allen after coming off the bench the first few games. He's been playing well since:
Passing: 62-93 (67%) 1,008 yards and 14 TDs to 5 INTs
Rushing: 49 rushes for 566 yards and 5 TDs
He leads the tam in passing yards, passing TDs, rushing yards, and rushing TDs.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:27 am
by woundedknees
UOducksTK1 wrote:StevensTechU wrote:Based on feedback, maybe I'll do this on a semi-regular basis, but I just want to write a summary of observations of what & how Oregon is doing on the football recruiting trail. There is so much information -- 247, Scout, Rivals, Oregonlive, ESPN, social media -- and so many targets, that it can get confusing pretty easily. Not only that, but teenagers change their minds often, and those reporting can sometimes skew the real picture so they can satisfy fanbases (their customers) and also not damage relationships with recruits (their suppliers).
The Past: Oregon has 14 commitments, which excludes Seth Green (QB). Why exclude Green? What we can gleam from the available information is that Oregon's staff, while thinking Green was a great get initially, significantly cooled on his prospects when he moved to Texas and was beat out for the starting job at Allen HS by a much less physically gifted, younger QB. Green visited Oregon on 9/26, and it appears Oregon's coaches pitched the idea of him moving to tight end so they could make room for another QB commitment, and the two sides parted ways. The QB the UO staff wanted to make room for is local product Justin Herbert of Sheldon HS, who has since committed to the Ducks.
Most Recent Commitment: Bryson Young (Clovis, CA), Drop End. 4*. Young has long been an Oregon lean, and it just took an official visit to seal the deal. That gives Oregon 2 drop end commits, though Bryson Young might grow into a defensive end, and Hunter Kampmoyer could potentially move inside or to the offensive side to play tight end.
Who's Next: So much to be said here. Arguably Oregon's top target is Nigel Knott, a cornerback out of Mississippi whose father played for John Neal in the 90s. The younger Knott is arguably the top cornerback in the country, and while not overly imposing physically, has tremendous athleticism and a quiet confidence about him. After his visit, Knott postponed a planned commitment ceremony, and started following (on twitter) a video production coordinator from Bleacher Report who has made a number of commitment videos for other recruits (Naseir Upshur, Iman Marshall, et al). While Knott doesn't say a lot, the activity of him following Oregon commitments and them following back gives quite a bit of reason for optimism that he could 'quack.'
Anything to be Worried About: Oregon's top overall commit is Jared Mayden, a CB from Sachse, TX. Mayden has visited Michigan and Georgia since committing to the Ducks, and while his whole family likes Oregon, he seems to still want to see what other options are out there. Coach Neal seems to have given him an ultimatum: Stay committed but stop taking visits, or decommit and keep visiting other schools. Seems he's set to make a decision this week on that, and I'd say it's 50/50 which way it will go.
The Green situation is interesting. He's taken over starting duties at QB for Allen after coming off the bench the first few games. He's been playing well since:
Passing: 62-93 (67%) 1,008 yards and 14 TDs to 5 INTs
Rushing: 49 rushes for 566 yards and 5 TDs
He leads the tam in passing yards, passing TDs, rushing yards, and rushing TDs.
Maybe he's being told he'll have to earn any spot on the Duck squad, despite observable deficiencies in the current product being presented on the field.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:38 am
by mdm0302
This is great. Thank you for doing that. Pellum/chinlander throwing s*** on a wall and seeing what sticks had me laughing.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:43 am
by StevensTechU
Thanks for the initial feedback. There's a ton of other things I could add that might become relevant down the road, but I just don't think now are worth using brainpower on. What I probably won't do is waste time talking about pie-in-the-sky recruits. In general, recruiting sites know they'll get the most clicks by mentioning the biggest names and connecting them to a dozen schools, but so often those are non-stories. I almost didn't mention Caleb Kelly at all due to the high, high probability that he goes to Oklahoma.
srsmiley007 wrote:Would like to keep Mayden but if I had to trade would gladly take Knott.
I hope Mayden sticks so Oregon can get both. He's a Jairus Byrd-type that can be a thick CB or slide over to play safety. Also, he's got a near-vintage Texas accent that's hilarious.... In case he doesn't stay committed, it seems like Oregon is already lining up contingency plans. At the top of the board appear to be Devron Davis (Merced, CA), a JUCO, and Damian Alloway (Fontana, CA), both of which are high-caliber players.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:45 am
by woundedknees
mdm0302 wrote:This is great. Thank you for doing that. Pellum/chinlander throwing s*** on a wall and seeing what sticks had me laughing.
On the wall is one thing... The product on the field smells a lot worse, so far!
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:51 am
by DmoneyDuck
Awesome write-up! Thank you for putting this together!
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 10:57 am
by mdm0302
woundedknees wrote:mdm0302 wrote:This is great. Thank you for doing that. Pellum/chinlander throwing s*** on a wall and seeing what sticks had me laughing.
On the wall is one thing... The product on the field smells a lot worse, so far!
haha

Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 11:14 am
by StevensTechU
UOducksTK1 wrote:
The Green situation is interesting. He's taken over starting duties at QB for Allen after coming off the bench the first few games. He's been playing well since:
Passing: 62-93 (67%) 1,008 yards and 14 TDs to 5 INTs
Rushing: 49 rushes for 566 yards and 5 TDs
He leads the tam in passing yards, passing TDs, rushing yards, and rushing TDs.
It is interesting. Green's numbers are looking better, but it's been against Hebron (1-5) and Lewisville (3-3), which would be like judging Justin Herbert based on his performances against South Eugene and Lakeridge. In my opinion, the recruitment of quarterbacks this cycle has been littered with a lot of mistakes. Green was offered before he showed more than just physical prowess. Then when he got evaluated first-hand by a lot of people and the results weren't great, so Frost looked to take a second guy, and the one he chose - Terry Wilson - is almost identical, meaning he's got great size and speed, but ability to quarterback is a big question mark. Then when both Green/Wilson get off to very shakey starts to their senior seasons, Frost finally realizes he has two guys who might not be able to complete passes at the Pac-12 level. Having Green OR Wilson is fine because of their upside, but recruiting two projects was not wise.
A lot to learn from that situation. We'll see what Frost does going forward.
Re: Recruiting Update - 10/14
Posted: Wed Oct 14, 2015 12:58 pm
by jimmy12
That's a BIG question mark. ?????