Page 1 of 1

Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 2:26 am
by jimmy12
What was once a strength of the team is now not as deep and likely won't be next year. With Charles Nelson and Malike Lovette moving to the defensive side of the ball (a move I love), I am concerned about the Ducks future speed. Yes, they have Taj Griffin, Royce and Tony Brooks James (who has done nothing this year) and Kirk Merritt, but the depth of speed skill positions is now getting low.

I am not convinced Tyner will return. I am also hearing noise that Bralon and Carrington will head to the NFL and Devon Allen will focus on the Olympics (both are reasonable moves by them).

Losses: Byron Marshall

It's no wonder the Ducks will likely take 2 RBs in this cycle and have just offered Crawford. (he's not a burner).

Anyone else concerned?

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 5:50 am
by StevensTechU
Ah, concern. The favorite emotion of Oregon fans. (I kid... sort of)

So what's interesting to me is that Oregon never really had a team full of burners. In the post about Oregon offering Crawford, I noted that receivers have different strengths, and when I was thinking about past Oregon burners, they were extremely hard to come across. Think about it- in the Kelly/Helfrich era, the best WRs have been Jeff Maehl, Lavasier Tuinei, Jaison Williams. Cam Colvin and Drew Davis added some speed, but the offense never went through either. Josh Huff and De'Anthony were the first explosive WRs Oregon has had. Further, Carrington and Bralon will both likely run in the 4.55-4.65 area at the combine if they're invited.

At running back, there's always been speed, and will be in the future. Taj is no slowpoke. If Tyner comes back, we could see 2016* and 2017 consist of a Tyner/Taj backfield, with TBJ and Vavae Malepeai backing them up, plus the next 4-5* Gary Campbell recruit.

The defense is what got a lot slower compared to the late Belotti years and early Chip Kelly years. Instead of Jairus Byrd, TJ Ward, Walter Thurmond, Josh Kaddu, John Boyett, Dion Jordan, et al, we have Reggie Daniels, Chris Seisay, et al.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 5:56 am
by jimmy12
I absolutely agree with you. I think my concern comes from changed expectations (or unmet expectations). This year we all talked about a wealth of speed and athleticism. That depth has changed. I agree with you on previous years and the mediocre speed. I would say, however, Chip always wanted speed and wanted to "build the fastest team ever." This was my hope when I looked at the depth of this year. Was this the offensive speed we have always wanted? You are absolutely correct that we forgot to maintain that level of speed and athleticism on the defensive side of the ball.

Finally, worries comes from losses and the future. I worry about leaning on transfers for fixes. I worry about QB misses and lack of development. That worries me.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 6:24 am
by StevensTechU
I'll admit up front that I've never been a fan of Chip Kelly's recruiting. I think he's schematically impressive, and above all else is fantastic at being a leader and producing a winning culture. But his eye for talent is/was not good. If you only go after the most athletic players, you get the Florida teams of the last few years. If you look at the NFL, you find that there's little correlation between the fastest players and best players. You want athleticism, but you want football players more than track stars. In a perfect world, you get guys that are both. In Chip's case, there was also an issue that he wasn't willing to recruit hard enough/coddle the best players, so we were often settling for less talented guys.

Transfers and JUCOs are a necessary part of the game because no school recruits every position perfectly. Alabama brought in Richard Mullaney from Oregon State! Their quarterback is a transfer from Florida State, and they tried to take in an abuser from Georgia to play on the defensive line. All this despite being the #1 recruiter for 4-5 years straight. When you get players for an average of 3-4 years, it's impossible to recruit so perfectly that every position is stocked with guys ready to step in. When you get lucky enough to have really good players across the board, you get a shot at a national title.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 9:41 am
by Duckattack7
I have seen Carrington talking about how he cant wait to ball out next year with Travis Jonsen so dont think he will go. And Bralon might leave but he would benefit from having another year. We got plenty of people and speed we will be fine.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 10:02 am
by DmoneyDuck
First off, let me state that I really hope Addison, Carrington, and Allen don't leave the program after this year to enter the NFL Draft or focus on track. But, if that is indeed the case, I think we will survive as WR is our most loaded position.

Returning would be (Eligibility Year in 2016):
Jalen Brown - Rs-SO
Kirk Merritt - SO
Alex Ofodile - Rs-FR
Dwayne Stanford - Rs-SR

Along with current incoming Freshman:
Dillion Mitchell: https://rivals.yahoo.com/oregon/footbal ... ell-161894 - 4*

Also, I could see us taking on more WRs if the trio of receivers decides to leave.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 10:07 am
by gofightingducks
I am not concerned about the speed or talent of the recruits, I am concerned about the play calling not being tailored around the strengths of the players, it doesn't matter how much speed you have if you don't get them the ball.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 11:15 am
by wlduck
In terms of doing what's best for them, not the team, I think Bralon should go to the NFL draft and Devon should focus on track. Carrington has played too little, and needs another year.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 11:42 am
by StevensTechU
Ehhhhhh. If Devon Allen could turn into an NFL caliber WR by the end of his college career, there's a lot more money going the football route. Being a 110 meter hurdler has very little money in it. That said, by all accounts Devon's first passion is track, so if that's what his heart tells him to do then I say go for it.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 7:33 pm
by gogreen55
Addison is a borderline NFL player. He isn't very big and he isn't super fast. His best chance of seeing playing time at the professional level is probably as a punt returner. Personally, I don't think players that are borderline NFL players should leave school early.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 8:17 pm
by wlduck
The reality is these guys pretty much are what they are for the NFL whether they come back for another year or not. I agree Bralon is a borderline NFL player. Coming back for another year won't change that. I don't think Devon will ever be in NFL caliber player. Just my opinion. Darren has such a small sample size he needs to come back for another year.

Speed Players

Posted: Thu Oct 22, 2015 8:36 pm
by UofDuck
Darren needs time to distance himself from his choices. A year of staying clean at school will be important for him. I think Devon could be a star on Sunday's IF he gets back into mentally. He just seems off this year after the injury. He's got decent size and is crazy fast with pretty good hands.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2015 6:22 am
by StevensTechU
I think Addison will make a splash in the NFL as long as he gets a legitimate chance. His speed isn't great, yet he has an NFL ability to get open and NFL hands to catch the ball.

Darren's misdeeds are overblown. Smoked weed in a state where it's legal and carried a drink outside the party. I'm a white collar guy in NYC and even I'm guilty of the latter.

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2015 4:40 pm
by hjpop
Carrington got busted for Weed in Oregon where it was not legal at the time to do so. He also had an open container violation. Both may be explained in some shape or fashion by the NFL at some later point (if they don't bust Manziel, this is petty in comparison)

Re: Speed Players

Posted: Sun Oct 25, 2015 1:07 am
by Pontius
StevensTechU wrote:Ah, concern. The favorite emotion of Oregon fans. (I kid... sort of)

So what's interesting to me is that Oregon never really had a team full of burners. In the post about Oregon offering Crawford, I noted that receivers have different strengths, and when I was thinking about past Oregon burners, they were extremely hard to come across. Think about it- in the Kelly/Helfrich era, the best WRs have been Jeff Maehl, Lavasier Tuinei, Jaison Williams. Cam Colvin and Drew Davis added some speed, but the offense never went through either. Josh Huff and De'Anthony were the first explosive WRs Oregon has had. Further, Carrington and Bralon will both likely run in the 4.55-4.65 area at the combine if they're invited.

At running back, there's always been speed, and will be in the future. Taj is no slowpoke. If Tyner comes back, we could see 2016* and 2017 consist of a Tyner/Taj backfield, with TBJ and Vavae Malepeai backing them up, plus the next 4-5* Gary Campbell recruit.

The defense is what got a lot slower compared to the late Belotti years and early Chip Kelly years. Instead of Jairus Byrd, TJ Ward, Walter Thurmond, Josh Kaddu, John Boyett, Dion Jordan, et al, we have Reggie Daniels, Chris Seisay, et al.
There were few faster WRs than Pat Johnson and Samie Parker. Both had big time Duck careers and decently long NFL careers.