Page 1 of 2
The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 3:27 pm
by DmoneyDuck
I've seen this call debated heavily in the game thread as well as throughout other topics, so felt like it deserved its own thread. You know the one I'm talking about.
Oregon up 26-20. Less than 90 seconds remaining. No timeouts remaining for the Huskies. 3rd and 7. And Frost calls a pass play to the TE.
Thoughts?
I loved it. If Adams makes a pretty easy throw, the game is over. I also wanted the staff to go for it on 4th and inches last week at Autzen to put the game out of reach against Washington State. As good as our defense had played up to that point, there were signs Washington was starting to figure things out and I didn't want to give them the ball back. *Insert flashback to last week's loss*
Also, it was 3rd and 7 and they did a fairly good job against the run all night. The probability of picking up seven in that situation was pretty slim, not to mention the Huskies were expecting a run. Which is exactly why I loved the call. Bayliss was WIDE OPEN and it caught UW by surprise.
We were 3-3 to that point and really playing with nothing to lose. This wasn't like other games against Washington where we needed to win to keep our Rose Bowl or National Championship hopes alive. If there was ever a time to play loose and roll the dice, this was it.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 4:08 pm
by Zyme
DmoneyDuck wrote:I've seen this call debated heavily in the game thread as well as throughout other topics, so felt like it deserved its own thread. You know the one I'm talking about.
Oregon up 26-20. Less than 90 seconds remaining. No timeouts remaining for the Huskies. 3rd and 7. And Frost calls a pass play to the TE.
Thoughts?
I loved it. If Adams makes a pretty easy throw, the game is over. I also wanted the staff to go for it on 4th and inches last week at Autzen to put the game out of reach against Washington State. As good as our defense had played up to that point, there were signs Washington was starting to figure things out and I didn't want to give them the ball back. *Insert flashback to last week's loss*
Also, it was 3rd and 7 and they did a fairly good job against the run all night. The probability of picking up seven in that situation was pretty slim, not to mention the Huskies were expecting a run. Which is exactly why I loved the call. Bayliss was WIDE OPEN and it caught UW by surprise.
We were 3-3 to that point and really playing with nothing to lose. This wasn't like other games against Washington where we needed to win to keep our Rose Bowl or National Championship hopes alive. If there was ever a time to play loose and roll the dice, this was it.
Major risk-reward play. I was ok with it but I would have prefered a run. If adams gets a little more loft on that pass that one is easily caught.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 4:51 pm
by gogreen55
Complete and utter stupidity is the only way to describe it, much like the game management that gave away the game against the Cougs.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 4:53 pm
by GoDucksIn09
The major problem with it is that if run the ball and Oregon does not pick up the first down then can use your last time out after running the 40 second clock down to zero and leave the Huskies about 30-45 seconds to drive the length of the field. It might be the safe call but when all Washington had to do was score a touchdown I think it is a no brainer call. Luckily for Oregon their new qb came in and threw an interception. I can pretty much guarantee if they drive the length of the field and score we would see a lot more calling out the coaches than is already. I have never played football at that level or coached it but it was a plain as day call in my opinion.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 5:19 pm
by Duck24
Something about calling a play for a cramping QB to roll out and make a throw that I don't agree with. Especially given the potential consequences of an incompletion. Had UW marched down the field and scored with say, 30 seconds to go, would you still have loved the call?
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 5:27 pm
by Duck07
Duck24 wrote:Something about calling a play for a cramping QB to roll out and make a throw that I don't agree with. Especially given the potential consequences of an incompletion. Had UW marched down the field and scored with say, 30 seconds to go, would you still have loved the call?
I think it was the right call because you've got to tell your qb to run or take a sack if nothing is there. In this case he simply missed on an easy throw.
Maybe a reverse would have been the better choice but if you want to question playcalling, look at what we were doing...sorry, not badmouthing the defense this week due to beating the poodles, lol
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 9:09 pm
by DmoneyDuck
Duck24 wrote:Something about calling a play for a cramping QB to roll out and make a throw that I don't agree with. Especially given the potential consequences of an incompletion. Had UW marched down the field and scored with say, 30 seconds to go, would you still have loved the call?
This is exactly why I liked the call. I felt it didn't matter if UW had 60 seconds or 30, they would give us a run for our money on that last drive because our of what our defense showed against Wazzu.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Sun Oct 18, 2015 9:51 pm
by UOducksTK1
Duck24 wrote:Something about calling a play for a cramping QB to roll out and make a throw that I don't agree with. Especially given the potential consequences of an incompletion. Had UW marched down the field and scored with say, 30 seconds to go, would you still have loved the call?
If Washington scored in 30-40 seconds with no timeouts left starting at ~20 yardline, then Pellum would for sure be gone this season and our future would have hope. But in all seriousness, I would have ran the ball. I highly doubt Browning could have lead a 30 second 80 yard game winning drive with no timeouts, and especially not his replacement.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Mon Oct 19, 2015 5:58 am
by wlduck
I don't see how philosophically you can be for going for it last week against the Cougs deep in our own territory, and against the play call here. And I happen to feel that what the staff did on both occasions was correct. Although only one had the desired outcome (meaning we won, I know we didn't convert).
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Mon Oct 19, 2015 6:15 am
by StevensTechU
The commentators noted this, but I don't see it mentioned; I bet VA was told "If there's not a wide open player, just run around and take a knee." Alas, a player was wide open, but he missed it. I'm totally fine with the call.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Mon Oct 19, 2015 6:11 pm
by FlDuckFan
Great call , poor execution. VA missed a wide open WR on which I'm 99% sure he was told "DON'T THROW IT UNLESS HE'S WIDE OPEN" and guess what everything was exactly how you'd want it and our WR was open. VA was suffering from cramps and didn't set and throw the ball correctly. It happens. VA wanted to seal the deal and win the game right there I don't fault him .
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2015 8:42 am
by StevensTechU
Jump to about 4:15. Confirms the comments made above about "easy completion of get down."
http://www.kezi.com/sports/ducks/Web_Ex ... 01715.html
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2015 10:06 am
by vagusnerve
FlDuckFan wrote:Great call , poor execution. VA missed a wide open WR on which I'm 99% sure he was told "DON'T THROW IT UNLESS HE'S WIDE OPEN" and guess what everything was exactly how you'd want it and our WR was open. VA was suffering from cramps and didn't set and throw the ball correctly. It happens. VA wanted to seal the deal and win the game right there I don't fault him .
Hate to say it, but he choked. Just like at msu.
I don't like the idea of criticizing college players, so if there's a more tactful way to say that he chokes under pressure I will use that instead. But VA chokes under pressure.
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2015 12:00 pm
by StevensTechU
vagusnerve wrote:
Hate to say it, but he choked. Just like at msu.
I don't like the idea of criticizing college players, so if there's a more tactful way to say that he chokes under pressure I will use that instead. But VA chokes under pressure.
This reminds me of people saying "Lebron ain't clutch." The reason Oregon was in the MSU game was in large part due to some pressure throws by VA. Adams hit Byron with a perfect ball down the sideline on 4th-and-7 in the 4th quarter, and then he had a huge TD pass to Byron later. Does someone choke if they hit less than 100% of high pressure throws?
Re: The Call - Oregon Vs. Washington
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2015 1:38 pm
by karlhungis
I think it was a good call that opened up exactly as they drew it up.... only Vern threw it into the dirt instead of into the hands of the wide open TE. He probably could have ran for the first as well but that TE was just so wide open, he had to take the shot.