Page 1 of 1
Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 9:46 am
by StevensTechU
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 9:51 am
by karlhungis
They don't have to know why the offense isn't clicking the way it has in recent years. But they aren't to wrong question why it isn't.
Most people don't completely understand how their cars work either. But they know when the engine is backfiring or sputtering or blowing toxic smoke out the tailpipe that something is wrong.
They trust their mechanics to fix the problem. If a mechanic doesn't do the job, they find another one.
It's something Frost should take to heart.
I think he is spot on.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 10:30 am
by rentdodger1
Frost gets paid well and is not above critical review. The main problem with Frost is that he has been OC for three years and has yet to recruit/develop a solid QB option to replace MM. That is a fail for Frost and Helfrich. Goe is right, the car is sputtering some but still good enough to be at 8-10 wins and with that Frost criticism should be secondary.
The real problem is with the
defensive driver, Pellum. He is playing bumper cars. Last virtually every stat category should get you fired and the next 4 games will really illustrate whether the D has actually made some adjustments and progress.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 10:48 am
by StevensTechU
Since this is very relevant for Oregon fans as well, I wanted to add this piece from Football Scoop that analyzes the concept of not discussing injuries.
http://footballscoop.com/news/dan-mulle ... -strategy/
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 10:49 am
by lmduck
While I find Goe more whiney than a teenage girl most of the time, I will give him some credit for this. He is right to an extent. I think the issue is as has been discussed a lot here and that is that Mahalak has not developed as many including the coaches originally thought he would . Is that the coaches fault, maybe.
His silly comments (again) about no access to practice are just so trite and tired. I will pose the question again, what difference would access to practice make for the media and fans???? I just don't get this constant complaining about not being able to see practice. Do they really need an army of 200-300 people in the Mo Center each day watching practice? How would Goe having access to
Practice solve the QB issues???
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 11:11 am
by pezsez1
I also find Goe's constant remarks on closed practices to be a bit tiring, but in this case, he brings up a good point... and this is a consequence of closed practices we haven't had to consider until this season.
Are the coaches terrible? Or are our quarterbacks not talented?
If practices were open, we might be able to answer that question with much more substance and far less opinion. Same goes for the defense. If what we'd seen in practice for the past couple years jived with what we're seeing on the field right now, then people might not be as shocked by how bad our defense has been this year. Or, we might see our guys looking all-pro during practice, but then falling apart during games. Who knows?
Definitely giving props to Goe on this, if anything just for making fans think.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 11:48 am
by StevensTechU
I wouldn't call myself a Ken Goe fan by any stretch, but I think the practices thing was more just to illustrate the disconnect between team and fans. There were people who attended Ducks practices for decades up until Chip rolled out the red tape. More consequently, when things all happen behind closed doors, that leads to speculation and frustration by those out-of-the-know, so some part the criticism that fans have showered the team with (mostly on the coaches, much less so the players from what I've seen) is largely a result of the coaches' policies. In other words, they're kind of doing it to themselves.
But while I was reading this, I was actually thinking more about how this is two articles this year (there was another, lengthier one by the Oregonian) where Scott Frost has strongly stated that people don't know what they're talking about, a jaded viewpoint he developed when he got slammed by the Nebraska fanbase when he was the QB there almost two decades ago. And while, like Goe, I largely agree that there are some crazy and stupid comments that get made, Frost just strikes me as a guy who developed a closed-minded approach and comes off a bit smug.
Admittedly, I do wish the coaches took a more community-friendly approach rather than disconnecting the team from the fanbase.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 12:44 pm
by fpsduck
"We talk to the kids all the time about not listening to the detractors, not listening to the critics. Most people that are criticizing them couldn't draw up 11 guys on a football field, where they're supposed to line up. So the people that think they know things don't."
I know that your offensive play call leaves something to be desired as does your ability to develop quarterbacks, Scott.

Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 12:47 pm
by StevensTechU
fpsduck wrote:
I know that your offensive play call leaves something to be desired as does your ability to develop quarterbacks, Scott.

And WRs before that...
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 1:06 pm
by fpsduck
StevensTechU wrote:fpsduck wrote:
I know that your offensive play call leaves something to be desired as does your ability to develop quarterbacks, Scott.

And WRs before that...
I never even thought about that. I always assumed all of the focus was on running the ball while Chip was head coach. Jeff Maehl did alright under frost, but I'm drawing a blank on other receivers that did well under Frost. Huff did ok, but he exploded when Lubick was hired.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 1:17 pm
by pezsez1
Don't forget that Marcus had something to do with our receivers, too.
I don't think it's fair to say Frost didn't develop good receivers; our guys were great blockers and we did have some playmakers. Addison and Huff both did great under Frost, as did Tuinei (spelling?), and can't forget Maehl.
When Lubick was hired, though, I seem to remember him bringing at least one recruit with him, and then we went on a nice little recruiting run. I think he's an outstanding coach, and there's no way I'd argue that Frost was better at developing receivers, but I don't think it's fair to say he failed to develop receivers.
I think his playcalling this season is totally fair game, though.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 1:26 pm
by StevensTechU
Josh Huff was asked what the biggest difference between Lubick and Frost was after Frost moved from WR to QB/OC. He responded by saying Lubick pays a lot more attention to details, and illustrates everything by showing tape of All-Pros performing certain things. Conversely, Huff said Frost was more of a "block hard, run hard" kind of coach.
Probably the most damning part of Frost's time coaching/recruiting WRs was that he was the guy who signed Devon Blackmon, BJ Kelley, and Tacoi Sumler, and that Drew Davis had a brief NFL career but we got no productivity out of him at UO.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 1:34 pm
by lmduck
StevensTechU wrote:I wouldn't call myself a Ken Goe fan by any stretch, but I think the practices thing was more just to illustrate the disconnect between team and fans. There were people who attended Ducks practices for decades up until Chip rolled out the red tape. More consequently, when things all happen behind closed doors, that leads to speculation and frustration by those out-of-the-know, so some part the criticism that fans have showered the team with (mostly on the coaches, much less so the players from what I've seen) is largely a result of the coaches' policies. In other words, they're kind of doing it to themselves.
But while I was reading this, I was actually thinking more about how this is two articles this year (there was another, lengthier one by the Oregonian) where Scott Frost has strongly stated that people don't know what they're talking about, a jaded viewpoint he developed when he got slammed by the Nebraska fanbase when he was the QB there almost two decades ago. And while, like Goe, I largely agree that there are some crazy and stupid comments that get made, Frost just strikes me as a guy who developed a closed-minded approach and comes off a bit smug.
Admittedly, I do wish the coaches took a more community-friendly approach rather than disconnecting the team from the fanbase.
Stevens- really appreciate your thought provoking posts. You bring some terrific insights to the board. Keep 'em coming.
My one area of disagreement is that I don't think the coaches or AD are making the team less accessible or are creating a disconnect by not allowing people to observe practice. They have simply eliminated what was in the past, a major distraction, and that was hordes of media and onlookers. Again would all of us seeing that Mahalak is not developing while attending practice make the situation any different???? Not likely. It just means we might have some specifics like 'he does not throw a good long ball', 'he seems nervous' (just examples). One of the things that I heard from a fairly reliable source a couple of years ago was that open practices in the past ( 7-8 years ago) meant that some less than savory folks were turning up. Specifically one of the examples that was cited was people that agents were sending to 'scout' potential candidates for their services. There were other examples but I will plead on those and respect confidentiality. Now does that mean you shut it down completely , maybe , maybe not. The other issue that I heard and there may be some credence to this is one of liability. IF someone gets injured while standing and observing play then the university is liable. Is this a big deal, I don't know.
Sort of a side topic but one I have thought about. The Pac12 network has this show called The Drive which gives fans an inside look as the network bills it. This year Utah and OSU are part of it. IMHO, I DON'T want Oregon to be a part of that. Why??? Not because Chris Peterson (or take your pick of any coach in the conference ) will see something and figure how to game plan against UO, but more because it is a MAJOR distraction to the kids and I personally think takes focus off the task at hand which is to prepare and win games. Apparetnly that is not the case with Utah this year but you never know.
On another note, I have met Frost and been with him in a few social situations. He is a nice guy, very contemplative. He actually comes off as being a bit shy. I think some of the steeliness we are seeing from him this year is as a result of some growing pains.
I am by no means an 'insider'. My seats at Autzen are near someone who is and I will admit I do hear some tidbits on occasion. This particular person would be one who would likely have carte blanche to observe practice at anytime but as I heard him say onetime "I stay out of there and let the coaches and staff do their job'.
Just my thoughts.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Wed Oct 28, 2015 1:45 pm
by StevensTechU
I get the practices bit, and personally agree with closing them for many of the same reasons you outline (Lmduck).
The protocols I agree much less with are how they deal with injuries (see the link I provided to Football Scoop above on the subject) which has led to rampant speculation that isn't good for the program or the players, the open practice held for season ticketholders that left many fans perturbed (
http://fishduck.com/2015/08/oregon-foot ... ay-an-egg/ ), that facilities are off limits to most fans, and a prevalent culture of exclusivity.
Re: Ken Goe on Scott Frost & Criticism
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2015 9:10 am
by GoDucksIn09
I think the thing Chip Kelly did when here more than anything was see what the defense was doing and attack the weakness part. With Mariota being a once in a lifetime qb he was able to get past a lot of deficiencies and just make great plays. We clearly do not have that with who we have. It is on the coaches to recognize what the opposing team is doing defensively and attack the weakness. We are not seeing that with Frost this year. I do not even want to discuss pillows Pellum. I am hoping for major changes at end of this year