Page 1 of 1
future concerns
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2015 3:12 pm
by picksix
Barring a stud JUCO QB signing this year, What is the next few years of offense going to look like? Our offense is only as good as our QB will take us. I'm holding out hope for Travis Jonsen, beyond that [ Mahalak, Lockie, Alie ... not going to consider Wilson or Herbert ]. We have studs at RB, WR, good TE's the next few years, but do we have a QB? Hopefully our defense well be good enough next season with so many young guys getting playing time/ experience, but just concerned about the immediate future of our QB's. I will be positive we'll get back to our winning ways next year, but wanted to read everyones thoughts on this.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2015 5:47 pm
by StevensTechU
It's a little ironic to write* a response to say I'm holding my opinion, but because there is so much that could change in the near future (transfers in, transfers out, commitments, etc.), I'm going to hold off on racking my brain over it too much until at least after National Signing Day in February.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2015 6:51 pm
by UOducksTK1
picksix wrote:Barring a stud JUCO QB signing this year, What is the next few years of offense going to look like? Our offense is only as good as our QB will take us. I'm holding out hope for Travis Jonsen, beyond that [ Mahalak, Lockie, Alie ... not going to consider Wilson or Herbert ]. We have studs at RB, WR, good TE's the next few years, but do we have a QB? Hopefully our defense well be good enough next season with so many young guys getting playing time/ experience, but just concerned about the immediate future of our QB's. I will be positive we'll get back to our winning ways next year, but wanted to read everyones thoughts on this.
But it shouldn't have to. I wouldn't say either Masoli or Darron Thomas were anything exceptional, but were good enough. There was enough talent surrounding them where they could give us a good season. Obviously Lockie and Alie are probably a bigger drop off, but even with VA as QB, our offense isn't quite the same. And that's crazy, because we have more supporting talent than ever. Anyway, we shouldn't be so dependent on the QB. Perhaps Mariota unintentionally made us more reliant on QB play, but now reality has settled in, we have to decouple that dependency, so we don't have a season like this again.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Tue Oct 27, 2015 11:06 pm
by GoDucksIn09
I think Mariota spoiled Frost and Helfrich. They are not good at developing qbs to be studs. Chip Kelly was able to utilize who he had and make it a strength to the point that could probably win with no matter who he had. I do not get that sense with Frost or Helfrich.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 5:21 am
by StevensTechU
UOducksTK1 wrote:
But it shouldn't have to. I wouldn't say either Masoli or Darron Thomas were anything exceptional, but were good enough.
Masoli is in the CFL and Darron was all-conference and is now in the AFL. I don't think Oregon fans realize how truly talented both of these guys were/are.
I think that translates as "Oregon can get it done with more than just an NFL-type quarterback" but they still need to be talented one way or another. Maybe I'll expand what I mean in another post down the road if that doesn't make sense.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 7:11 am
by Oregon Ownage
GoDucksIn09 wrote:I think Mariota spoiled Frost and Helfrich. They are not good at developing qbs to be studs. Chip Kelly was able to utilize who he had and make it a strength to the point that could probably win with no matter who he had. I do not get that sense with Frost or Helfrich.
Seems harsh to base this after a half of a season doesnt it? Lets play this season out and see if Adams grows and then we can re-evaluate this.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 8:35 am
by woundedknees
StevensTechU wrote:UOducksTK1 wrote:
But it shouldn't have to. I wouldn't say either Masoli or Darron Thomas were anything exceptional, but were good enough.
Masoli is in the CFL and Darron was all-conference and is now in the AFL. I don't think Oregon fans realize how truly talented both of these guys were/are.
I think that translates as "Oregon can get it done with more than just an NFL-type quarterback" but they still need to be talented one way or another. Maybe I'll expand what I mean in another post down the road if that doesn't make sense.
Makes perfect sense... There are a lot of "good" college level quarterbacks who will never develop the stuff between the ears it takes to be a good NFL quarterback. Masoli and Thomas are prime examples of that. So is Tim Tebow.
There is a different "It" factor involved at the next level.
That said, both Thomas and JM were plenty good for Oregon, and there is little doubt that were there a guy of that caliber on the current roster, it is entirely possible we would not have seen the coaches pursue Adams.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 7:38 pm
by UOducksTK1
StevensTechU wrote:UOducksTK1 wrote:
But it shouldn't have to. I wouldn't say either Masoli or Darron Thomas were anything exceptional, but were good enough.
Masoli is in the CFL and Darron was all-conference and is now in the AFL. I don't think Oregon fans realize how truly talented both of these guys were/are.
I think that translates as "Oregon can get it done with more than just an NFL-type quarterback" but they still need to be talented one way or another. Maybe I'll expand what I mean in another post down the road if that doesn't make sense.
They are talented for sure, but there's at least 10 other guys in college football when they were playing that I'd consider more talented (if not more).
Re: future concerns
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2015 5:15 am
by StevensTechU
UOducksTK1 wrote:
They are talented for sure, but there's at least 10 other guys in college football when they were playing that I'd consider more talented (if not more).
That's actually interesting to consider. In general, I'd say I'm more than happy with a top 10-15 QB.
Re: future concerns
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2015 6:04 am
by Duckattack7
Marcus was a 3* and I Will trust the coaches for another year they recruited Travis Jonsen and he will have a full year to be ready. If he is as bad as lockie then I would call it a concern. We had a qb with crazy talent show up, get hurt and now finally coming back. If we win out then I think the coaches will be ready next year if not and we lose 3 of 4 then I would have concern.