Page 1 of 2
Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd OT
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 11:20 am
by gofightingducks
12063433_1720992948129185_2747579172905829360_n.jpg
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 11:55 am
by pezsez1
So, about that...
I read that based on the front foot alone, it should have been ruled incomplete because his foot makes the continuous motion of heel-toe-out of bounds. You can land on your toes and slide out of bounds, or fall out of bounds, but like you can't land on your toes, then come down with your toes in and your heels out.
HOWEVER!
What we all neglected to look at last night was Bralon's trailing right toe, which was touching the turf before his left toe came down out of bounds.
And that, my friends, is a catch!!!
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 11:59 am
by gofightingducks
pezsez1 wrote:So, about that...
I read that based on the front foot alone, it should have been ruled incomplete because his foot makes the continuous motion of heel-toe-out of bounds. You can land on your toes and slide out of bounds, or fall out of bounds, but like you can't land on your toes, then come down with your toes in and your heels out.
HOWEVER!
What we all neglected to look at last night was Bralon's trailing right toe, which was touching the turf before his left toe came down out of bounds.
And that, my friends, is a catch!!!
That is true, his lead foot wouldn't matter because his trailing foot dragged before going out of bounds with his lead foot. These things are always crazy because they are a judgement call more than anything, but like many have said there were bad calls both ways and the INT in the end zone for the Ducks was a blatant one.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:01 pm
by pezsez1
I think it's huge that officials were able to see that his toe wasn't out of bounds when he caught the ball, because then they could see that his trailing toe counted as the one foot inbounds.
And yeah, that overturned INT was a TERRIBLE call. I don't get how the referees decided to overturn that. Sure, it didn't look clean, but his fingers were still under the ball. You could tell from his reaction too that he genuinely felt he had it.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:03 pm
by dthomas=ddixon
Is there a screenshot of the trailing toe?
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:11 pm
by greenyellow
dthomas=ddixon wrote:Is there a screenshot of the trailing toe?
I haven't been able to find any clear still photo of his trailing toe drag, besides a screenshot of the in-game footage that's a bit fuzzy.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:36 pm
by fpsduck
We need a camera view from the other side of the field to see his right toe as the official is im the way from this camera angle.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:42 pm
by pezsez1
I think this is the best we'll get of his back toe being down:
http://www.gannett-cdn.com/-mm-/30e7e69 ... .58-AM.png
Unfortunately, we can't see what the front foot is doing in this pic, but ESPN froze this at the moment of the catch, and in that moment from the other pics we know his front foot was not yet out of bounds.
Bang-bang play, but officials made the right call.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 12:48 pm
by ncduck
It was bothering me too much that the announcers never mentioned the right foot! I had to bite my lip to not yell at the TV.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 1:32 pm
by hjpop
It all hinges on when the receiver is deemed to be in possession of the ball. According to the rulebook, any part of a player not in contact with another player that is on the line makes the player out of bounds.
In the NCAA Football Casebook for 2015, they have an almost perfect case example. If a player comes down with a legal pass and his heel touches inbounds and his toe, in the natural momentum, steps out of bounds and is ruled a catch, the play should be reversed and called "an incomplete pass". So, if the receiver is in possession before the heel-toe comes into play, it is a completed pass and TD stands. If he is in possession when the heel touches inbounds but his toe touches out, as it appeared on the replay, he is out and the TD is reversed.
Also found where the first INT in the endzone should've been upheld (the Casebook and the 2015 Rulebook would call it an INT). Gotta love PAc-12 refs and review officials.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 1:49 pm
by pezsez1
I think possession in this case started the moment he caught the ball; he never lost control of it, so that issue of when possession started never would have reset.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 2:20 pm
by hjpop
That's where I think the replay official decided to hang his hat on because he lacked the photo evidence that leads more people to believe his foot was inbounds. It doesn't matter about his foot trailing because the rule states that although college only requires one foot inbounds, it has to be the first foot down. If possession is deemed made with the heel-toe foot, he would be out of bounds and the trailing foot is immaterial.
In the end, if Graham hadn't wasted his challenge earlier, this might have been a close one to call. But he did and serendipity smiled on us.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 2:33 pm
by UOducksTK1
pezsez1 wrote:I think it's huge that officials were able to see that his toe wasn't out of bounds when he caught the ball, because then they could see that his trailing toe counted as the one foot inbounds.
And yeah, that overturned INT was a TERRIBLE call. I don't get how the referees decided to overturn that. Sure, it didn't look clean, but his fingers were still under the ball. You could tell from his reaction too that he genuinely felt he had it.
I don't know if I would credit the Addison call to the refs, especially after they botched the Daniels pick. Frankly I think they were just flipping a coin the whole time.
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 3:23 pm
by gofightingducks
12122605_10153746793984216_4294853143750491178_n.jpg
Here is one dragging the back foot
Re: Good shot of foot inbounds on Bralon Addison TD in 3rd O
Posted: Fri Oct 30, 2015 3:24 pm
by gofightingducks
gofightingducks wrote:12122605_10153746793984216_4294853143750491178_n.jpg
Here is one dragging the back foot
That appears to be an NFL TD catch!!